The Conflict/ Continuity between Renaissance and Neoclassicism: Multi-voiced Presentation of the Human Capability in Pope's Essay on Criticism_

:::

詳目顯示

第 1 筆 / 總合 1 筆

/1頁

來源文獻資料
摘要
外文摘要
引文資料

題名：	The Conflict/ Continuity between Renaissance and Neoclassicism: Multi-voiced Presentation of the Human Capability in Pope's Essay on Criticism
書刊名：	興大人文學報
作者：	張登翰
作者(外文)：	Zhang, Deng-han
出版日期：	2010
卷期：	45
頁次：	頁107-151
主題關鍵詞：	亞歷山大．波普；批評論；巴克汀；對話；多重音；人之能力；Alexander Pope；Essay on Criticism；Bakhtin；Dialogue；Multi-voicedness；Human capability
原始連結：	連回原系統網址
相關次數：	被引用次數:期刊(0) 博士論文(0) 專書(0) 專書論文(0) 排除自我引用:0 共同引用:0 點閱:67

波普肩負文藝復興時代人文主義之承傳，在其詩學及對人類能力的論述中，展現了多重音(multi-voicedness)的特色。此多重音之特性實源於波普學習過程中，和古人及今人不斷對話，彰顯了文藝復興和新古典之衝突∕承續，且可從巴克汀之對話理論觀點，以《批評論》加以進一步說明。波普研究經典，用功頗深，企圖實現人文主義中「文藝復興人」(Renaissance Man)的理想；然而，波普強調限制才思，不可任其肆意發展，並認為人的潛力有限；在他詩學之中，看不到明顯的「進步觀」(the idea of progress)－而這是啟蒙時代特有的思想。他鼓勵批評家對文化及社會要培養全方位的認知，並在文化的架構下閱讀文學；不過他也指出：由於人的能力有限，批評家最好專精一項「學問」即可。《批評論》中之說話者，可認定為波普本人；他其實偏離了卡斯提里歐(Castiglione)所提「文藝復興人」的理想，也沒有建立一套前後一致、觀點和諧的詩學。他預設了天道(Nature)，一種超然的力量，並意圖將之加諸在詩歌與評論上；然而波普多重音論述所帶來的異質性，卻顛覆了此超然力量的絕對性。所謂真理和批評，並非出自一超越、絕對標準之指引，而出於批評家與文化之持續對話。

以文找文

With the heritage of Renaissance humanism, Alexander Pope demonstrates multi-voicedness in his poetics and in his discourse on human capability. This multi-voicedness, resulting from his dialogues with ancients and moderns, exemplifies the conflict/continuity of Renaissance and Neoclassicism, and can be further illustrated in Essay on Criticism from the Bakhtinian dialogism. Pope studied the classics assiduously, and intended to achieve a humanist ideal of the Renaissance man; however, he emphasizes the restraint of wit and the limitation of human potential more than he affirms the idea of progress, the unique mark of Enlightenment. He encourages critics to cultivate a panoramic view of culture and society, and to read literature in the context of culture, but he also indicates that a critic can only devote himself to studying one specific "art" because of the limits of human capability. The multi-voiced speaker in Essay on Criticism, which can be identified as Pope himself, deviates from the ideal Renaissance courtier proposed by Castiglione and does not establish consistent, harmonious poetics. He endeavors to impose a transcendental power, Nature, on poetry and criticism, yet this centripetal force is upset by heterogeneity in Pope's multi-voiced discourse. Valid truth and criticism do not come from the guidance of a transcendental and absolute standard, but from continual dialogue between critics (parts) and culture (whole).

以文找文

期刊論文
1.	Bellanca, Mary Ellen(1994)。Alien Voices, Ancient Echoes: Bakhtin, Dialogism, and Pope's Essay on Criticism。Papers on Language and Literature: A Journal for Scholars and Critics of Language and Literature，30(1)，57-72。
2.	Brown, Murray、Spahr, Heather(2000)。Studies in the Literary Imagination38(1)。
3.	Cutting-Gray, Joanne、Swearingen, James E.(1992)。System, the Divided Mind, and the Essay on Man。Studines in English Literature, 1500-1900，32(3)，479-494。
4.	Edgecombe, Rodney Stenning(2005)。Pope's An Essay on Criticism。Explicator，63(4)，212-213。
5.	Griffin, Robert(1983)。Pope, the Prophets, and The Dunciad。Studies in English Literature 1500-1900，23(3)，435-446。
6.	Lindop, Grevel(2001)。Wordsworth, Pope and the Alps。Romanticism: The Journal of Romantic Culture and Criticism，7(1)，58-72。
7.	Peterson, R. G.(1975)。Renaissance Classicism in Pope's Dunciad。Studies in English Literature 1500-1900，15(3)，431-445。
8.	Rogers, Pat(2000)。John Philips, Pope, and Political Georgic。Modern Language Quarterly，66(4)，411-412。
9.	Woodman, Thomas(2005)。Pope and the Paradoxical Centrality of the Satirist。Studies in the Literary Imagination，38(1)，1-13。

