:::

詳目顯示

回上一頁
題名:Politics Aestheticized: An Interpretation of Hannah Arendt's Theory of Political Action
書刊名:人文及社會科學集刊
作者:江宜樺
作者(外文):Jiang, Yi-huah
出版日期:1993
卷期:6:1
頁次:頁303-340
主題關鍵詞:漢娜•鄂蘭行動理論Hannah Arendt
原始連結:連回原系統網址new window
相關次數:
  • 被引用次數被引用次數:期刊(1) 博士論文(0) 專書(2) 專書論文(0)
  • 排除自我引用排除自我引用:1
  • 共同引用共同引用:0
  • 點閱點閱:62
本文試圖從「政治學美學化」的角度來詮釋漢娜.鄂蘭的政治行動理論。首先我
注意到鄂蘭一再地把政治行動比擬為一種表演藝術。對她來講,政治行動之所以能被當成一
種表演藝術,主要是因為兩者同樣以表述技藝之美善為該行為終極意義所在。相形之下,世
俗的道德要求或哲學真理就不是政治行動所必須考慮的事。其次,我發現鄂蘭不只視政治行
動為表演藝術,並且還認為惟有美才足以使人間事務臻於永恆。偉大的政治行動所體現的對
不朽的追求,是人類有異於其他動物汲汲於維持生命或改善生存環境的最大特色所在。當然
,由於鄂蘭主張政治行動不應受制於道德考量,所以在行動的原動力上她必須另有一套說法
。在第三節中我指出她的說法就是以「原則」取代「動機」,以「承諾」與「寬恕」做為調
節行動後果的機制。但是,不論是原則、承諾或寬恕,都不是傳統道德意義下的概念。在最
後一部分,我針對鄂蘭美學化政治學的企圖給予某些評價。一方面我認為鄂蘭面對後現代的
來臨,嘗試以美的觀點來界定政治,自然與近代德國哲學傳統的演變有關,同時也充分體現
她做為一個政治哲學家的原創力。但是由於她對美的過度堅持,以及因此而導致的對社經問
題道德考量的輕視,卻又使其理論失之偏頗,非經修改,不足以回應現實政治的種種挑戰。
The essay tries to provide a new interpretation of Hannah Arendt's
political theory from the view point of aesthetic politics. First I exploxe how
Arendt perceives political action as a kind of performing art. Political action,
distinct from labor and work, is for Arendt the human capacity to initiate
something unexpected and extraordinary. It is invaluable because it can make the
world more beautiful with magnificent deeds and words, regardless of
considerations of the good and the true. Arendt's aesthetic politics is not only
illustrated in her interpreting political action as a performing art, but also
in her discussion of the criterion with which we judge human affairs. In the
second section, I point out with various evidences that beauty is the supreme
value of Arendt's politics. Without beauty, all human enterprise would be futile
and no political engagement could become part of our eternal memory. Arendt's
attempt to elevate beauty and greatness to be the highest criterion of political
action, needless to say, raises the suspicion of moral indifference or nihilism.
I examine this problem in section three, arguing that Arendt does try to replace
conventional morality with "principles" as the inspiring force of free action.
The only two apparent moralities in Arendt's political theory, promise and
forgiveness, prove nothing more than the control mechanism inside action itself.
Political action is eventually bounded by nothing external. In the final part of
the essay I assess the positive and negative sides of Arendt's aesthetic
politics. I think Arendt's project is unique in that she tries to aestheticize
politics so that a new way of political thinking can appear and respond to the
general trend our society is moving along with. Yet I also think her attempt is
infeasible because, first, socio-economic problems are excluded from its
coverage; and second, its moral ground is too weak to assume the result of
boundless action. To resolve these problems, I suggest that, first, social
welfare should be juxtaposed with personality revelation as the essential
function of politics; and second, morality of ordinary people should be taken
into account in the assessment of political action. The modification, to be
sure, will weaken the strength and attraction of Arendt's aesthetic politics.
But it is the only way to preserve some of her political insights without
damaging her originality.
期刊論文
1.Villa, Dana R.(1992)。Postmodernism and the Public Sphere。The American Political Science Review,86(3),712-721。  new window
2.Canovan, Margaret(198302)。A Case of Distorted Communication: A Note on Habermas and Arendt。Political Theory,11(1),105-116。  new window
3.Cooper, Leroy A.(1976)。Hannah Arendt's Political Philosophy: An Interpretation。The Review of Politics,38(2),145-176。  new window
4.Habermas, Jürgen(1977)。Hannah Arendt's Communications Concept of Power。Social Research,44(1),3-24。  new window
