:::

詳目顯示

回上一頁
題名:國際綜評性論文之分析
書刊名:體育學報
作者:張育愷 引用關係宋岱芬 引用關係陳豐慈
作者(外文):Chang, Yu-kaiSong, Tai-fenChen, Feng-tzu
出版日期:2017
卷期:50:4
頁次:頁375-384
主題關鍵詞:敘述式綜評系統性綜評統合分析學術品質Narrative reviewSystematic reviewMeta-analytic reviewQuality of research
原始連結:連回原系統網址new window
相關次數:
  • 被引用次數被引用次數:期刊(9) 博士論文(0) 專書(0) 專書論文(0)
  • 排除自我引用排除自我引用:9
  • 共同引用共同引用:48
  • 點閱點閱:5
學術研究發表為研究者傳播知識的主要渠道之一,故學術社群經常將發表視為客觀性評估學術表現之參考依據。近年,體育運動領域的學者在期刊論文發表已有顯著與持續的整體提升,然其主要型態係以實證性研究為主,而綜評此另一種重要型態的期刊論文則相對較少被聚焦。為此,本文之主旨在針對綜評進行基本概念之介紹。經統整國際綜評趨勢後,本文指出主要綜評類型包括有敘述式、系統性,及統合分析式三種。敘述式綜評為所有類型中相對簡易與富有彈性,其架構主要是聚焦於一段時間內對特定主題的陳述,並將之分做群組分類與探討。而系統性綜評在擇選文獻上則相對嚴謹,其具備使用方法與可複製性、清楚地定義問題、全面性的搜尋策略、詳盡的納入標準、以方法學品質評估等特徵。統合分析式綜評則為層次相對高之綜評類型,其主要多了較為「客觀」之統計方式進行文獻評價與整理。最後,作者亦以自身經驗歸納出撰述國內與國際綜評時可思考之要點。以國內社群方面而言,針對各群組進行摘要整理、撰述群組時以概念性加以整合、引用第一手資料,以及較新的文獻等要點,可作為未來撰述綜評之思量。而在國際社群方面,全面性搜尋、圖表統合、建立新理論或模式,以及跨領域結合等要點亦可作為日後參考。本文期望透過此綜評之簡易介紹,能提供國內體育運動領域學者增加對於綜評之知能,再次提升學術期刊論文品質之方向邁進。
Academic research is one of the main approaches used in presenting new scientific knowledge, and the academic community generally employs research approaches as objective indices in order to evaluate academic performance. Recently, the field of Physical Education, Sports and Exercise has shown great progress in publishing journal papers. For the most part, empirical studies are typically the relevant material. However, reviews, another important area of research, are generally not given much attention. Therefore, the present manuscript attempts to provide a brief review concerning the basic concept of reviews. After integrating international trends applicable for reviewing, we concluded that the narrative review, the systematic review, and the meta-analytic review are the three main types of reviews. Among all the types of reviews, the narrative review is simpler and has more flexibility, and permits describing the specific topic with brevity and with further classification and discussion. The systematic review is related in a more rigorous manner, because this type of reporting uses methods targeting the study's reproducibility, including its defining of questions, its broadly conceived research strategy, and the criteria of its details, while evaluating its quality of research methodology. The meta-analytic review is the highest level of all the review types, because it uses statistical analysis methods as objective indices in order to measure and evaluate the study's outcome. Lastly, the author has also provided several suggestions based upon professional authors' experiences, which should be considered by those writing reviews, both nationally and internationally. Regarding the national community, providing abstracts for each group title, integrating conceptually the group titles, citing original information, and referencing the latest journal papers, are to be considered as professional standards for writing reviews in the future. For submitting a journal paper to the international community, we suggested that future experts can and ought to use broadly conceived research methods, by integrating figures and tables, building new theories and models, and applying multidisciplinary approaches in order to increase visibility for the review. This manuscript that briefly introduces a review may provide the knowledge basis regarding the purposes of the review, thereby enabling further methods for improving the quality of academic research the in Physical Education, Sports and Exercise field.
期刊論文
1.張育愷、洪聰敏(20140300)。臺灣運動與體育領域學術期刊論文發表之現況分析。體育學報,47(1),1-9。new window  延伸查詢new window
2.吳昇光、吳聰義(20120600)。運動科學界使用科學引用指數來評比學者學術成就:客觀或爭議?。身體活動與運動科學學刊,1(1),19-29。new window  延伸查詢new window
3.張育愷(20130300)。邁向體育運動領域的學術頂尖:回顧2012年心得紀要。人文與社會科學簡訊,14(2),93-100。  延伸查詢new window
4.張育愷、祝堅恆(20120600)。體育與運動的SCI與SSCI。體育學報,45(2),79-91。new window  延伸查詢new window
5.Chang, Y.-K.、Pan, C.-Y.、Chen, F.-T.、Tsai, C.-L.、Huang, C.-C.(2012)。Effect of resistance-exercise training on cognitive function in healthy older adults: A review。Journal of Aging and Physical Activity,20(4),497-517。  new window
6.張育愷、林珈余(20100600)。身體活動對孩童認知表現的影響。中華體育季刊,24(2)=93,83-92。new window  延伸查詢new window
7.陳豐慈、張育愷(20121100)。阻力健身運動對老人認知功能影響之回顧。臺灣運動心理學報,12(2),37-56。new window  延伸查詢new window
8.Etnier, J. L.、Chang, Y.-K.(2009)。The effect of physical activity on executive function: A brief commentary on definitions, measurement issues, and the current state of the literature。Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology,31(4),469-483。  new window
9.Chang, Y. K.、Nien, Y. H.、Tsai, C. L.、Etnier, J. L.(2010)。Physical activity and cognition in older adults: the potential of Tai Chi Chuan。Journal of Aging and Physical Activity,18(4),451-472。  new window
