:::

詳目顯示

回上一頁
題名:形上學中的存有問題─柏拉圖形上學的存有問題
作者:魏德驥
作者(外文):Jacob Wei
校院名稱:臺灣大學
系所名稱:哲學研究所
指導教授:陳文團
學位類別:博士
出版日期:2004
主題關鍵詞:二分法法哲學亞里斯多德辯證法場域數理型本體發生論原理論方法陳康柏拉圖未書寫理論理型數杜賓根學派ChorismosChoraMetaphysicsLudwig C. H. Chenthe GoodDialecticsAutarkeiaAristotleTheory of PrinciplesPlatoPythagorean
原始連結:連回原系統網址new window
相關次數:
  • 被引用次數被引用次數:期刊(0) 博士論文(1) 專書(0) 專書論文(0)
  • 排除自我引用排除自我引用:0
  • 共同引用共同引用:0
  • 點閱點閱:53
  本論文導論從討論陳康先生的博士論文《亞里斯多德的分離問題》中對於分離問題的詮釋開始。進而透過對於未書寫理論的討論,理解亞里斯多德對於柏拉圖詮釋的方式,從而批判杜賓根學派與通俗的詮釋學方法,建立原理論辯證的理解方法。在第二章中進而對方法問題提出解釋,方法是原理論辯證所形成的二分法,而這個二分法具有穿透變化提升到存有的四重結構。這個辯證方法透過對於錯誤的揚棄而提升,為第二原理在知識論中提供一個詮釋學所沒有完全顧慮到的積極角色。而這個辯證法從假設出發,而達到分離的超越對象。在第三章中,將柏拉圖方法所描述的系統建構透過名、言、實存的說明,確定系統建構在柏拉圖對話錄中的基本角色。進而探究系統建構與方法建構的類比關係。進而理解主道德與副道德的發生系譜。在道德系譜的說明之後,進入三層靈魂論與三層世界論的系統建構。最後是柏拉圖將哲學三分的可能性之討論。在結論中,則從原理辯證法發展可能的自由法哲學,藉由辯證法的能力反省人性尊嚴以及自由的幾個基本範例。
The Problem of Being in Metaphysics
By Plato’s Metaphysics, it is understood as the method for a thinking living being to relate itself to the transcendental object- the Good (an object with positive value)- and to live with it and partake in it. This method is called by Plato as Dialectics, which involves the interaction of two or more lives, which are uneducable to thinking subjects. The Good has an autarky before the existence and the definitive actions of understanding, and this autarkical Good is the goal for the relating life and also the principle of its individuality. Such an ability for transcendence is named and under the names to become trascendentalia.
To these characteristics of object, we have relevant characteristics for method: a post-aristotelic apodeictics is regarded since Aristotle as different from Plato’s Dialectics. This difference results difficulty for approaching the multifarious beginning in Plato’s thought. Only a direct (!) confluence with Plato’s opinion, starting from principle towards principles brings us to his object. This thesis discusses Mr. Ludwig C. H. Chen’s conclusion in his research for the Chorismos, namely Chorismos as Autarkeia instead of spatial separation, e.g. two worlds, as starting hypothesis. This hypothesis brings us, like Aristotle, to the discussion over Chora, hence the dispute over Plato’s theory of principles: the definite one and indefinite two as the Good with its dynamis in its unity develops itself to be dual principles in contemplation, which is different from a Pythagorean Ontology in Onoma about its principle, and hence a difference between Ontology and Metaphysics. Duplication of dual principle becomes the quadruple structure of knowledge, and the individual consolidation in this quadruple caused a three level world system. This three level world system becomes the characteristic way of Plato for the explanation in a threefolded analogy in Physics, Philosophy of Language(logike), and Ethics.
This system, based on the autarchic Good, not only reflects the Athenian Polity in Platonic ideas, but also affords the freedom in relation for individuals in the city state, not a infinite subjective freedom, a metaphysical basis in respect of natural law.
Ⅰ、中文部份
陳康 《柏拉圖巴曼尼得斯篇》,重慶:1942.台北:問學出版社,1979重印.
---《陳康:論希臘哲學》,北京:商務印書館,1990.
