University Research Rankings : From Page Counting to Academic Accountability_

:::

詳目顯示

第 1 筆 / 總合 1 筆

/1頁

來源文獻資料
外文摘要
引文資料

題名：	University Research Rankings : From Page Counting to Academic Accountability
書刊名：	高教評鑑
作者：	Pagell, Ruth A.
出版日期：	2009
卷期：	3:1
頁次：	頁71-102
主題關鍵詞：	Higher education；Universities and colleges；Bibliometrics；Research；University rankings
原始連結：	連回原系統網址
相關次數：	被引用次數:期刊(0) 博士論文(0) 專書(0) 專書論文(0) 排除自我引用:0 共同引用:0 點閱:184

The globalization of the education industry and concern by governments and funding bodies for academic accountability have turned university rankings into an international game with widening participation not only from North America and Europe but from the Asia-Pacific region. This paper provides a literature review that synthesizes current international and national policies and accountability initiatives with the history of research rankings and the use of bibliometrics to produce 21st century university research rankings. It explains key bibliometric measures and how the current ranking systems apply them. It highlights the commonalities and differences in rankings over time. The growth of research from Asian universities is a positive sign for the gradual rise of Asian universities in the top lists at the same time that the best from the past remain the best of today.

以文找文

期刊論文
1.	Farrell, E. R.、Van Der Werf, M.(2007)。Playing the rankings game。The Chronicle of Higher Education，53(38)，A.11。
2.	Leung, K.(2007)。The glory and tyranny of citation impact: An East Asian perspective。Academy of Management Journal，50(3)，510-513。
3.	Merisotis, J.、Sadlak, J.(2005)。Higher education rankings: Evolution, acceptance, and dialogue。Higher Education in Europe，30(2)，97-101。
4.	Robinson, Larry M.、Adler, Roy(1981)。Measuring the Impact of Marketing Scholars and Institutions: An Analysis of Citation Frequency。Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science，9，147-162。
5.	Kirkpatrick, S. A.、Locke, E. A.(1992)。The development of measures of faculty scholarship。Group & Organization Management，17(1)，5-23。
6.	(2002)。From the Editors。Higher Education in Europe，27(4)，359。
7.	Garfield, E.、Sher, I. H.(1963)。New factors in the evaluation of scientific literature through citation indexing。American Documentation，14(3)，195-201。
8.	Baltagi, B. H.(2007)。Worldwide econometric rankings。Econometric Theory，23(5)，952-1012。
9.	Bjomebom, L.、Ingwersen, P.(2004)。Toward a basic framework for webometrics。Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology，55(14)，1216-1227。
10.	Blau, P. M.、Margulies, R. Z.(1974)。A research replication. The Reputations of American Professional Schools。Change，74/75，42-47。
11.	Bollag, B.(2007)。College rankings catch on overseas。The Chronicle of Higher Education，53(38)，A.17。
12.	Byrne, J. A.(1988)。The best B-Schools。Business Week，3081，76-80。
13.	Cleary, F. R.、Edwards, D. J.(1960)。The origins of the contributors to the A.E.R. during the fifties。The American Economic Review，50(5)，1011-1014。
14.	Corley, K.、Gioia, D.(2000)。The ranking game: Managing business school reputation。Corporate Reputation Review，3(4)，319-333。
15.	Hazelkorn, E.(2008)。Learning to live with league tables and ranking: The experience of institutional leaders。Higher Education Policy，21(2)，193-215。
16.	Henry,W. R.、Burch, E. E.(1974)。Institutional contributions to scholarly journals of business。The Journal of Business，47(1)，56-66。
17.	Heck, J. L.、Cooley, P. L.、Hubbard, C. M.(1986)。Contributing authors and institutions to the Journal of Finance: 1946-1985。The Journal of Finance，41(5)，1129-1140。
18.	Declan, B.(2007)。Academics strike back at spurious rankings。Nature，447(7144)，514-515。
19.	(2007)。Editorial。Higher Education in Europe，32(1)，1-3。
20.	Enserink, M.(2007)。Who ranks the university rankers?。Science，317(5841)，1026-1028。
21.	Hirsch, J.(2005)。An index to quantify and individual's scientific research output。Proceedings of the National Academy of Science，102(46)，16569-16572。
22.	Hall, A. D.(1990)。Worldwide rankings of research activity in econometrics: An update: 1980-1988。Econometric Theory，6(1)，1-16。
23.	Hall, A. D.(1987)。Worldwide rankings of research activity in econometrics: 1980-1985。Econometric Theory，3(2)，171-194。
