治理理論與國家職能的辯證：英國觀點__臺灣人文及社會科學引文索引資料庫

:::

詳目顯示

第 1 筆 / 總合 1 筆

/1頁

來源文獻資料
摘要
外文摘要
引文資料

題名：	治理理論與國家職能的辯證：英國觀點
書刊名：	政治科學論叢
作者：	陳嫈郁
作者(外文)：	Chen, René Ying-yu
出版日期：	2012
卷期：	53
頁次：	頁1-52
主題關鍵詞：	方法論；國家理論；治理理論；治理網絡；後設治理；國家職能；Methodology；State theory；Governance theory；Governance network；Meta-governance；State capacity
原始連結：	連回原系統網址
相關次數：	被引用次數:期刊(5) 博士論文(2) 專書(0) 專書論文(0) 排除自我引用:3 共同引用:0 點閱:54

近年來，台灣對於治理相關理論的議題在學術界與實務界幾乎是全盤性的接受。亦即是在政策初始點即把治理視為一種民主政體既定的發展路徑與模式，鮮少回溯到治理理論在規範性國家理論、政治理論與方法論的爭辯上來討論。然而，西方國家尤其是英國與歐盟地區卻已悄悄的興起另一股對於「治理」概念的反思與批判浪潮。因此，本文試圖從解構規範性國家理論的方式，以回歸到理論根源、權力機制與方法論的層次討論「治理」典範，並論證全球化與民主化中的治理模式與國家職能並不需要建立在國家是否已被其他權力結構與行動者侵蝕而「空洞化」的兩難辯證上。本文首先以分析治理理論根源為起點，論述新多元與自由貨幣主義、傅科主義與「可治理性」、季登斯的「內省現代性」與哈伯瑪斯的參與及審議式民主等四大理論對整個治理理論典範發展與變遷的影響。其次，剖析三波治理理論建構的假設與權力機制，驗證治理理論本質上即是一種具有時空獨特性的工具性國家理論。第三、進而針對治理理論的假設與機制提出批判，指出其實踐範圍的限制與可能缺失。最後，本文主張政策規劃與實踐在引用「治理」典範時，需要先釐清該政策層次與屬性以及執行政策所需的國家職能差異，始能有效達到政策目標。

以文找文

In recent years, studies on governance in Taiwan have universally accepted the network-based model of governance and its predetermined development path following globalization and democratization. At both academic and practical levels, little of the existing empirical literature calls into question the theoretical propositions that set out from the normative state theory, political theory, power theory (institutions and mechanisms) and methodological arguments. As such, there are two purposes of this article. First, the article will anatomize ”governance” according to its theoretical origins, mechanisms, and methodological inferences. By doing so, it will help to clarify the concept of governance and verify the state hollowing-out dilemmas in globalization and democracy. Second, at an empirical level, drawing on the insights from ”state-centric meta-governance,” this article suggests that the employment of governance-related theories in any particular spatio-temporal fix should take the character and level of policy seriously. The article also attempts to clarify the differentiated state capacities needed for warfare, workfare and welfare policies. Concerns with contingency between the global environment, form of capitalism, and civil society are emphasized.

