:::

詳目顯示

回上一頁
題名:The Question of Chinese Representation in the United Nations
書刊名:臺灣國際法季刊
作者:趙國材
作者(外文):Chao, John K. T.
出版日期:2007
卷期:4:3
頁次:頁33-91
主題關鍵詞:中國代表權問題安理會加入聯合國之程序緩議案重要問題案雙重代表案聯合國大會2758號決議中華民國中華人民共和國聯合國Chinese representation questionSecurity councilProcedure of admission to the United NationsMoratorium deviceImportant questionDual representation of ChinaGeneral assembly resolution 2758Republic of ChinaPeople's Republic of ChinaUnited Nations
原始連結:連回原系統網址new window
相關次數:
  • 被引用次數被引用次數:期刊(0) 博士論文(0) 專書(0) 專書論文(0)
  • 排除自我引用排除自我引用:0
  • 共同引用共同引用:0
  • 點閱點閱:197
國的唯一政府,惟中華人民共和國政府每年都向聯合國大會提出議案,試圖取代中華民國政府以取得「中國代表權」。直至1971年10月25日,聯合國大會通過2758號決議後,「中國代表權」的爭議始暫告平息。本文旨在討論聯合國「中國代表權」問題,研究聚焦於重建與分析聯合國中國代表權的爭執過程。其中聯合國安理會與大會上,所涉及之美國利益、台灣安全等各項問題,以及所有對應中國代表權的策略,分析緩議案、重要問題案、整批交易及雙重代表等方案,並評估其結果。內文除前言與結論外,分別就聯合國之會員國、否決權與整批交易、國家加入聯合國之條件與大會所具權限、中國代表權問題等議題進行申述。本研究不認爲當時中華民國政府若能保留其在聯合國大會在席位,就能阻止中華人民共和國政府進入聯合國;蓋中華人民共和國政府及其盟友並不會因此就容忍兩岸政權並存於聯合國之中,而放棄迫使中華民國政府喪失其代表中國的國際法人資格。
The question of the Chinese Representation in the United Nations (UN) arose with the People's Republic of China (PRC) putting forward its demand for a seat in the UN Security Council on 18 January 1949. Since 1951, the government of the PRC applied annually to the UN General Assembly to be replaced the government of the Republic of China (ROC) as the representative of China. From 1950 to 1971 the ROC government was recognized as the sole government representing China in the UN. With the adoption of General Assembly Resolution 2758 on 25 October 1971, expelling the ROC government, the representatives of the PRC government replaced the ROC representatives as the sole legitimate representative of China to the UN, and have since held the seat in the General Assembly, the Security Council, as well as in all organs and specialized agencies of the UN. The issue of the Chinese representation in the UN came to a close. The objective of this essay is to reconstruct and analyse the struggle over the issue of the Chinese representation in the UN. The essay is divided into two parts, namely conditions of entering into the UN, and the Chinese representation question to the UN. It provides an analysis of veto power and package deal, conditions of admission to the UN, the competence of the General Assembly, and the essence of Chinese representation question to the U N. It discusses the different solutions to the Chinese representation question involvement with the U.S. interest, the security of Taiwan and submits a realistic assessment of the ultimate outcome of the struggle from a ROC viewpoint. It will show that all strategies in dealing the of Chinese representation question depended on the voting situation in the Security Council and the General Assembly. If an "Important Question Variation" or "Dual Representation Resolution" had been approved and the resolution promulgated by Albania would have failed, the PRC would have been seated in the General Assembly and in the Security Council. But as long as Taiwan retained a seat in the UN, the PRC would not join the UN. PRC and its allies, however, would continue to find ways to exclude the ROC from their right to represent China. It concludes that the aim of the foreign policy is to pursuit national interest. Taiwan's attempt to enter the United Nations is not only unrealistic; conversely it also increases the tension across the Taiwan Strait. One must know that bilateral diplomatic relations is the base of international relations, without the strengthening of bilateral relations and the support of the United Nations member States, Taiwan's entrance into the United Nations is unfeasible. Strengthening the relations between two sides of Taiwan Strait is paramount.
