社會關係的類型和效應：臺灣、美國、中國大陸的三地比較_

:::

詳目顯示

第 1 筆 / 總合 1 筆

/1頁

來源文獻資料
摘要
外文摘要
引文資料

題名：	社會關係的類型和效應：臺灣、美國、中國大陸的三地比較
書刊名：	臺灣社會學刊
作者：	林南／陳志柔／傅仰止
作者(外文)：	Lin, Nan／Chen, Jay Chih-jou／Fu, Yang-chih
出版日期：	2010
卷期：	45
頁次：	頁117-162
主題關鍵詞：	社會資本；社會網絡；關係；跨國比較；Social capital；Social networks；Guanxi；Cross-national comparison
原始連結：	連回原系統網址
相關次數：	被引用次數:期刊(12) 博士論文(3) 專書(1) 專書論文(0) 排除自我引用:12 共同引用:34 點閱:194

本文研究台灣、美國、中國大陸三地社會關係的不同模式，及由此導致個人獲取社會資本差異的影響過程。我們採取定位法(position generator)測量社會資本，並呈現社會關係在三個社會所呈現的模式差異，如親屬關係、工作關係、機構關係、朋友關係等。經濟結構（工業化及市場化）、文化與社會制度、政治經濟體制等因素，可能可以解釋這三地社會關係的類型差異以及因此導致的社會資本取得的過程。研究結果顯示：台灣、美國、中國大陸具有不同的社會關係類型。在美國，工作關係、朋友、親屬關係在個人的社會關係網絡中，基本上彼此分立、涇渭分明；其中，相較於工作和親屬關係，朋友關係對於獲取較好的社會資本有最強的作用。中國大陸的社會關係顯示多重關係交織的脈絡：朋友、親屬、同學、同鄉等關係相互交織，且值得注意的是，朋友並沒有成爲獨立的社會關係類型。台灣的社會關係類型介於美中兩者之間：朋友是社會關係的獨立類屬，但還是和親屬關係存在某種程度的交集。研究資料顯示，經濟結構（工業化及市場化）的解釋觀點，相較於「文化／社會制度」或「政治經濟體制」的解釋，比較能解釋我們所呈現的社會關係類型及作用的跨社會差異。同時，它們也揭示了華人社會文化的持續影響力以及文化與社會變遷的緩慢過程。另外，本文也呈現華人社會的「關係」內涵以及「同質互動」(homophily)社會機制的影響力。

以文找文

In this paper we examine how social relations show differential patterns and exert differential effects on accessing social capital in three societies: Taiwan, the United States, and China. Employing data from the position generator, a measure of social capital, we discerned different patterns of social relations in the three societies, such as kin ties, work ties, friends, and other ties. Three possible explanations are posed for assessing possible patterns of social relations and their effects on social capital across the three societies: economic structures (industrialization and marketization), socio-cultural institutions, and political-economic regimes. Our results indicate different patterns of social relations in the three societies. In the U.S., work ties, friends, kin ties, and other ties are distinctive types of social relations. Friends and other ties, rather than work ties or kin ties, exert stronger effects on accessing better social capital. In China, kin ties, friends, and other ties are interrelated, and share effects on accessing social capital. In Taiwan, kin ties, friends, and other ties still overlap but to a lesser extent than they exhibit in China, and the relative effect of kin ties on social capital, while still persisting, has eased up relative to the effects of work ties, friends, and other ties. We suggest that these patterns are more consistent with an economic-structure explanation than a socio-cultural or political-economic regime explanation. In addition to suggesting a slow but persistent process of cultural change, the data also shed light on the nature of guanxi in Chinese societies, and on the prevalence of the social principle of homophily transcending developmental or economic processes.

