:::

詳目顯示

回上一頁
題名:Wind Farms and Community Engagement in Australia: A Critical Analysis for Policy Learning
書刊名:East Asian Science, Technology and Society: An International Journal
作者:Hindmarsh, Richard
出版日期:2010
卷期:4:4
頁次:頁541-563
主題關鍵詞:Wind farmsCommunity engagementAustraliaPolicy learning
原始連結:連回原系統網址new window
相關次數:
  • 被引用次數被引用次數:期刊(1) 博士論文(0) 專書(0) 專書論文(0)
  • 排除自我引用排除自我引用:1
  • 共同引用共同引用:7
  • 點閱點閱:43
Abstract In late 2007, after signing the Kyoto Protocol, a new Australian federal government committed to generating 20% of Australia's electricity from renewable energy by 2020, for a transition to a low-carbon economy. With wind energy the most viable technology for such expansion, little recognition, however, was paid to intense social conflict surrounding wind farm location. By 2006, inadequate community engagement had emerged as the primary governance issue underpinning a host of issues that local communities faced with the prospect of hosting wind farms. Acknowledged by all Australian governments as an issue to address for effective renewable energy transitions, current policy responses addressing community engagement are analysed for their adequacy to ensure such transitions in a context of democratic legitimacy and fairness and the issues of place-based local communities. Analysis is informed by comparative cross-jurisdictional policy learning analysis featuring European participatory developments; policy analysis of current Australian governmental policy responses; and prior narrative analysis of the behavioural rationalities (the underlying beliefs, attitudes and perceptions) that inform the qualifications and place-protective actions about wind farm location of local stakeholders at the forefront of wind farm contestation: landscape guardian groups. The conclusion is that current policy responses with regard to community engagement, which encourage a largely inform-consult participatory engagement approach, are inadequate. A more promising approach is the collaborative approach, which can also facilitate social mapping of local community qualifications and boundaries about wind farm location alongside technical mapping of wind resources. This is needed to identify the most socially, economically and technically viable locations to locate wind farms to ensure effective renewable energy transitions.
期刊論文
1.Wynne, Brian(1993)。Public uptake of science: a case for institutional reflexivity。Public Understanding of Science,2(4),321-337。  new window
2.Barnes, M.、Newman, J.、Knops, A.、Sullivan, H.(2003)。Constituting 'the public' in public participation。Public Administration,81(2),379-399。  new window
3.Beierle, T.、Konisky, D.(2000)。Values, conflict, and trust in participatory environmental planning。Journal of Policy Analysis and Management,19(4),587-602。  new window
4.Bell, D.、Gray, T.、Haggett, C.(2005)。The ‘social gap’ in wind farm siting decisions: Explanations and policy responses。Environmental Politics,14(4),460-477。  new window
5.Cantrill, J.、Senecah, S.(2001)。Using the ‘sense of self-in-place’ construct in the context of environmental policy-making and landscape planning。Environmental Science & Policy,4,185-203。  new window
6.Chen, D. -S.、Deng, C. -Y.(2007)。Interaction between citizens and experts in public deliberation: A case study of consensus conferences in conferences in Taiwan。East Asian Science, Technology and Society: An International Journal,1,77-91。  new window
7.Colclough, G.、Sitaraman(2005)。Community and social capital: What is the difference?。Sociological Inquiry,75(4),474-496。  new window
8.Connelly, S.、Richardson, T.(2004)。Exclusions: The necessary difference between ideal and practical consensus。Journal of Environmental Planning and Management,47(1),3-17。  new window
9.Devine-Wright, P.(2005)。Beyond NIMBYism: Towards an integrated framework for understanding public perceptions of wind energy。Wind Energy,8(2),125-139。  new window
10.Devine-Wright, P.(2009)。Rethinking NIMBYism: The role of place attachment and place identity in explaining place-protection action。Journal of Community and Applied Social Psychology,19(6),426-441。  new window