10.Prakash, R. S.、Voss, M. W.、Erickson, K. I.、Kramer, A. F.(2015)。Physical activity and cognitive vitality。Annual Review of Psychology,66(1),769-797。  new window
11.Khan, N. A.、Hillman, C. H.(2014)。The relation of childhood physical activity and aerobic fitness to brain function and cognition: A review。Pediatric Exercise Science,26(2),138-146。  new window
12.Crews, D. J.、Landers, D. M.(1987)。A meta analytic review of aerobic fitness and reactivity to psychosocial stressors。Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise,19(5 Suppl),S114-S120。  new window
13.吳淑真(20160300)。臺灣體育運動科學發展現況與未來趨勢。體育學報,49(1),1-14。new window  延伸查詢new window
14.Chang, Y. K.、Chu, C. H.、Chen, F. T.、Hung, T. M.、Etnier, J. L.(2017)。Combined effects of physical activity and obesity on cognitive function: Independent, overlapping, moderator, and mediator models。Sports Medicine,47(3),449-468。  new window
15.Alvarez-Bueno, C.、Pesce, C.、Cavero-Redondo, I.、Sanchez-Lopez, M.、Pardo-Guijarro, M. J.、Martinez-Vizcaino, V.(2016)。Association of physical activity with cognition, metacognition and academic performance in children and adolescents: A protocol for systematic review and meta-analysis。BMJ Open,6(6),e011065。  new window
16.Chu, C. H.、Chen, F. T.、Pontifex, M. B.、Sun, Y.、Chang, Y. K.(2016)。Health-related physical fitness, academic achievement, and neuroelectric measures in children and adolescents。International Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology,1-16。  new window
17.Chang, Y. K.、Nien, Y. H.、Chen, A. G.、Yan, J.(2014)。Tai Ji Quan, the brain, and cognition in older adults。Journal of Sport and Health Science,3(1),36-42。  new window
18.Chung, K. C.、Burns, P. B.、Kim, H. M.(2006)。A practical guide to meta-analysis。The Journal of Hand Surgery,31(10),1671-1678。  new window
19.Esteban-Cornejo, I.、Tejero-Gonzalez, C. M.、Sallis, J. F.、Veiga, O. L.(2015)。Physical activity and cognition in adolescents: A systematic review。Journal of Science and Medicine in Sport,18(5),534-539。  new window
20.Donnelly, J. E.、Hillman, C. H.、Castelli, D.、Etnier, J. L.、Lee, S.、Tomporowski, P.、Szabo-Reed, A. N.(2016)。Physical activity, fitness, cognitive function, and academic achievement in children: A systematic review。Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise,48(6),1197-1222。  new window
21.de Greeff, J. W.、Bosker, R. J.、Oosterlaan, J.、Visscher, C.、Hartman, E.(2017)。Effects of physical activity on executive functions, attention and academic performance in preadolescent children: A meta-analysis。Journal of Science and Medicine in Sport。  new window
22.Ferrari, R.(2015)。Writing narrative style literature reviews。Medical Writing,24(4),230-235。  new window
23.Glass, Gene V.(1976)。Primary, Secondary, and Meta-Analysis of Research。Educational Researcher,5(10),3-8。  new window
24.Halloway, S.、Wilbur, J.、Schoeny, M. E.、Arfanakis, K.(2016)。Effects of endurance-focused physical activity interventions on brain health: A systematic review。Biological Research for Nursing。  new window
25.Shamseer, L.、Moher, D.、Clarke, M.、Ghersi, D.、Liberati, A.、Petticrew, M.、Stewart, L. A.(2015)。Preferred reporting items for systematic review and meta-analysis protocols (PRISMA-P) 2015: elaboration and explanation。British Medical Journal,349,g7647。  new window
26.Lin, J. S.、O'Connor, E.、Rossom, R. C.、Perdue, L. A.、Eckstrom, E.(2013)。Screening for cognitive impairment in older adults: A systematic review for the U. S. Preventive Services Task Force。Annals of Internal Medicine,159(9),601-612。  new window
27.Sutherland, S. E.(2004)。An introduction to systematic reviews。Journal of Evidence-Based Dental Practice,4(1),47-51。  new window
28.Zheng, G.、Xia, R.、Zhou, W.、Tao, J.、Chen, L.(2016)。Aerobic exercise ameliorates cognitive function in older adults with mild cognitive impairment: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomised controlled trials。British Journal of Sports Medicine,50(23),1443-1450。  new window
29.Chang, Y. K.、Labban, J. D.、Gapin, J. I.、Etnier, J. L.(2012)。The effects of acute exercise on cognitive performance: A meta-analysis。Brain Research,1453(250),87-101。  new window
30.Northey, J. M.、Cherbuin, N.、Pumpa, K. L.、Smee, D. J.、Rattray, B.(2018)。Exercise interventions for cognitive function in adults older than 50: A systematic review with meta-analysis。British Journal of Sports Medicine,52(3),154-160。  new window
圖書
1.American Psychological Association(2010)。Publication manual of the American Psychological Association。Washington, DC:American Psychological Association。  new window
 
 
 
 
第一頁 上一頁 下一頁 最後一頁 top