壓迫與解放：美國種族主義中的認同政治(下)__臺灣人文及社會科學引文索引資料庫

:::

詳目顯示

第 1 筆 / 總合 1 筆

/1頁

來源文獻資料
摘要
外文摘要
引文資料

題名：	壓迫與解放：美國種族主義中的認同政治(下)
書刊名：	成大法學
作者：	李佳玟
作者(外文)：	Lee, Chia-wen
出版日期：	2004
卷期：	8
頁次：	頁109-155
主題關鍵詞：	國家認同；種族主義；美國刑事正義；多元文化主義；文化辯護；National identity；Racism；American criminal justice；Multiculturalism；Cultural defense
原始連結：	連回原系統網址
相關次數：	被引用次數:期刊(3) 博士論文(0) 專書(0) 專書論文(2) 排除自我引用:1 共同引用:1 點閱:71

美國人一向自豪其擁有民主、自由、平等的傳統，美國亦以這些自由主義的價值作為其獨特的國家認同。然而，在現實上，美國人卻無法否認，該國歷史上對待少數民族的方式，踐踏這個國家所自豪的「美國傳統」或「美國精神」。對於美國國家認同與種族主義的關係，一般認為：美國歷史上對於少數民族的歧視與壓迫，是部分美國人背棄美國精神的結果。在這類解釋裡，美國國家認同是道德無暇的，與少數民族一樣，都是種族主義傷害的對象。本文綜合法學與歷史學的研究方式，針對美國刑事司法體制對於弱勢族群之處置，探索美國國家認同、種族主義與司法正義之間的關係。本文發現：美國國家認同在種族問題上扮演曖昧的角色。一方面，在美國歷史中，國家認同經常成為種族主義的同義詞。透過對於正義與犯罪之定義的影響，國家認同成為壓迫少數民族的合理化依據。然而在另一方面，美國國家認同中的自由、平等等價值，亦是弱勢民族藉以反抗種族壓迫的利器。弱勢者要求主流社會必須依據美國精神，給予自由的保護，以及平等的尊重與待遇。換言之，美國的國家認同在種族議題上，同時具有壓迫性與解放性。即便在強調多元文化的今日，依然維持這樣的曖昧狀況。

以文找文

Abstract America is widely recognized to be founded on liberal values. Nevertheless, in reality, there has been a systematic denial of these values in the American history, particularly in cases involving racial minorities. A conventional interpretation is that racist sentiments had overcome the conscience of Americans and caused the deviation of American national identity. Under this interpretation, the American national identity is morally innocent, standing squarely in opposition to racism. This paper is intended to demonstrate that, in the American history, American national identity had been standing firmly with racism. State-sponsored forms of national identity historically helped to distinguish members from others, and dictated how internal others (racially and culturally) were managed. But at the same time, American national identity was used by minorities to fight racism. Through defining crime and justice, the multidimensional American national identity has in fact performed substantial but ambiguous influences on the race issues even in the era of multiculturalism.

