:::

詳目顯示

回上一頁
題名:「事前立法」對國家履行人權義務之必要性--以國家規制權與國家契約中之穩定條款為核心
書刊名:東吳法律學報
作者:王自雄
作者(外文):Wang, Tzu-hsiung
出版日期:2010
卷期:22:2
頁次:頁47-78
主題關鍵詞:人權人權立法國家之規制權穩定條款凍結條款經濟平衡條款國家契約公民與政治權利國際公約經濟社會文化國際公約Human rightsHuman rights legislationState's right to regulateStabilization clausesFreezing clauseEconomic equilibrium clausesState contractsInternational covenant on civil and political rightsICCPRInternational covenant on economic, social and cultural rightsICESCR
原始連結:連回原系統網址new window
相關次數:
  • 被引用次數被引用次數:期刊(1) 博士論文(1) 專書(0) 專書論文(0)
  • 排除自我引用排除自我引用:0
  • 共同引用共同引用:13
  • 點閱點閱:40
國家保障個人所享有之人權不受侵害,屬於人權義務在垂直法律關係上的具體表現。國家透過立法與行政措施,對個人行為進行規制,則是國家履行人權義務的主要方式。疏於或未進行相關之立法與行政措施,而構成的消極不作為,即屬於國家因應作為而不作為,而違反其在國際法上的人權義務。然而,國家與他國締結之國際投資協定,以及與外國投資人就投資事項所簽訂的國家契約,卻往往希望透過待遇標準或穩定條款的適用,希望限縮或排除地主國規制權的行使。另一方面,地主國也希望吸引外人直接投資,以促進其總體經濟發展。就此,本文在簡介人權立法對國家履行人權義務的重要性,以及地主國與外國投資人對穩定條款的立場與期待之後,即從穩定條款的類型與作用出發,分析地主國的人權保障義務在不同的穩定條款下所會受到的影響,以及人權立法在什麼條件下,能夠使地主國在免於人權義務之干擾的同時,又能兼顧國家總體的經濟發展。本文發現,國家在准許外人投資進入之前,其相關人權立法是否完善,是最為關鍵的因素。因此,國家如何透過立法與相關的規範投射,確立人權的規範向度,並利用以人權為規範目的的規制措施,強化人權保障的實效,來理出一條能夠兼顧人權保障與經濟發展的道路,實至關重要。
State’s right to regulate individuals by means of legislation and administrative measures is the main means to fulfill human rights obligations, whereas States provide protection to individuals from violations under vertical human rights law. Failing that, it would constitute a violation of human rights obligations upon States under international law. On the one hand,treatment standards and stabilization clauses in the international investment agreements concluded with other States and State Contract entered into with foreign investors may be used to limit or exclude the application of Host State’s human right legislation. On the other,stabilization clauses, in Host State’s view, be a magnet for foreign direct investments and conducive to macro-economic development. This article, at the outset, introduced the significance of legislation in view of the fulfillment of State’s human rights obligations and the positions and prospects held by Host States and foreign investors on the stabilization clauses. Then,the types and functions of stabilization clauses would be examined to analyze the extent to which Host State’s human rights obligations would have under different ones—namely, freezing clauses and economic equilibrium clauses. And, under what conditions, the ends of fulfillment of human rights obligations and achievement of economic development could be arrived. This article finds that the crucial factor is the maturity of legislation before the establishment of foreign investment. As a result, after the establishment of human rights dimension in the ‘investor-State’ context through State’s pre-established legislation and ‘normative projection, the efficacy of human rights protection could be strengthened, and, most important, States and investors could reap what they had sown—a field grown with fruits of human rights and economic development.
期刊論文
1.Mann, F. A.(1960)。State Contracts and State Responsibility。American Journal of International Law,54(3),572-591。  new window
2.李貴英(20050600)。從契約義務到條約義務--論Salini Costruttori S.p.A. and Italstrade S.p.A. v. the Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan--案管轄權裁定。臺灣國際法季刊,2(2),115-159。new window  延伸查詢new window
3.陳俊仁(20081200)。公司社會責任之國際法實踐--論跨國企業監理套利規範之演繹與規範困境。中華國際法與超國界法評論,4(2),417-476。new window  延伸查詢new window
