友誼何以重要？--蘇格蘭啟蒙作家論市民友誼與公民友誼_

:::

詳目顯示

第 1 筆 / 總合 1 筆

/1頁

來源文獻資料
摘要
外文摘要
引文資料

題名：	友誼何以重要？--蘇格蘭啟蒙作家論市民友誼與公民友誼
書刊名：	新史學
作者：	陳正國
作者(外文)：	Chen, Jeng-guo
出版日期：	2023
卷期：	34:2
頁次：	頁179-253
主題關鍵詞：	友誼；蘇格蘭啟蒙；大衛休姆；亞當史密斯；威廉克里洪；亞當佛格森；市民社會；Friendship；The Scottish Enlightenment；David Hume；Adam Smith；William Cleghorn；Adam Ferguson；Civil society
原始連結：	連回原系統網址
相關次數：	被引用次數:期刊(0) 博士論文(0) 專書(0) 專書論文(0) 排除自我引用:0 共同引用:17 點閱:20

本文綜述幾位重要蘇格蘭啟蒙思想家如何以社會友誼觀念來理解現代市民社會的內涵與品質。本文的核心論旨有二：第一，本文認為蘇格蘭啟蒙有意識地建立社會友誼的討論；此一新的友誼論傳統與希臘羅馬以降，乃至近代早期貴族所流行的擇友論大不相同。第二，蘇格蘭啟蒙作家們認為，現代市民社會或文明社會的出現，並非只是為了保全個人生存與福祉，更有自然的情感因素為基礎。本文以市民友誼與公民友誼來指認這些作家的友誼論述。蘇格蘭啟蒙作家們有意識地回應霍布斯、普芬多夫以及曼德維爾所留下的智識遺產與難題：人是否僅僅是因為自利或自愛的理由而結成社會。面對個體主義與理性主義的社會哲學，蘇格蘭啟蒙作家從情感論的角度強勢介入辯論。從哈奇森的普遍慈愛開始，繼起的蘇格蘭啟蒙作家，漸次發展出不同的社會友誼觀點，包括休姆與米勒的文明論，史密斯的習慣性共感與情境論，克里洪的心智論，與佛格森的社會衝突論等。雖然這些啟蒙作家所論友誼面貌不一，類型有別，但他們的著作卻共同宣稱，社會必然有友愛情感的基礎。市民社會或公共領域不只滿足人們對快樂與安全的追求，也是創造友誼的場所。對蘇格蘭啟蒙道德哲學家們而言，社會友誼與家庭中兄弟姊妹，甚至夫妻的情誼只有程度上的差別，而無本質上的差異。

以文找文

By reconstructing discussions of several influential figures in the Scottish Enlightenment, this article sheds light on novel arguments about social friendship. First, it argues that these Scottish luminaries forged a new approach to social friendship, distinct from the time-honored Greco-Roman tradition of friendship that cautioned the young to be prudent in choosing friends. Second, the article identifies two subtypes of social friendship, namely civil friendship and civic friendship, and argues that these enlightened writers actively propagated and deliberated upon the concept of general social friendship as conscientious responses to the ideas put forth by Hobbes, Pufendorf, and Mandeville, who claim that society or associations are formed for little more than the sake of self-love and self- preservation. Inspired by Francis Hutcheson’s idea of universal benevolence, David Hume, Adam Smith, William Cleghorn and Adam Ferguson engaged forcefully with the fashionable social philosophy of egoism and rationalism. While they distanced themselves from Hutcheson’s universalism, each philosopher developed unique forms of social friendship, aligned with their respective concerns surrounding civilization, habitual sympathy, philosophy of mind, and social conflict. Despite the subtle distinctions in their presentations and arguments, these Enlightenment thinkers collectively held firm to the entrenched principle that people enter into society, driven by mutual sentiments of agreement, care, or affection. To the Scottish moral philosophers, a civil society or public sphere is as much a space for the aggregation of individuals seeking mutual happiness and protection as it was a workshop of friendship.

