In this paper, we aim at analyzing the inconclusive results of leader-member exchange (LMX) differentiation. Data from 228 supervisor-subordinate dyads in 23 branches of a large Taiwanese bank provided concrete evidence that LMX differentiation was negatively related to team cohesion and that the quality of team cohesion mediated the negative effect of LMX differentiation on workgroup creativity. Moreover, the relationship between the LMX quality and employee creativity was positively moderated by team cohesion and negatively moderated by non-performance-based LMX differentiation. We also find out negative relationship between LMX differentiation and team cohesion was moderated by nonperformance- based LMX differentiation.