24.	Harzing, A. W. K.、van der Wall(2008)。Google Scholar as a new source for citation analysis。Ethics in Science and Environmental Politics，8(1)，61-73。
25.	Hazelkom, E.(2007)。The impact of league tables and ranking systems on higher education decision making。Higher Education Management & Policy，19(2)，87-110。
26.	Meredith, M.(2004)。Why do universities compete in the ratings game? An empirical analysis of the effects of the U.S. news and world report college rankings。Research in Higher Education，45(5)，443-461。
27.	Mishra, D. C.(2008)。Citations: Rankings weigh against developing nations。Nature，451(7116)，244。
28.	Hvistendahl, M.(2008)。The man behind the world's most-watched college rankings。The Chronicle of Higher Education，55(8)，A.29。
29.	Jacsó, Peter(2006)。Deflated, inflated and phantoin citation counts。Online Information Review，30(3)，297-309。
30.	Jacsó, P.(2005)。As we may search -- Comparison of major features of the Web of Science, Scopus, and Google Scholar。Current Science，89，1537-1547。
31.	Jacso, P.(2008)。Google Scholar revisited。Online Information Review，32(1)，102-114。
32.	Jin, J. C.、Hong, J.-H.(2008)。East Asian rankings of economics departments。Journal of Asian Economics，19(1)，74-82。
33.	Jin, J. C.、Yau, L.(1999)。Research productivity of the economics profession in East Asia。Economic Inquiry，37(4)，706-710。
34.	Klemlcosky, R. C.、Tuttle, D. L.(1977)。A ranking of doctoral programs by financial research contributions of graduates。The Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis，12(3)，491-497。
35.	Kroc, R. J.(1984)。Using citation analysis to assess scholarly productivity。Educational Researcher，13(6)，17-22。
36.	Labi, A.(2008)。Obsession with rankings goes global。The Chronicle of Higher，55(8)，A.27。
37.	Liu, N, C.、Cheng, Y.(2005)。The academic ranking of world universities。Higher Education in Europe，30(2)，127-136。
38.	Magoun, H. W.(1966)。The cartter report on quality in graduate education: Institutional and divisional standings compiled from the report。The Journal of Higher Education，37(9)，481-492。
39.	Meho, L. I.、Yang, K.(2007)。Impact of data sources on citation counts and rankings of LIS faculty: Web of Science Versus Scopus and Google Scholar。Journal of the American Society for Information Science & Technology，58(13)，2105-2125。
40.	Moore, L. J.、Taylor, B. W, I.(1980)。A study of institutional publications in business-related academic journals, 1972-78。Quarterly Review of Economics and Business，Spring，87-97。
41.	Niemi, A. W.(1988)。Research productivity of American business schools, 1975-85。Review of Business and Economic Research，23(1)。
42.	Pagell, R. A.、Lusk, E, J.(2002)。Benchmarking academic business school libraries relative to their business school rankings。Journal of Business & Finance Librarianship，7(4)，3。
43.	Paul, R. J.(2008)。Measuring research quality: The United Kingdom government's research assessment exercise。European Journal of Information Systems，17(4)，324-329。
44.	Petry, G. H.(1981)。A history and analysis of scholarly papers presented at the seven academic Finance association from 1939 through 1980。Financial Management (1972)，10(2)，93-104。
45.	Pritchard, A.(1969)。Statistical bibliography or bibliometric?。Journal of Documentation，25，348-349。
46.	Petry, G. H.、Settle, J.(1988)。A comprehensive analysis of worldwide scholarly productivity in selected US business journals。The Quarterly Review of Economics and Business，25(3)，88。
47.	Salmi, J.、Saroyan, A.(2007)。League tables as policy instruments: Uses and misuses。Higher Education Management & Policy，19(2)，31-68。
48.	Schubert, W. H.(1979)。Contributions to AERA annual programs as an indicator of institutional productivity。Educational Researcher，8(7)，13-17。
49.	(2008)。Tender: Designing and Testing the Feasibility of a Multi-Dimensional Global University Ranking。EUBusiness。
50.	Trieschmann, J. S.、Dennis, A. R.、Northcraft, G. B.、Niemi, A., W. Jr.(2000)。Serving multiple constituencies in business schools: M.B.A. program versus research perfonnance。Academy of Management Journal，43，1130。
51.	Klemlcosky, R. C.、Tuttle, D. L.(1977)。The institutional source and concentration of financial research。The Journal of Finance，32(3)，901-907。

