:::

詳目顯示

回上一頁
題名:我國精神衛生法強制社區治療制度之未來--以比較法制之經驗切入
書刊名:軍法專刊
作者:丁正杰
作者(外文):Ting, Chen-chieh
出版日期:2010
卷期:56:3
頁次:頁207-226
主題關鍵詞:強制社區治療精神衛生法CTOMOTMental health actCommunity treatment ordersMandatory outpatient treatment
原始連結:連回原系統網址new window
相關次數:
  • 被引用次數被引用次數:期刊(3) 博士論文(0) 專書(0) 專書論文(0)
  • 排除自我引用排除自我引用:3
  • 共同引用共同引用:0
  • 點閱點閱:129
精神衛生法已於2007 年修正並於隔年施行,且本次修正也開東亞之先河,引進強制社區治療制度。然精神衛生法之條文規定,仍存有某程度之解釋疑義存在,而撰文之時尚未出現任何案例,故難以求諸實務見解答上開疑義。本文由比較法出發,先對於此一國人極度陌生之制度,由定義、歷史脈絡、爭議點等不同面相,予以概略性之介紹。次而以加拿大為例,介紹其強制社區治療制度,並輔以實證研究之成果,探討強制社區治療在加拿大之實踐情況。從而以比較法之經驗為借鏡,主張現行強制社區治療之適用標準,可依文義解釋及擴張解釋,而納入加拿大造成自己或他人傷害或是惡化性之標準,彌補我國法適用標準空泛之弊病。此外,本文也認為我國法可無視病人之反對施予強制社區治療之規定有所不妥,應予刪除。另應明定每次延長治療均應經過審查會實體審查通過方可為之。最後在程序保障以及資訊提供方面,由於加拿大法制也較缺乏,可以西澳洲之法制規定為借鏡,建議我國於修法時,應對於強制社區治療病患之權利清單以及救濟途徑有所規定,以達法制完備之目的。
Taiwan's Mental Health Act was revised in 2007, and came into effect in 2008. After this revision, Mandatory outpatient treatment (MOT) was formally induced into Taiwan. Although there hasn't been any case in Taiwan since 2008, There are still certain problems that need to be solved in interpreting laws. In this article, I will review Canadian's system, and try to find solutions to the Taiwanese problems via Canadian and other countries'expe rience First, I will define the concept of MOT, classifies the type of MOT, especially so-called community treatment order (CTO), and point out some of common arguments about CTO. Then I will focus on Canadian's experience. Next section I will contend that Canadian's standard can be used to help us deal with the abstract Taiwanese Mental health Act. Furthermore, some part of the Act, such as the duration of CTO, the consent of receiving CTO, and the procedural protection of patients, need to be improved and revised.
期刊論文
1.Geller, Jeffrey L.(2006)。The evolution of outpatient commitment in the USA: From conundrum to quagmire。International Journal of Law and Psychiatry,29。  new window
2.Gray, John E.、O'Reilly, Richard L.(2005)。Canadian compulsory community treatment laws: Recent reforms。International Journal of Law and Psychiatry,28。  new window
3.Gray, John E.、O'Reilly, Richard L.(2001)。Clinically Significant Differences Among Canadian Mental Health Acts。Canadian Journal of Psychiatry,46。  new window
4.Hunt, Alison M.、da Silva, Angela(2007)。Community Treatment Orders in Toronto: The Emerging Data。Canadian Journal of Psychiatr,52(10)。  new window
5.Kisely, Stephen、Campbell, Leslie Anne、Preston, Neil J.、Xiao, Jianguo(2006)。Can epidemiological studies assist in the evaluation of community treatment orders? The experience of Western Australia and Nova Scotia。International Journal of Law and Psychiatry,29。  new window
6.O'Reilly, Richard L.、Brooks, Simon A.(2003)。CPA Position Paper: Mandatory Outpatient Treatment。Canadian Journal of Psychiatry,48(7)。  new window
7.O'Reilly, Richard(2004)。Why Are Community Treatment Orders Controversial?。Canadian Journal of Psychiatry,49(9),579-584。  new window
8.O'Brien, Anthony J.、McKenna, Brian G.、Kydd, Robert R.(2009)。Compulsory community mental health treatment: Literature review 6。International Journal of Nursing studies。  new window
9.O'Reilly, R.L.、Keegan, D.L.、Elias, J.W.(2000)。A Survey of the Use of Community Treatment Orders by Psychiatrists in Saskatchewan。Canadian Journal of Psychiatry,45。  new window
10.O'Brien, Ann-Marie A.、Farrell, Susan J.(2005)。Community Treatment Orders: Profile of a Canadian Experience。Canadian Journal of Psychiatry,50(1)。  new window
11.Power, Paddy(1999)。Community treatment orders: the Australian experience。The Journal of Forensic Psychiatry,10(1)。  new window
12.Preston, Neil J.、Kisely, Steve、Xiao, Jianguo(2002)。Assessing the outcome of compulsory psychiatric treatment in the community: epidemiological study in Western Australia。British Medical Journal \url\http://www.bmj.com/cgi/content/full/324/7348/1244,324。  new window
13.Rolfe, Tim、Sheehan, Bernadette、Davidson, Rowan(2008)。Are consumers on community treatment orders informed of their legal and human rights? A West Australian study。International Journal of Mental Health Nursing,17(1)。  new window
14.吳建昌、宋維村。強制社區治療之倫理問題。臺灣精神醫學,22(2)。  延伸查詢new window
學位論文
1.林思蘋(2009)。強制治療與監護處分--對精神障礙者之社會控制(碩士論文)。臺灣大學。  延伸查詢new window
2.王皇玉(1995)。醫療行為於刑法上之評價:以患者之自我決定權為中心(碩士論文)。國立臺灣大學。  延伸查詢new window
3.洪長成。強制精神醫療審查會之社會控制機能。國立臺灣大學。  延伸查詢new window
其他
1.Churchill, Rachel,Owen, Gareth,Singh, Swaran,Hotopf, Matthew(2007)。International experiences of using community treatment orders, Institute of Psychiatry, London。  new window
2.  延伸查詢new window
3.  延伸查詢new window
4.  延伸查詢new window
5.  延伸查詢new window
 
 
 
 
第一頁 上一頁 下一頁 最後一頁 top
QR Code
QRCODE