臺灣人文及社會科學引文索引資料庫系統

:::

詳目顯示

回上一頁
第 1 筆 / 總合 1 筆   第一頁 上一頁 下一頁 最後一頁
/1頁
題名：國家應維護社會權嗎？--評當代反社會權論者的幾項看法
書刊名：人文及社會科學集刊
作者：陳宜中
作者(外文)：Chen, I-chung
出版日期：2003
卷期：15:2
頁次：頁309-338
主題關鍵詞：社會權；正義；積極權利；消極權利；自由主義；Social rights；Justice；Positive rights；Negative rights；Liberalism
原始連結：連回原系統網址new window
相關次數：
  • 被引用次數被引用次數:期刊(5) 博士論文(3) 專書(0) 專書論文(0)
  • 排除自我引用排除自我引用:4
  • 共同引用共同引用:5
  • 點閱點閱:207
本文從政治哲學的角度探討社會權的理論意涵，並針對當代反社會權論者的幾項看法，進行分析和評估。社會權的理論家們認為，社經基本需要滿足必須視為是公民之基本權利，以及一項最基本的社經正義原則。反對者則認為社會權是一種「積極」權力而不應予以保障，因其違背了古典自由主義對權利與正義之「消極」理解及對國家角色之認定。批評者指出，社會權是一種施加於國家及第三人某些積極義務之權利，而此種積極權利的問題在於：請求稀少資源；內容、程度及實現與否難以判定；不具普遍性；所隱含的權利義務關係不夠明確；與私產權相衝突；以矯治後果或事態為目的。本文針對這些看法進行評估，並說明其為什麼是不成功的。本文認為，社經基本需要之滿足是一項正當的社經主義╱權利主張，旨在釐清究竟哪些社經事務具有政治道德上的重要性，而必須予以高度關切。儘管社會權仍必須面對不少理論與實踐上的難題，但此種權利之「積極」或「消極」與否，並非其是否應予保障之問題關鍵。
Socail rights are widely viewed as a species of 'positive rights', namely rights that impose 'positive obligations' on the state and other people, demanding that they act in certain ways for the right-holders. According to some contemporary critics of social rights, 'positive rights' should not be enforced by the state and treated as a matter of justice. Being positive, social rights are said to be problematic in the following ways: they are inevitably asserted to scarce goods and therefore do not possess the property of compossibility; they are highly indeterminate and not easily ascertainable; they cannot claim the property of universality; they do not entail correlative obligations; their realization necessitates a redistribution of resources that violates rights of legitimate propetry-holders; and they involve an erroneous conception of justice. This article shows that none of these arguments has any significant force. The distinction between negative and positive rights is one thing; whether social rights ought to be protected by the state is quite another. The former has to do with different occasions for performance, not issues of moral importance.
期刊論文
1.陳新民(19881100)。論「社會基本權利」。人文及社會科學集刊，1(1)，199-225。new window  延伸查詢new window
2.Tushnet, M.(1984)。An Essay on Rights。Texas Law Review，62，1363-1394。  new window
3.Griffin, J.(2000)。Welfare Rights。The Journal of Ethics，4，27-43。  new window
4.Haakonssen, K.(1985)。Hugo Grotius and the History of Political Thought。Political Theory，13，239-265。  new window
5.Pereira-Menault, A. C.(1988)。Against Positive Rights。Valparaiso Law Review，22，359-383。  new window
6.Schneewind, J. B.(1987)。Pufendorf's Place in the History of Ethics。Synthese，72(1)，123-155。  new window
7.Schneewind, J. B.(1993)。Kant and Natural Law Ethics。Ethics，104，53-74。  new window
8.Steiner, H.(1977)。The Structure of a Set of Compossible Rights。Journal of Philosophy，74，767-775。  new window
9.Waldron, J.(2000)。The Role of Rights in Practical Reasoning。The Journal of Ethics，4，115-135。  new window
10.Walzer, M.(1981)。Philosophy and Democracy。Political Theory，9，379-400。  new window
圖書
1.Nagel, Thomas(1991)。Equality and Partiality。Oxford。  new window
2.Waldron, Jeremy(1993)。Liberal Rights。Cambridge：Cambridge University Press。  new window
3.Cranston, M.(1973)。What are Human Rights?。The Bodley Head。  new window
4.Kymlicka, Will(1990)。Contemporary Political Philosophy: An Introduction。Oxford：Oxford University Press。  new window
5.Walzer, Michael(1983)。Spheres of Justice。Oxford：Basil Blackwell。  new window
6.Smith, A.(1976)。The Wealth of Nations。Chicago：University of Chicago Press。  new window
7.Rosen, Allen D.(1993)。Kant's Theory of Justice。Cornell University Press。  new window
8.Plant, Raymond(1991)。Modern Political Thought。Oxford：Basil Blackwell。  new window
9.Tuck, Richard(1979)。Natural Rights Theories。Cambridge：Cambridge University Press。  new window
