Emerging Processes and Concepts of Restorative Justice and Its Implication to Criminal Justice in the United States_

:::

詳目顯示

第 1 筆 / 總合 1 筆

/1頁

來源文獻資料
摘要
外文摘要
引文資料

題名：	Emerging Processes and Concepts of Restorative Justice and Its Implication to Criminal Justice in the United States
書刊名：	犯罪與刑事司法研究
作者：	郭世雅
作者(外文)：	Kuo, Shih-ya
出版日期：	2011
卷期：	16
頁次：	頁1-45
主題關鍵詞：	修復式正義；受害者加害者調解會；家庭團體討論會；判決討論會；Restorative justice；Victim-offender mediation；Family group conferencing；Sentencing circles
原始連結：	連回原系統網址
相關次數：	被引用次數:期刊(0) 博士論文(0) 專書(0) 專書論文(0) 排除自我引用:0 共同引用:0 點閱:41

長久以來，犯罪被害人並未受到應有的重視。直到一九六０年代，經過社會學者及社會運動者疾呼，才引起社會的注意。雖然自此之後，建立了一連串的方法協助被害人，但被害人和被害人家屬仍不斷表達對刑事司法體系的不滿，並稱刑事司法體系根本無法回應他們的需求。約在一九八０年代，修復式正義崛起，修復式正義給予受害者及受害家屬各種機會，例如表達他們對事件的感受、充分被告知司法程序的進展、被公平的對待，以及讓他們可與加害者面對面要求補償和接受道歉的機會。修復式正義曾被運用於各種場合，例如學校及工作場所；修復式正義也曾被西方 (如加拿大) 和非西方國家 (如日本) 用來處理人與人之間的紛爭。本文焦點在於討論西方國家 (特別是美國) 如何將修復式正義帶進刑事司法體系。本文分五個部分，第一部分談論新興崛起的修復式正義是如何在美國對刑事司法形成一股影響力量；其次介紹修復式正義定義的演進；第三部分探討修復式正義的正當性及其如何融入西方國家 (如紐西蘭、加拿大及美國) 的刑事法及刑事政策；第四部分介紹修復式正義的主要形式，包括被害加害者調解會 (VOM) 及家庭團體討論會 (FGC)；最後本文探討修復式正義所衍生的問題以及如何將修復式正義延伸至美國刑事司法體系及刑事政策。

以文找文

Historically, victims were given little or no consideration in the criminal justice process until social movements formed in the 1960s, in which activists and scholars called for social reforms. Since then, a series of measures aiming to assist victims have been established. However, over years victims and their families have been expressing their frustration and dissatisfaction toward the criminal justice system and claiming that the system has failed to fulfill their needs. The restorative justice process emerged in the 1980s, which allows victims to speak about their victimization, to be informed, to be treated fairly, and to discuss the reparation with offenders, including an apology. While restorative justice practices have been applied in various settings, such as schools, and workplaces and different cultural contexts, including Western and non-Western countries, this paper focuses on the criminal justice system within Western cultural contexts, the United States, particularly. This paper consists of five sections. The first looks at how restorative justice emerged as an influential force in American criminal justice. The second discusses the evolving definition of restorative justice. The third discusses underlying justification of restorative justice and how restorative justice was integrated into criminal justice legislation or policies in some countries, including New Zealand, Canada, and the United States. The fourth introduces the major forms of restorative justice, such as victim-offender mediation (VOM) and family group conferencing (FGC). The fifth section identifies issues and implications for expanding restorative justice policies in the United States.

