Crucial Dynamics: The Practice of Constructive Controversy vs. That of Concurrence Seeking in EFL Contexts_

:::

詳目顯示

第 1 筆 / 總合 1 筆

/1頁

來源文獻資料
摘要
外文摘要
引文資料

題名：	Crucial Dynamics: The Practice of Constructive Controversy vs. That of Concurrence Seeking in EFL Contexts
書刊名：	全人教育學報
作者：	易青青
作者(外文)：	Yi, Ching-Ching
出版日期：	2007
卷期：	1
頁次：	頁243-284
主題關鍵詞：	建設性論辯模式；尋求共識模式；變數；求知慾；合作；競爭；特質；中國人；Constructive controversy；Concurrence seeking；Variables；Epistemic curiosity；Cooperation；Competition；Attributes；Chinese
原始連結：	連回原系統網址
相關次數：	被引用次數:期刊(1) 博士論文(0) 專書(0) 專書論文(0) 排除自我引用:0 共同引用:0 點閱:25

鑑於作者前兩項研究已證實了「建設性論辨模式」（建式）無論在態度改變上或在論說文寫作本身方面的成效都優於「尋求共識模式」（尋式），此項研究意在探尋影響這兩個模式在英語教學成效上的主要變數以及相同變數在這兩個不同教學模式中的相關或相異性，以期作者研發的「建設性論辯模式」不僅能更有效地運用在英語教學上更能導引進一步的相關研究。　　如前兩項研究，五班共121位非英語系的大學生在兩種教學情境中，就兩個議題四篇文章，依設計好的教學步驟，對論題進行瞭解、分享、交換及探討。為了減少在課室裡非同步測試兩種教學模式所可能帶來的彩響，不僅五班學生都給予兩種教學且部分以〔建式〕開始，部分以〔尋式〕開始。此外，為了測試四篇文章在難度與爭議性上的差異，在正式實驗前尚對141位大學生做了測試。正式實驗為期六個星期，以三星期為一教學單元，分別在每一單元未給予問卷調查。問卷主要改編自Dooley & Fryxell (1999); Johnson and Johnson (1985); Tjosvold et al. (1981); Tjosvold (1998)等的研究。在兩個模式中所給的問卷相同，但由於有兩個不同的論題，因此有兩種僅在第一題不同的問卷；該題意在探詢作答者對所涉論題之興趣。每份問卷有30題；題目分五大類：求知慾、學習模式、〔尋式〕特質、〔建式〕能力以及學習成效。　　從兩個教學模式收集來的兩組問卷資料，透過the rotated component matrix, the Pearson correlation, the Factor Analysis以及Wilcoxon Signed Ranks Test的統計方法來分析。分析結果與多數專家學者之論述或研究發現吻合，不過使某些論述更精緻化，尤其是牽涉到中國學生的部分。

以文找文

With the present author's two previous studies having verified the positive effect of constructive controversy (CC) over concurrence seeking (CS) on both the attitude change (2004) and persuasive writing itself (to be published) in EFL contexts, this study mainly tended to identify and distinguish the crucial mechanism that might have operated differently during the practice of the two models so that the interaction effects on learning, and the correlation between the interaction effects and potential dynamics might be better understood for further research on as well as a more successful application of the EFL Constructive Controversy Procedure this author revised and proposed. As in the two preceding studies, 5 classes of 121 non-English college majors were treated with the 2 measures: CC and CS, on 2 different topics by being given 2 pairs of texts alternatively to minimize the effect likely to result from a non-synchronic practice of the two measures in natural settings. In addition, a pilot study was conducted with 141 other college students to examine the distinction between and within the 4 texts in difficulty and controversy. The whole experiment lasted for 6 weeks, with 3 weeks as a unit. On the basis of the implications made or quest6ionnaires designed by many researchers (Dooley & Fryxell 1999; Johnson and Johnson 195; Tjosvold et al. 1981; Tjosvold 1998; and among others), two post-instruction surveys composed of 30 questions each were created across 5 major categories; epistemic curiosity, learning modes, CS attributes, CC strategic competence, and outcomes, with the last part saved for free comments. The two surveys were identical except for the first question regarding the intensity of interest in the addressed topic, which were administered on the 2nd and 4th weeks. The two corpuses of survey data collected from the 2 pedagogical models were computed through the rotated component matrix, the Pearson correlation, the Factor Analysis and Wilcoxon Signed Ranks Test. The findings corroborate many previous ones on one hand, and on the other hand, further elaborate some, particularly those concerning Chinese learners.