10.Hayek, F. A.(1976)。Law, Legislation and Liberty。Chicago, IL：University of Chicago Press。  new window
11.Fabre, C.(2000)。Social Rights under the Constitution。Oxford：Clarendon Press。  new window
12.Sen, A. K.(1984)。Resources, values and development。Oxford：Basil Blackwell。  new window
13.Donnelly, Jack(1985)。The Concept of Human Rights。St. Martin's Press。  new window
14.Jones, Peter(1994)。Rights。St. Martin's Press。  new window
15.Tully, James(1993)。An Approach to Political Philosophy: Locke in Contexts。Cambridge University Press。  new window
16.Phillips, Anne(1999)。Which Equalities Matter?。Polity Press。  new window
17.Griswold, Charles L. Jr.(1999)。Adam Smith and the Virtues of Enlightenment。Cambridge University Press。  new window
18.Hobhouse, Leonard T.、Meadowcroft, James(1994)。Liberalism and Other Writings。Cambridge：Cambridge University Press。  new window
19.Bobbio, Norberto、Cameron, Allan(1996)。The Age of Rights。Cambridge：Polity。  new window
20.Bulmer, Martin、Rees, Anthony M.(1996)。Citizenship Today: The Contemporary Relevance of T. H. Marshall。London：University College London Press(UCL Press)。  new window
21.Raz, Joseph(1988)。The Morality of Freedom。New York, NY：Clarendon Press。  new window
22.Gray, John(2000)。Two faces of liberalism。Cambridge：Polity Press。  new window
23.Gewirth, Alan(1996)。The Community of Rights。Chicago, IL：The University of Chicago Press。  new window
24.Dworkin, Ronald(1977)。Taking Rights Seriously。London：Gerald Duckworth and Co Ltd.。  new window
25.Dworkin, Ronald(2000)。Sovereign Virtue: Theory and Practice of Equality。Cambridge, Massachusetts：Harvard University Press。  new window
26.Heater, Derek B.(1999)。What is citizenship?。Polity Press。  new window
27.Marshall, T. H.、Bottomore, T.(1992)。Citizenship and Social Class。Citizenship and Social Class. London: Pluto.。London, Concord (Mass.)：Pluto Press。  new window
28.Esping-Andersen, Gøsta(1990)。The Three World of Welfare Capitalism。Oxford：Polity Press。  new window
29.Donnelly, Jack(1989)。Universal Human Rights in Theory and Practice。Cornell University Press。  new window
30.Gewirth, Alan(1982)。Human rights: Essays on justification and applications。University of Chicago Press。  new window
31.Pogge, Thomas W.(1989)。Realizing Rawls。Cornell University Press。  new window
32.Feinberg, Joel(1973)。Social Philosophy。Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey：Prentice Hall。  new window
33.Nozick, Robert(1974)。Anarchy, State and Utopia。Blackwell。  new window
34.Rawls, John(1993)。Political Liberalism。Cambridge University Press。  new window
35.Rawls, John(1999)。A Theory of Justice。Harvard University Press。  new window
36.Hayek, Friedrich A.(1973)。Law, Legislation and Liberty。Chicago：University of Chicago Press。  new window
37.Shklar, Judith N.(1990)。The faces of injustice。New Haven：Yale University Press。  new window
38.Locke, J.(1997)。Political Essays。Cambridge：Cambridge University Press。  new window
39.Barry, N.(1990)。Welfare。Welfare。Milton Keynes, UK。  new window
40.(1995)。Politics and Human Rights。Politics and Human Rights。Oxford。  new window
41.(1998)。Necessary Goods。Necessary Goods。Oxford。  new window
42.Claeys, G.(1989)。Thomas Paine: Social and Political Thought。Thomas Paine: Social and Political Thought。London, UK。  new window
43.Dworkin, R.(1996)。Do Liberty and Equality Conflict?。Living as Equals。Oxford。  new window
44.Flew, A.(1989)。Equality in Liberty and Justice。Equality in Liberty and Justice。London, UK。  new window
45.Frankfurt, H. G.(1988)。The Importance of What We Care About: Philosophical Essays。Cambridge University Press。  new window