以文找文

期刊論文
1.	Braithwaite, John(2002)。Setting standards for restorative justice。British Journal of Criminology，42(3)，563-577。
2.	Marshall, Tony F.(1996)。The Evolution of Restorative Justice in Britain。European Journal on Criminal Policy and Research，4(4)，21-43。
3.	Latimer, J.、Dowden, C.、Muise, D.(2005)。The effectiveness of restorative justice practices: A meta-analysis。The Prison Journal，85(2)，127-144。
4.	Umbreit, Mark(1997)。Humanistic Mediation: A Transformative Journey of Peacemaking。Mediation Quarterly，14(3)，201-213。
5.	Bies, R. J.、Shapiro, D. L.(1988)。Voice and Justification: Their Influence on Procedural Fairness Judgments。The Academy of Management Journal，31(3)，676-685。
6.	Martinson, Robert(1974)。What works?--Questions and Answers about Prison Reform。The Public Interest，35，22-54。
7.	Anstiss, B.(2003)。Just how effective is correctional treatment at reducing re-offending?。New Zealand Journal of Psychology，23，84-91。
8.	Bies, R. J.、Tyler, T. R.(1993)。The “Litigation Mentality” in organization: A test of alternative psychological explanations。Organization Science，4，352-366。
9.	Melton, A.(1995)。Indigenous justice systems and tribal society。Judicature，70，126-133。
10.	Nugent, W.R.、Paddock, J. B.(1995)。The effect of victim-offender mediation on severity of reoffense。Mediation Quarterly，12，353-367。
11.	Kurik, L.(2000)。Restorative and community justice in the United States。Crime and Justice，27，235-303。
12.	Batley, M.(2008)。The value of restorative justice to the reintegration of offenders。Crime Quarterly，26，27-35。
13.	Bliss, M.(2000)。Serious reasons for considering: Minimum standards of procedural fairness in the application of the Article 1F Exclusion Clauses。International Journal of Refugee Law，12，92-132。
14.	Cullen, F. T.、Gendreau, P.(2000)。Assessing correctional rehabilitation: Policy, practice, and prospects。Criminal Justice，3，109-175。
15.	Daly, K.、Immarigeon, R.(1998)。The past, present, and future of restorative justice: Some critical reflections。Contemporary Justice Review，1，21-45。
16.	Gabbay, Z.(2005)。Justifying restorative justice: A theoretical justification for the use of restorative justice practices。Journal of Dispute Resolution，2，349-397。
17.	Kurik, L.(1999)。Incorporating restorative and community justice into American sentencing and corrections。Sentencing & Corrections: Issues For the 21st Century，3，1-11。
18.	Leinweber, S、Jones, M.(2009)。Taking control: Victims and the mediation/dialogue process。Victims' Informer，14，1-2。
19.	Gilbert, M. J.、Settles, T. L.(2007)。The next step: Indigenous development of neighborhood-restorative community justice。Criminal Justice Review，32，5-25。
20.	Balfour, G.(2008)。Falling between the cracks of retributive and restorative justice: The victimization and punishment of aboriginal women。Feminist Criminology，3，101-120。
21.	Umbreti, M. S.、Vos, B.(2000)。Homicide survivors meet the offender prior to execution: restorative justice through dialogue。Homicide Studies，4，63-87。
22.	Umbreit, M.、Lightfoot, E.、Fier, J.(2003)。Legislative statutes on victim offender mediation: A national review。Connections，15，6-12。
23.	Lightfoot, E.、Umbreit, M.(2004)。An analysis of state statutory provisions for victim-offender mediation。Criminal Justice Policy Review，15，418-436。
24.	Zehr, H.(1997)。Restorative justice。The concept，59，68-71。
25.	Wilkinson, R.(1997)。Back to basics: Modern restorative justice principles have their roots in ancient cultures (editorial)。Corrections Today，59，6。
26.	Griffits, C. T.(1996)。Sanctioning and healing: Restorative justice in Canadian aboriginal communities。International Journal of Comparative and Applied Criminal Justice，20，195-208。
27.	Karp, D.、Drakulich, K.(2004)。Minor crime in a quaint setting: Practices, outcomes, and limits of Vermont Reparative Probation Boards。Criminology & Public Policy，3，655-686。
28.	Walker, L.(2002)。Conferencing - A new approach for juvenile justice in Honolulu。Federal Probation，66，38-44。
29.	Pavelka, S.(2008)。Restorative juvenile justice legislation and policy: A national assessment。International Journal of Restorative Justice，4，100-118。
30.	Presser, L.、Van Voorhis, P.(2002)。Values and evaluation: Assessing processes and outcomes of Restorative Justice programs。Crime & Delinquency，48(1)，162-188。
31.	Roche, D.(2001)。The evolving definition of restorative justice。Contemporary Justice Review，4，341-353。
32.	Roy, S.(1993)。Two types of juvenile restitution programs in two Midwestern counties: A comparative study。Federal Probation，57，48-53。
33.	Tellegen, A.(1988)。The analysis of consistency in personality。Journal of Personality，56，621-663。
34.	Walker, S. P.、Louw, D.(2005)。The court for sexual offences: Perceptions of the families of the victims of sexual offences。International Journal of Law and Psychiatry，28，418-429。

