中國鄉村快速工業化的制度動力：地方產權體制與非正式私有化_

:::

詳目顯示

第 1 筆 / 總合 1 筆

/1頁

來源文獻資料
摘要
外文摘要
引文資料

題名：	中國鄉村快速工業化的制度動力：地方產權體制與非正式私有化
書刊名：	臺灣政治學刊
作者：	吳介民
出版日期：	1998
卷期：	3
頁次：	頁3-63
主題關鍵詞：	工業化；產權理論；私有化；鄉鎮企業；農民抗議；中國；Industrialization；Property rights theory；Privatization；Township and village enterprises；TVEs；Peasant protest；China
原始連結：	連回原系統網址
相關次數：	被引用次數:期刊(25) 博士論文(7) 專書(3) 專書論文(5) 排除自我引用:24 共同引用:2 點閱:133

　　　　　關於中國鄉鎮企業快速成長的制度誘因，主要有三種觀點：生產合作社、地方政府公有制、以及市場轉型論。本文論證前兩種看法都不符實情。而市場轉型論的觀點，則與比較接近現實; 惟其對產權制度安排的分析，欠缺一個完整的理論架構。本文提出地方產權體制 (local property rights regime) 的分析架構，以剖析中國農村工業之非正式私有化(informal privatization) 的過程。這個架構幫助釐清中國局部改革策略的動力與難題。一方面，在地方層次所塑造的非正式產權制度，提供了有效的經濟誘因，而使得鄉村工業蓬勃發展。但是，另一方面，非正式的私有化策略，方便鄉村幹部操控產權，而導致虛假的財產關係。虛假的所有權安排，使中國無數的非國營企業仍然維持著一個公有制的外貌。實際上，這些企業大部份的控制權都握在官僚和幹部手裡; 或是官僚幹部假手私人名義，行控制企業產權之實。此類虛假關係，滋生了愈來愈多的產權糾紛，使得鄉鎮企業持續發展面臨制度障礙。同時，許多在急遽工業化過程中遭受嚴重剝奪的農民，其不滿情緒，也正在醞釀成集體抗議行運動。一旦中國現行的政治體制遭遇劇烈的變革，農村的產權糾紛將引爆巨大的經濟與社會動盪。對中國政府而言，理清農村的產權關係、或是任其繼續模糊，是當前所面對的最大困局之一。

以文找文

　　　　　Three perspectives have been prevalent in explaining the rapid growth of rural industry in China: producer cooperative, local government ownership, and market transition. This article contends that the first two approaches do not hold empirically. Instead, the market transition can better interpret the dynamics of the Chinese development. However, it lacks a comprehensive framework for the analysis of property rights across regions. A concept of local property rights regime is proposed to explore the processes of informal privatization in China. This research finds that the strategy of informal privatization, on the one hand, provided enterprises with incentives for rapid growth; but on the other hand, it brought about complicated webs of pseudoownership arrangements. The pseudo-ownership enabled rural cadres to manipulate property rights. Farmland were reconcentrated in the hands of village leadership; and collective assets were transferred into private coffers. The peasants, deprived under this pattern of privatization, staged collective protests in response to the collusion between cadres and local governments. Whether to overhaul the vague property rights or not has become a dilemma for the central government. It is predicted that if this issue is not resolved properly, the rising rural conflict could dampen the rural development and threaten the Communist power.