圖書
1.	Brower, Reuben A.(1959)。Alexander Pope: The Poetry of Allusion。Oxford：Oxford UP。
2.	Richetti, John(2005)。The Cambridge History of English Literature, 1660-1780。Cambridge：Cambridge UP。
3.	Sutherland, James(1969)。Restoration Literature 1660-1700: Dryden, Bunyan, and Pepys。Oxford：Clarendon。
4.	Emerson, Caryl、Holquist, Michael、McGee, Vern W.(1994)。Speech Genres and Other Late Essays。Texas UP。
5.	Sitter, John(2001)。The Cambridge Companion to Eighteenth Century Poetry。Cambridge UP。
6.	Sampson, George(1970)。The Concise Cambridge History of English Literature。Cambridge。
7.	Booth, Wayne C.(1961)。Introduction。Minneapolis。
8.	Plato(1993)。Republic。Oxford。
9.	Jameson, Fredric(1984)。Foreword。The Postmodern Condition: A Report on Knowledge。Bloomington。
10.	Greenblatt, Stephen(2006)。The Norton Anthology of English Literature。New York：Norton。
11.	Frye, N.(1947)。Fearful Symmetry: A Study of William Blake。Princeton, NJ：Princeton University Press。
12.	Morson, Gary Saul、Emerson, Caryl(1990)。Mikhail Bakhtin: Creation of a Prosaics。Stanford University Press。
13.	Adams, Hazard(1992)。Critical Theory Since Plato。Harcourt Brace Jovanovich。
14.	Bakhtin, Mikhail Mikhailovich、Emerson, Caryl、Holquist, Michael(1981)。The Dialogic Imagination: Four Essays by M. M. Austin。Austin, TX：University of Texas Press。
15.	Bakhtin, Mikhail M.、Medvedev, P. N.、Wehrle, Albert J.(1978)。The Formal Method in Literary Scholarship: A Critical Introduction to Sociological Poetics。Johns Hopkins University Press。
16.	Frye, Northrop(1971)。Anatomy of Criticism: Four Essays。Princeton University Press。
17.	Bakhtin, Mikhail、Emerson, Caryl(1984)。Problems of Dostoevsky's Poetics。University of Minnesota Press。
18.	Bakhtin, Mikhail Mikhailovich、Liapunov, Vadim、Holquist, Michael(1993)。Toward a philosophy of the act。University of Texas Press。
19.	Bakhtin, Mikhail M.、Iswolsky, Hélène(1984)。Rabelais and His World。Indiana University Press。
20.	Longinus, Cassius(1992)。On the Sublime。Critical Theory Since Plato。New York。
21.	Aristotle(1992)。Poetics。Critical Theory Since Plato。Fort Worth。
22.	Ashton, Robert(1985)。Reformation and Revolution, 1558-1660。Reformation and Revolution, 1558-1660。Chicago。
23.	Bakhtin, Mikhail M.(2007)。Crime and Punishment。Cambridge Companion to Alexander Pope。Cambridge。
24.	Rogers, Pat(2007)。Cambridge Companion to Alexander Pope。Cambridge：Cambridge UP。
25.	Bakhtin, Mikhail M.(1981)。Forms of Time and Chronotope in the Novel。The Dialogic Imagination: Four Essays。Austin。
26.	Bakhtin, Mikhail M.(1994)。The Problem of Speech Genres。Speech Genres and Other Late Essays。Austin。
27.	Bakhtin, Mikhail M.(1994)。The Problem of the Text in Linguistics, Philology, and the Human Sciences: An Experiement in Philosophical Analysis。Speech Genres and Other Late Essays。Austin。
28.	Bakhtin, Mikhail M.(1994)。Response to a Question from the Novy Mir Editorial Staff。Speech Genres and Other Late Essays。Austin。
29.	Barnard, John(1973)。Pope: The Critical Heritage。Pope: The Critical Heritage。London。
30.	Bate, Walter Jackson(1945)。From Classic to Romantic: Premises of Taste in Eighteenth Century England。New York：Harper。
31.	Jackson, Wallace、Yoder, R. Paul(1993)。Approaches to Teaching Pope's Poetry。Approaches to Teaching Pope's Poetry。New York。
32.	Battestin, Martin C.(1993)。Alexander Pope: Ideas of Order and the Sense of Form。Approaches to Teaching Pope's Poetry。New York。
33.	Berger, Harry, Jr.(2002)。Sprezzatura and the Absence of Grace。The Book of the Courtier。New York。
34.	Javitch, Daniel(2002)。The Book of the Courtier。The Book of the Courtier。New York。
35.	Copenhaver, Brian P.(1992)。Renaissance Philosophy。Renaissance Philosophy。Oxford。
36.	Cruttwell, Patrick(1974)。The Classical Line。Ben Jonson and the Cavalier Poets。New York。