會議論文
1.	Van Ness, D. W.(200504)。An overview of restorative justice around the world。Eleventh United Nations Congress on Crime Prevention and Criminal Justice，(會議日期: 18-25 April)。Bangkok。
2.	McCold, P.(2009)。Conducting Restorative Justice Research。2nd National Conference of Restorative Justice，(會議日期: 03132009)。San Antonio, Texas。
3.	Leinweber, S. H.(2009)。“Willie's wish”: Scenes from a quadriplegic's meeting with his attackers。San Antonio, TX。
4.	McElrea, F.(2005)。The New Zealand Experience of Restorative Justice Legislation。Minneapolis, Minnesota。
5.	Sage, J.(2009)。Highlights。San Antonio, TX。
6.	Strang, H.(1999)。Restoring victims: An international view。Melbourne。
7.	Blackard, K.、Sage, J.(2009)。Bridges to Life: Study Guide。San Antonio, TX。

研究報告
1.	Evje, A.、Cushman, R. C.(2000)。A Summary of the Evaluation of Six California Victim Offender Reconciliation Programs。

學位論文
1.	Watt, L. J.(2005)。A shift of paradigms: Using restorative justice processes in schools。

圖書
1.	Zehr, H.(2005)。Changing Lenses: A New Focus for Crime and Justice。Scottsdale, PA：Herald Press。
2.	Umbreit, M. S., Vos, B.、Coates, R. B.、Brown, K. A.(2003)。Facing Violence : The Path of Restorative Justice and Dialogue。Monsey, NY：Criminal Justice Press。
3.	Loevinger, Jane(1976)。Ego Development。Jossey-Bass。
4.	Lipton, D.、Martinson, R.、Wilks, J.(1975)。The effectiveness of correctional treatment: A survey of treatment evaluation studies。New York：Praeger。
5.	Zehr, H.(2002)。The Little Book of Restorative Justice。Intercourse, PA：Good Books。
6.	Umbreit, M. S.(1994)。Victim Meets Offender: The Impact of Restorative Justice and Mediation。Monsey, NY：Willow Tree Press, Inc.：Criminal Justice Press。
7.	Sheppard, Blair H.、Lewicki, Roy J.、Minton, John W.(1992)。Organizational justice: The search for fairness in the workplace。New York：Lexington Books。
8.	Thibaut, John W.、Walker, Laurens(1975)。Procedural Justice: A Psychological Analysis。Lawrence Erlbaum Associates。
9.	Kline, S.(1988)。Jail inmates 1987。
10.	Cameron, A.(2005)。Restorative justice: A literature review。Vancouver, B.C.。
11.	Harrison, P. M.、Beck, A. J.(2006)。Prison and jail inmates at midyear 2005。Washington, DC。
12.	Hughes, P.、Mossman, M. J.(2001)。Re-Thinking Access to Criminal Justice in Canada: A Critical Review of Needs and Responses。Ottawa, Canada。
13.	Skelton A.、Batley, M.(2006)。Charting Progress, Mapping the Future: Restorative Justice in South Africa。Pretoria, South Africa。
14.	Strang, H.(2002)。Repair or Revenge。Oxford, UK。
15.	Clear, T. R.、Cole, F. F.、Reisig, M. D.(2009)。American Corrections。Belmont, CA。
16.	Beck, A. J.、Gilliard, D. K.(1995)。Prison in 1994。Washington, DC。
17.	Harrison, P. M.、Beck, A. J.(2006)。Prisoners in 2005。Washington, DC。
18.	Pennsylvania Commission on Crime and Delinquency .(2004)。Mission and Guiding Principles for Pennsylvania's Juvenile Justice System。Prepared by the Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention Committee of The Pennsylvania Commission on Crime and Delinquency。Harrisburg, PA。
19.	Walgrave, L.(2008)。Restorative justice, self-interest and responsible citizenship。Portland, OR。
20.	Marquart, J. W.、Mullings, J. L.、Davila, M.、Hartley, D.、Hughes, M.(2004)。Texas Crime Victimization Survey Report。Texas。
21.	McCold, P.、Wachtel, B.(1998)。Restorative Policing Experiment: The Bethlehem, Pennsylvania, Police Family Group Conferencing Project。Pipersville, PA。
22.	Umbreit, M. S.、Greenwood, J. J.(2000)。Guidelines for Victim-Sensitive Victim-Offender Mediation: Restorative Justice through Dialogue。MI。
23.	Umbreit, M. S.(2001)。The Handbook of Victim of Offender Mediation: An Essential Guide to Practice and Research。San Francisco, CA。