以文找文

期刊論文
1.	Cheung, Steven N. S.(1974)。A Theory of Price Control。The Journal of Law & Economics，17(1)，53-71。
2.	Qian, Yingyi、Xu, Chenggang(199306)。Why China’s Economic Reforms Differ: The M-Form Hierarchy and Entry/Expansion of the Non-State Sector。The Economics of Transition，1(2)，135-170。
3.	Rocca, J. L.(1992)。Corruption and its shadow: An anthropological view of corruption in China。The China Quartely，130，402-416。
4.	Alchian, A. A.、Demsetz, H.(1973)。The property right paradigm。The Journal of Economic History，33(1)，16-27。
5.	Kuran, T.(1991)。Now out of never: the element of surprise in the East European Revolution of 1989。World Politics，44(1)，7-48。
6.	Naughton, B.(199201)。Implications of the State Monopoly over Industry and Its Relaxation。Modern China，18(1)，14-41。
7.	Demsetz, H.(1967)。Towards a Theory of Property Rights。American Economic Review，57(2)，347-359。
8.	Coase, R. H.(1937)。The Problem of Social Cost。Journal of Law and Economics，3，1-44。
9.	AIchian, Armen A.(1950)。Uncertainty, Evolution, and Economic Theory。Journal of Political Economy，58(3)，211-221。
10.	Oi, Jean C.(1995)。The Role of the Local State in China's Transitional Economy。The China Quarterly，144(12)，1132-1149。
11.	Oi, Jean C.(1992)。Fiscal Reform and the Economic Foundation of Local State Corporatism in China。World Politics，45(1)，99-126。
12.	Zweig, David(199504)。Developmental Communities’ on China's Coast: The Impact of Trade, Investment, and Transnational Alliances。Comparative Politics，27(3)，253-274。
13.	Wu, Jieh‐min(1997)。Strange bedfellows: Dynamics of government-business relations between Chinese local authorities and Taiwanese investors。Journal of Contemporary China，6(15)，319-346。
14.	Wong, Christine P. W.(1992)。Fiscal Reform and Local Industrialization: The Problematic Sequencing of Reform in Post-Mao China。Modern China，18(2)，197-227。
15.	Naughton, Barry(19940500)。Chinese Institutional Innovation and Privatization from Below。The American Economic Review，84(2)，266-270。
16.	Lin, Nan(1995)。Local Market Socialism : Local Corporation in Action in Rural China。Theory and Society，24(3)，301-354。
17.	Bhagwati, Jagdish N.(1982)。Directly Unproductive, Profit-seeking (DUP) Activities。Journal of Political Economy，90(5)，988-1002。
18.	Yusuf, Shahid(1994)。China's Macroeconomic Performance and Management During Transition。Journal of Economic Perspectives，8(2)，71-92。
19.	Montinola, Gabriella R.、Qian, Yingyi、Weingast, Barry R.(1995)。Federalism, Chinese style: The political basis for economic success in China。World Politics，48(1)，50-81。
20.	Kornai, Janos(1986)。The Soft Budget Constraint。Kyklos，39(1)，3-30。
21.	Krueger, Anne O.(1974)。The Political Economy of the Rent-Seeking Society。American Economic Review，64(3)，291-303。
22.	Liu, Ya-Ling(1992)。Reform from Below: The Private Economy and Local Politics in the Rural Industrialization of Wenzhou。China Quarterly，130，293-316。
23.	Nee, Victor(1989)。A Theory of Market Transition: From Redistribution to Markets in State Socialism。American Sociological Review，54(5)，663-681。
24.	Nee, Victor(1992)。Organizational Dynamics of Market Transition: Hybrid Forms, Property Rights, and Mixed Economy in China。Administrative Science Quarterly，37(1)，1-27。
25.	Parris, Kristen(1993)。Local Initiative and National Reform: The Wenzhou Model of Development。The China Quarterly，134，242-263。
26.	Sachs, Jeffrey、Woo, Wing Thye(1994)。Structural Factors in the Economic Reforms of China--Eastern Europe, and the Former Soviet Union。Economic Policy，9(18)，101-145。
27.	Unger, Jonathan、Chan, Anita(1995)。China, Corporatism, and the East Asian Model。The Australian Journal of Chinese Affairs，33，29-53。
28.	Walder, Andrew G.(1995)。Local Governments as Industrial Firms: An Organizational Analysis of China's Transitional Economy。American Journal of Sociology，101(2)，263-301。
29.	Wank, David L.(1996)。The Institutional Process of Market Clientelism: Guanxi and Private Business in a South China City。The China Quarterly，147，820-838。
30.	Jensen, Michael C.、Meckling, William H.(1976)。Theory of the firm: Managerial behavior, agency costs and ownership structure。Journal of Financial Economics，3(4)，305-360。
31.	Bhagwati, J. H.(1983)。DUP activities and rent seeking。Kyklos，36，634-637。
32.	Walder, A. G.(1996)。Markets and Inequality in Transitional Economies: Toward Testable Theories。American Journal of Sociology，101(4)，1060-1073。
33.	Stark, David(1990)。Privatization in Hungary: From Plan to Market or from Plan to Clan?。East European Politics and Society，4(3)，351-392。
34.	Walder, A. G.(1995)。China's Transitional Economy: Interpreting its Significance。The China Quarterly，144，963-979。
35.	Whyte, Martin King(1996)。The Chinese Family and Economic Development: Obstacle or Engine?。Economic Development and Cultural Change，45(1)，1-30。
36.	鄭毓盛、曾澍基(1996)。Agricultural Land reform in a Mixed System: The Chinese Experience of 1984-1994。China Information，10(3)，44-74。
37.	崔之元(1995)。中國農村工業化新探：靈活專業化與莫比烏斯帶組織。香港社會科學學報，6，131-153。延伸查詢
38.	杜鷹(1992)。股份合作制是一種獨立的經濟組織形態。中國農村經濟，95，11-13。延伸查詢
39.	李鑫(1993)。周村股份合作制改革試驗及其初步效應。中國農村經濟，99，29-32。延伸查詢
40.	Christiansen, Flemming(1992)。'Market Transition' in China: The Case of the Jiangsu Labor Market, 1978-1990。Modern China，18(1)，72-93。
41.	Eggertsson, T.(1993)。Mental Models and Social Values: North's Institutions and Credible Commitment。Journal of Institutional and Theoretical Economics，149(1)，24-28。
42.	Frydman, Roman、Rapaczynski, Andrzej(1993)。Insiders and the State: Overview of Response to Agency Problems in East European Privatizations。Economics of Transition，1(1)，39-59。
43.	Goldstein, Steven M.(1995)。China in Transition: The Political Foundations of Incremental Reform。The China Quarterly，144(December)，1105-1131。
44.	Jefferson, Garry H.、Rawski, Thomas G.(1994)。Enterprise Reform in Chinese Industry。The Journal of Economic Perspectives，8(2)，47-70。
45.	McKinnon, Ronald I.(1991)。Financial Control in the Transition from Classical Socialism to a Market Economy。The Journal of Economic Perspectives，5(4)，107-122。
46.	North, Douglass C.(1993)。Institutions and Credible Commitment。Journal of Institutional and Theoretical Economics，149(1)，11-23。
47.	Odggard, Ole(1990)。Inadequate and Inaccurate Chinese Statistics: the Case of Private Rural Enterprises。China Information，5(Winter)，29-38。
48.	Putterman, Louis(1995)。The Role of Ownership and Property Rights in China's Economic Transition。The China Quarterly，144，1047-1064。
49.	Smart, Alan(1993)。Gifts, Bribes, and Guanxi: A Reconsideration of Bourdieu's Social Capital。Cultural Anthropology，8(3)，388-408。
50.	Smart, Alan(1993)。The Political Economy of Rent-seeking in a Chinese Factory Town。Anthropology of Work Review，14(2/ 3)，15-19。
51.	Solnick, Steven(1996)。The Breakdown of Hierarchies in the Soviet Union and China: A Neoinstitutional Perspective。World Politics，48(January)，209-238。