37.	Cunningham, Lawrence S.、Ehrenreich, John H.(2002)。Culture and Values: A Survey of the Western Tradition。Culture and Values: A Survey of the Western Tradition。London。
38.	Deutsch, Helen(2007)。Pope, Self, and World。Cambridge Companion to Alexander Pope。Cambridge。
39.	Dryden, John(2006)。Mac Flecknoe。The Norton Anthology of English Literature (Vol. 1)。New York。
40.	Elwin, Whitwell、Courthope, William John(1967)。The Works of Alexander Pope。New York：Gordian。
41.	Emerson, Caryl(1984)。Editor's Preface。Problems of Dostoevsky's Poetics。Minneapolis。
42.	Fairer, David(1993)。Pope and Imagination。Approaches to Teaching Pope's Poetry。New York。
43.	Fellows, Nicholas(2002)。Disorder and Rebellion in Tudor England。Disorder and Rebellion in Tudor England。New York。
44.	Halliwell, Martin、Mousley, Andy(2004)。Critical Humanisms: Humanis/AntiHumanist Dialogues。Critical Humanisms: Humanis/AntiHumanist Dialogues。Edinburge。
45.	Hoppit, Julian(2000)。The New Oxford History of England: A Land of Liberty? England 1689-1727。Oxford：Oxford UP。
46.	Hunter, J. Paul(2005)。Political, satirical, didactic and lyric poetry (I): from the Restoration to the Death of Pope。The Cambridge Companion to Eighteenth Century Poetry。Oxford。
47.	Javitch, Daniel(2002)。Il Cortegiano and the Constraints of Despotism。The Book of the Courtier。New York。
48.	Johnson, Samuel。The Life of Pope。Lives of the English Poets。
49.	Johnson, Samuel(1962)。Rasselas。Rasselas。New York。
50.	Locke, John(1992)。An Essay Concerning Human Understanding。Critical Theory Since Plato。Fort Worth。
51.	Mebane, John M.(1992)。Renaissance Magic and the Return of the Golden Age: The Occult Tradition and Marlowe, Jonson, and Shakespeare。Renaissance Magic and the Return of the Golden Age: The Occult Tradition and Marlowe, Jonson, and Shakespeare。New York。
52.	Morris, David B.(1993)。Wit, Rhyme, and Couplet: Style as Content in Pope's Art。Approaches to Teaching Pope's Poetry。New York。
53.	Nisbet, Robert(2010)。The Idea of Progress。The Forum at the Online Library of Liberty。
54.	Plotinus(1992)。On the Intellectual Beauty。Critical Theory Since Plato。Fort Worth。
55.	Pope, Alexander(1967)。Dunciad。Dunciad。New York。
56.	Pope, Alexander(1967)。Epistle to Dr. Arbuthnot。Epistle to Dr. Arbuthnot。New York。
57.	Rawson, Claude J.、Higgins, Ian(2010)。The Essential Writings of Jonathan Swift。The Essential Writings of Jonathan Swift。New York。
58.	Reynolds, Henry(1992)。Mythomystes。Critical Theory Since Plato。Fort Worth。
59.	Zwicker, Steven N.(1998)。The Cambridge Companion to English Literature 1650-1740。Cambridge UP。
60.	Spurr, John(1998)。England 1649-1750: Differences Contained?。The Cambridge Companion to English Literature 1650-1740。Cambridge。
61.	Shakespeare, William(1987)。Hamlet。Hamlet。Oxford。
62.	Sitter, John(2007)。Pope's Versification and Voice。Cambridge Companion to Alexander Pope。Cambridge。
63.	Swift, Jonathan(2010)。Swift to Alexander Pope: Sep. 29. 1725。The Essential Writings of Jonathan Swift。New York。
64.	Swift, Jonathan(2010)。Thoughts on Various Subjects。The Essential Writings of Jonathan Swift。New York。
65.	Swift, Jonathan(2006)。Verses on the Death of Dr. Swift。The Norton Anthology of English Literature (Vol. 1)。New York。
66.	Tasso, Torquato(1992)。Discourses on the Heroic Poem。Critical Theory Since Plato。Fortworth。
67.	Voloshinov, V. N.(1976)。Discourse in Life and Discourse in Art。Freudianism: A Marxist Critique。New York。
68.	Walmsley, Peter(1993)。Neoclassical Aesthetics and An Essay on Criticism。Approaches to Teaching Pope's Poetry。New York。
69.	Weinbrot, Howard D.(1997)。Pope and the Classics。Cambridge Companion to Alexander Pope。Cambridge。
70.	Wordsworth, William(1979)。The Prelude 1790, 1805, 1850。The Prelude 1790, 1805, 1850。New York。