以文找文

期刊論文
1.	Alaimo, Stacy(2000)。Multiculturalism and Epistemic Rupture: The Vanishing Acts of Guillermo Gomez-Pena and Alfredo Vea Jr.。Melus，25(2)，163-185。
2.	Alfieri, Anthony V.(1997)。Book Review: Black and White。California Law Review，85，1647-1686。
3.	Asumah, Seth N.、Bradley, Matthew Todd(2001)。Making Sense of U.S. Immigration Policy and Multicultuialism。Western Journal of Black Studies，25(2)，82-92。
4.	Chiu, Daina C.(1994)。The Cultural Defense: Beyond Exclusion, Assimilation, and Guilty Liberalism。California Law Review，82，1053-1125。
5.	Dussias, Allison M.(1997)。Ghost Dance and Holy Ghost: The Echoes of Nineteenth-Century Christianization Policy in Twentieth-Century Native American Free Exercise Cases。Stanford Law Review，49，773-852。
6.	Gaynes, Elizabeth A.(1993)。The Urban Criminal Justice System: Where Young + Black + Male = Probable Cause。Fordham Urban Law Journal，20，621-640。
7.	Harris, Angela P.(2000)。Equality Trouble: Sameness and Difference in Twentieth-Century Race Law。California Law Review，88，1923-2015。
8.	Inniss, Lolita K. Buckner(1999)。Tricky Magic: Blacks as Immigrants and the Paradox of Foreignness。DePaul Law Review，49，85-137。
9.	Johnson, Sheri Lynn.(1988)。Unconscious Racism And The Criminal Law。Cornell Law Review，73，1016-1037。
10.	Kaczorowski, Robert J.(1986)。Revolutionary Constitutionalism In The Era Of The Civil War And Reconstruction。New York University Law Review，61，863-970。
11.	Kaczorowski, Robert J.(1987)。To Begin the Nation Anew: Congress, Citizenship, and Civil Rights after the Civil War。American Historical Review，92(1)，45-68。
12.	Kennedy, Randall L.(1988)。Mccleskey v. Kemp: Race, Capital Punishment, and the Supreme Court。Harvard Law Review，101，1388-1443。
13.	Lam, Anh T.(1993)。Culture As A Defense: Preventing Judicial Bias Against Asians And Pacific Islanders。Asian American Pacific Islands Law Journal，1，49-68。
14.	李佳玟(20030600)。Nation Building and American Criminal Justice。歐美研究，33(2)，235-290。
15.	Lyman, John C.(1986)。Cultural Defense: Viable Doctrine or Wishful Thinking?。Criminal Justice Journal，9，87-117。
16.	Mack, Eric(1996)。Ugly Ethnic Politics Lie Behind Mask of Trendy Multiculturalisiru。Human Events，52(40)，18。
17.	Maclin, Tracey(1991)。Black and Blue Encounters, -Some Preliminary Thoughts About Fourth Amendment Seizures: Should Race Matter?。Valparaiso University Law Review，26，243-279。
18.	Monsivais, Jose(1997)。A Glimmer Of Hope: A Proposal To Keep The Indian Child Welfare Act Of 1978 Intact。American Indian Law Review，22，1-36。
19.	(1986)。The Cultural Defense in the Criminal Law。Harvard Law Review，99(6)，1293-1311。
20.	Peller, Gary(1990)。Frontier Of Legal Thought III: Race Consciousness。Duke Law Journal，758-847。
21.	Peller, Gary(1992)。Symposium On Race Consciousness And Legal Scholarship: Notes Toward A Postmodern Nationalism。University of Illinois Law Review，1095-102。
22.	Sacks, Valerie L.(1996)。An Indefensible Defense: On The Misuse Of Culture In Criminal Law。Arizona Journal of International and Comparative Law，13，523-550。
23.	Siegel, Reva B.(1997)。Why Equal Protection No Longer Protects: The Evolving Forms of Status-Enforcing State Action。Stanford Law Review，49(5)，1111-1148。
24.	Trende, Sean P.(2000)。Why Modest Proposals Offer the Best Solution for Combating Racial Profiling。Duke Law Journal，50，331-80。
25.	Wallenstein, Peter.(1994)。Freedom: Personal Liberty And Private Law: Race, Marriage, And The Law Of Freedom: Alabama And Virginia, 1860s-1960s。Chicago-Kent Law Review，70，371-437。
26.	Weston, Rose(2001)。Facing the Past, Facing the Future: Applying the Truth Commission Model to the Historic Treatment of Native Americans in the United States。Arizona Journal of International and Comparative Law，18，1017-1059。
27.	Wilkins, David(2000)。An Inquiry Into Indigenous Political Participation: Implications for Tribal Sovereignty。Kansas Journal of Law & Public Policy，9，732-49。
28.	Coleman, Doriane Lambelet(1996)。Individualizing Justice Through Multiculturalism: The Liberals' Dilemma。Columbia Law Review，96(5)，1093-1167。
29.	Harris, David A.(1994)。Factors for Reasonable Suspicion: When Black and Poor Means Stopped and Frisked。Indiana Law Journal，69(3)，659-687。
30.	Huntington, S. P.(1997)。the Erosion of American National Interests。Foreign Affairs，76(5)，28-49。
31.	Karst, Kenneth L.(2000)。Universal Rights and Cultural Pluralism: The Bonds of American Nationhood。Cardozo Law Review，21，1141-1182。
32.	Sarat, Austin、Simon, Jonathan(2001)。Beyond Legal Realism?: Cultural Analysis, Cultural Studies, and the Situation of Legal Scholarship。Yale Journal of Law & the Humanities，13，3-32。
33.	Volpp, Leti(1994)。(Mis)Identifying Culture: Asian Women and the ''Cultural Defense''。Harvard Women's Law Journal，17，57-101。
34.	Hall, Stuart(19891000)。Ethnicity: Identity and difference。Radical America，23(4)，9-20。