以文找文

期刊論文
1.	Forbes, Duncan(1954)。Scientific' Whiggism: Adam Smith and John Millar。The Cambridge Journal，7，643-670。
2.	Schwarzenbach, Sibyl A.(1996)。On Civic Friendship。Ethics，107(1)，97-128。
3.	Hill, Lisa、McCarthy, Peter(2004)。On friendship and necessitudo in Adam Smith。History of the Human Sciences，17(4)，1-16。
4.	Silver, Allan(1990)。Friendship in commercial society: Eighteenth-century social theory and modern sociology。American Journal of Sociology，95(6)，1474-1504。
5.	陳正國(20121200)。陌生人的歷史意義--亞當史密斯論商業社會的倫理基礎。中央研究院歷史語言研究所集刊，83(4)，779-835。延伸查詢
6.	Emerson, Roger L.(1973)。The social composition of enlightened Scotland: The Select Society of Edinburgh, 1754-1764。Studies on Voltaire and the Eighteenth Century，114，291-329。
7.	陳正國(20040900)。從利他到自律：哈其森與史密斯經濟思想間的轉折。政治與社會哲學評論，10，1-31。延伸查詢
8.	Klein, Laurence E.(2002)。Politeness and the Interpretation of the British Eighteenth Century。The Historical Journal，45(4)，869-898。
9.	Sher, Richard B.(1989)。Adam Ferguson, Adam Smith, and the Problem of National Defense。The Journal of Modern History，61(2)，240-268。
10.	陳建元(20200900)。交談、商業與文雅--丹尼爾．笛福與十八世紀初英格蘭的文雅文化。新史學，31(3)，1-70。延伸查詢
11.	謝佳娟(20200600)。藝術的進程：十八世紀下半葉英國藝術、製造業、商業勵進會對文雅藝術的提倡。藝術學研究，26，57-142。延伸查詢
12.	Andrews, Corey E.(2007)。Drinking and Thinking: Club Life and Convivial Sociability in Mid-Eighteenth-Century Edinburgh。The Social History of Alcohol and Drugs，22(1)，65-82。
13.	陳正國(2021)。蘇格蘭啟蒙思想中的盧梭問題：市民社會與政治社會的辯證。思想史，10，311-377。延伸查詢
14.	陳正國(20080600)。Ethic and Aesthetic Friendship--Francis Hutcheson and Bernard Mandeville's Debate on Economic Motivation。歐美研究，38(2)，211-242。
15.	Emerson, Roger L.(1979)。The Philosophical Society of Edinburgh, 1737-1747。British Journal for the History of Science，12(2)，154-191。
16.	Darwall, Stephen(2012)。Pufendorf on Morality, Sociability, and Moral Powers。Journal of the History of Philosophy，50(2)，213-238。
17.	Cowan, Brian(2001)。What Was Masculine About the Public Sphere? Gender and the Coffeehouse Milieu in post-Restoration England。History Workshop Journal，51(1)，127-157。
18.	Emerson, Roger L.(1985)。The Philosophical Society of Edinburgh 1768-1783。British Journal for the History of Science，18(3)，255-303。
19.	Harris, James(2021)。Phillipson's Hume in Phillipson's Scottish Enlightenment。History of European Ideas，48(2)，145-159。
20.	Moloney, Pat(2005)。Savages in the Scottish Enlightenment's History of Desire。Journal of the History of Sexuality，14(3)，237-265。
21.	Nobbs, Douglas(1965)。The Political Ideas of William Cleghorn, Hume's Academic Rival。The Journal of the History of Ideas，26(4)，575-584。
22.	Olson, Richard(1998)。Sex and Status in Scottish Enlightenment Social Science: John Millar and the Sociology of Gender Roles。History of Human Sciences，11(1)，73-100。
23.	Den Uyl, Douglas J.、Griswold, Charles L. Jr.(1996)。Adam Smith on friendship and love。The Review of Metaphysics，49(3)，609-637。