24.	Miers, D.、Maguire, M.、Goldie, S.、Sharpe, K.、Hale, C.、Netten, A.、Uglow, S.、Doolin, K.、Hallam, A.、Enterkin, J.、Newburn, T.(2001)。An Exploratory Evaluation of Restorative Justice Schemes。London, UK。
25.	Ashworth, A.(2003)。Is restorative justice the way forward for criminal justice?。Restorative Justice: Critical Issues。Thousand Oaks, CA。
26.	Bazemore, G.、Walgrave, L.(1999)。Restorative juvenile justice: In search of fundamentals and an outline for systemic reform。Restorative Juvenile Justice: Repairing the Harm of Youth Crime。Monsey, NY：Criminal Justice Press。
27.	Boyack, J.、Bowen, H.、Marshall, C. C.(2004)。How does restorative justice ensure good practices?。Critical Issues in Restorative Justice。Monsey, NY。
28.	Jantzi, V. E.(2004)。What is the role of the state in restorative justice。Critical Issues in Restorative Justice。Monsey, NY。
29.	Johnstone, G.、Van Ness, D. W.(2007)。The meaning of restorative justice。Handbook of Restorative Justice。Portland, OR。
30.	Masters, G.(2004)。What happens when restorative justice is encouraged, enabled and/or guided by legislation?。Critical Issues in Restorative Justice。Monsey, NY。
31.	Mirsky, L.(2004)。A Summary of “A Survey of Assessment Research on Mediation and Restorative Justice” by Paul McCold。Restorative Practices EForum。
32.	Morris, A.、Maxwell, G.(2000)。The practice of family group conferencing in New Zealand: Assessing the place, potential and pitfalls or restorative justice。Integrating a Victim Perspective within Criminal Justice: International Debates。Burlington, VT。
33.	Morris, A.、Young, W.(2000)。Reforming criminal justice: The potential of restorative justice。Restorative Justice: Philosophy to Practice。Burlington, VT。
34.	Vanfraechem, I.(2005)。Evaluating conferencing for serious juvenile offenders。New Directions in Restorative Justice: Issues, Practice, Evaluation。OR。
35.	Rugge, T.、Cormier, R.(2005)。Restorative justice in cases of serious crime: An evaluation。New Directions in Restorative Justice: Issues, Practice, Evaluation。Portland, Oregon。
36.	Van Ness. D.、Morris, A.、Maxwell, G.(2001)。Introducing restorative justice。Restorative Justice for Juveniles: Conferencing, Mediation & Circles。Oxford, UK。
37.	Walgrave, L.(2006)。Toward restoration as the mainstream in youth justice。New Directions in Restorative Justice: Issues, Practice, Evaluation。Portland, OR。
38.	Corrado, R. R.、Cohen, I. M.、Odgers, C.(2003)。Muti-problem violent youth: A challenge for the restorative justice paradigm。Restorative Justice in Context: International Practice and Directions。Portland, OR。
39.	Howley, S.、Dorris, C.(2007)。Victim participation in the criminal justice system。Victims of Crime。Thousand Oaks, CA。
40.	Dilulio, J. J.(1993)。Rethinking the criminal justice system: Toward a new paradigm。Performance Measures for the Criminal Justice System。Washington, DC。
41.	Greenberg, J.、Folger, R.(1983)。Procedural justice, participation and the fair process effect in groups and organizations。Basic Group Processes。NY。
42.	Hollin, C. R.(2003)。To treat or not to treat? An historical perspective。The essential Handbook of Offender Assessment and Treatment。Hobolken, NJ。
43.	Stuart, B.(1996)。Circle sentencing: Turning swords into ploughshares。Restorative Justice: International Perspectives。Monsey, NY。
44.	Schultz, L. H.、Selman, R. L..(1998)。Ego development and interpersonal development in young adulthood: A between-model comparison。Personality Development: Theoretical, Empirical, and Clinical Investigations of Loevinger's Conception of Ego Development。NJ。