以文找文

期刊論文
1.	Hwang, K. K.(2003)。Critique of the methodology of empirical research on individual modernity in Taiwan。Asian Journal of Social Psychology，6，241-262。
2.	Zhang, Q.(1994)。An intervention model of constructive conflict resolution and cooperative learning。Journal of Social Issues，50(1)，99-116。
3.	Hwang, K. K.(1997)。Guanxi and Mientze: Conflict resolution in Chinese society。Intercultural Communication Studies，7(1)，17-42。
4.	Thompson, Leigh L.、Hrebec, Dennis(1996)。Lose-lose agreements in interdependent decision making。Psychological Bulletin，120(3)，396-409。
5.	Tjosvold, D.(1983)。Social face in conflict: A critique。International Journal of Group Tensions，13(1-4)，49-64。
6.	陳昭全、陳曉萍、Meindl, J. R.(1998)。How can cooperation be fostered? The cultural effects of individualism-collectivism。Academy of Management Review，23(2)，285-304。
7.	Chu, L.(1979)。The sensitivity of Chinese and American children to social influences。The Journal of Social Psychology，109，175-186。
8.	Cooper, L.、Johnson, D. W.、Johnson, R. T.、Wilderson, F.(1980)。Effects of cooperative, competitive, and individualistic experiences on interpersonal attraction among heterogeneous peers。Journal of Social Psychology，111，243-252。
9.	Cosier, R. A.、Ruble, T. L.(1981)。Research on Conflict-handling Behavior: An Experimental Approach。Academy of Management Journal，24(4)，816-831。
10.	Cox, T. H.、Lobel, S. A.、McLeod, P. L.(1991)。Effects of ethnic group cultural differences on cooperative and competitive behavior on a group task。Academy of Management Journal，34(4)，827-847。
11.	Daniels, R.(1994)。Motivational mediators of cooperative learning。Psychological Reports，74，1011-1022。
12.	Deutsch, M.(1949)。An experimental study of the effects of cooperation and competition upon group processes。Human Relations，2(3)，199-232。
13.	Deutsch, M.(1994)。Constructive conflict resolution: Principles, training, and research。Journal of Social Issues，50(1)，13-32。
14.	Dooley, R. S.、Fryxell, G. E.(1999)。Attaining decision quality and commitment from dissent: The moderating effects of loyalty and competence in strategic decision-making teams。Academy of Management Journal，42(4)，389-402。
15.	Falk, D. R.、Johnson, D. W.(1977)。The effects of perspective-taking and egocentrism on problem solving in heterogeneous and homogeneous groups。Journal of Social Psychology，102，63-72。
16.	Innami, I.(1994)。The quality of group decisions, group verbal behavior, and intervention。Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes，60，409-430。
17.	Johnson, D. W.(1971)。Role reversal: A summary and review of the research。International Journal of Group Tensions，1(4)，318-334。
18.	Johnson, D. W.(1971)。The effectiveness of role reversal: The actor or the listener。Psychological Reports，28，275-282。
19.	Johnson, D. W.、Johnson, R. T.(1979)。Conflict in the classroom: Controversy and learning。Review of Educational Research，49(1)，51-70。
20.	Johnson, D. W.、Johnson, R.(1985)。Classroom conflict: Controversy versus debate in learning groups。American Educational Research Journal，22(2)，237-256。
21.	Johnson, D. W.、Johnson, R.(1994)。Constructive conflict in the schools。Journal of Social Issues，50(1)，117-137。
22.	Johnson, R.、Brooker, C.、Stutzman, J.、Hultman, D.、Johnson, D. W.(1985)。The effects of controversy, concurrence seeking, and individualistic learning on achievement and attitude change。Journal of Research in Science Teaching，22(3)，197-205。
23.	Littlewood, W. T.(1999)。Defining and developing autonomy in East Asian contexts。Applied Linguistics，20(1)，71-94。