期刊論文
1.Bloomfield, Lincoln P.(1966)。China, the United States, and the United Nations。International Organization,20(4),653-671。  new window
2.Boeg, N. V.(1954)。Review of the Charter of the United Nations。Transactions of the Grotius Society,40,5-23。  new window
3.Briggs, Herbert W.(1952)。Chinese Representation in the United Nations。International Organization,6,192-209。  new window
4.Fitzmaurice, G. G.(1952)。The United Nations and the Rule of Law。Transactions of the Grotius Society,38,135-150。  new window
5.Humber, P. O.(1947)。Admission to the United Nations。British Year Book of International Law,24,90-115。  new window
6.Liang, Yuen-Li(1949)。Notes on Legal Questions Concerning the United Nations: Conditions of Admission of a State to Membership in the United Nations。American Journal of International Law,43,288-311。  new window
7.Liang, Yun-li(1951)。Recognition by the United Nations of the Representation of a Member State: Criteria and Procedure。American Journal of International Law,45,691-695。  new window
8.Talmon, Stefan(1992)。Recognition of Governments: An Analysis of the New British Policy and Practice。British Year Book of International Law,63(1),231-297。  new window
9.Zhu, Jianmin(1964)。Ten Years of the Moratorium Decision (1950-1960): The Question of the Chinese Legitimate Status in the UN。Journal of the National Chengchi University,5,73-94。  new window
圖書
1.Bailey, Sydney D.(1988)。The Procedure of the UN Security Council。Oxford:Clarendon Press。  new window
2.Sato, Tetsuo(1996)。Evolving Constitutions of International Organizations: A Critical Analysis of the Interpretative Framework of the Constituent Instruments of International Organizations。The Hague:Kluwer Law International。  new window
3.Baehr, Peter R.、Gordenker, Leon(1999)。The United States at the End of the 1990s。London:Macmillan Press。  new window
4.Bailey, Sydney D.(1970)。Chinese Representation in the Security Council and the General Assembly of the United Nations。Brighton:Institute for the Study of International Organisation。  new window
5.Barros, James(1989)。Trygve Lie and the Cold War: The UN Secretary-General Pursue Peace, 1946-1953。DeKalb, Illinois:Northern Illinois University Press。  new window
6.Bisson, T. S.(1943)。Far Eastern Survey。Institute of Pacific Relations。  new window
7.Brook, David(1956)。The U. N. and the China Dilemma。New York:Vantage Press。  new window
8.Brown, Benjamin H.、Greene, Fred(1955)。Chinese Representation: A Case Study in the United Nations Political Affairs。New York:Woodrow Wilson Foundation。  new window
9.Che, Tiqiang(1985)。國際法論文集。Beijing:Falu chubanshe。  延伸查詢new window
10.Chen, Zhimai(1967)。Jiang Tingfu's Records and Life。Taipei:Zhuanji wenxue chubanshe。  new window
11.Chiang, Kai-Shek(1969)。Soviet Russia in China。Taipei:China Publishing Co。  new window
12.China Institute of International Affairs(1959)。Report of a Study Group set up by the China Institute of International Affairs。New York:Manhattan Publishing Co。  new window
13.Committee for the Party History of the Central Committee of GMD。Collection of Important Documents of the Republic of China: The Period of the Sino-Japanese War, Vol. 3: Diplomatic Relation during the War。Taipei:Committee for the Party History of the Central Committee of GMD。  new window
14.Donner, Ruth(1988)。International Adjudiction: Using the International Court of Justice with special reference to Finland。Helsinki:Academia Scientiarum Fennica。  new window