11.Diesendorf, M.(2006)。Wind power in Australia。International Journal of Environmental Studies,63(6),765-776。  new window
12.Dolowitz, D.、Marsh, D.(2000)。Learning from abroad。Governance,13(1),5-23。  new window
13.Edwards, P.、Hindmarsh, R.、Mercer, H.、Bond, M.、Rowland, A.(2008)。A three-stage evaluation of a deliberative event on climate change and transforming energy。Journal of Public Deliberation,4(1)。  new window
14.Ellis, G.、Cowell, R.、Warren, C.、Strachan, P.、Szarka, J.、Hadwin, R.(2009)。Wind power: Is there a‘planning problem ’ ? Expanding wind power: A problem of planning, or of perception? The problems of planning--A developer’s perspective; Wind farms: More respectful and open debate needed, not less; Planning: Problem ‘Carrier’ or problem ‘source’ ? ‘Innovative’ wind power planning。Planning Theory & Practice,10(4),523-547。  new window
15.Fischer, F.(2006)。Participatory governance as deliberative empowerment: The cultural politics of discursive space。American Review of Public Administration,36(1),19-40。  new window
16.Geva-May, I.(2002)。Comparative studies in public administration and public policy。Public Management Review,4(3),275-290。  new window
17.Graham, J. B.、Stephenson, J. R.、Smith, I. J.(2009)。Public perceptions of wind energy developments: Case studies from New Zealand。Energy Policy,37(9),3348-3357。  new window
18.Gross, C.(2007)。Community perspectives of wind energy in Australia: The application of a justice and community fairness framework to increase social acceptance。Energy Policy,35,2727-2736。  new window
19.Hamdouch, A.、Depret, M. -H.(2010)。Policy integration strategy and the development of the ‘green economy’: Foundations and implementation patterns。Journal of Environmental Planning and Management,53(4),473-490。  new window
20.Hindmarsh, R.、Du Plessis, R.(2008)。The new civic geography of life sciences governance: Perspectives from Australia and New Zealand。New Genetics and Society,27(3),175-180。  new window
21.Hindmarsh, R.、Matthews, C.(2008)。Deliberative speak at the turbine face: Community engagement, windfarms, and renewable energy transitions, in Australia。Environmental Policy and Planning,10(3),217-232。  new window
22.Hophmayer-Tokich, S.、Krozer, Y.(2008)。Public participation in rural area water management: Experiences from the North Sea countries in Europe。Water International,33(2),243-257。  new window
23.Jobert, A.、Laborgne, P.、Mimler, S.(2007)。Local acceptance of wind energy: Factors of success identified in French and German case studies。Wind Energy,10,2751-2760。  new window
24.Jones, C.、Eiser, R.(2010)。Understanding ‘local’ opposition to wind development in the UK: How big is a backyard。Energy Policy,38,3106-3117。  new window
25.Koehler, B.、Koontz, T.(2008)。Citizen participation in collaborative watershed partnerships。Environmental Management,41,143-154。  new window
26.Lund, H.(2000)。Choice awareness: The development of technological and institutional choice in the public debate of Danish energy planning。Journal of Environmental Policy & Planning,2,249-259。  new window
27.McClymont, K.、O’Hare, P.(2008)。‘We’re not NIMBY’s! ’ : Contrasting local protest groups with idealised conceptions of sustainable communities。Local Environment,13(4),321-335。  new window
28.McGurk, B.、Sinclair, A.、Diduck, A.(2006)。An assessment of stakeholder advisory committees in forest management: Case studies from Manitoba, Canada。Society & Natural Resources,19(9),809-826。  new window
29.Melo, M.、Baiocchi, G.(2006)。Deliberative democracy and local governance: Towards a new agenda。International Journal of Urban and Regional Research,30(3),587-600。  new window
30.Messali, E.、Diesendorf, M.(2009)。Potential sites for off-shore wind power in Australia。Wind Engineering,33(4),335-348。  new window
31.Meyer, N. I.(2007)。Learning from wind energy policy in the EU: Lessons from Denmark, Sweden and Spain。European Environment,17(5),347-362。  new window
32.Mulligan, M.、Nadarajah, Y.(2008)。Working on the sustainability of local communities with a ‘community-engaged’ research methodology。Local Environment,13(2),81-94。  new window