其他
1.	Bazemore, G.，Umbreit, M.(2001)。A comparison of four restorative conferencing models，http://www.ncjrs.gov/html/ojjdp/2001_2_1/contents.html#acknowledge， 20100529。
2.	John Howard Society of Alberta(1996)。Prison overcrowding，http://www.johnhoward.ab.ca/PUB/C42.htm#effect， 20100601。
3.	Griffiths, M.(2004)。Working with serious violent crime using Restorative Justice Conferencing，www.jss.org.au， 20100420。
4.	International Association of Chiefs of Police(2000)。What do Victims Want? Effective Strategies to Achieve Justice for Victims of Crime，http://theiacp.org/LinkClick.aspx?fileticket=9eQ30BjqFCg%3D&tabid=87， 20100516。
5.	Bowen, H.，Boyack, J.(2003)。Adult Restorative Justice in New Zealand/Aotearoa，Auckland, New Zealand。
6.	Leung, M.(1999)。The origin of Restorative Justice，http://cfcj-fcjc.org/clearinghouse/drpapers/leung.htm， 20100529。
7.	Levin, M.(2005)。Restorative justice in Texas: Past, present & future，http://www.texaspolicy.com/pdf/2005-09-restorativejustice.pdf， 20100310。
8.	Office of the Victim Advocate. April(2003)。Pennsylvania Statutes, annotated by Lexisnexis™，http://www.pbpp.state.pa.us/ova/cwp/view.asp?A=3&Q=， 20100521。
9.	Restorative Justice Online(2009)。Legislation，http://www.restorativejustice.org/old-content/resources/policy/legislation， 20100527。
10.	Van Wormer, K.(2002)。Restorative Justice and Social Work，http://www.restorativejustice.org/resources/docs/vanwormer/， 20100511。
11.	Warren, R. K.(2007)。Evidence-Based practice to reduce recidivism: Implications for state for state judiciaries，http://www.wicourts.gov/about/organization/programs/docs/cjijudicialpaperfinal.pdf， 20100530。
12.	MacKay, R.(2007)。Bill C-9: An act to amend the criminal code (conditional sentence of imprisonment)，http://www2.pari.gc.ca/Content/LOP/LegislativeSummaries/39/1/c9-e.pdf， 20100603。
13.	Maxwell, G.(1998)。Crossing cultural boundaries: The Experience of Family Group Conferences，http://www.restorativejustice.org/10fulltext/maxwell， 20100529。
14.	McCold, P.(1999)。Restorative Justice Practice - The State of the Field，http://www.iirp.org/library/vt/vt_mccold.html， 20100419。
15.	Ministry of Justice(2008)。Restorative justice，http://www.justice.govt.nz/ministry/20090402%20MoJ%20Profile%20booklet%20-%20final.pdf， 20100527。
16.	Nuzum, M.(2007)。Summary of State Restorative Justice Legislation，http://stopviolence.com/restorative/rjleg-summary.htm， 20100604。
17.	Umbreit, M. S.(2008)。Victim Offender Mediation and Dialogue，http://cehd.umn.edu/ssw/rjp/Resources/RJ_， 20100522。
18.	Uniform Crime Report(2007)。Federal Bureau of Investigation，http://www.fbi.gov/ucr/cius2007/data/table_01.html， 20100516。
19.	United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime.(2006)。Handbook on restorative justice programmes，http://www.unodc.org/pdf/criminal_Jusrtice/06-56290_Ebook.pdf， 20100116。
20.	Van Ness, D. W.(1997)。Perspectives on achieving satisfying justice: Values and principles of restorative justice，http://www.restorativejustice.org/resources/docs/vanness15/view， 20100416。
21.	Moorhead, R.，Sefiton, M.，Scanlan, L.(2008)。Just Satisfaction? What Drives Public and Participant Satisfaction with Courts and Tribunals，http， 20100516。