以文找文

期刊論文
1.	Lash, S.(2007)。Power after Hegemony: Cultural Studies in Mutation。Theory, Culture & Society，24(3)，55-78。
2.	Klij, Erik Hans、Chris, Skelcher(2007)。Democracy and Governance Networks: Compatible or Not?。Public Administration，85(3)，587-608。
3.	Marsh, David、Smith, Martin J.(2000)。Understanding Policy Networks: toward a Dialectical Approach。Political Studies，48(1)，4-21。
4.	Skelcher, C.、Mathur, N.、Smith, M.。The Public Governance of Collaborative Space: Discourse, Design and Democracy。Public Administration，183(3)，573-596。
5.	Jessop, Bob(1997)。Capitalism and its future: Remarks on regulation, government and governance。Review of International Political Economy，4(3)，561-581。
6.	Börzel, T.(2010)。European Governance: Negotiation and Competition in the Shadow of Hierarchy。Journal of Common Market Studies，48(2)，191-219。
7.	Marsh, D.(2011)。The New Orthodoxy: The Differentiated Polity Model。Public Administration，89(1)，32-48。
8.	Agranoff, Robert、McGuire, Michael(2001)。Big Questions in Public Network Management Research。Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory，11(3)，295-326。
9.	O'Toole, Laurence J. Jr.、Meier, Kenneth J.(2004)。Desperately seeking Selznick: Cooptation and the dark side of public management in networks。Public Administration Review，64(6)，681-693。
10.	De Alcantara, C. Hewitt(1998)。Use and Abuses of the Concept of Governance。International Social Science Journal，50(155)，105-113。
11.	Papadopoulos, Yannis(2003)。Cooperative Forms of Governance: Problems of Democratic Accountability in Complex Environments。European Journal of Political Research，42(4)，473-501。
12.	Stillman, R. J. II(1995)。The Refounding Movement in American Public Administration: From "Rabid" Anti-Statism to "Mere" Anti-Statism in the 1990s。Administrative Theory & Praxis，17(1)，29-45。
13.	Weiss, Linda(1995)。Governed Interdependence: Rethinking the Government-Business Relationship in East Asia。The Pacific Review，8(4)，589-616。
14.	Jessop, B.(1993)。Toward a Schumpeterian Workfare State? Preliminary Remarks on Post-Fordist Political Economy。Studies in Political Economy，40，7-39。
15.	Stoker, Gerry(1998)。Governance as Theory: Five Propositions。International Social Science Journal，50(155)，17-28。
16.	Marinetto, Michael(2003)。The Governmentality of Public Administration: Foucault and the Public Sphere。Public Administration，81(3)，621-649。
17.	Börzel, Tanja A.(2011)。Networks: reified metaphor or governance panacea?。Public Administration，89(1)，49-63。
18.	Sørensen, E.、Torfing, J.(2009)。Making governance networks effective and democratic through meta-governance。Public Administration，87(2)，234-258。
19.	Walters, W.(2004)。Some critical notes on 'governance'。Studies in Political Economy，73，27-46。
20.	Bellamy, C.(2011)。The Whitehall Programme and After: Researching Government in Time of Governance。Public Administration，89(1)，78-92。
21.	Kooiman, J.、Jentoft, S.(2009)。Meta-governance: Value, Norms and Principles, and the Making of Hard Choice。Public Administration，87(4)，818-836。
