:::

詳目顯示

回上一頁
題名:How Can Political Culture Be a Useful Independent Variable?
書刊名:臺灣政治學刊
作者:黃旻華 引用關係
作者(外文):Huang, Min-hua
出版日期:2004
卷期:8:1
頁次:頁147-191
主題關鍵詞:政治文化政治學方法論公民文化宗教與政治Political cultureMethodologyCivic cultureReligion and politics
原始連結:連回原系統網址new window
相關次數:
  • 被引用次數被引用次數:期刊(2) 博士論文(0) 專書(0) 專書論文(1)
  • 排除自我引用排除自我引用:2
  • 共同引用共同引用:0
  • 點閱點閱:43
美國政治學者奧蒙(Gabriel Almond)和佛巴(Sidney Verba)所著《公民文化》一書,至今仍是政治學中最受歡迎的指定教材之一,儘管此書的批評眾多,時間證明其學術地位是後來的著作所無法超越的。本文指出,《公民文化》在學界所持續受到的重視不但反映其原創性價值,同時也展現其將政治文化作為一自變數在解釋上的巧妙之處;弔詭的是,雖然針對此書有數不盡的批評出現,但一直都沒有能與之競逐的典範產生。這現象證明了此一領域在過去四十多年間研究與創新的貧乏。關鍵問題除了形成文化變數過程中所遇到的方法論難題,同時也與學者試圖以權宜性方法來處理文化變數有關。在回顧政治文化研究中兩個重要的辯論後,本文主張,政治文化作為自變數是一套內化於大眾心中,被理解為一般常識的隱然邏輯關係。最後本文將使用巴基斯坦和摩洛哥的民意調查資料進行實證經驗研究,說明如何將政治文化形成一個有用的自變數。
For the past four decades, Almond and Verba's pioneering work, The Civic Culture, has remained one of the most popular books in political science, despite many criticisms. Indeed, the continuing popularity of The Civic Culture in the academic community is evidence of its groundbreaking quality and subtlety in treating culture as an independent variable. However, the number of criticisms and the lack of alternative paradigms paradoxically reflect the poverty of originality and progress in this field. The key question not only lies in the methodological problem of variable formation, but also originates from the expedient treatment of culture as a residual category. In this article, I examine two major debates in political culture studies and argue that culture should be treated as an implicit logic internalized in people' s mind as common knowledge. Finally, this article will demonstrate how to formulate political culture as a useful independent variable by using survey data from Pakistan and Morocco.
期刊論文
1.Elster, Jon(2000)。Rational Choice History: A Case of Excessive Ambition。American Political Science Review,94(3),685-695。  new window
2.Swidler, Ann(1986)。Culture in Action :Symbol and Strategies。American Sociological Review,51,273-286。  new window
3.Tarrow, Sidney(1996)。Making Social Science Work Across Space and Time: A Critical Reflection on Robert Putnam's Making Democracy Work。American Political Science Review,90(2),389-397。  new window
4.Seligson, M. A.、Booth, J. A.(1993)。Political Culture and Regime Type: Evidence from Nicaragua and Costa Rica。Journal of Politics,55(3),777-792。  new window
5.Barber, B.(199203)。Jihad vs. McWorld。The Atlantic,269(3),53-65。  new window
6.Tessler, M.(2002)。Islam and Democracy in the Middle East: The Impact of Religious Orientations on Attitudes Toward Democracy in Four Arab Countries。Comparative Politics,34(3),337-354。  new window
7.Eckstein, Harry(1988)。A Culturalist Theory of Political Change。American Political Science Review,82(3),789-804。  new window
8.Tessler, Mark、Warriner, Ina(1997)。Gender, Feminism, and Attitudes Toward International Conflict: Exploring Relationships with Survey Data from the Middle East。World Politics,49,250-281。  new window
9.Smith, Tony(1979)。The Underdevelopment of Development Literature: The Case of Dependency Theory。World Politics,31(2),247-288。  new window
10.Tessler, M.、Nachtwey, J.(1998)。Islam and Attitudes Toward International Conflict: Evidence from Survey Research in the Arab World。Journal of Conflict Resolution,42,619-636。  new window
11.Dittmer, L.(1977)。Political Culture and Political Symbolism。World Politics,29(4),552-583。  new window
12.Axelrod, R.(1987)。Laws of Life: How Standards of Behavior Evolve。Science,27(2),44-51。  new window
13.Axelrod, R.(1997)。The Dissemination of Culture: A Model with Local Convergence and Global Polarization。Journal of Conflict Resolution,41(2),203-226。  new window
14.Berman, Sheri(2001)。Ideas, Norms, and Culture in Political Analysis。Comparative Politics,33(2),231-250。  new window
15.Bates, R.(1997)。Areas Studies and the Discipline。PS: Political Science & Politics,30(2),166-169。  new window
16.Bates, R.(2000)。The Analytic Narrative Project。American Political Science Review,94(3),696-702。  new window
17.Carpenter, D.(2000)。Commentary: What is the Marginal Value of Analytic Narratives?。Social Science History,24(4),653-667。  new window
18.Elkins, D. J.、Simeon, R. E. B.(1979)。A Cause in Search of Its Effect, or What Does Political Culture Explain?。Comparative Politics,11(2),127-146。  new window