15.Feltham, R. G.(1998)。Diplomatic Handbook。London:Longman。  new window
16.Higgins, Rosalyn(1963)。The Development of lnternational Law through the Political Organs of the United Nations。London:Oxford University Press。  new window
17.Hu, Shi Zhou-Zhiping(2001)。A Collection of Hu Shi's Unpublished English Essays and Speeches。Taipei:Lianjing。  new window
18.Keith, J. K.(1971)。The Extent of the Advisory Jurisdiction of the International Court ofJustice。Leyden:A. W. Sijthoff。  new window
19.Li, Enguo(1970)。Introduction to the UN Charter。Taipei:Zhengzhong shuju。  new window
20.Liang, Yun-li、Wang, Yuxiu(1958)。Collectionsof Essays in Memoriam of Cui Qin on Art of Politics。Taipei:Zhonghua congshu weiyuanhui yinhang。  new window
21.Liu, Zhigong(1985)。The Republic of China in the UN: Foreign Politics, International Environment and Participation。Taipei:Taiwan shangwu yinshuguan。  new window
22.Ma, Zedong、中共中央文獻研究室(1956)。Selections of Mao Zedong's Texts about Foreign Policy。Beijing:中共中央文獻研究室。  延伸查詢new window
23.Ma, Zedong、中共中央文獻研究室(1961)。Selections of Mao Zedong's Texts about Foreign Policy。Beijing:中共中央文獻研究室。  延伸查詢new window
24.Nicholas, H. G.(1959)。The United Nations as a Political Institution。London:Oxford University Press。  new window
25.Qian, Fu(2005)。Memoirs of Qian Fu。Taipei Tianxia wenhua。  new window
26.Rosenne, Shabtai(1973)。The World Court: What It is and How it。Leiden:A. W. Sijthoff。  new window
27.Tetlow, Edwin(1970)。The United Nations: The First 25 Years。London:Peter Owen。  new window
28.Tyler, Patrick(2000)。A Great Wall: Six Presidents and China。Taipei:Lianjing chubanshe。  new window
29.Vandenbosch, N. Army、Hogan, Willard N.(1963)。Toward World Order。New York:McGraw-Hill Book Co.。  new window
30.Wang, Jinghong(2000)。Interviewing History: The View on Taiwan from the Files in the White House。Taipei:Yuanliu。  new window
31.Wang, Kuo-Chang(1984)。United Nations Voting on Chinese Representation: An Analysis of General Assembly Roll-Calls 1950-1971。Taipei:Institute of American Culture, Academia Sinica。  new window
32.Whiteman, M.(1993)。Digest of International。Washington, D. C.:Government Printing Office。  new window
33.Xu, Boxiong(1973)。Documentation of the Political Struggle in the General Assembly of the United Nations。Hong Kong:Xinwen Tiandishe。  new window
34.Swift, Richard N.(1969)。International Law: Current and Classic。John Wiley & Sons。  new window
35.Pomerance, M.(1973)。The Advisory Function of the International Court in the League and the United Nations Eras。Baltimore:London。  new window
36.Dugard, John(1987)。Recognition and the United Nations。Cambridge:Grotius Publications。  new window
37.Schermers, Henry G.、Blokker, Niels M.(1995)。International Institutional Law。Nijhoff。  new window
38.Duara, Prasenjit(2003)。Sovereignty and Authenticity: Manchuko and the East Asian Modern。London:Rowman & Littlefield Publishers, Inc.。  new window
39.Malanczuk, Peter(1997)。Akehurst's Modern Introduction to International Law。Routledge。  new window
40.Langer, Robert(1969)。Seizure of Territory: The Stim- son Doctrine md Related Principles in Legal Theory and Diplomatic Practice。New York:Greenwood Press。  new window
圖書論文
1.Fitzmaurice, Sir Gerald(1952)。Chinese representation in the United Nations。YearBook of World Affairs。  new window
 
 
 
 
第一頁 上一頁 下一頁 最後一頁 top