Acidic level is an important index for observing paper deterioration. In recent years, in the field of preservation science and document maintenance, paper pH value is usually used as a reference to evaluate paper deterioration. Paper acidic/basic test has its limitation, because it is affected by factors such as: sample and solvent quantity, operating conditions, and the basic properties of the paper. Sample and solvent quantity will affect directly the H3O+ concentration in the water. Different operating temperatures will affect the dissolution of material contained in the paper, and the hydrolysis of cellulose, hemi-cellulose and lignin. The basic properties such as categories, paper manufacturing method, additives and surface structures will affect the dissolution speed of the material contained in the paper. This study conducts experiments and evaluations by using the direct measurement method, cold water extraction method, hot water extraction method, etc., which are commonly used in paper acidification related studies. The experimental materials are five kinds of paper available from the market such as: coated paper, printing paper, book printing paper, recycling paper, copy paper, etc. The results show that the direct measurement method most commonly used in lots of studies leads to big data variance after 10 times of repeated verifications. The acidic/basic value distribution ranges for these papers are: 5.44 to 5.88 for coated paper, 4.18 to 4.80 for printing paper, 4.40~5.72 for book printing paper, 5.02 to 6.10 for recycling paper, 5.15 to 6.18 for copying paper; and the differences in percentage between the maximum and the minimum values are: 8.08% for coated paper, 14.83% for printing paper, 29.55% for book copying paper, 21.15% for recycling paper, 20.00% for copying paper. The stability of the obtained data is not good enough. When the measurement is performed by using hot water extraction method, one measurement at 20-minute interval within a period of 180 minutes, the measured data shows unstable and non-representative. For the cold water extraction method, the measured data is unstable at the initial stage, but tends to be stable in certain amount of time. Due to the urgency requirement of paper acidification research, and under the condition that the new method and theory still need to be thoroughly discussed studied, this study thus suggests that the cold water extraction method be used for paper pH value test.