會議論文
1.	Hellman, Joel S.(1992)。The Revenge of the Past: Building Market Institutions in Soviet-Type Economies。The Palmer House Hilton。
2.	吳介民(1995)。A Tale of Two Villages: Deconstructing the Developmentalist Image of the Chinese Rural Industrialization。0。
3.	吳介民(1997)。Guanxi across the Balance Sheet and the Taiwan Strait: Political Connections, Economic Structure, and Chinese Societies。Chicago, IL。

學位論文
1.	Wu, Jieh-Min(1998)。Local Property Rights Regime in Socialist Reform: A Case Study of China's Informal Privatization(-)。Columbia University，New York。

圖書
1.	Hirschman, A. O.(1982)。Shifting Involvements: Private Interest and Public Action。Oxford：Basil Blackwell。
2.	Oi, Jean C.(1999)。Rural China Takes Off: The Political Basis of Economic Reform。Berkeley, CA：University of California Press。
3.	Haggard, Stephen(1990)。Pathways from the Periphery: The Politics of Growth in the Newly Industrialized Countries。Ithaca。
4.	Stinchcombe, Arthur L.(1990)。Information and Organizations。Berkeley, CA：University of California Press。
5.	Nove, Alec(1983)。The Economics of Feasible Socialism。London：George Allen & Unwin。
6.	Gereffi, Gary、Wyman, Donald L.(1990)。Manufacturing Miracles: Paths of Industrialization in Latin America and East Asia。New Jersey：Princeton University Press。
7.	Barzel, Yoram(1989)。Economic Analysis of Property Rights。Cambridge University Press。
8.	Yang, Mayfair(1994)。Gifts, Favors, and Banquets: The Art of Social Relationships in China。New York：Cornell University Press。
9.	Lu, Xiaobo、Perry, Elizabeth J.(1997)。Danwei: The Changing Chinese Workplace in Historical and Comparative Perspective。Armonk, N. Y.：M. E. Sharpe Inc.。
10.	Orru, Marco、Biggart, Nicole Woolsey、Hamilton, Gary G.(1997)。The Economic Organization of East Asian Capitalism。Sage。
11.	Kornai, János(1990)。The Road to a Free Economy。W. W. Norton & Company。
12.	Walder, Andrew(1986)。Communist Neo- Traditional ism: Work and Authority in Chinese Industry。Berkeley：University of California Press。
13.	Walder, Andrew G.(1995)。The Waning of the Communist State: Economic Origins of Political Decline in China and Hungary。Berkeley, CA：University of California Press。
14.	Deyo, Frederic C.(1987)。The Political Economy of the New Asian Industrialism。Berkeley：University of California Press。
15.	Buchanan, James M.、Tollison, Robert D.、Tullock, Gordon(1980)。Toward a Theory of the Rent-Seeking Society。College Station, TX：Texas A&M University Press。
16.	Libecap, Gary D.(1989)。Contracting for Property Rights。Cambridge University Press。
17.	Eggertsson, Thráinn(1990)。Economic Behavior and Institutions。Cambridge University Press。
18.	Shirk, Susan L.(1993)。The Political Logic of Economic Reform in China。University of California Press。
19.	吳國光、鄭永年(1995)。論中央--地方關係：中國制度轉型中的一個軸心問題。牛津大學。延伸查詢
20.	Naughton, Barry(1995)。Growing Out of the Plan: Chinese Economic Reform, 1978-1993。Cambridge University Press。
21.	Wade, Robert(1990)。Governing the Market: Economic Theory and the Role of Government in East Asian Industrialiation。Princeton University Press。
22.	Krasner, Stephen D.(1983)。International Regimes。Cornell University Press。
23.	Walder, Andrew G.(1994)。Corporate Organization and Local Government Property Rights in China。Changing Political Economies: Privatization in Post-Communist and Reforming Communist States。Boulder, CO。