考夫曼《法律哲學》,台北:五南出版社,2000.= Kaufmann 1997

Ⅱ、外文
Albinos. Eisagoge. in “Platonis dialogi secundum Thrasylli Tetralogias dispositi ex recognitione Caroli Frideric Hermanni” T. VI. Leipzig: 1873.
Allen,R.E.(ed.). Studies in Plato''s Metaphysics. London: 1965.
Archer-Hind,R.D.: The Timaeus of Plato (Gr.-eng. with comm. by Archer-Hind,repr. of ed. New York,1888).Salem: 1988.
Aristoteles: Organon. hrsg. von Theodor Waitz. Leipzig: 1844.
--- Aristotelis Opera (ed. Academie Regia Borussica,Olof Gigon ed.altera) 5vols.,Berlin,1960.H.Bonitz〈Index Aristotelicus〉in Vol.V..
--- Aristotelis Fragmenta Selecta (Ross ed.,Sriptorum Classicorum Bibliotheca Oxoniensis).Oxford: 1987.
--- The Complete Works of Aristotle(The Revised Oxford Translation,eng.tr.) 2Vols..Princeton:1984.
Ashbaugh,Anne Freire. Plato''s Theory of Explanation A Study of Cosmological Account in the Timaeus.New York: 1988.
Ast,Friedrich. Lexicon Platonicum III Vols.Berlin: 1908.
Baeumker,Clemens. Das Problem der Materie in der griechischen Philosophie. Muenster: 1890.
Brandwood,Leonard. A Word Index to Plato. Leeds : Maney, 1976.
--- The Chronology of Plato''s Dialogues.Cambridge: 1990.
Brisson,Luc. Le Même et L''autre dans la Structure ontologique du Timée de Platon un commentaire systematique du Timée de Platon. Paris: 1974.
---Phedre(Traduction inedite,introduction et notes).Paris: 1989.
Burnet,John. Early Greek Philosophy (4th ed.) .New York: 1957.
Bury,R.G. Plato in twelve volumes ( Loeb Classical Library,eng. tr. with Zurich text ). Mass. Cambridge: 1952.
Calcidius Timaeus a Calcidio Translatus Commentarioque Instructus (Plato Latinus Vol.IV.,Lat.tr. with comm.,ed.J.H. Waszink,editio altera).London: 1975.
Chen, Ludwig C. H. Das Chorsimos Problem bei Aristoteles. Berlin: 1940.
--- Sophia. Hildesheim: 1976.
--- Acquiring knowledge of the ideas : a study of Plato''s methods in the Phaedo, the Symposium and the central books of the Republic. Stuttgart : Steiner, 1992.
Cherniss,Harold. Aristotle''s Criticism of Plato and the Academy. Vol.I. Baltimore: 1946.
Cicero: Timaeus in ”De Divinatione De Fato Timaeus” (Gr.-Lat. BT fasc.46) pp177-228. Leipzig: 1975.
--- Topica. Hamburg : Meiner, 1983.
Commentaria in Aristotelem Graeca
Cornford,F.M. Plato''s Cosmology The Timaeus of Plato translated with a running commentary(eng.).London: 1956.
--- Plato''s Theory of Knowledge (The Theaetetus and the Sophist of Plato,eng.tr.). New York: 1957.
Derrida,Jacques. La Pharmacie de Platon (1972 ed.) in Platons “Phédre” pp259-403. Paris: 1989.
--- chora in “Poikilia” pp265-296. Paris: 1987.
Diels,Hermann & Kranz,Walther. Die Fragmente der Vorsokratiker. (Gr. und Dt.,6. Auflage) III.Vols.Zuerich: 1972.
Dies,Auguste. Autour de Platon (Volumes.I & II,1976repr.).Paris: 1927.
Diogenes Laertius. Lives of Eminent Philosophers (Loeb Classical Library,Gr. text with eng.tr. by H.D.Hicks,Plato in Vol.I. book 3.)II.Vols. Mass. Cambridge: 1950.
Dodds,E.R. Gorgias a revised text with introduction and commentary (Gr.text with Comm.). Oxford: 1959.
Düring, I. Aristoteles : Darstellung und Interpretation seines Denkens. Heidelberg : Winter, 1966.
Empirikos, Sextos. Opera ex recensione Immanuelis Bekkeri. Berlin : Reimer, 1842.
Frank,Erich. Plato und die sogennante Pythagoreer. Halle: 1923.