24.	Lowry, N.、Johnson, D. W.(1981)。Effects of controversy on epistemic curiosity, achievement, and attitudes。The Journal of Social Psychology，115，31-43。
25.	Nemeth, C.、Wachtler, J.(1974)。Creating the perceptions of consistency and confidence: A necessary condition for minority influence。Sociometry，37(4)，529-540。
26.	Owens, L.、Straton, R. G.(1980)。The development of a co-operative, competitive, and individualized learning preference scale for students。British Journal of Educational Psychology，50(2)，147-161。
27.	Rubin, J. Z.(1994)。Models of conflict management。Journal of Social Issues，50(1)，33-45。
28.	Schweiger, D. M.、Sandberg, W. R.、Ragan, J. W.(1986)。Group Approaches for Improving Strategic Decision Making: A Comparative Analysis of Dialectical Inquiry, Devil's Advocacy, and Consensus。The Academy of Management Journal，29(1)，51-71。
29.	Smith, K. A.、Johnson, D. W.、Johnson, R. T.(1981)。Can conflict be constructive? Controversy versus concurrence seeking in learning groups。Journal of Educational Psychology，73(5)，651-663。
30.	Smith, K. A.、Johnson, D. W.、Johnson, R. T.(1984)。Effects of controversy on learning in cooperative groups。The Journal of Social Psychology，122，199-209。
31.	Tjosvold, D.(1998)。Cooperative and Competitive Goal Approach to Conflict: Accomplishments and Challenges。Applied Psychology: An International Review，47(3)，285-342。
32.	Tjosvold, D.、Dann, V.、Wong, C.(1992)。Managing conflict between departments to serve customers。Human Relations，45(10)，1035-1054。
33.	Tjosvold, D.、Johnson, D. W.(1978)。Controversy within a cooperative or competitive context and cognitive perspective taking。Contemporary Educational Psychology，3，376-386。
34.	Tjosvold, D.、Johnson, D. W.(1977)。The effects of controversy on cognitive perspective taking。Journal of Educational Psychology，69，679-685。
35.	Tjosvold, D.、Johnson, D. W.、Lemer, J.(1981)。Effects of affirmation and acceptance on incorporation of opposing information in problem-solving。The Journal of Social Psychology，114，103-110。
36.	Wong, C. C.、Tjosvold, D.、Lee, F.(1992)。Managing conflict in a diverse workforce: A Chinese perspective in North America。Small Group Research，23，302-332。
37.	Yi, Ching-ching(20010100)。Practical Ways to Maximize the Efficacy of Cooperation。英語教學，25(3)=99，64-85。
38.	Fiske, A. P.(2002)。Using individualism and collectivism to compare cultures: A critique of the validity and measurement of the constructs. Comment on Oyserman et al (2002)。Psychological Bulletin，128，78-88。
39.	Hwang, K. K.(2003)。In search of a new paradigm for cultural psychology。Asian Journal of Social Psychology，6，287-291。
40.	Ho, J.、Crookall, D.(1995)。Breaking with Chinese cultural traditions: Learner autonomy in English language teaching。System，23(2)，235-244。
41.	Deutsch, M.(1969)。Conflicts: Productive and destructive。Journal of Social Issues，25(1)，7-41。
42.	Dörnyei, Z.、Malderez, A.(1997)。Group dynamics and foreign language teaching。System，25(1)，65-81。
43.	Hofetede, Greet(1993)。Cultural constraints in management theories。Academy of Management Executive，7(1)，81-94。
44.	黃光國(1987)。Face and favor: the Chinese power game。American Journal of Sociology，92(4)，944-974。
45.	Johnson, D. W.(1967)。The use of role reversal in intergroup competition。Journal of Personality and Social Psychology，7，135-141。
46.	Van Blerkom, M.、Tjosvold, D.(1981)。The effects of social context on engaging in controversy。Journal of Psychology，107，141-145。