19.Enders, W.、Sandler, T.(2000)。Transnational Terrorism in the Post-Cold War Era。International Studies Quarterly,43(1),145-167。  new window
20.Gil, A.(2001)。Religion and Comparative Politics。Annual Review of Political Science,4,117-138。  new window
21.Granato, J.、Inglehart, R.、Leblang, D.(1996)。The Effects of Economic Development on Cultural Values。American Journal of Political Science,40(3),607-631。  new window
22.Jackman, R. W.、Miller, R. A.(1996)。A Renaissance of Political Culture?。American Journal of Political Science,40(3),632-659。  new window
23.Johnson, C.(1997)。Preconception vs. Observation, or the Contributions of Rational Choice Theory and Area Studies to Contemporary Political Science。PS: Political Science & Politics,30(2),170-174。  new window
24.Lane, R.(1992)。Political Culture: Residual Category or General Theory?。Comparative Political Studies,25(3),362-387。  new window
25.Lockhart, C.(1999)。Cultural Contributions to Explaining Institutional Form, Political Change, and Rational Decisions。Comparative Political Studies,32(7),862-893。  new window
26.Muller, E. N.、Seligson, M. A.(1994)。Civic Culture and Democracy: The Question of Causal Relationships。American Political Science Review,88(3),635-652。  new window
27.Nachtwey, J.、Tessler, M.(2002)。The Political Economy of Attitudes Toward Peace Among Israelis and Palestinians。Journal of Conflict Resolution,46(2),260-285。  new window
28.Pye,L.W.(1991)。Political Culture Revisited。Political Psychology,12(3),487-508。  new window
29.Seligson, M. A.(2002)。The Renaissance of Political Culture or the Renaissance of the Ecology Fallacy。Comparative Politics,34(3),273-292。  new window
30.Swank, D.(1996)。Culture, Institution, and Economic Growth: Theory, Recent Evidence, and the Role of Communitarian Polities。American Journal of Political Science,40(3),660-679。  new window
31.Tanwir, F.(2002)。Religious Parties and Politics in Pakistan。International Journal of Comparative Sociology,43(3),250-268。  new window
32.Tessler, M.(2003)。Arab and Muslim Political Attitudes: Stereotypes and Evidence from Survey Research。International Studies Perspective,4(2),175-181。  new window
33.Tessler, M.、Nachtwey, J.、Grant, A.(1999)。Further Test of the Women and Peace Hypothesis: Evidence from Cross-National Survey Research in the Middle East。International Studies Quarterly,43(3),519-531。  new window
34.Wilson, R. W.(2000)。The Many Voices of Political Culture: Assessing Different Approaches。World Politics,52(2),246-273。  new window
圖書
1.Kim, J.、Mueller, C. W.(1978)。Introduction to Factor Analysis: What It is and How to Do It。Beverly Hills, CA:Sage。  new window
2.Inglehard, R.(1990)。Culture Shift。Princeton, NJ:Princeton University Press。  new window
3.Hulin, C. L.、Drasgow, F.、Parsons, C. K.(1983)。Item Response Theory。Homewood, IL:Dow Jones-Irwin。  new window
4.Atmond, Gabriel A.、Verba, Sidney(1980)。The Civic Culture Revisited。Boston:Little, Brown and Company。  new window
5.Bernstein, Richard J.(1976)。The Restructuring of Social and Political Theory。New York:Harcourt Brace Jovanovich Inc.。  new window
6.Horowitz, Donald L.(1985)。Ethnic Groups in Conflict。University of California Press。  new window
7.Pye, Lucian W.、Verba, Sidney(1965)。Political Culture and Political Development。Princeton University Press。  new window
8.Inglehart, Ronald(1997)。Modernization and Postmodernization: Culture, Economic, and Political Change in 43 Societies。Princeton, NJ:Princeton University Press。  new window
9.Huntington, Samuel P.(1981)。American Politics: The Promise of Disharmony。Cambridge, Massachusetts:The Belkanp Press of Harvard University Press。  new window
10.Habermas, Jürgen、Viertel, J.(1973)。Theory and practice。Boston, MA:Beacon Press。  new window
11.Rodrik, Dani(1997)。Has Globalization Gone Too Far?。Washington, D. C.:Institute for International Economics。  new window
12.Bates, Robert H.、Greif, Avner、Levi, Margaret、Rosenthal, Jean-Laurent、Weingast, Barry R.(1998)。Analytic Narratives。Princeton University Press。  new window
13.Geertz, Clifford(1973)。The interpretation of cultures。New York:Harper & Row。  new window
14.Almond, Gabriel A.、Verba, Sidney(1963)。The Civic Culture: Political Attitudes and Democracy in Five Nations。Princeton, New Jersey:Princeton University Press。  new window
