The primary purpose of the study is to evaluate the students’ health-related conditions by applying two Grey System Theory based methods, Grey Relational Analysis and Grey Multi-Objective Decision Making, and to compare the difference of the outcomes of the two methods. The study surveyed 42 dancing group students at the Jinwen University of Science & Technology as subjects during the academic year 105. The participants were tested on the items prescribed by the “College Students’ Health Fitness Form;” consisting of body-mass index (BMI), sit-and-reach, one-minute sit-ups, standing long jumps, and step height. The fitness testing data were then analyzed by Grey Relational Analysis and Grey Multi-Objective Decision Making. The outcomes show that the evaluations by the two methods are close and representative of the fitness conditions of the students.