會議論文
1.	Federkeils G.(2008)。Ranking higher education institutions -- A European perspective。
2.	Federkeils G.(2009)。Ranking -- New developments in Europe。
3.	Huang, M.-H.(2008)。Performance ranking of scientific papers for world universities。
4.	Pagell, R. A.(2008)。Bibliometrics: From bean counting to academic accountability。
5.	Usher, A.(2008)。Rankings 2.0 -- The foture of university rankings。
6.	Morse, R. J.(2008)。U.S. News & World Report's America's Best College Rankings: Why are they done? What methodology is used? What has been the impact in the U.S. and the world? What are some implications of the U.S. ranking experience for Taiwan universities and Taiwan colle。

圖書
1.	Carter, Allan Murray(1966)。An Assessment of Quality in Graduate Education。Washington, D. C.：American Council on Education, Commission on Plans for Higher Education。
2.	Henshaw, J. T.(2006)。The ratings game: Overall 'measurement and rankings'. In Does measurement measure up? : How numbers reveal and conceal the truth。Baltimore。
3.	Hughes, R. M.(1925)。A study of the graduate schools of America。Oxford, Ohio。
4.	Morse, R. J.(2009)。Paper on university, rankings for HEEACT。New York。
5.	Uslier, A.、Savino, M.(2006)。A world of difference: A global survey of university league tables。Toronto (ON)。