會議論文
1.	Ashbee, Eddie(2002)。Being American? Representations of National Identity。The 2002 British Association for American Studies Annual Conference，Political Studies Association (會議日期: 04/05-04/08)。

圖書
1.	Delgado, Richard(1995)。Critical Race Theory: The Cutting Edge。Temple University Press。
2.	Deveaux, M.(2000)。Cultural Pluralism and Dilemmas of Justice。Ithaca：Cornell University Press。
3.	Lowe, Lisa(1996)。Immigrant acts: On Asian American cultural politics。Duke University Press。
4.	Aiibinder, Tyler Gregory(1992)。Nativism and Slavery: The Northern Know Nothings and the Politics of the 1850's。New York：Oxford University Press。
5.	Beckett, Katherine(1997)。Making Crime Pay: Law and Order in Contemporary American Politics。New York：Oxford University Press。
6.	Bell, Derrick(1992)。Faces at The Bottom of the Well : The Permanence of Racism。New York：BasicBooks。
7.	Bernstein, Richard(1994)。Dictatorship of Virtue: Multiculturalism, Diversity, and the American Future。New York：A.A. Knopf。
8.	Cruse, Harold(1967)。The Crisis of the Negro Intellectual。New York：Morrow。
9.	Dinnerstein, Leonard、Nichols, Roger L.、Reimers, David M.(1996)。Natives and Strangers : A Multicultural History of Americans。New York：Oxford University Press。
10.	Dudziak, Mary(2000)。War Civil Rights: Race and the Image of American Democracy。Princeton, N J：Princeton University Press。
11.	Foner, Eric(1995)。Free Soil Free Labor. Free Men: The Ideology of the Republican Party Before the Civil War。Oxford：New York：Oxford University Press。
12.	Friedman, Lawrence(1993)。Crime and Punishment in American History。New York：BasicBooks。
13.	Garland, David(2001)。The Culture of Control: Crime and Social Order in Late Modernity。Oxford：Clarendon。
14.	Grant, Susan-Mary(2000)。North over South: Northern Nationalism and American Identity in the Antebellum Era。Lawrence：University Press of Kansas。
15.	Hing, Bill Ong(1997)。To Be an American: Cultural Pluralism and the Rhetoric of Assimilation。New York：New York University Press。
16.	Jacobs, James B.、Potter, Kimberly(2000)。Hate Crimes: Criminal Law & Identity Politics。Oxford University Press。
17.	Jordan, Winthrop D.(1968)。White over Black: American Attitudes toward the Negro, 1550-1812。Virginia：University of North Carolina Press。
18.	Knobel, Dale T.(1986)。Paddy and the Republic: Ethnicity and Nationality in Antebellum。Middletown, Conn：Scranton, Pa.：Wesleyan University Press：Harper & Row。
19.	Lind, Michael(1995)。The Next American Nation: The New Nationalism and the Fourth American Revolution。New York：Free Press。
20.	Mann, Arthur(1979)。The One and The Many: Reflections on the American Identity。Chicago：University of Chicago Press。
21.	Oshinsky, David M.(1996)。Worse Than Slavery: Parchman Farm and the Ordeal of Jim Crow Justice。New York：Free Press。
22.	Pearce, Roy Harvey(1965)。Savagism and Civilization: A Study of the Indian and the American Mind。Baltimore：Johns Hopkins Press。
23.	Ringer, Benjamin B.(1983)。"We the People" and Others: Duality and America's Treatment of Its Racial Minorities。New York：Tavistock Publications。
24.	Schlesinger, Arthur M. Jr.(1992)。The Disuniting of America。New York：Norton。
25.	Ward, W. Peter(2002)。White Canada Forever: Popular Attitudes and Public Policy toward Orientals in British Columbia。McGill-Queen's University Press。
26.	Washbum, Wilcomb E.(1973)。The American Indian and the United States: A Documentary History。New York：Random House。
27.	Barry, B. M.(2001)。Culture and Equality: An Egalitarian Critique of Multiculturalism。Cambridge, MA：Harvard University Press。
28.	Dower, John W.(1986)。War Without Mercy: Race and Power in the Pacific War。New York：Pantheon Books。
29.	Higham, John(1988)。Strangers in The Land : Patterns of American Nativism, 1860-1925。New Brunswick, N.J：Rutgers University Press。
30.	King, Desmond S.(2000)。Making Americans: Immigration. Race, and the Origins of the Diverse Democracy。Cambridge, Mass：Harvard University Press。
31.	Melzer, Arthur M.、Weinberger, Jerry、Zinman, M. Richard(1998)。Multiculturalism and American Democracy。Lawrence, Kan：University Press of Kansas。
32.	Miller, Stuart Creighton(1969)。The Unwelcome Immigrant: The American Image of the Chinese, 1785-1882。University of California Press。
33.	Musto, David F.(1999)。The American Disease: Origins of Narcotic Control。New York：Oxford University Press。
34.	Renshon, Stanley A.(2001)。One America?: Political Leadership, National Identity, and the Dilemmas of Diversity。Washington, D.C.：Georgetown University Press。
35.	Schaefer, Richard T.(2000)。Racial and Ethnic Groups。New Jersey：Prentice-Hall, Inc。
36.	Schmidt, Alvin J.(1997)。America's Fight for Its Soul in the Menace of Multiculturalism-Trojan Horse in America。Westport, Conn：Praeger。
37.	Neumann, Iver B.(1999)。Uses of the Other: the "East" in European Identity Formation。Minneapolis：University of Minnesota Press。
38.	Crenshaw, Kimberle、Thomas, Kendall、Gotanda, Neil、Peller, Gary(1995)。Critical race theory: The key writings that formed the movement。The New Press。
39.	Takaki, Ronald T.(1993)。A Different Mirror: A History of Multicultural America。New York：Boston：Little, Brown and Company。
40.	Smith, Anthony D.(1991)。National Identity。Reno, NV：University of Nevada Press。
41.	Glazer, Nathan(1997)。We Are All Multiculturalists Now。Cambridge, Massachusetts：Harvard University Press。
42.	Anderson, Benedict(1991)。Imagined Communities: Reflections on the Origin and Spread of Nationalism。Verso。
43.	Rhea, Joseph Tilden(1997)。Race Pride and the American Identity。Cambridge, Mass：Harvard University Press。
44.	Kymlicka, Will(1995)。Multicultural Citizenship: A Liberal Theory of Minority Rights。Clarendon Press。

