The discovery of the phenomenology of voice in Emmanuel Levinas's posthumous manuscripts helps us to understand the ideas in his two great books: Totality and Infinity and Otherwise than Being or Beyond Essence. In his unpublished lecture notes from the 1940's, voice is the way in which the invisible other is presented to me: it makes the other "heard". In this sense, the concept of "face" in Totality and Infinity, published more than ten years later, is not only the continuation and development of the concept of the phenomenology of voice, but also the exposition of its metaphysical principle. Face and voice complement each other in describing the unique way in which the invisible other is present. In the 1970's, the phenomenology of voice reappears in Otherwise than Being or Beyond Essence with a new development: the external voice turns into my voice, and, as the vibration and exchange of breath, the phenomenology of voice evolves into the phenomenology of respiration. It not only describes more fully how the other is present as an inspiration to me, but also describes more deeply my subjectivity and spiritual structure when I respond to the other: the other is in me, and I am the substitute of the other.