15.Pye, Lucian W.、Pye, Mary W.(1985)。Asian Power and Politics: The Cultural Dimensions of Authority。Cambridge:The Belk nep Press of Harvard University Press。  new window
16.Huntington, Samuel Phillips(1996)。The Clash of Civilizations and the Remaking of World Order。Simon & Schuster Company, Inc.。  new window
17.Skocpol, Theda(1979)。States and Social Revolutions: A Comparative Analysis of France, Russia, and China。Cambridge University Press。  new window
18.Putnam, Robert D.、Leonardi, Robert、Nanetti, Raffaella Y.(1993)。Making Democracy Work: Civic Traditions in Modern Italy。Princeton University Press。  new window
19.Axelrod, Robert M.(1984)。The Evolution of Cooperation。Basic Books。  new window
20.Embretson, Susan E.、Reise, Steven P.(2000)。Item Response Theory for Psychologists。Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Inc.。  new window
21.Nachtwey, J.、Tessler, M.(1999)。Explaining Women's Support for Political Islam: Contributions from Feminist Theory。Area Studies and Social Science: Strategies for Understanding Middle East Politics。Bloomington。  new window
22.Moghadam, V. M.(1993)。Modernizing Women: Gender and Social Change in the Middle East。Modernizing Women: Gender and Social Change in the Middle East。Boulder:Lynne Rienner。  new window
23.Abed, S. B.(1995)。Islam and Democracy。Democracy, War, and Peace in the Middle East。Bloomington。  new window
24.Humphreys, R. S.(1999)。Between Memory and Desire: The Middle East in a Troubled Age。Between Memory and Desire: The Middle East in a Troubled Age。Berkeley, CA。  new window
25.Al-Suwaidi, J.(1995)。Arab and Western Conceptions of Democracy: Evidence from a UAE Opinion Survey。Democracy, War, and Peace in the Middle East。Bloomington。  new window
26.Pharr, S.(1990)。Losing Face: Status Politics in Japan。Losing Face: Status Politics in Japan。Berkeley。  new window
27.Almond, G. A.(1987)。The Development of Political Development。Understanding Political Development。Prospect Heights, IL:Waveland Press。  new window
28.Chong, D.(2000)。Rational Lives。Rational Lives。Chicago, IL。  new window
29.(2003)。IRT from SSI。IRT from SSI。Lincolnwood, IL。  new window
30.Edgerton, R. B.(2000)。Traditional Beliefs and Practices - Are Some Better than Others?。Culture Matters。New York, NY。  new window
31.Glazer, N.(2000)。Disaggregating Culture。Culture Matters。New York, NY。  new window
32.(2000)。Culture Matters。Culture Matters。New York, NY。  new window
33.Kepel, G.(1993)。Muslim Extremism in Egypt。Muslim Extremism in Egypt。Berkeley。  new window
34.Kepel, G.(1994)。The Revenge of God。The Revenge of God。University Park, PA。  new window
35.Lijphart, A.(1980)。The Structure of Inference。The Civic Culture Revisited。Newbury Park。  new window
36.Packenham, R. A.(1992)。The Dependency Movement。The Dependency Movement。Cambridge, MA。  new window
37.Patterson, O.(2000)。Taking Culture Seriously: A Framework and an Afro-American Illustration。Culture Matters。New York, NY。  new window
38.Pitts, J. R.(1963)。Continuity and Change in Bourgeois France。In Search of France。New York, NY。  new window
39.Shweder, R. A.(2000)。Mora Maps, 'First Word' Conceits, and the New Evangelists。Culture Matters。New York, NY。  new window
40.Tessler, M.(1997)。The Origins of Popular Support for Islamist Movement: A Political Economy Analysis。Islam, Democracy, and the State in North Africa。Bloomington, IN。  new window
41.Tessler, M.、Nachtwey, J.、Banda, A.(1999)。The Area Studies Controversy。Area Studies and Social Science。Bloomington, IN。  new window
42.(1993)。Arab Women: Old Boundaries, New Frontiers。Arab Women: Old Boundaries, New Frontiers。Bloomington, IN。  new window
43.Verba, S.(1980)。On Revisiting The Civic Culture: A Personal Postscript。The Civic Culture Revisited。Newbury Park。  new window
其他
1.薛承泰(2004)。老人照顧老人 將是臺灣現象,http://ntu.edu.tw/~psc_news9312/120701.htm, 20041207。  延伸查詢new window
圖書論文
1.Thelen, Kathleen、Steinmo, Sven(1992)。Historical Institutionalism in Comparative Politics。Structuring Politics: Historical Institutionalism in Comparative Analysis。Cambridge University Press。  new window
2.Tessler, M.、Grobschmidt, M.(1995)。Democracy in the Arab World and the Arab-Israeli Conflict。Democracy, War, and Peace in the Middle East。Bloomington:Indiana University Press。  new window
 
 
 
 
第一頁 上一頁 下一頁 最後一頁 top