22.	Ryfe, David M.(2005)。Does Deliberative Democracy Work?。Annual Review of Political Science，8(1)，49-71。
23.	Hooghe, Liesbet、Marks, Gary(2003)。Unraveling the Central State, but How? Types of Multi-Level Governance。American Political Science Review，97(2)，233-243。
24.	Rhodes, Robert A. W.(1996)。The New Governance: Governing without Government。Political Studies，44(4)，652-667。
25.	Jessop, Bob(1998)。The rise of governance and the risks of failure: the case of economic development。International Social Science Journal，50(155)，29-45。
26.	Bevir, M.、Rhodes, R. A. W.(2008b)。The Differentiated Polity as Narrative。The British Journal politics & International Relations，10，251-268。
27.	Bevir, M.、Rhodes, R.A.W.(2006)。Interpretive Approaches to British Government and Politics。British Politics，1，84-112。
28.	Bevir, M.(2004)。Governance and Interpretation: What Are the Implications of Post-foundationalism?。Public Administration，79(2)，469-509。
29.	Bevir, M.(2010)。Rethinking Governmentality: Toward Genealogies of Governance。European Journal of Social Theory，13(4)，423-441。
30.	Bevir, M.(2011b)。Public Administration as Storytelling。Public Administration，89(1)，183-195。
31.	Colebatch, H.(2009)。Governance As Conceptual Development in the Analysis of Policy。Critical Policy Studies，3(1)，58-67。
32.	Davies, J. S.(2005)。Local Governance and the Dialectics of Market, Hierarchy and Network: a Conflict Analysis。Policy Studies，26(3)，311-335。
33.	Davies, J. S.(2007)。The Limits of Partnership: an Exit-action Strategy for Local Democratic Inclusion。Political Studies，55(4)，779-800。
34.	Davies, J. S.(2009b)。The Limits of Joined Up Government: Toward a Political Analysis。Public Administration，87(1)，80-96。
35.	Delwaide, J.(2011)。The Return of the State?。European Review，19(1)，69-91。
36.	Downing, K.(1995)。Model or Metaphor? A Critical Review of Policy Network Approach。Political Studies，43(1)，136-158。
37.	Fawcett, P.、Daugbjerg, C.(2012)。Explaining Governance Outcome: Epistemology, Network Governance and Policy Network Analysis。Political Studies Review，10(2)，195-207。
38.	Gains, F.(2011)。Elite Ethnographies: Potential, Pitfalls and Prospects for Getting ‘Up Close and Personal。Public Administration，89(1)，1-20。
39.	Goodwin, M.、Grix, J.(2011)。Bringing Structures Back in: The ‘Governance Narrative’, the ‘Decentred Approach’ and ‘Asymmetrical Network Governance’ in the Education and Sport Policy Communities。Public Administration，89(1)，156-166。
40.	Grindle, Merilee S.(2004)。Good Enough Governance: Poverty Reduction and Reform in Developing Countries。Governance: An International Journal of Policy’Administration, and Institutions，17(4)，525-548。
41.	Hay, C.(2011)。Interpreting Interpretivism Interpreting Interpretations: The New Hermeneutics of Public Administration。Public Administration，89(1)，167-182。
42.	Jessop, B.(2001)。Bringing the State Back In (Yet Again): Reviews, Revision, Rejections, and Redirections。International Review of Sociology，11(2)，149-153。