其他
1.	Dolan, W. P.(1976)。The ranking game: The power of the academic elite。
2.	Harzing, A.-W.(2009)。Publish or perish。
3.	(n.d.)。Business School Research Ranking，http://www.kelley.indiana.edu/ardennis/rankings/， 20090104。
4.	(2007)，http://www.sinoss.net/en-us/stat/index.jsp， 20090127。
5.	(n.d.)，http://www.sinoss.net/en-us/stat/stat02.htm， 20090105。
6.	(2008)。Leiden Ranking 2008，http://www.cwts.nl/ranlcing/LeidenRankingWebSite.html， 20081223。
7.	(n.d.)。2008 International Symposium Ranking in Higher Education on the Global and National Stages，http://www.heeact.edu.tw/conference2008/， 20090530。
8.	(2003)。Academic Ranking of World Universities \ ARWU，http://www.arwu.org/rank2008/EN2008.htm， 20090121。
9.	(2008)。Academic Research and Development，http://www.nsf.gov/statistics/seind08/， 20090103。
10.	Bollag, B.。International group endorses principles for ranking of higher-education，http://chronicle.com/daily/2006/06/2006060103n.htm， 20081224。
11.	Keniston, H.(1959)。Graduate study and research in the arts and sciences at the university of Pennsylvania (1957)，http;//repositoiy.upenn.edu/penn_history/4/， 20081229。
12.	(2009)。Master Journal List，http://scientific.thomson.com/mjl/， 20090120。
13.	Institute for Higher Education Policy(2007)。College and university ranking systems: Global perspectives and American challenges，http://www.ihep.org/Publications/publications-detail.efm?id=11， 2008/12/14。
14.	European Commission(2008)。Design and test the feasibility of a multidimensional global university ranking，http://ec.europa.eu/education/programmes/calls/3608/annexl_en.pdf， 20090104。
15.	(2008)。The Excellence in Research for Australia (ERA) Initiative，http://www.axc.gov.au/era/， 20081218。
16.	Geuna, A.，Martin, B. R.(2001)。University research evaluation and funding: An international comparison，http://www.sussex.ac.uk/spru/publications/imprint/sewps/sewp71/sewp71.pdf， 20090125。
17.	(2009)。IDEAS Rankings，http://ideas.repec.org/top/， 20090214。
18.	IHEP(2006)。Berlin principles on ranking of higher education institutions，http://www.ihep.org/assets/files/publications/a-f/BerlinPrinciplesRanking.pdf， 20090502。
19.	Johnson, L. B.(1965)。514 -- Statement by the president to the cabinet and memorandum on strengthening academic capability for science，http://www.presidency.ucsb.edu/ws/index.php?pid=27257， 20090213。
20.	UT Dallas School of Management(2008)。The UTD top 100 business school research rankings，http://top100.utdallas.edu/， 20090116。
21.	Miyairi, N.(2008)。Using bibliometrics: A guide to evaluating research.performance with citation data，http://www.online-information.co.uk/online08/files/brochures/2492/Bibliometrics_white_paper.pdf， 20081228。
22.	(2007)。Morse Code: Inside College Ranking，http://www.usnews.com/blogs/college-rankmgs-blog/index.html， 20090601。
23.	OECD Directorate for Education(2008)。OECD feasibility study for the international assessment of higher education learning outcomes (AHELO) 20081223。
24.	(2009)。Scopus in Detail: What does it Cover?，http://www.info.scopus.com/detail/what/， 20090120。
25.	THE-QS(2005)。THE-QS world university rankings，http://www.topuniversities.com/， 20090125。
26.	(2009)，http://www.ugc.edu.hk/eng/ugc/about/about.htm， 20090125。
27.	van Raan, A. F. J.，Moed,Henk，van Leeuven, Thed N.(2007)。Scoping study on the use of bibliometric analysis to measure the quality of research in UK higher education institutions, 131，http://www.hefce.ac.uk/pubs/rdreports/2007/rd18_07/， 20090301。
28.	Walslie, J.(2007)。OECD: Worldwide obsession with league tables，http://www.universityworldnews.com/article.php?story=20071108145803689， 20090226。
29.	(2008)。World's Best Colleges and Universities，http://www.usnews.com/sections/education/worlds-best-colleges/index.html， 20081201。
30.	Gooch, L.(2008)。A new order ranking for universities in SE Asia should focus on development。
31.	Hazelkorn, E.(2007)。OECD: Consumer concept becomes a policy instrument，http://www.universityworldnews.com/article.php?story=20071108144018483， 20090226。
32.	HEEACT(2007)。Performance rankings of scientific papers for world universities，http://www.heeact.org.tw/eng/EngIntroduction.aspx?F=1， 20090124。
33.	HEEACT(2009)。College navigator in Taiwan，http://140.136.202.38:83/mdex2.asp?method=eintro， 20090218。
34.	HEFCE(2009)。Higher education funding council for England -- Research，http://www.hefce.ac.uk/research/， 20090301。

推文
推薦
引用網址
引用嵌入語法
轉寄

top

:::

相關期刊
相關論文
相關專書
相關著作
熱門點閱

無相關期刊論文

無相關博士論文

無相關書籍

無相關著作

1.	學術論文被引用次數之分析研究：以Science Citation Index Expanded及Scopus為例

QR Code

臺灣人文及社會科學引文索引資料庫系統

詳目顯示

臺灣人文及社會科學引文索引資料庫