其他
1.	Hume, David。A Treatise of Human Nature。

圖書論文
1.	Bakhtin, Mikhail Mikhailovich(1981)。Discourse in the Novel。The Dialogic Imagination: Four Essays。Austin, TX：University of Texas Press。
2.	Pope, Alexander(1967)。An Essay on Criticism。The Works of Alexander Pope。New York：Gordian。
3.	Pope, Alexander(1967)。An Essay on Man。The Works of Alexander Pope。New York：Gordian。
4.	Sidney, Philip(1992)。An Apology for Poetry。Critical Theory Since Plato。Harcourt Brace Jovanovich College Publishers。
5.	Bakhtin, Mikhail M.(1994)。From Notes Made in 1970-71。Speech Genres and Other Late Essays。Austin：Texas UP。
6.	Dryden, John(2006)。A Song for St. Ceclia's Day。The Norton Anthology of English Literature。New York：Norton。
7.	Hattaway, Michael(1990)。Drama and Society。The Cambridge Companion to English Renaissance Drama。Cambridge University Press。
8.	Hunter, J. Paul(2001)。Couplets and Conversation。The Cambridge Companion to Eighteenth Century Poetry。Oxford。
9.	Jackson, Wallace(1993)。Teaching Pope with a View to the Whole。Approaches to Teaching Pope's Poetry。New York：MLA。
10.	Johnson, Samuel(1992)。Preface to Shakespeare。Critical Theory Since Plato。Fort Worth：Harcourt。
11.	Young, Brian(2007)。Pope and Ideology。Cambridge Companion to Alexander Pope。Cambridge：Cambridge UP。

推文
推薦
引用網址
引用嵌入語法
轉寄

top

:::

相關期刊
相關論文
相關專書
相關著作
熱門點閱

1.	Embarrassing Authority: The Conflict between Pope's Monologic Belief and Polyphonic Discourse in An Essay on Man
2.	Dialogue, Wit, and Judgment in "An Essay on Criticism" by Alexander Pope
3.	Nature and Dialogue : The Conflict-ridden Authoritative Discourse of Alexander Pope
4.	Dialogue, Heterogeneity, and An Essay on Criticism by Alexander Pope
5.	Divinity on the Implacable and Immemorial Earth: Dialectics of Pregnancy in Light in August

無相關博士論文

無相關書籍

無相關著作

1.	政治．暴力．自由主義--司馬桑敦及其小說之戰爭書寫析論
2.	德國當代高等教育改革評述
3.	教育哲學研究歷史發展之國際比較
4.	魯曼的溝通運作：一個去人文主義化的轉向
5.	C. Macaulay 的「兩性平等」人性觀與教育學說
6.	評Jörn Rüsen and Henner Laass (eds.), Humanism in Intercultural Perspective: Experiences and Expectations [跨文化視野中的人文主義：經驗與期待]
7.	Rethinking the Conditions for Inter-cultural Interaction: A Commentary on Levinas' Humanism of the Other
8.	人文主義取向的全球公民課程--兼對九年一貫課程的檢視

QR Code

臺灣人文及社會科學引文索引資料庫系統

詳目顯示

臺灣人文及社會科學引文索引資料庫