其他
1.	American Social History Project(2003)。Some Reasons for Chinese Exclusion: Meat vs. Rice, American Manhood against Asiatic Coolieism. Which Shall Survive?，City University of New York, Graduate Center and the Center for History and New Media, George Mason University.。，http://historymatters.gmu.edU/d/5035/， 2003/05/26。
2.	American Social History Project(2003)。Eye on the East: Labor Calls for Ban on Chinese Immigration，City University of New York， Graduate Center and the Center for Histoiy and New Media, George Mason University。，http://historymatters.gmu.edU/d/5035/， 2003/05/26。
3.	Baker, Sean(2003)。American Nativism, 1830-1845, The American Religious Experience，West Virginia University Department of History。，http://are.as.wvu.edu/bakerhtm， 2003/05/26。
4.	Emancipation Proclamation(2003)。Britannica Student Encyclopedia 2003 Encyclopaedia Britannica Online，http://search.ebxom/ebi/article?eu=296031， 2003/05/26。
5.	Know-Nothing Party(2003)。Encyclopaedia Britannica，http://search.eb.com/eb/article?eu=46877， 2003/04/23。
6.	(2003)。Latter-day Saints, Church of Jesus Christ -History，http://www.encyclopedia.com/html/section/LattrdaCh_History.asp， 2003/05/26。
7.	Schwarz, Benjamin(1995)。The Diversity Myth，http://www.theatlantic.com/politics/foreign/divers.htm。
8.	Waite, Philip A.(2003)。Liberia's History--The American Colonization Society，http://webby.cc.denison.edu/~waite/liberia/history/acs.htm。