圖書
1.	Stone, Lawrence(1965)。The Crisis of the Aristocracy, 1558-1641。Clarendon Press。
2.	Phillipson, Nicholas、Skinner, Quentin R. D.(1993)。Political Discourse in Early Modern Britain。Cambridge：Cambridge University Press。
3.	Pocock, John Greville Agard(1987)。The Ancient Constitution and the Feudal Law。Cambridge：Cambridge University Press。
4.	Abbot, Henry(1713)。Unity, Friendship, and Charity, Recommended in a Sermon。Bristol：Sam Farley。
5.	Bryson, Anna(1998)。From Courtesy to Civility: Changing Codes of Conduct in Early Modern England。Oxford：Oxford University Press。
6.	Kuehn, Manfred(2001)。Kant: a biography。Cambridge University Press。
7.	Tadmor, Naomi(2001)。Family and Friends in Eighteenth-century England: Household, Kinship, and Patronage。Cambridge：Cambridge University Press。
8.	Force, Pierre(2003)。Self-interest before Adam Smith。Cambridge：Cambridge University Press。
9.	Pangle, Lorraine Smith(2003)。Aristotle and the philosophy of friendship。Cambridge：Cambridge University Press。
10.	Dumont, Louis(1977)。From Mandeville to Marx: The Genesis and Triumph of Economic Ideology。Chicago：The University of Chicago Press。
11.	Berry, Christopher J.(2013)。The Idea of Commercial Society in the Scottish Enlightenment。Edinburgh University Press。
12.	Rasmussen, Dennis C.(2008)。The Problems and Promise of Commercial Society: Adam Smith's Response to Rousseau。Pennsylvania State University Press。
13.	Pagden, Anthony(1987)。The Languages of Political Theory in Early-Modern Europe。Cambridge Univ. Press。
14.	McDaniel, Iain(2013)。Adam Ferguson in the Scottish Enlightenment: The Roman past and Europe's Future。Harvard University Press。
15.	Brewer, John(2013)。The Pleasures of the Imagination: English Culture in the Eighteenth Century。London：Routledge。
16.	Tolonen, Mikko S.(2013)。Mandeville and Hume: anatomists of civil society。University of Oxford, Voltaire Foundation。
17.	Harris, James A.(2015)。Hume: An Intellectual Biography。Cambridge：Cambridge University Press。
18.	Hill, Jack A.(2017)。Adam Ferguson and Ethical Integrity: The Man and His Prescriptions for the Moral Life。Lexington Books。
19.	Montesquieu、Versini, Laurent(1995)。De l'esprit des lois。Paris：Gallimard。
20.	Mandeville, Bernard、Kaye, F. B.(1988)。The Fable of the Bees or Private Vices, Publick Benefits。Indianapolis：Liberty Fund。
21.	Smith, Adam(1982)。The Theory of Moral Sentiments。Indianapolis：Liberty Fund。
22.	Ferguson, Adam、Oz-Salzberger, Fania(1996)。An Essay on the History of Civil Society。Cambridge University Press。
23.	Clark, Peter(2000)。British Clubs and Societies, 1580-1800: The Origins of an Associational World。Oxford University Press。
24.	Audley, Mathew(1739)。A Sermon Preached at St. Paul's, Deptford, Kent on June the 23rd 1739。John Carter。
25.	d'Argens, Jean-Bastiste Marquis(1747)。New Memoirs Establishing a True Knowledge of Mankind。D. Brown。
26.	Aristotle。Nicomachean Ethics。
27.	Hutcheson, Francis(1990)。Thoughts on Laughter。Thoemmes Continuum。
28.	Millar, John(1990)。The Origin of the Distinction of Ranks。Thoemmes。
29.	Berry, Christopher(2009)。David Hume。Bloomsbury Academic。
30.	Berry, Christopher(2016)。The Idea of Commercial Society in the Scottish Enlightenment。Edinburgh University Press。
31.	Blanning, T. C. W.(1996)。Culture of Power and the Power of Culture: Old Regime Europe 1660-1789。Oxford University Press。
32.	Brown, Michael(2002)。Francis Hutcheson in Dublin 1719-1730。Four Courts Press。
33.	Campbell, Argyll Archibald(1689)。Instructions to a Son。Richard Baldwin。
34.	Camic, Charles(1983)。Experience and Enlightenment: Socialization for Cultural Change in Eighteenth-Century Scotland。Edinburgh University Press。
35.	Caine, Barbara(2014)。Friendship: A History。Routledge。
36.	Curzer, Howard J.(2012)。Aristotle and the Virtues。Oxford University Press。
37.	Finlay, Christopher(2007)。Hume's Social Philosophy: Human Nature and Commercial Sociability in a Treatise of Human Nature。Continuum。
38.	Gaskill, Howard(1991)。Ossian Revisited。Edinburgh University Press。
39.	Grote, Simon William(2017)。The Emergence of Modern Aesthetic Theory: Religion and Morality in Enlightenment Germany and Scotland。Cambridge University Press。