4.李貴英(2008)。論仲裁條款與穩定條款。月旦法學雜誌,161 期,234-244。new window  延伸查詢new window
5.Asante, S. K. B.(1979)。Stability of contractual relations in the transnational investment process。International and Comparative Law Quarterly,28(3),401-423。  new window
6.Berger, K. P.(2003)。Renegotiation and adaptation of international investment contracts: The role of contract drafters and arbitrators。Vanderbilt Journal of Transnational Law,36(4),1347-1380。  new window
7.Bernardini, P.(2008)。Stabilization and adaptation in oil and gas investments。Journal of World Energy Law & Business,1(1),98-112。  new window
8.Carlston, K. S.(1958)。Concession agreements and nationalization。American Journal of International Law,52(2),260-279。  new window
9.Cheng, T.-H.(2005)。Power, authority and international investment law。American University International Law Review,20(3),465-520。  new window
10.Cotula, L.(2008)。Reconciling regulatory stability and evolution of environmental standards in investment contracts: Towards a rethink of stabilization clauses。Journal of World Energy Law & Business,1(2),158-179。  new window
11.Geiger, R.(1974)。The unilateral change of economic development agreements。International and Comparative Law Quarterly,23(1),73-104。  new window
12.Jiménez de Aréchaga E.(1978)。International law in the past third of a century。Recueil des Cours,159,1-344。  new window
13.Leben, Charles(2003)。La théorie du contrat d’état et l’évolution du droit international des investissements。Recueil des Cours,302,197-386。  new window
14.Redfern, A.(1984)。The arbitration between the government of Kuwait and Aminoil。British Year Book of International Law,55,65-110。  new window
15.Tesón F. R.(1984)。State contracts and oil expropriations: The Aminoil-Kuwait arbitration。Virginia Journal of International Law,24(2),323-358。  new window
16.Waelde, T. W.、Ndi, G.(1996)。Stabilizing international investment commitments: International law versus contract interpretation。Texas International Law Journal,31,216-267。  new window
17.White, R. C. A.(1981)。Expropriation of the Libyan oil concessions: Two conflicting international arbitrations。International and Comparative Law Quarterly,30(1),1-19。  new window
會議論文
1.Cotula, L.(2008)。Regulatory takings, stabilization clauses and sustainable development。Paris。  new window
圖書
1.Sornarajah, M.(2004)。The international law on foreign investment。Cambridge:Cambridge University Press。  new window
2.Sornarajah, M.(1986)。The Pursuit of Nationalized Property。Dordrecht:Martinus Nijhoff Publishers。  new window
3.Morgera, Elisa(2009)。Corporate Accountability in International Environmental Law。Oxford University Press。  new window
4.Henkin, Louis(1995)。International Law: Politics and Values。Dordrecht:Martinus Nijhoff Publishers。  new window
5.Alston, P. Ed..(2005)。People’s rights。New York。  new window
6.Amnesty International.(2003)。Human rights on the line: The Baku-Tbilisi-Ceyhan pipeline project。London。  new window
7.Mann, H.(2008)。International investment agreements, business and human rights: Key issues and opportunities。Manitoba, Canada。  new window
8.Shemberg, A.(2008)。Stabilization clauses and human rights。Washington, DC。  new window
圖書論文
1.KOSKENNIEMI, M.(2006)。What is international law for?。INTERNATIONAL LAW。  new window
2.鄧衍森(2006)。法治與人權:兼論我國憲法解釋上之應用。法治與人權。台北:新學林。new window  延伸查詢new window
 
 
 
 
第一頁 上一頁 下一頁 最後一頁 top
:::
無相關著作
 
QR Code
QRCODE