5.Hinchman, Lewis P.、Hinchman, Sandra K.(1999)。Existentialism Politicized : Arendt's Debt to Jaspers。The Review of Politics,53(3),435-468。  new window
6.Kohn, Jerome(1990)。Thinking/Acting。Social Research,57(1),105-134。  new window
7.Pitkin, Hanna F.(1981)。Justice On Relating Private and Public。Political Theory,9(3),327-352。  new window
8.Jay, Martin(1978)。Hannah Arendt: Opposing Views。Partisan Review,45(3),348-367。  new window
9.Benhabib, Seyla(1988)。Judgment and the Moral Foundations of Politics in Arendt's Thought。Political Theory,16(1),29-51。  new window
10.Heather, Gerard P.、Stolz, Matthew(1979)。Hannah Arendt and the Problem of Critical Theory。Journal of Politics,41(1),2-22。  new window
11.Luban, David(1979)。On Habermas, On Arendt, On Power。Philosophy and Social Criticism,6(1),80-95。  new window
12.O'Sullivan, N. K.(1973)。Politics, Totalitarianism and Freedom: The Political Thought of Hannah Arendt。Political Studies,21(2),183-198。  new window
13.Thompson, Kirk(1969)。Constitutional Theory and Political Action。Journal of Politics,31(3),655-681。  new window
學位論文
1.Jiang, Yi-Huah(1993)。Thinking without a Bannister: An Interpretation of Hannah Arendt's Aesthetic Politics(博士論文)。Yale University。  new window
圖書
1.Parekh, Bhikhu(1982)。Hannah Arendt。Contemporary Political Thinkers。Oxford:Martin Robertson。  new window
2.Arendt, Hannah(1966)。The Origins of Totalitarianism。Harcourt, Brace & World。  new window
3.Arendt, Hannah(1977)。On Revolution。New York:Pelican Books。  new window
4.Arendt, Hannah(1978)。The Life of the Mind, Vol. 2: Willing。San Diego:Harcourt Brace Jovanovich。  new window
5.Kateb, George(1983)。Hannah Arendt: Politics, Conscience, Evil. Totowa。New Jersey:Rowman and Allanheld。  new window
6.Beiner, Ronald(1983)。Political Judgment。Chicago:University of Chicago Press。  new window
7.Arendt, Hannah(1978)。The Life of the Mind, vol. 1: Thinking。New York:Harcourt, Brace & Jovanovich。  new window
8.Nietzsche, Friedrich、Kaufmann, Walter(1968)。The Basic Writings of Nietzsche。New York:The Modem Library。  new window
9.Arendt, Hannah(1972)。Crises of the Republic。Harcourt Brace Jovanovish。  new window
10.Canovan, Margaret(1974)。The Political Thought of Hannah Arendt。New York:Harcourt Brace Jovanovich。  new window
11.Whitfield, Stephen J.(1980)。Into the Dark : Hannah Arendt and Totalitarianism。Philadelphia:Temple University Press。  new window
12.Bradshaw, Leah(1989)。Acting and Thinking: The Political Thought of Hannah Arendt。Toronto:University of Toronto Press。  new window
13.Braudel, Fernand、Reynolds, Sian(1979)。The Structures of Everyday Life, Civilization and Capitalism 15th-18th Century。New York:Harper & Row。  new window
14.Arendt, Hannah(1977)。Between Past and Future: Eight Exercises in Political Thought。Penguin Books。  new window
15.McKenna, George(1984)。Bannisterless Politics: Hannah Arendt and Her Children。History of Political Thought。  new window
16.Arendt, Hannah(1958)。The Human Condition。University of Chicago Press。  new window
17.Skocpol, Theda(1979)。States and Social Revolutions: A Comparative Analysis of France, Russia, and China。Cambridge University Press。  new window
圖書論文
1.Beiner, Ronald(1982)。Interpretive Essay。Hannah Arendt : Lectures on Kant’s Political Philosophy。Chicago:University of Chicago Press。  new window
2.Bernstein, Richard(1977)。Hannah Arendt: The Ambiguities of Theory and Practice。Political Theory and Praxis: New Perspectives。Minneapolis:University of Minnesota Press。  new window
3.Feldman, Ron H.(1978)。[The Jew as Pariah: Jewish Identity and Politics in the Modern Age]Introduction。The Jew as Pariah: Jewish Identity and Politics in the Modern Age。New York:Grove Press。  new window
 
 
 
 
第一頁 上一頁 下一頁 最後一頁 top