40.	Haakossen, Knud(1997)。Natural Law and Moral Philosophy: From Grotius to the Scottish Enlightenment。Cambridge University Press。
41.	Gaskill, Howard(1996)。The Poems of Ossian。Edinburgh University Press。
42.	Harris, Bob(2014)。The Scottish Town in the Age of the Enlightenment 1740-1820。Edinburgh University。
43.	Heath, Eugene、Merolle, Vincenzo(2008)。Adam Ferguson: Philosophy, Politics and Society。Pickering and Chatto。
44.	Heath, Eugene、Merolle, Vincenzo(2008)。Adam Ferguson: History, Progress and Human Nature。Pickering and Chatto。
45.	Hyatte, Reginald(1997)。The Arts of Friendship: The Idealization of Friendship in Medieval and Early Renaissance Literature。E. J. Brill。
46.	Justice, George(2002)。The Manufacturers of Literature: Writing and the Literary Marketplace in Eighteenth-Century England。Delaware University Press。
47.	Leaman, Oliver(1996)。Friendship East and West。Routledge。
48.	Langer, Ullrich(1994)。Perfect Friendship: Studies in Literature and Moral Philosophy from Boccaccio to Corneille。Dorz。
49.	Marquer, Éric(2012)。Léviathan et la loi des marchands: Commerce et civilité dans l'oeuvre de Thomas Hobbes。Classiques Garnier。
50.	Mason, Roger A.(1987)。Scotland and England, 1286-1815。Edinburgh University Press。
51.	Maurer, Christian(2019)。Self-Love, Egoism and the Selfish Hypothesis: Key Debates from Eighteenth-Century British Moral Philosophy。Edinburgh University Press。
52.	Oz-Salzberger, Fannia(1995)。Translating the Enlightenment: Scottish Civic Discourse in Eighteenth-Century Germany。Cambridge University Press。
53.	Pangle, Lorraine Smith(2009)。Aristotle and the Philosophy of Friendship。Cambridge University Press。
54.	Pocock, John G. A.(1974)。The Machiavellian Moment。Princeton University Press。
55.	Risseeuw, Carla、van Raalte, Marlein(2017)。Conceptualizing Friendship in Time and Place。Brill。
56.	Rasmussen, Dennis C.(2017)。The Infidel and the Professor: David Hume, Adam Smith, and the Friendship That Shaped Modern Thought。Princeton University Press。
57.	Porter, Roy、Tomaselli, Sylvana(1990)。Dialects of Friendship。Routledge。
58.	Sher, Richard(2000)。The Enlightenment and the Book: Scottish Authors and Their Publishers in Eighteenth-Century Britain, Ireland, and America。University of Chicago Press。
59.	Skinner, Quentin(2007)。Liberty Before Liberalism。Cambridge University Press。
60.	Smith, Craig(2019)。Adam Ferguson and the Idea of Civil Society: Moral Science in the Scottish Enlightenment。Edinburgh University。
61.	Stone, Lawrence(1972)。The Causes of the English Revolution: 1529-1642。Oxford University Press。
62.	Thomas, Keith(1990)。The Ends of Life。Oxford University Press。
63.	Wilson, Kathleen(1995)。The Sense of the People: Politics, Culture and Imperialism in England 1715-1785。Cambridge University Press。
64.	Wei, Jia(2017)。Commerce and Politics in Hume's History of England。Boydell。
65.	Wallace, Mark C.、Rendall, Jane(2020)。Association and Enlightenment: Scottish Clubs and Societies 1700-1830。Bucknell University Press。
66.	Velásquez, Eduardo A.(2003)。Love and Friendship: Rethinking Politics and Affection in Modern Times。Lexington Books。
67.	Wheeldon, John(1793)。The Life of Bishop Taylor, and the Purest Spirit of His Writings。George Bigg。
68.	Hutcheson, Francis、Mautner, Thomas(1993)。Two Texts on Human Nature。Two Texts on Human Nature。Cambridge：Cambridge University Press。
69.	Greated, Timothy(1726)。An Essay on Friendship; or, a Moral Discourse on the Nature and Effects of Mutual Love。London：J. Lives。
70.	Hutcheson, Francis(1747)。A Short Introduction to Moral Philosophy。Glasgow：Robert Foulis。
71.	Hutcheson, Francis、Moore, James、Silverthome, Michael(2006)。Logic, Metaphysics, and the Natural Sociability of Mankind。Indianapolis：Liberty Fund。
72.	Mossner, Ernest Campbell(1980)。The Life of David Hume。Oxford：Clarendon Press。
73.	Ferguson, Adam(1995)。Principles of Moral and Political Science。Hildesheim：Georg Olms Verlag。
74.	Hill, Lisa(2006)。The Passionate Society: The Social, Moral and Political Thought of Adam Ferguson。Dorecht：Springer。