會議論文
1.	Yi, C. C.(2004)。Effects of cognitive conflict on attitude change: Controversy versus concurrence seeking。Thirteenth International Symposium on English Teaching。
2.	Yi, C. C.(2005)。Provoking and Utilizing Cognitive Conflicts in EFL Speaking Instruction。The 2nd Cross-Strait Conference on Foreign Languages Teaching and Learning in Shanghai, China。Shanghai, China。

圖書
1.	Deutsch, Morton(1973)。The Resolution of Conflict: Constructive of Destructive Processes。New Haven：Yale University Press。
2.	Piaget, Jean、Piercy, M.、Berlyne, D. E.(1950)。The Psychology of Intelligence。Routledge and Kegan Paul。
3.	Tjosvold, D.(1991)。The conflict-positive organization: Stimulate diversity and create unity。Reading, Massachusetts：Addison-Wesley Publishing Company。
4.	Yi, C. C.(2004)。Constructive Controversy vs. Concurrence Seeking: An Action Research in EFL Contexts。Taipei：Taiwan ELT Publishing Co., LTD。

圖書論文
1.	Tjosvold, D.、Leung, K.、Johnson, D. W.(2000)。Cooperative and competitive conflict in China。Handbook of Conflict Resolution: Theory and Practice。San Francisco, CA：Jossey-Bass Publishers。
2.	Raider, E.、Coleman, S.、Gerson, J.(2000)。Teaching conflict resolution skills in a workshop。The Handbook of Conflict Resolution: Theory and Practice。San Francisco：Jossey-Bass Publishers。
3.	Johnson, D. W.、Johnson, R. T.、Tjosvold, D.(2000)。Constructive controversy: The value of intellectual opposition。The Handbook of Conflict Resolution: Theory and Practice。San Francisco：Jossey-Bass Publishers。
4.	Weitzman, E. A.、Weitzman, P. F.(2000)。Problem solving and decision making in conflict resolution。The Handbook of Conflict Resolution: Theory and Practice。San Francisco：Jossey-Bass Publishers。

推文
推薦
引用網址
引用嵌入語法
轉寄

top

:::

相關期刊
相關論文
相關專書
相關著作
熱門點閱

1.	合作與競爭關係中社會比較對高中生認知信任與情感信任的影響
2.	供應鏈環境下的企業競爭情報增值運作模式研究
3.	供應鏈環境下企業內外部競爭情報體系及其運作流程分析--基於信息和關係視角
4.	不同決策模式下製造商與再製造商的博弈策略研究
5.	Factors Influencing the Practice of Constructive Controversy across Different Levels of Language Proficiency
6.	美中關係：既競爭又合作
7.	競爭與合作對團隊凝聚力的影響
8.	電腦遊戲對學習動機與學習效果的影響：一個學習二進位數字之運算的研究
9.	企業要競爭更要合作--專訪經濟部中小企業處第二組簡世雄組長
10.	臺灣、香港國小學童的競爭與合作行為

1.	引進再生能源之關係遠景：適合永續市場發展之政策

1.	學「競爭」？學「合作」？

無相關著作

無相關點閱

QR Code

臺灣人文及社會科學引文索引資料庫系統

詳目顯示

臺灣人文及社會科學引文索引資料庫