Friedländer,Paul. Plato. 3Vols.(eng.tr. of Platon,zweite ed.,Berlin,1954). New York: 1958.
Gadamer, Hans-Georg & Schadewaldt, Wolfgang. Idee und Zahl. Vorgelegt von Hans-Georg Gadamer und Wolfgang Schadewaldt. Heidelberg: Carl Winter, 1968.
Gadamer, H. G. Gesammelte Werke. X Bde. Stuttgart: 1999.
Gaiser,Konrad. Platons ungeschrieben Lehre (zweite Aufgabe).Stuttgart: 1968.
--- Das Platonbild. Hrg. Von Gaiser. Hildesheim: 1969.
Greene,W.C.(ed.). Scholia Platonica (Gr.,repr.of 1938 ed. by William Chase Greene).Ann Arbor: 1981.
Guthrie,W.K.C. History of Greek Philosophy. 6Vols. Plato in IV.&V..Cambridge: 1989.
Hamilton,Edith & Cairns,Huntington. The Collected Dialogues of Plato . New York: 1963.
Hartmann, Nicolai. Zur Grundlegung der Ontologie. Berlin : de Gruyter, 1935.
Henrich, Dieter. Der ontologische Gottbeweis. Sein Problem und seine Geschichte in der Neuzeit. Tuebingen: J. C. B. Mohr, 1960.
Hermann,Karl Friedrich. Geschichte und System der platonischen Philosophie. Heidelberg: 1839.
Iamblikhos. Iamblichi Chalcidensis in Platonis Dialogos Commentariorum Fragmenta. (Gr.-Eng.,ed. with tr. & comm. by John M. Dillon). Leiden:1973.
Jaeger, Werner. Paideia. Berlin: 1936.
Kaufmann, Arthur. Rechtsphilosophie. 2nd revised ed. München:C. H. Beck, 1997.
Konnick,Thomas de & Planty-Bonjour,Guy. La question de Dieu selon Aristote et Hegel. Paris; 1991.
Kühner,Raphael & Gerth,Bernhard. Ausfuerliche Grammatik der Griechischen Sprach (unver. Nachdr. der 3.Auflage 1898) II Teile (4 Bde.). Hannover; 1992.
Krämer, Hans Joachim.Arete bei Platon und Aristoteles : zum Wesen und zur Geschichte der platonischen Ontologie. Heidelberg : Winter, 1959.
--- Der Ursprung der Geistmetaphysik. Amsterdam: 1964.
--- Platonismus und hellenistische Philosophie. Berlin : de Gruyter, 1971.
--- Platone e I fondamenti della metafisica. 4th edition. Milan: 1989.
--- Dialettica e definizione del Bene in Platone. tr. By Enrico Peoli, introd. By Giovanni Reale. Milan: 1989.
--- Plato and the Foundation of Metaphysics. English translation of Platone e I fondamenti della metafisica by Catan, John R. New York: State of New York Press, 1990. =Krämer1989.
Liddell,H.G. & Scott,R. A Greek-English Lexicon (9th. ed.with a supplment). Oxford: 1968.
Mittelstrass,Juergen. Die Rettung der Phaenomene . Berlin : 1962.
Moreau,Joseph. L’âme du monde de Platon aux Stoiciens. (repr. of Paris,1939 ed.) Hildesheim: 1981.
Natorp,Paul. Platos Ideenlehre. (zweite Auflage) Leipzig: 1921.
Paquet,Leonce. La Mediation du Regard. Leiden: 1973.
Platon Platons Werke. 6Bde. übers. v. Schleiermacher, F. Berlin: 1817-1828.
--- Platonis Scripta Graece Omnia (Gr. with Latin annot.,Imannuel Bekker ed.). 9 Vols. London: 1826.
--- Platonis Opera (Gr.-Lat.,so-called Didotiana ed.,by R.B.Hirschig) 3Vols. Paris: 1891.
--- Platonis Opera(Gr.,Oxford Classical Text,ed.by John Burnet) 5Vols. Oxford: 1986.
--- Oeuvres complètes (tr. & note. by Leon Robin with M.-J. Moreau)2vols. Paris, 1942.
--- Sämtliche Dialoge . (Dt.,repr. of Lepzig,1922 ed.,tr. & ed. by Otto Apelt) 7Bde.,Hamburg: 1988.