以文找文

期刊論文
1.	林南(19890600)。Chinese Family Structure and Chinese Society。中央研究院民族學研究所集刊，65，59-129。延伸查詢
2.	Burt, R. S.(1984)。Network Items and the General Social Survey。Social Networks，6，293-339。
3.	Van der Gaag, Martin、Snijders, Tom A. B.(2005)。The Resource Generator: Social Capital Quantification with Concrete Items。Social Networks，27(1)，1-29。
4.	Marsden, P. V.(1990)。Network Data and Measurement。Annual Review of Sociolog，16，435-463。
5.	陳東升、陳端容(20021200)。跨族群政治討論網絡的形成及其影響因素。臺灣社會學，4，119-157。延伸查詢
6.	羅啟宏(1992)。臺灣省鄉鎮發展類型之研究。臺灣經濟月刊，190，41-68。延伸查詢
7.	Lin, Nan(1999)。Building a Network Theory of Social Capital。Connections，22(1)，28-51。
8.	傅仰止(20020600)。個人網絡中他人聯繫強度的結構原理。臺灣社會學，3，163-209。延伸查詢
9.	黃光國(1987)。Face and favor: the Chinese power game。American Journal of Sociology，92(4)，944-974。
10.	Bian, Yan-Jie(1994)。Guanxi and the Allocation of Urban Jobs in China。The China Quarterly，140，971-999。
11.	Lin, Nan、Dumin, Mary(1986)。Access to Occupations through Social Ties。Social Networks，8(4)，365-385。
12.	Granovetter, Mark S.(1973)。The Strength of Weak Ties。American Journal of Sociology，78(6)，1360-1380。
13.	Bekkers, Rene, et al.,(2008)。“Social Networks of Participants in Voluntary Associations.”。Social Capital: An International Research Program，185-205。
14.	Bian, Yanjie and Soon Ang,(1997)。“Guanxi Networks and Job Mobility in Mainland China and Singapore.”。Social Forces，75(3):，981-1006。
15.	Blau, Peter M. and J. E. Schwartz,(1984)。Crosscutting Social Circles。
16.	Burt, Ronald S.,(1984)。“Network items and the General Social Survey.”。Social Networks，6(4):，293-339。
17.	Chen, Chih-Jou Jay,(2006)。“Elite Mobility in Post-Reform Rural China.”。Issues & Studies，42(2):，53-83。
18.	Fei, Xiaotong,(1992)。From the Soil, the Foundations of Chinese Society。A Translation of Fei Xiaotong’s Xiangtu Zhongguo, with an introduction and epilogue by Gary G. Hamilton and Wang Zheng。
19.	Fischer, Claude S. and Shavit, Yossi,(1995)。“National differences in network density: Israel and the United States.”。Social Networks，17(2):，129-145。
20.	Flap, Henk and Beate Volker,(2008)。“Social, Cultural, and Economic Capital and Job Attainment: The Position Generator as a Measure of Cultural and Economic Resources.”。Social Capital: An International Research Program，65-80。
21.	Fu, Yang-chih,(2008)。“Position Generator and Actual Networks in Everyday Life: An Evaluation with Contact Diary.”。Social Capital:An International Research Program，49-64。
22.	Hsung, Ray-May and Yi-Jr Lin,(2008)。“Social Capital of Personnel Managers: Causes and Return of Position-Generated Networks and Participation in Voluntary Associations.”。Social Capital: An International Research Program，234-254。
23.	King, Ambrose Y. C.,(1985)。“The Individual and Group in Confucianism: A Relational Perspective.”。Individualism and Holism: Studies in Confucian and Taoist Values，57-70。
24.	Lai, Gina,(2001)。“Social Support Networks in Urban Shanghai.”。Social Networks，23(1):，73-85。
25.	Mcpherson, Lynn Smith-Lovin and Matthew Brashears,(2006)。“Social Isolation in America: Changes in Core Discussion Networks over Two Decades.”。American Sociological Review，71(3):，353-375。
26.	Marsden, Peter V.,(1987)。“Core Discussion Networks of Americans.”。American Sociological Review，52(1):，122-131。
27.	Marsden, Peter V.,(1990)。“Network data and measurement.”。Annual Review of Sociology，16:，435-63。
28.	Marsden, Peter V.,(2005)。“Recent Developments in Network Measurement.”。Models and Methods in Social Network Analysis，8-30。
29.	Moerbeek, Hester and Henk Flap,(2008)。“Social Resources and Their Effect on Occupational Attainment through the Life Course.”。Social Capital: An International Research Program，133-156。
30.	Ruan, Danching,(1998)。“The Content of the General Social Survey Discussion Networks: An Exploration of General Social Survey Discussion Name Generator in a Chinese Context.”。Social Networks，20 (3):，247-264。
31.	Ruan, Danching et al.,(1997)。“On the Changing Structure of Social Networks in Urban China.”。Social Networks，19(1):，75-89。
32.	Smith, Sandra Susan,(2008)。“A Question of Access or Mobilization? Understanding Inefficacious Job Referral Networks among the Black Poor.”。Social Capital: An International Research Program，157-181。
33.	Tindall, D. B. and Jeffrey J. Cormier,(2008)。“Gender, Network Capital, Social Capital, and Political Capital: The Consequences of Personal Network Diversity for Environmentalists in British Columbia.”。Social Capital: An International Research Program，282-307。
34.	Bian, Yanjie(1994)。Guanxi and the Allocation of Jobs in Urban Mainland China。China Quarterly，140，971-999。
35.	Bian, Yanjie、Ang, Soon(1997)。Guanxi Networks and Job Mobility in Mainland China and Singapore。Social Forces，75(3)，981-1006。
36.	Chen, Chih-Jou Jay(2006)。Elite Mobility in Post-Reform Rural China。Issues & Studies，42(2)，53-83。
37.	Fischer, Claude S.、Shavit, Yossi(1995)。National differences in network density。Israel and the United States，129-45。
38.	Lai, Gina(2001)。Social Support Networks in Urban Shanghai。Social Networks，23(1)，73-85。
39.	Smith-Lovin, Mcpherson Lynn、Brashears, Matthew(2006)。Social Isolation in America: Changes in Core Discussion Networks over Two Decades。American Sociological Review，71(3)，353-375。
40.	Marsden, Peter V.(1987)。Core Discussion Networks of Americans。American Sociological Review，52(1)，122-131。
41.	Martin, van der Gaag、Snijders, Tom(2005)。The Resource Generator: Social Capital Quantification with Concrete Items。Social Networks，27(1)，1-29。
42.	Ruan, Danching(1998)。The Content of the General Social Survey Discussion Networks: An Exploration of General Social Survey Discussion Name Generator in a Chinese Context。Social Networks，20 (3)，247-264。
43.	Ruan, Danching(1997)。On the Changing Structure of Social Networks in Urban China。Social Networks，19(1)，75-89。