43.	Jessop, B.(2002c)。Liberalism, Neo-liberalism, and Urban Governance: A State-Theoretical Perspective。Antipode，34(3)，452-472。
44.	Joseph, J.(2011)。The Limits of Governmentality: Social Theory and the International。European Journal of international Relations，16(2)，223-246。
45.	Kjær, A. M.(2011)。Rhodes’ Contribution to Governance Theory: Praise, Criticism and the Future Governance Debate。Public Administration，89(1)，101-113。
46.	Lawless, P.(2004)。Locating and Explaining Area-Based Urban Initiatives: New Deal for Communities in England。Environment and Planning C: Policy and Politics，22(3)，383-399。
47.	Leftwich, A.(1993)。Governance, Democracy and Development in the ThirdWorld。Third World Quarterly，14(3)，605-624。
48.	Lemke, T.(2007)。An Indigestible Meal? Foucault, Governmentality and State Theory。Distinktion: Scandinavian Journal of Social Theory，8(2)，43-64。
49.	Macleod, G.(2002)。From Urban Entrepreneurialism to a ‘Revanchist City’? On the Spatial Injustices of Glasgow’s Renaissance。Antipode，34(3)，602-604。
50.	Marinetto, M.(2003b)。Governing Beyond the Center: A Critique of the Anglo-Governance School。Political Studies，51，592-608。
51.	Marsh, D.、Hall, M.(2003)。Political Tradition(s): Beyond Bevir and Rhodes。British Politics，2(2)，215-238。
52.	Marsh, D.(2008a)。Understanding British Government Analysing Competing Models。The British Journal politics & International Relations，10，251-268。
53.	Marsh, D.(2008b)。What is at Stake? A Response to Bevir and Rhodes。The British Journal politics & International Relations，10，735-739。
54.	Marsh, D.、Richard, D.、Smith, M.(2003)。Unequal Plurality: Towards an Asymmetric Power Model of British Politics。Government and Opposition，38(3)，306-332。
55.	Papadopoulos, Y.(2000)。Governance, Coordination and Legitimacy in Public Policies。International Journal of Urban and Regional Research，24(1)，210-223。
56.	Peters, B. G.(2009)。The Two Futures of Governing: Decentering and Recentering Process in Governing。Journal of Public Administration and Policy，2(1)，7-24。
57.	Smith, M. J.(2008)。Re-centring British Government: Belief, Traditions and Dilemmas in Political Science。Political Studies Review，6，143-154。
58.	Somerville, P.(2005)。Community Governance Through Democracy。Policy and Politics，33(1)，117-144。
59.	Stoker, G.(2011)。Was Local Governance Such a Good Idea? A Global Comparative Perspective。Public Administration，89(1)，15-31。
60.	Thoburn, N.(2007)。Patterns of Production: Cultural Studies after Hegemony。Theory, Culture & Society，24(3)，79-94。
61.	Thompson, F. J.(2008)。State and Local Governance Fifteen Years Later: Enduring and New Challenge。Public Administration Review，68(Supplement 1)，8-19。
62.	Torfing, J.(1999)。Workfare With Welfare: Recent Reforms of the Danish Welfare State。Journal of European Social Policy，9(1)，5-28。
63.	Wanna, J.、Weller, P.(2011)。The Irrepressible Rod Rhodes: Contesting Traditions and Blurring Genres。Public Administration，89(1)，1-14。
64.	Whitehead, M.(2003)。In the Shadow of Hierarchy’: Meta-governance, Policy reform and Urban Regeneration in the West Midlands。Area，35(1)，6-14。