24.	Winiecki, Jan(1991)。Resistance to Change in the Soviet Economic System: A Property-Rights Approach。Resistance to Change in the Soviet Economic System: A Property-Rights Approach。London, UK。
25.	Weitzman, Martin L.、Xu, Chenggang(1997)。Chinese Township-Village Enterprises as Vaguely Defined Cooperatives。Property Relations, Incentives and Welfare。New York, NY。
26.	倪志偉、Su, Sijin(1996)。Institutions, Social Ties, and Commitment in China's Corporatist Transformation。Reforming Asian Socialism: The Growth of Market Institutions。Ann Arbor, MI。
27.	張五常(1985)。中國的前途。中國的前途。香港。延伸查詢
28.	張五常(1987)。再論中國。香港：信報有限公司。延伸查詢
29.	Kornai, Janos(1994)。邁向自由經濟之路。邁向自由經濟之路。臺北。延伸查詢
30.	李國書(1993)。中國農村股份經濟的實踐與探索。中國農村股份經濟的實踐與探索。北京。延伸查詢
31.	托馬斯、勞甘(1991)。蒙德拉貢－對現代工人合作制的經濟分析。蒙德拉貢－對現代工人合作制的經濟分析。上海。延伸查詢
32.	王西玉(1993)。中國耕地制度的個案研究：平度、無錫、樂清三縣（市）的比較分析。中國農村土地制度的變革。北京。延伸查詢
33.	周其仁、戴小京(1994)。農民，市場和制度創新。農村變革與中國發展。香港。延伸查詢
34.	Bernstein, Thomas P.(1992)。Ideology and Rural Reform: The Paradox of Contingent Stability。State and Society in China: The Consequences of Reform。Boulder, CO。
35.	Bhagwati, Jagdish(1991)。Protectionism。Protectionism。Cambridge, MA。
36.	Christman, John(1994)。The Myth of Property: Toward an Egalitarian Theory of Ownership。New York, NY：Oxford University Press。
37.	Cooter, Robert(1992)。Organization as Property: Economic Analysis of Property Law Applied to Privatization。The Emergence of Market Economy in Eastern Europe。Cambridge。
38.	(1993)。Privatization in the Transition to a Market Economy: Studies of Preconditions and Policies in Eastern Europe。Privatization in the Transition to a Market Economy: Studies of Preconditions and Policies in Eastern Europe。New York, NY。
39.	Estrin, Saul(1989)。Workers' Co-operatives: Their Merits and Their Limitations。Market Socialism。Oxford。
40.	Frydman, Roman、Rapaczynski, Andrzej、Earle, John S.(1993)。The Privatization Process in Russia, Ukraine, and Baltic States。The Privatization Process in Russia, Ukraine, and Baltic States。London, UK。
41.	Furuboton, E. G.、Pejovich, S.(1974)。The Economics of Property Rights。Cambridge, Massachusetts：Ballinger Publishing Company。
42.	Gelb, A.、Svejnar, Jan(1990)。Chinese TVPs in an International Perspective。China's Rural Industry: Structure, Development, and Reform。Oxford。
43.	Hutchgcroft, Paul(1994)。Booty Capitalism: Business-Government Relations in the Philippines。Business and Government Relations in Industrializing Asia。Itasca, IL。
44.	MacIntyre, Andre(1994)。Business and Government Relations in Industrializing Asia。Business and Government Relations in Industrializing Asia。Itasca, IL。
45.	McKinnon, Ronald I.(1992)。Taxation, Money, and Credit in a Liberalizing Socialist Economy。The Emergence of Market Economies in Eastern Europe。Cambridge。
46.	Sable, Charles(1991)。Moebius-Strip Organizations and Open Labor Markets。Social Theory for a Changing Society。Boulder。
47.	(1996)。Uncertainty in Economic Thought。Uncertainty in Economic Thought。Cheltenham, UK。
48.	North, Douglass C.(1984)。Three Approaches to the Study of Institutions。Neoclassical Political Economy: The Analysis of Rent-seeking and DUP Activities。Cambridge, MA。
49.	(1996)。China After Socialism: In the Footsteps of Eastern Europe or East Asia?。China After Socialism: In the Footsteps of Eastern Europe or East Asia?。Armonk, NY。
50.	(1996)。Reforming Asian Socialism: The Growth of Market Institutions。Reforming Asian Socialism: The Growth of Market Institutions。Ann Arbor, MI。