圖書論文
1.	Hume, David(1985)。That Politics May be Reduced to a Science。Essays: Moral, Political, and Literary。Indianapolis：Liberty Fund。
2.	Aelred of Rievaulx(1991)。Spiritual Friendship。Other Selves Philosophers on Friendship。Hackett。
3.	Hutcheson, Francis(1770)。Consideration on Patronage addressed to the Gentlemen of Scotland 1735。Tracts Concerning Patronage。
4.	Allan, David、Chiodi, G. M.(2009)。Die Socialitas in der ersten Hälfte des 18. Jahrhunderts in Deutschland. Ein philosophisches Sittenbild von der Entstehung der bürgerlichen Gesellschaft。Das Naturrecht der Geselligkeit: Anthropologie, Recht und Politik im 18. Jahrhundert。Duncker & Humblot。
5.	Brubaker, Laurence(2003)。'A Particular Turn or Habit of the Imagination': Adam Smith on Love, Friendship, and Philosophy。Love and Friendship。Lexington Books。
6.	Brühlmeier, Daniel(1991)。Isaak Iselin and the Call for Civic Virtue, a Model of Swiss Republicanism。Revolution and Enlightenment in Europe。Aberdeen University Press。
7.	Burke, Peter(1999)。Humanism and Friendship in Sixteenth-Century Europe。Friendship and Medieval and Early Modern Europe。Sutton Publishing。
8.	Forbes, Duncan(1976)。[An Essay on the History of Civil Society] Introduction。An Essay on the History of Civil Society。Edinburgh University Press。
9.	Hont, Istvan(2009)。The Language of Sociability and Commerce: Samuel Pufendorf and the Theoretical Foundation of 'Four-Stages-Theory'。The Languages of Political Theory in Early Modern Europe。Cambridge University Press。
10.	Ignatieff, Michael(1983)。John Millar and Individualism。Wealth & Virtue: The Shaping of Political Economy in the Scottish Enlightenment。Cambridge University Press。
11.	Keller, Vera(2010)。Painted Friends: Political Interest and the Transformation of International Sociability。Friendship in the Middle Ages and Early Modern Age。De Gruyter。
12.	Llyod, Mark(2003)。Shaftesbury's Liberal Enthusiasm。Love and Friendship。Lexington Books。
13.	Moore, James(1990)。Two Systems of Francis Hutcheson: On the Origins of the Scottish Enlightenment。Studies on the Philosophy of the Scottish Enlightenment。Oxford University Press。
14.	Phillipson, Nicholas(1973)。Toward a Definition of the Scottish Enlightenment。Society in the Eighteenth Century。Hakkert。
15.	Schneewind, J. B.(2009)。Good out of Evil: Kant and the Idea of Unsocial Sociability。Kant's Idea for a Universal History with a Cosmopolitan Aim。Cambridge University Press。
16.	Scott, James T.(2003)。Godolphin and the Whale: Friendship and the Framing of Hobbes' Leviathan。Love and Friendship: Rethinking Politics and Affection in Modern Times。Lexington Books。
17.	Silver, Allan(2017)。Historical Moments of Friendship Ideals: David & Jonathan, Montaigne, Adam Smith。Conceptualizing Friendship in Time and Place。Brill。
18.	Stutcliffe, Ada(2017)。Friendship in the European Enlightenment: The Rationalization of Intimacy?。Conceptualizing Friendship in Time and Place。Brill。
19.	Phillipson, Nicholas(2000)。Language, Sociability, and History: Some Reflections on the Foundations of Adam Smith's Science of Man。Economy, Polity and Society: British Intellectual History 1750-1950。Cambridge：Cambridge University Press。