會議論文
1.	Daugbjerg, C.、Fawcett, P.(2010)。Governance Theory and the Question of Power: Lesson Drawing From the Governance Network and Policy Network Analysis Schools。Australian Political Studies Association Conference , Melbourne, Australia，(會議日期: September 27-29)。
2.	Davies, J. S.(2009)。Re-stating Hegemony: a Critique of Postmodern Governance Theory。City Future Conference，Municipal Training Center (會議日期: June 4-6)。Madrid。
3.	Jessop, B.(2002b)。Developmental States and Knowledge-Driven Economies。International Conference: Revisiting the Asian State，(會議日期: June 28-30)。Leiden。

學位論文
1.	Fawcett, P.(2009)。Government, Governance and Meta-governance in the British Core Executive(-)。University of Birmingham, UK.。

圖書
1.	Smith, Martin J.(1999)。The Core Executive in Britain。New York：Macmillan。
2.	Marsh, David、Rhodes, R. A. W.(1992)。Policy Networks in British Government。Oxford：Clarendon Press。
3.	Jessop, Bob(2007)。State Power。Cambridge：Polity Press。
4.	Laclau, Ernesto、Mouffe, Chantal(2001)。Hegemony and Socialist Strategy: Towards a Radical Democratic Politics。London：Verso。
5.	Beck-Gernsheim, Elisabeth(2002)。Reinventing the Family: In Search of New Lifestyles。Polity Press。
6.	Jessop, B.(2002)。The Future of the Capitalist State。Cambridge：Polity Press。
7.	Fukuyama, F.(2004)。State-Building: Governance and World Order in the 21st Century。New York：Cornell University Press。
8.	Rose, Nikolas(1999)。Powers of Freedom: Reframing Political Thought。Cambridge University Press。
9.	Pierre, Jon(2000)。Debating Governance: Authority, Steering, and Democracy。New York：Oxford University Press。
10.	Burchell, Graham、Gordon, Colin、Miller, Peter(1991)。The Foucault effect: Studies in governmentality with two lectures by and an interview with Michel Foucault。Chicago：Harvester and Wheatsheaf：University of Chicago Press。
11.	Giddens, Anthony(1998)。The Third Way: The Renewal of Social Democracy。Oxford：Blackwell publishers Ltd.。
12.	Porter, Michael E.(1990)。The Competitive Advantage of Nations。New York：Free Press。
13.	Habermas, Jürgen、Burger, Thomas、Lawrence, Frederick(1989)。The Structural Transformation of the Public Sphere: An Inquiry into a Category of Bourgeois Society。Cambridge, MA：MIT Press。
14.	Weiss, Linda(2003)。States in the Global Economy: Bringing Domestic Institutions Back In。Cambridge：Cambridge University Press。
15.	Pierre, Jon、Peters, B. Guy(2000)。Governance, Politics and the State。London：New York：Hampshire：Macmillan Press：St. Martin's Press：Houndmills。
16.	Dean, M.(2010)。Governmentality : power and rule in modern society。Los Angles, Calif.：London：SAGE。
17.	Bell, Stephen、Hindmoor, Andrew(2009)。Rethinking Governance: The Centrality of the State in Modern Society。Cambridge University Press。
18.	Kooiman, Jan(2003)。Governing as Governance。Sage Publications。
19.	Evans, Peter B.(1995)。Embedded Autonomy: States and Industrial Transformation。Princeton, New Jersey：Princeton University Press。
20.	Giddens, Anthony(1994)。Beyond Left and Right: The Future of Radical Politics。Cambridge：Polity Press。
21.	Mouffe, Chantal(2005)。On the Political。Routledge。
22.	Putnam, Robert D.(2000)。Bowling Alone: The Collapse and Revival of American Community。Simon & Schuster。
23.	Barry, A.、Osborne, T.、Rose, N.(1996)。Foucault and Political Reasoning: Liberalism, Neo-liberalism and Rationalities of Government。London：UCL Press。
24.	Bevir, M.、Rhodes, R. A. W.(2003)。Interpreting British Governance。London：Routledge。
25.	Bevir, M.、Rhodes, R. A. W.(2010)。The State As Cultural Practice。Oxford：Oxford University Press。
26.	Cox, R. W.(1986)。Social Forces, States, and World Orders。New York：Columbia University Press。
27.	Dent, C. M.(2002)。The Foreign Economic Policies of Singapore, South Korea and Taiwan。Cheltenham Glos：Edward Elgar Publishing Limited。
28.	Dryzek J. S.、Dunleavy P.(2009)。Theories of the Democratic State。London：Palgrave Macmillan。
29.	Hay, C.(2002)。Political Analysis。London：Palgrave。
30.	Kjær, A. M.(2004)。Governance。Cambridge：The Polity Press。
31.	Luck, T.(1997)。Eco-critique: Contesting the Politics of Nature, Economy, and Culture。Minneapolis：University of Minnesota Press。
32.	Mann, M.(1993)。The Sources of Social Power。New York：Cambridge University Press。
33.	Marsh, D.(1998)。Comparing Policy Network。Buckingham：Open University Press。
34.	Migdal, Joel S.(1988)。Strong State and Weak State: State-Society Relations and State Capacities in the Third World。New Jessey：Princeton University Press。
35.	Newman, J.(2005)。Remaking Governance-Peoples, Politics and the Public Sphere。Bristol：The Policy Press。
36.	Rhodes, R. A. W.(2010)。Everyday Life at the Top。Oxford：Oxford University Press。
37.	Sørensen, E.、Torfing, J.(2008)。Theories of Democratic Network Governance。Hampshire：Palgrave Macmillan。
38.	Stones, R.(1996)。Sociological Reasoning: Toward a Post-Modern Sociology。London：Macmillan。
39.	Torfing, J.、Peters, G.、PierreJ.、Sørensen, E.(2012)。Interactive Governance: Advancing the Paradigm。Oxford：Oxford University Press。