圖書
1.	張文宏(2006)。中國城市的階層結構與社會網絡。上海：上海人民出版社。延伸查詢
2.	Fischer, Claude S.(1982)。To Dwell Among Friends。The University of Chicago Press。
3.	Laumann, Edward O.(1973)。Bonds of Pluralism: The Forms and Substance of Urban Social Networks。New York：Wiley。
4.	Hsung, Ray-May、Lin, Nan、Breiger, Ronald L.(2009)。Contexts of Social Capital: Social Networks in Markets, Communities, and Families。London：Routledge。
5.	Blau, Peter M.、Schwartz, Joseph E.(1984)。Crosscutting Social Circles。Orlando, FL：Academic Press。
6.	Lin, Nan、Erickson, Bonnie(2008)。Social Capital: An International Research Program。Oxford：Oxford University Press。
7.	Eisenstandt, S. N.(1966)。Modernization:Protest and Change。New Jersey：Prentice-Hall。
8.	林南(2001)。Social Capital: A Theory of Social Structure and Action。Cambridge University Press。
9.	邊燕杰、李路路、蔡禾(2004)。社會調查實踐：中國經驗及分析。香港：牛津大學出版社。延伸查詢
10.	金耀基(1988)。〈人際關係中人情之分析〉。台北。延伸查詢
11.	Andersen, Jorgen Goul and Sigrid Bobteutscher,(2007)。“Small-scale Democracy: Citizen Power in the Domains of Everyday Life.”。Citizenship and Involvement in European Democracies: A Comparative Analysis, edited by Jan W. van Deth, Jose Ramon Montero,and Anders Westholm。London and New York。
12.	Bian, Yanjie,(2000)。“Getting a Job Through a Web of Guanxi in Urban Mainland China.”。Networks in the Global Village。Boulder, CO。
13.	Bian, Yanjie,(2001)。“Guanxi Capital and Social Eating: Theoretical Models and Empirical Analyses.”。Social Capital: Theory and Research。New York。
14.	Chen, Chih-Jou Jay,(2009)。“The Distribution and Return of Social Capital in Taiwan.”。Contexts of Social Capital: Social Networks in Communities。
15.	Erickson, Bonnie H.,(2009)。“The Context Challenge: Generalizing Social Capital Processes Across Two Different Settings.”。Contexts of Social Capital: Social Networks in Markets, Communities, and Families。London and New York。
16.	Fu, Yang-chih,(2009)。“The Immediate Returns on Time Investment in Daily Contacts: Exploring the Network-Overlapping Effects from Contact Diaries.”。Contexts of Social Capital: Social Networks in Markets, Communities, and Families。London and New York。
17.	Galaskiewicz, Joseph, Beth M. Duckles and Olga Mayorova,(2009)。“Childcare Networks and Embedded Experiences.”。Contexts of Social Capital: Social Networks in Markets, Communities, and Families。London and New York。
18.	Lin, Nan, Dan Ao, and Lijun Song,(2009)。“Production and Returns of Social Capital: Evidence from Urban China.”。Contexts of Social Capital: Social Networks in Communities, Markets and Organizations。
19.	Bekkers, Rene(2008)。Social Networks of Participants in Voluntary Associations。Social Capital: An International Research Program。Oxford。
20.	金耀基(1988)。人際關係中人情之分析。中國人的心理。台北。延伸查詢
21.	Lin, Nan、Ao, Dan、Song, Lijun(2009)。Production and Returns of Social Capital: Evidence from Urban China。Contexts of Social Capital: Social Networks in Communities, Markets and Organizations。London ; New York。
22.	Goul, Andersen Jorgen、Bobteutscher, Sigrid(2007)。Small-scale Democracy: Citizen Power in the Domains of Everyday Life。Citizenship and Involvement in European Democracies: A Comparative Analysis。London ; New York。
23.	Bian, Yanjie(2000)。Getting a Job Through a Web of Guanxi in Urban Mainland China。Networks in the Global Village。Boulder, CO。
24.	Bian, Yanjie(2001)。Guanxi Capital and Social Eating: Theoretical Models and Empirical Analyses。Social Capital: Theory and Research。New York。
25.	Chen, Chih-Jou Jay(2009)。The Distribution and Return of Social Capital in Taiwan。Contexts of Social Capital: Social Networks in Communities, Markets and Organizations。London ; New York。
26.	Erickson, Bonnie H.(2009)。The Context Challenge: Generalizing Social Capital Processes Across Two Different Settings。Contexts of Social Capital: Social Networks in Markets, Communities, and Families。London ; New York。
27.	Flap, Henk、Volker, Beate(2008)。Social, Cultural, and Economic Capital and Job Attainment: The Position Generator as a Measure of Cultural and Economic Resources。Social Capital: An International Research Program。Oxford。
28.	Fu, Yang-chih(2009)。The Immediate Returns on Time Investment in Daily Contacts: Exploring the Network-Overlapping Effects from Contact Diaries。Contexts of Social Capital: Social Networks in Markets, Communities, and Families。London ; New York。
29.	Galaskiewicz, Joseph、Duckles, Beth M.、Mayorova,Olga(2009)。Childcare Networks and Embedded Experiences。Contexts of Social Capital: Social Networks in Markets, Communities, and Families。London ; New York。
30.	Hsung, Ray-May、Lin, Yi-Jr,(2008)。Social Capital of Personnel Managers: Causes and Return of Position-Generated Networks and Participation in Voluntary Associations。Social Capital: An International Research Program。Oxford。
31.	Marsden, Peter V.(2005)。Recent Developments in Network Measurement。Models and Methods in Social Network Analysis。Cambridge：Cambridge University Press。
32.	Moerbeek, Hester、Flap, Henk(2008)。Social Resources and Their Effect on Occupational Attainment through the Life Course。Social Capital: An International Research Program, edited by Nan Lin and Bonnie H. Erickson。Oxford。
33.	Smith, Sandra Susan(2008)。A Question of Access or Mobilization? Understanding Inefficacious Job Referral Networks among the Black Poor。Social Capital: An International Research Program。Oxford。
34.	Tindall, D. B.、Cormier, Jeffrey J.(2008)。Gender, Network Capital, Social Capital, and Political Capital: The Consequences of Personal Network Diversity for Environmentalists in British Columbia。Social Capital: An International Research Program。Oxford。