46.Frankfurt, H. G.(1998)。Necessity and Desire。Necessary Goods。Oxford。  new window
47.Fried, C.(1978)。Right and Wrong。Right and Wrong。Cambridge, MA。  new window
48.Friedman, F.、Friedman, R.(1980)。Free to Choose。Free to Choose。London, UK。  new window
49.Goodin, R. E.(1998)。Vulnerabilities and Responsibilities。Necessary Goods。Oxford。  new window
50.Gray, J.(1992)。The Moral Foundations of Market Institutions。The Moral Foundations of Market Institutions。London, UK。  new window
51.Haakonssen, Knud(1996)。Natural Law and Moral Philosophy: From Grotius to the Scottish Enlightenment。Cambridge University Press。  new window
52.Holfeld, W. N.(1919)。Fundamental Legal Conceptions as Applied in Juridical Reasoning。Fundamental Legal Conceptions as Applied in Juridical Reasoning。New Haven。  new window
53.Hont, I.、Ignatieff, M.(1983)。Needs and Justice in the Wealth of Nations。Wealth and Virtue。Cambridge。  new window
54.Horne, T. A.(1988)。Welfare Rights as Property Rights。Responsibility, Rights, and Welfare。Boulder, CO/ London, UK。  new window
55.Horne, T. A.(1990)。Property Rights and Poverty: Political Argument in Britain 1605-1834。Property Rights and Poverty。Chapel Hill：University of North Carolina Press。  new window
56.Locke, J.、Locke, John(1960)。John Locke: Two Treatises of Government。John Locke: Two Treatises of Government。Cambridge。  new window
57.(1985)。Positive and Negative Duties。Positive and Negative Duties。沒有紀錄。  new window
58.Michelman, F.(1989)。Constitutional Welfare Rights and A Theory of Justice。Reading Rawls。California。  new window
59.Mill, J. S.(1989)。On Liberty and Other Essays。On Liberty and Other Essays。Cambridge。  new window
60.Mill, J. S.(1993)。Utilitarianism。Utilitarianism。London, UK。  new window
61.Narveson, J.(1984)。Negative and Positive Rights in Gewirth's Reason and Morality。Gewirth's Ethical Rationalism。Chicago, IL。  new window
62.Nino, Carlos S.(1991)。The Ethics of Human Rights。The Ethics of Human Rights。Oxford。  new window
63.Nussbaum, M.(1998)。Aristotelian Social Democracy。Necessary Goods。Oxford。  new window
64.O'Neill, O.(1996)。Towards Justice and Virtue。Towards Justice and Virtue。Cambridge。  new window
65.O'Neill, O.(1998)。Rights, Obligations, and Needs。Necessary Goods。Oxford。  new window
66.Paine, T.(1967)。The Writings of Thomas Paine。The Writings of Thomas Paine。New York, NY。  new window
67.Plant, R.(1998)。Citizenship, Rights, Welfare。Social Policy and Social Justice。Cambridge。  new window
68.Plant, Raymond、Lesser, Harry、Taylor-Gooby, Peter(1980)。Political Philosophy and Social Welfare。Routledge & Kegan Paul。  new window
69.Sen, A.(1991)。Poor, Relatively Speaking。Contemporary Political Theory。New York, NY。  new window
70.Shue, H.(1980)。Basic Rights。Basic Rights。New Jersey。  new window
71.Sumner, L. W.(1987)。The Moral Foundation of Rights。The Moral Foundation of Rights。Oxford。  new window
72.Waldron, J.(1987)。Nonsense Upon Stilts。Nonsense Upon Stilts。London, UK/ New York, NY。  new window
73.Waldron, J.(1988)。The Right to Private Property。The Right to Private Property。Oxford。  new window
其他
1.Boyd, R. A.(2001)。Whig History and Lockean Political Economy，沒有紀錄。  new window
圖書論文
1.Sen, Amartya(1993)。Capability and Well-being。The Quality of Life。Oxford University Press。  new window
2.Wiggins, David(1998)。What Is the Force of the Claim That One Needs Something?。Necessary Goods: Our Responsibilities to Meet Others' Needs。Oxford：Rowman & Littlefield Publishers。  new window
 
 
 
 
第一頁 上一頁 下一頁 最後一頁 top
QR Code
QRCODE

臺灣人文及社會科學引文索引資料庫

目前上線人數：817（臺灣：773，外國：44） ／ 本年度總使用人次：1473665 ／ 訪客人次（自102年09月）：67281565
國家圖書館著作權聲明 Copyright © 2013 All rights reserved.
本館地址: 100201臺北市中山南路20號． 本館地圖及交通資訊．
總機：(02)23619132．最佳瀏覽解析度為1024x768以上