其他
1.	Cabinet Office(2000)。Wiring It Up-Whitehall’s Management of Cross-Cutting Policies and Service，http://ctpr.org/wp-content/uploads/2011/03/Wiring-it-Up-2000.pdf.， 2011/06/01。

圖書論文
1.	Sterling, Rebekah(2005)。Promoting Democratic Governance through Partnerships?。Remaking Governance: Peoples, Politics and the Public Sphere。Bristol：Policy Press。
2.	Rhodes, R. A. W.、Marsh, David(1992)。Policy Networks in British Politics: A Critique of Existing Approaches。Policy Networks in British Government。New York：Oxford University Press。
3.	Rhodes, Rod A. W.(2012)。Waves of Governance。The Oxford Handbook of Governance。Oxford University Press。
4.	Kim, Hyuk Rae(2000)。Fragility or Continuity? Economic Governance of East Asia Capitalism。Politics and Markets in the Wake of the Asian Crisis。London：Routledge Press。
5.	Foucault, Michel(1982)。The subject and power。Michael Foucault: Beyond structuralism and hermeneutics。Chicago：Chicago University Press。
6.	McKinlay, Alan、Starkey, Ken(1998)。Managing Foucault: Foucault, Management and Organization Theory。Foucault, Management & Organization Theory。London：Sage。
7.	Mouffe, Chantal(1992)。Democratic Citizenship and the Political Community。Dimensions of Radical Democracy。London：Verso。
8.	Foucault, Michel(1991)。Governmentality。The Foucault Effect: Studies in Governmentality。Chicago：The University of Chicago Press。
9.	Jessop, B.(2003)。Governance and meta-governance: on reflexivity, requisite variety, and requisite irony。Governance as social and political communication。Manchester：Manchester University Press。
10.	Jessop, B.(2011)。Meta-governance。The Sage handbook of governance。London：Sage Publication Ltd。
11.	Bang, H.(2005)。Among Everyday Makers and Expert Citizens。Remaking Governance-Peoples, Politics and the Public Sphere。Bristol：the Policy Press。
12.	Bevir, M.、Rhodes, R. A. W.(2007)。Traditions of Political Science in Contemporary Britain.” In Modern Political Science: Anglo-American Exchanges Since 1880。Princeton:：Princeton University Press。
13.	Bevir, M.、Rhodes, R. A. W.(2008a)。Decentred Theory, Change and Network Governance。Theories of Democratic Network Governance。Hampshire：Palgrave Macmillan。
14.	Bevir, M.、Rhodes, R. A. W.(2011)。The Stateless State.” In The Sage Handbook of Governance。The Sage Handbook of Governance。London：Sage Publication Ltd.。
15.	Bevir, M.(2011a)。Interpretive Theory.” In The Sage Handbook of Governance。The Sage Handbook of Governance。London：Sage Publication Ltd.。
16.	Brown, W.(2006)。Power After Foucault。The Oxford Handbook of Political Theory。Oxford：Oxford University Press。
17.	Bryant, P.(2009)。Deliberative Governance: Political Fad or a Vision of Empowerment?In The Limits To Governance: The Challenge of Policymaking for the New Life Sciences。The Limits To Governance: The Challenge of Policymaking for the New Life Sciences。Burlington：Ashgate Publishing Company。
18.	Donzelot J.(1991)。The Mobilization of Society。The Foucault Effect: Studies in Governmentality。Chicago：University of Chicago Press。
19.	Habermas, J.(1994)。Some Questions Concerning the Theory of Power: Foucault Again。Critique and Power Recasting the Foucault/ Habermas Debate。Cambridge：MIT Press。
20.	Habermas, J.(1998)。Three Normative Models of Democracy。The Inclusion of the Other: Studies in Political Theory。Cambridge：MIT Press。
21.	Hay, C.(2001)。The ‘Crisis’ of Keynesianism and the Rise of Neo-Liberalism in Britain: An Ideational Institutionalist Approach。The Rise of NeoLiberalism and Institutional Analysis。Princeton：Princeton University Press。
22.	Hirst, P.(2000)。Democracy and Governance。Debating Governance: Authority, Steering, and Democracy。New York：Oxford University Press。
23.	Johansson H.、Hivnden, B.(2005)。Welfare Governance and the Remaking of Citizen。Remarking Governance-Peoples, Politics and the Public Sphere。Bristol：Policy Press。
24.	Lowndes, V.(2010)。The Institutional Approach。Theory and Methods in Political Science。Basingstoke：Palgrave Macmillan。
25.	Marinetto, M.(2012)。Pessimism of the Modernist Intellect Versus Optimism of the Democratic Will: The Interpretive School of Governance。Comparative European Politics。
26.	Rose, N.(1996)。Governing ‘Advanced’ Liberal Democracy。Foucault and Political Reason: Liberalism, Neo-Liberalism and Rationality of Government。Chicago：University of Chicago Press。
27.	Saward, M.(2005)。Governance and the Transformation of Political Representation。Remarking Governance-Peoples, Politics and the Public Sphere。Bristol：The Policy Press。

推文
推薦
引用網址
引用嵌入語法
轉寄

top

:::

相關期刊
相關論文
相關專書
相關著作
熱門點閱

1.	審計新村變身記--城市文化治理與創意場域形構
2.	莫拉克風災後高屏地區重建服務網絡之研究：災難治理的觀點
3.	評析Schmidt「論述制度論」與對政策制訂的啟示
4.	國家與國家職能之思辯：一個歷史社會學的觀點
5.	治理與公民參與--淡水河流域治理之Q方法論分析

1.	後代議民主之參與制度設計－以我國觀光賭場博弈公投為例
2.	高科技產業全球生產網絡下的國家角色困境

無相關書籍

無相關著作

無相關點閱

QR Code

臺灣人文及社會科學引文索引資料庫系統

詳目顯示

臺灣人文及社會科學引文索引資料庫