其他
1.	薛承泰(2004)。老人照顧老人將是臺灣現象，http://ntu.edu.tw/~psc_news9312/120701.htm， 20041207。延伸查詢
2.	林南，陳志柔。Local Elites and Shareholding: Property Rights Transformation of Rural Enterprises in China，Stanford, CA。

圖書論文
1.	Schmitter, Philippe C.(1974)。Still the Century of Corporatism?。The New Corporatism: Social-Political Structures in the Iberian World。University of Notre Dame Press。
2.	Miller, G. J.、Moe, T. M.(1986)。The Positive Theory of Hierarchies。Political Science: The Science of Politics。New York：Agathon Press。
3.	Tullock, Gordon(1990)。The Costs of Special Privilege。Perspectives on Positive Political Economy。Cambridge University Press。
4.	Bourdieu, P.(1986)。The forms of capital。Handbook of theory and research for the sociology of education。Greenwood Press。
5.	Stark, David(1989)。Coexisting Organizational Forms in Hungary's Emerging Mixed Economy。Remaking the Economic Institutions of Socialism: China and Eastern Europe。Stanford University Press。
6.	Qian, Yingyi、Stiglitz, Joseph(1996)。Institutional Innovations and the Role of Local Government in transition Economies: The Case of Guangdong Province of China。Reforming Asian Socialism: The Growth of Market Institutions。The University of Michigan Press。