33.Nadai, A.(2007)。‘Planning’ , ‘siting’ and the local acceptance of wind power: Some lessons from the French case。Energy Policy,35,2715-2726。  new window
34.Oughto, D.(2008)。Public participation--Potential and pitfalls。Energy & Environment,19(3/4),485-496。  new window
35.Owens, S.、Driffill, L.(2008)。How to change attitudes and behaviours in the context of energy。Energy Policy,36(12),4412-4418。  new window
36.Sullivan, R.、Consideine, M. -L.(2010)。Hastening slowly in the global renewables race154,16-19。  new window
37.Toke, D.(2005)。Explaining wind power planning outcomes: Some findings from a study in England and Wales。Energy Policy,33,1527-1539。  new window
38.Van der Horst, D.(2007)。NIMBY or not? Exploring the relevance of location and the politics of voiced opinions in renewable energy siting controversies。Energy Policy,35(5),2705-2714。  new window
39.Videira, N.、Antunes, P.、Santos, R.、Lobo, G.(2006)。Public and stakeholder participation in European water policy: A critical review of project evaluation processes。European Environment,16,19-31。  new window
40.Wagenet, L.、Pfeffer, M.(2006)。Organizing citizen engagement for democratic environmental planning。Society and Natural Resources,20,801-813。  new window
41.Walker, Gordon、Devine-Wright, Patrick、Hunter, Sue、High, Helen、Evans, Bob(2010)。Trust and community: Exploring the meanings, contexts and dynamics of community renewable energy。Energy Policy,38,2655-2663。  new window
42.Walmsley, D.(2000)。Community, place and cyberspace。Australian Geographer,31(1),5-19。  new window
43.Wawryk, A.(2004)。Planning for wind energy: Controversy over wind farms in coastal Victoria。Australian Journal of Natural Resources Law & Policy,9(1),103-143。  new window
44.Wolsink, M.(2005)。Wind power implementation: The nature of public attitudes: Equity and fairness instead of ‘backyard motives’。Renewable & Sustainable Energy Reviews,11,1188-1207。  new window
45.Wolsink, M.(2006)。theory impedes our understanding: A critique on the persistence of the language of NIMBY。Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers,31,85-91。  new window
46.Wolsink, M.(2007)。Planning of renewables schemes: Deliberative and fair decision-making on landscapes issues instead of reproachful accusations of non-cooperation。Energy Policy,35(5),2692-2704。  new window
47.Zografos, C.、Martinez-Alier, J.(2009)。The politics of landscape value: A case study of wind farm conflict in Catalonia。Environment and Planning A,41,1726-1744。  new window
48.May, Peter J.(1992)。Policy learning and Failure。Journal of Public Policy,12(4),331-354。  new window
49.Inalhan, G.、Finch, E.(2004)。Place attachment and sense of belonging。Facilities,22(5/6),120-128。  new window
50.Chen, Dung-sheng、Wu, Chia-ling(20071200)。Introduction: Public Participation in Science and Technology in East Asia。East Asian Science, Technology and Society,1(1),15-18。new window  new window
51.Clark, F.、Illman, D.(2001)。Dimensions of civic science: Introductory essay。Science Communication,23(1),5-27。  new window
52.Hidalgo, M. C.、Hernández, B.(2001)。Place attachment: Conceptual and empirical questions。Journal of Environmental Psychology,21(3),273-281。  new window
53.Welber, Thomas、Tuler, Seth(2000)。Fairness and Competence in Citizen Participation。Administration & Society,32(5),566-595。  new window
54.Rowe, Gene、Frewer, Lynn J.(2000)。Public Participation Methods: A Framework for Evaluation。Science, Technology & Human Values,25(1),3-29。  new window
55.Jasanoff, Shelia(2004)。Science and Citizenship: A New Synergy。Science and Public Policy,31(2),90-94。  new window
56.Arnstein, Sherry R.(1969)。A ladder of citizen participation。Journal of the American Institute of Planners,35(4),216-224。  new window
57.Pretty, Grace H.、Chipuer, Heather M.、Bramston, Paul(2003)。Sense of place amongst adolescents and adults in two rural australian towns: The discriminating features of place attachment, sense of community and place dependence in relation to place identity。Journal of Environmental Psychology,23(3),273-287。  new window
58.Stedman, Richard C.(2002)。Toward a social psychology of place: Predicting behavior from place-based cognitions, attitude, and identity。Environment and Behavior,34(5),561-581。  new window