圖書論文
1.	King, A. Y. C.(1985)。The individual and group in Confucianism: A relational perspective。Individualism and holism: Studies in Confucian and Taoist values。Ann Arbor, MI：Center for Chinese Studies, University of Michigan。
2.	熊瑞梅(2001)。性別、個人網絡與社會資本。華人社會的調查研究方法與發現。香港：牛津大學出版社。延伸查詢
3.	Lin, Nan(1982)。Social Resources and Instrumental Action。Social Structure and Network Analysis。Beverly Hills, CA：Sage。
4.	林南、傅仰止、熊瑞梅(2001)。The Position Generator: Measurement Techniques for Investigations of Social Capital。Social Capital: Theory and Research。New York：Aldine de Gruyter。
5.	Van der Gaag, Martin、Snijders, Tom A. B.、Flap, Henk(2008)。Position Generator Measures and Their Relationship to Other Social Capital Measures。Social Capital: An International Research Program。Oxford：Oxford University Press。
6.	Fei, Xiaotong(1992)。From the Soil, the Foundations of Chinese Society。A Translation of Fei Xiaotong’s Xiangtu Zhongguo。Berkeley：University of California Press。
7.	Fu, Yang-chih(2008)。Position Generator and Actual Networks in Everyday Life: An Evaluation with Contact Diary。Social Capital: An International Research Program。Oxford：Oxford University Press。