圖書論文
1.	Greenberg, Jerald(1993)。The Social Side of Fairness: Interpersonal and Informational Classes of Organizational Justice。Justice in the Workplace: Approaching Fairness in Human Resource Management。Lawrence Erlbaum Associates。
2.	Van Ness, D. W.(2002)。Creating restorative systems。A restorative justice reader: Texts, sources, context。NY：Willan Publishing。

推文
推薦
引用網址
引用嵌入語法
轉寄

top

:::

相關期刊
相關論文
相關專書
相關著作
熱門點閱

無相關期刊論文

無相關博士論文

無相關書籍

無相關著作

1.	美國媒體對在華跨國污染的環境正義框架研究--以生態馬克思主義理論為視角
2.	美國媒體中在華跨國污染的國際與國內環境正義框架研究--一種生態馬克思主義的理論分析
3.	環境程序正義在褐地重建中的實踐條件：我國污染土地再利用實例的觀察分析
4.	性別平等教育法下的校園性騷擾暨性侵害調查之程序正義：受害人保護及行為人權益之兼顧
5.	論環境正義的多元涵義
6.	CCTV對犯罪防制之實證研究：以桃園市為例
7.	監獄化程度與申訴制度關聯之研究
8.	歸因方式、自我效能與飲酒行為對酒駕次數的影響：新竹市男性酒駕者之個案對照研究
9.	羈押與具保之認知分析
10.	從族群正義到環境論述：達悟反核廢運動者的框架移轉
11.	貧窮、犯罪與社會排除：新自由主義全球化下臺灣少年犯罪治理之研究
12.	安全了嗎？安全網方案高危機案件的追蹤研究初探
13.	臺灣大學生與警察接觸經驗和影響警察信心程度之成因探究
14.	受刑人心理特質與犯罪類型之區辨分析：以桃園監獄為例
15.	歧視與暴力下的土地掠奪：臺灣環境正義與人權的凝視

QR Code

臺灣人文及社會科學引文索引資料庫系統

詳目顯示

臺灣人文及社會科學引文索引資料庫