59.Fujigaki, Y.(2009)。STS in Japan and East Asia: Governance of science and technology and public engagement。East Asian Science, Technology and Society: An International Journal,3,511-518。  new window
會議論文
1.Bunting, A.、Jenkins, N.(2002)。Environmental conflicts: The Portland wind farm debate。the Environment, Culture and Community Conference。Brisbane:University of Queensland。  new window
學位論文
1.Devlin, E.(2002)。Factors affecting public acceptance of wind turbines in Sweden(碩士論文)。Lund University,Sweden。  new window
圖書
1.Australian Bureau of Agricultural and Resource Economics(2010)。Australian energy resource assessment。Canberra:Commonwealth of Australia。  new window
2.Bunting, A.(2004)。Opposition to wind power: Can it be a catalyst for improving public understanding of energy usage? (Technologies, Publics and Power Conference)。Christchurch:University of Canterbury。  new window
3.Dalton & Dalton(1975)。Community and its relevance to Australian society. An examination of the sociological definition。Canberra:Australian Government Publishing Service。  new window
4.Dovers, S.(2005)。Environmental and sustainability policy: Creation, implementation, evaluation。Annandale:Federation。  new window
5.Ellis, G.、Barry, J.、Robinson, C.(2006)。Renewable energy and discourses of objection: Towards deliberative policy-making: Summary of main findings。Northern Ireland:Queen’s University Belfast。  new window
6.EPHC(2009)。National wind farm development guidelines--public consultation draft。Adelaide:Environmental Protection and Heritage Council。  new window
7.EPHC(20091028)。Best practice guide for wind farms released for comment。Adelaide:Environmental Protection and Heritage Council。  new window
8.EPHC(2010)。National wind farm development guidelines--Draft。Adelaide:Environmental Protection and Heritage Council。  new window
9.EPHC(2008)。Report on the impediments to environmentally and socially responsible wind farm development。Adelaide:Environmental Protection and Heritage Council。  new window
10.Government, A.(2004)。Securing Australia’s energy future。Canberra:AGPS。  new window
11.Government, A.(2006)。National code for windfarms: A discussion paper。Canberra:Department of Environment and Water Resources。  new window
12.Peter, F.(2008)。Democratic legitimacy。UK:Routledge。  new window
13.Tambling, G.、Laver, P.、Oliphant, M.、Stevens, N.(2003)。Renewable opportunities: A review of the renewable energy (Electricity) Act 2000。Australian Greenhouse Office。  new window
14.Rad, Gerhard, von(1965)。Old Testament Theology (2)。Old Testament Theology (2)。London。  new window
15.丁紹儀(1957)。東瀛識略。臺灣銀行經濟研究室。  延伸查詢new window
其他
1.Babbage, J.(20100108)。Wind farms: Generating power and jobs?,http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/business/8443865.stm., 20100212。  new window
2.Campbell, I.(20060331)。Campbell calls for national wind farm agreement,Canberra, Department of Environment and Heritage, Commonwealth Government of Australia。  new window
3.Cohen, I.(20091216)。Inquiry into rural wind farms, media release,NSW Legislative Council。  new window
4.ESAA(20071030)。ALP interim renewable energy target。  new window
5.Formby, J.(2009)。Submission to GP Standing Committee No 5,Inquiry into Rural Wind Farms。  new window
6.Hindmarsh, R.(20091030)。Effective transitions for renewable energy & beyond: Community Engagement and Wind Farms. Submission to the Parliament of New South Wales General Purpose Standing Committee No. 5 Rural Wind Farms Inquiry,http://www.parliament.nsw.gov.au/Prod/parlment/committee.nsf/0/C19EBAF2D3FDBDE9CA257664000EBA27, 20100210。  new window
7.NSW(201006)。NSW Government response: rural wind farms。  new window
8.NSW(2009)。Final report, rural wind farms,Sydney:NSW Legislative Council。  new window
9.Victoria(2009)。Inquiry into the Approvals Process for Renewable Energy Projects in Victoria,http://www.parliament.vic.gov.au/enrc/inquiries/article/870.。  new window
圖書論文
1.Cavaye, J.(2004)。Governance and Community Engagement: The Australian Experience。Participatory Governance: Planning, Conflict Mediation and Public Decision-Making in Civil Society。Ashgate Publish Co.。  new window
 
 
 
 
第一頁 上一頁 下一頁 最後一頁 top