推文
推薦
引用網址
引用嵌入語法
轉寄

top

:::

相關期刊
相關論文
相關專書
相關著作
熱門點閱

1.	社會資本與公民意識：世代差異的比較
2.	老人社會資本對健康生活品質的影響：以臺中市老人為例
3.	中國互聯網使用對社會資本影響的元分析
4.	志工教育訓練成效與影響因素之研究--以社會網絡分組為途徑
5.	社會資本與個人健康之關係：以科技業從業人員之運動社團參與為例
6.	「中國式政治經濟景氣循環」：中央與地方領導菁英之鍊結與互動
7.	高齡者參與學習轉化內涵之研究
8.	社群媒體與大學生的網絡界限：伴遊圈、談話圈、接觸圈
9.	關係對異質群體行為選擇的影響--基於人際關係網絡調查數據的實證研究
10.	從社會網絡觀點探討家長學校參與的測量
11.	有關係就是沒關係：中國勞動市場中社會網絡對尋職管道與薪資的影響分析
12.	臺灣青年世代的政治認同(1995~2015)
13.	網路「社會資本」與跨媒介敘事的運用--以「Flying V」線上募資案為例
14.	弱勢族群的微型創業--以單親婦女為例
15.	社會資本及幸福感相關性之跨國與跨年齡層比較

1.	大型重機社團社會資本之探究： Putnam理論的批判性分析
2.	制度變遷、社會資本與政治參與間關係
3.	跨部門及組織間協力關係網之研究：以多元就業開發方案中彰投區為例
4.	性別化的社會資本及其政治效果：以同鄉會為例
5.	我國原住民於臺北都會地區就業之研究︰一個社會資本的觀察
6.	執誰之手：台灣教育婚姻配對的社會學分析
7.	老年喪偶女性的家族網絡類型變化與憂鬱傾向之研究
8.	全球治理與台灣的活絡模式
9.	居民社區參與行為之影響模式研究
10.	華人商業交易場域中的應酬經驗與“關係流”管理－有關係、沒關係？
11.	社區行動的菁英參與和社會資本
12.	社會資本之分散與整合

1.	制度變遷、社會資本、政治參與：三者之間的關係
2.	族群認同與文化外交：以日本關西崇正會為例

無相關著作

1.	臺北縣靜脈注射毒癮者用藥行為及心理衛生狀況初探
2.	中國大陸的不平等結構與制度變遷
3.	邁向老人福利國？臺灣社會安全支出結構的分析
4.	誰來審議？臺灣民眾對審議民主的支持程度和參與意願
5.	臺灣與美國小學教學現況比較：曾任兩地導師的現場觀察
6.	督察系統之比較研究--以臺灣、中國大陸與法國等三個歐陸係警察系統區域建立督察之相關專門理論
7.	學校社工員在生態系統中工作的目標與策略：衝突解決系統取向之初探
8.	全球化效果的侷限：臺灣民眾對接納跨國移民的態度
9.	大陸、香港、臺灣電視新聞主播可信度的比較研究
10.	大陸學生在臺灣生活適應與學習滿意度之研究
11.	想像的階層流動：中國大陸臺灣學生的就學就業分析
12.	階級不同不相為謀：大陸臺灣人社會融入狀況之研究
13.	社群治理與社會創新 [演講稿]
14.	社會接觸及政治態度影響臺灣民眾對大陸印象、認知、政策評估之分析

QR Code

臺灣人文及社會科學引文索引資料庫系統

詳目顯示

臺灣人文及社會科學引文索引資料庫