推文
推薦
引用網址
引用嵌入語法
轉寄

top

:::

相關期刊
相關論文
相關專書
相關著作
熱門點閱

1.	評《自下而上的改革：中國地方經濟發展的路徑分歧》[劉雅靈著，(臺北：巨流，2017)]
2.	外生的中國資本主義形成：以珠江三角洲私營企業主創業過程為例
3.	社會學與中國研究：臺灣的位置(1955~2005)
4.	文化旅遊與地方發展--以「中國第一水鄉」周莊為例
5.	拉丁美洲農村剩餘勞動力的流動及其對中國的啟示
6.	中國大陸基層選舉中的物質誘因與投票動員：以上海「先進」、「發達」兩社區「村改居」為例
7.	市場政治：中國出口導向製鞋產業的歷史形構與轉變
8.	空間規劃和論述的政治：對珠江三角洲城市化戰略的反思
9.	國家與農民工：無法完成的無產階級化
10.	蘇州臺商的政企關係--制度鑲嵌與比較觀點的考察
11.	從失序市場到有序市場：中介組織與市場規範--以溫州市鞋革行業協會為例
12.	中國大陸地方土地產權體制的形構與演化：東莞地區案例
13.	中國的經濟改革：市場社會主義下的雙層重經濟體制
14.	快速工業化下的中國大陸區域治理：以蘇州地區土地產權體制轉化為例
15.	跨界治理：臺資參與昆山制度創新的個案研究

1.	中國制度分歧中的地方金融與經濟發展：溫州、上海、天津之比較
2.	制度變遷、社會資本與經濟發展—溫州模式研究
3.	從「飛地」到學習型區域：地方制度與外資帶動的蘇州經濟轉型
4.	中共對台商的制度規範與台商因應對策分析~~交易成本理論之運用~~
5.	當代中國「國家─農民」關係的重構：農村村民自治制度運作之探討
6.	組織同形與制度內捲：中國國企改革與股市發展的動態邏輯
7.	中國大陸經濟轉型中政府角色與企業行為

1.	尋租中國：臺商、廣東模式與全球資本主義
2.	臺商在蘇州--全球化及在地化的考察
3.	制度變遷與產業發展 : 從工業到金融體制之轉型
4.	中國的經濟發展與制度變遷中法律的功能
5.	地方政府與發展
6.	地方政府與發展
7.	中國大陸地方土地產權體制轉化與區域治理模式 : 以蘇州地區為例
8.	中國大陸內陸城市經濟發展與地方產權體制轉化 : 涪陵模式的個案研究
9.	「家本位」與中國的工業化、現代化

無相關著作

1.	官僚組織的異化問題: 理論與方法背景初探
2.	地方永續發展與公眾認知: 資訊整合理論之應用
3.	政策分析家角色類型之探討: 兼論我們需要何種政策分析家
4.	公民參與與有效的政策執行
5.	建立以「生產知識」為基礎的行政體制
6.	再造「政府再造」的立基: 簽約外包的理論與策略
7.	論政府再造與預算改革之方向
8.	資訊科技與公共組織結構變革之探討
9.	美國聯邦政府的人力精簡經驗: 自願離退制度的分析
10.	政策論述與政策變遷的關聯性--批判取向的分析
11.	北市選民的候選人評價與投票決定
12.	搜尋臺灣民眾統獨態度的動力：一個個體動態模型的建立
13.	教育對於統獨傾向的作用
14.	臺灣選民的國家認同與黨派投票行為：一九九一至一九九三年間的實證研究結果
15.	臺灣族群認同的政治心理分析

QR Code

臺灣人文及社會科學引文索引資料庫系統

詳目顯示

臺灣人文及社會科學引文索引資料庫