The paper is to explore the comments on Shang-Yang (商鞅) which basically are divided into two factions-criticism and recognition-through the relevant articles of Su-Shi (蘇軾). From all the past dynasties, most comments on Shang-Yang are inclined to be negative, so no wonder that Su-Shi always directly criticizes Shang-Yang. Besides, the paper discovers that Su-Shi also has many viewpoints about recognizing Shang-Yang indeed, which is the difference between Su-Shi and other scholars who condemn Shang-Yang.