圖書論文
1.	Barron, Anne(1993)。The Illusions of the T: Citizenship and the Politics of Identity。Closure or Critique: New Directions in Legal Theory。Edinburg：Edinburg University Press。
2.	Bestor, Authur(1988)。The American Civil War as a Constitutional Crisi。American Law and the Constitutional Order: Historical Perspectives。Cambridge, Mass：Harvard University Press。
3.	Franklin, Benjamin(1905)。Observations: Concerning the Increase of Mankind, Peopling of Countries, Etc。The Writings of Beniamin Franklin。New York：The Macmillan company。
4.	Guibemau, Montserrat(2001)。National Identity and Modernity。Modem Roots: Studies of National Identity。Aldershot; Burlington, VT：Ashgate。
5.	Gutmann, Amy(1992)。[Multiculturalism and the Politics of Recognition: An Essay]Introduction。Multiculturalism and the Politics of Recognition: An Essay。Princeton, N.J.：Princeton University Press。
6.	Higham, John(1999)。The Redifinition of America in the Twentieth Century。German and American Nationalism: A Comparative Perspective。Oxford：New York：Berg。
7.	Holquist, Michael(1999)。Dialogism: Bakhtin and his World。Critical Essays on Mikhail Bakhtin。New York：G.K. Hall。
8.	Koptiuch, Kristin(1996)。Cultural Defense' and Criminological Displacements: Gender, Race, and (Trans)Nation in the Legal Surveillance of U.S. Diaspora Asians。Displacement, Diaspora, and Geographies of Identity。Durahm & London：Duke University Press。
9.	Mouffe, Chantal(1995)。Democratic Politics and the Question of Identity。The Identity in Question。New York：Routledge。
10.	Osumi, Megumi Dick(1982)。Asians and California’s Anti-Miscegenation Laws。Asian and Pacific American Experiences: Women's Perspectives。Minneapolis: Asian/Pacific American Learning Resource Center and General College, University of Minnesota。
11.	Sarat, Austin、Keams, Thomas R.(1999)。Responding to the Demands of Difference: An Introduction。Cultural Pluralism, Identity Politics, and the Law。Ann Arbor, Mich：University of Michigan Press。
12.	Smith, Anthony D.(2001)。Interpretations of National Identity。Modem Roots: Studies of National Identity。Aldershot; Burlington, VT：Ashgate。
13.	Vecoli Rudolph J.(2000)。[Gale encyclopedia of multicultural America]Introduction。Gale encyclopedia of multicultural America。Detroit：Gale Group。
14.	Taylor, Charles(1992)。The Politics of Recognition。Multiculturalism and the Politics of Recognition: An Essay。Princeton, NJ：Princeton University Press。

推文
推薦
引用網址
引用嵌入語法
轉寄

top

:::

相關期刊
相關論文
相關專書
相關著作
熱門點閱

1.	美國“多元文化主義”的困境及理論重構
2.	兜口兜面的多元文化主義：香港菲律賓移工重奪公共空間和公民權運動
3.	遷移的家園：論《密西西比的馬薩拉》之印度離散再現
4.	族群、文化與認同：連鎖關係的再檢視
5.	被害者認同與刑事政策
6.	美國國家認同的新實驗
7.	女性犯罪責任的敘事建構--以鄧如雯殺夫案為例
8.	壓迫與解放：美國種族主義中的認同政治(上)
9.	Nation Building and American Criminal Justice
10.	美、澳多元文化教育在歷史課程中實踐的比較--種族、文化、認同相關課題的探討

1.	防制組織犯罪法律規範之研究
2.	台灣族群問題的探源與進路

1.	刑法秩序與多元文化：以東亞刑事法院為中心的考察
2.	多元文化主義之下的民族認同與國家認同
3.	遷移的家園 : 論《密西西比的馬薩拉》之印度離散再現
4.	我國弱勢族群參政與自治之憲法基礎

無相關著作

1.	Die Familienrechtliche Rezeption des Schweizerischen Zivilgesetzbuches in der Türkei und die Kulturkonflikte
2.	Die Schuld des Straftäters--Psychisches Faktum oder Normative Zuschreibung?
3.	公民參與刑事審判之上訴審量刑審查問題--日本最高法院二○一四年七月二十四日第一小法庭判決研析
4.	論專有部分、共有部分與約定專用部分之判斷--以屋頂突出物與地下室停車位為例評最高法院一○一年度臺上字第六四三號民事判決
5.	客觀淨額所得原則的憲法基礎以及界限
6.	再論內線交易持有說與利用說--從最高法院九十四年度臺上字第一四三三號刑事判決(訊碟案)談起
7.	刑罰目的與刑法體系--論Günther Jakobs功能主義刑法體系中的罪責
8.	著作技術保護措施之互通性之法律研究
9.	從哲學基礎論智慧財產權體系下人格權之功能
10.	再審程序的再省思--以挪威及美國北卡羅來納州的法制為借鏡
11.	日本の特許権侵害訴訟の最近の動向
12.	論親權及監護對未成年人財產之作用--以大理院所建構之子女財產管理法制為例
13.	聯合國安理會決議在歐盟中之效力與執行
14.	成本分攤協議適用於我國之稅務議題探討
15.	公法契約爭議仲裁判斷之撤銷訴訟--以管轄法院和法院審理基準為中心

QR Code

臺灣人文及社會科學引文索引資料庫系統

詳目顯示

臺灣人文及社會科學引文索引資料庫