--- Werke (Gr. text of Bude series & Dt. tr.by H.Mueller & F.Schleiermacher) 8Bde. Darmstadt: 1990.
Plotinos. Plotini Opera (Editio Minor,ed. by Paul Henry and Hans-Rudolf Schwyzer,Scriptorum Classicorum Biblitheca Oxoniensis)3 Vols. Oxford: 1987.
Proclus. Commentaire sur le Timée (Fr.,tr. et notes par A.J.Festugiere) 5Vols.(the author has received only IV. & V.) Paris: 1968.
Ritter,Constantin. Neue Untersuchungen ueber Platon. Muenchen: 1910.
--- Die Kerngedanken der platonischen Philosophie. Muenchen: 1931.
Robin,Leon. La pensée grecque et les origines de l''esprit scientifique. Paris: 1923.
Ross,Sir W.D. Aristotle’s Metaphysics. 2 vol. Oxford: 1924.
--- Plato''s Theory of Ideas. Oxford: 1951.
Sachs,Eva. Die Fünf Platonischen Koerper (1976 repr.). Berlin: 1917.
Schuhl,Pierre-Maxime La Fabulation platonicienne. Paris: 1968.
Souilhe,Joseph Étude sur le terme DYNAMIS dans les dialogues de Platon. Paris: 1919.
Stenzel, J. Zahl und Gestalt bei Platon und Aristoteles. Kiel, 1924.
--- Kleine Schriften zur griechischen Philosophie. Darmstadt : Wiss. Buchges., 1956.
Szlezák, T. A. Platon und die Schriftlichkeit der Philosophie : Interpretationen zu den frühen und mittleren Dialogen. Berlin : de Gruyter, 1985.
--- Platon Lesen. Stuttgart-Bad Cannstatt : Frommann-Holzboog, 1993.
Taylor,Alfred Edward Varia Socratica. Oxford: 1911.
--- Plato the Man and His Work (repr.). New York: 1959.
Tennemann, Wilhelm Gottlob System der Platonischen Philosophie, 4 Bde. Leipzig, 1791.
Timaeus Locrus. De Natura Mundi et Animae.(Editio Major,trad. test. Gr.text Dt. tr. by Walter Marg). Leiden: 1972.new window
Totok,Wilhelm. Handbuch fuer die Geschichte der Philosophie . II.Bde. (Bibliography of Plato in I.Bd.,pp146-212). Frankfurt: 1964.
Überweg, F. & Flashar, H. Grundriss der Geschichte der Philosophie, Die Philosophie der Antike. Sog. Neue Ueberweg. Schwabe: 1994- .
Vernant,Jean-Pierre Mythe et Pensée chez les grecs. Paris: 1990.
von Arnim, Hans Stoicorum veterum fragmenta. Ed. stereotypa ed. primae. Stutgardiae : Teubner, 1904.
--- Platos Jugenddialoge und die Entstehungszeit des Phaidros. Leipzig ; Berlin : Teubner, 1914.
Wilamowitz-Moerllendorf,Urlich von. Platon. II.Bde. Berlin: 1920.
Wissowa,Georg.(ed.) Paulys Realencyclopaedie der classischen Altertumswissenschaft.Stuttgart: 1896- .
Zeller,Eduard. Die Philosophie der Griechen in ihrer geschichtlichen Entwicklung. (fuenfte Auflage) 6Bde.,Platon in II.1.,Leipzig: 1922.
Zekl, Hans Günther. Platon Timaios. Gr.- Dt. , hrsg. Übers., mit Einl.und Anm. Vers. von Hans Günther Zekl. Hamburg:Felix Meiner Verlag, 1992.
--- Aristoteles Organon. Bd. 1 Topik, 1997. Bd. 2 Kategorien, Hermeneutik, 1998. Bd. 3/4 Erste Analytik ; Zweite Analytik, 1998.Gr.- Dt. , hrsg. Übers., mit Einl.und Anm. Vers. von Hans Günther Zekl. Hamburg: Felix Meiner, 1997-1998.
Ziegler,K. & Sontheimer,W. & Gaertner,H.(Hrsg.). Der Kleine Pauly. 5Bde. Muenchen: 1979.
 
 
 
 
第一頁 上一頁 下一頁 最後一頁 top
:::
無相關著作
 
QR Code
QRCODE