推文
推薦
引用網址
引用嵌入語法
轉寄

top

:::

相關期刊
相關論文
相關專書
相關著作
熱門點閱

1.	史學作為政治思想--古憲法、東方專制、與《古印度史論》
2.	蘇格蘭啟蒙思想中的中國
3.	新教倫理從現代社會中絕跡了嗎？論韋伯思想的現實意涵
4.	丹尼爾．笛福論風俗改革運動及其改進之道
5.	交談、商業與文雅--丹尼爾．笛福與十八世紀初英格蘭的文雅文化
6.	亞當史密斯的帝國論述及其背景
7.	藝術的進程：十八世紀下半葉英國藝術、製造業、商業勵進會對文雅藝術的提倡
8.	亞里斯多德與亞當斯密正義觀之比較
9.	從勤奮到自立--霍加斯版畫中的勞動者形象與工作倫理觀
10.	評Alexander Broadie, «A History of Scottish Philosophy» (Edinburgh University Press)
11.	以激情解釋民族特性，以效益創造道德對話：休謨政治思想的一個側面
12.	行善於樂--十八世紀中葉倫敦扶幼院的藝文形象與英國慈善文化
13.	休謨是契約論者嗎？對高提也的"David Hume, Contractarian"之批判性反思
14.	絕對王權下貴族的書寫與出版--拉侯什傅科公爵的《道德箴言錄》與巴黎菁英讀者
15.	陌生人的歷史意義--亞當史密斯論商業社會的倫理基礎

1.	臺灣高中生參與海外寄宿家庭式國際交流學習經驗之探究

1.	當經濟遇上法律：明清中國的市場演化

無相關著作

無相關點閱

QR Code

臺灣人文及社會科學引文索引資料庫系統

詳目顯示

臺灣人文及社會科學引文索引資料庫