:::

詳目顯示

回上一頁
題名:NIMBY Syndrome and Facility Siting
書刊名:中國行政評論
作者:丘昌泰 引用關係
作者(外文):Chiou, Chang-tay
出版日期:2005
卷期:14:3
頁次:頁33-64
主題關鍵詞:環境糾紛自力救濟鄰避情結衝突管理Environmental disputesSelf-help protestNIMBYConflict management
原始連結:連回原系統網址new window
相關次數:
  • 被引用次數被引用次數:期刊(2) 博士論文(0) 專書(1) 專書論文(0)
  • 排除自我引用排除自我引用:2
  • 共同引用共同引用:0
  • 點閱點閱:34
在公共設施廠址選定過程中,鄰避情結(Not In My Backyard,簡稱NIMBY)是世界各工業化國家普遍遭遇的現象,故鄰避主義(NIMBYism)的研究一直受到實務界與學術界的重視。產生鄰避情結的公共設施,通稱為鄰避型設施,往往導致公共政策的制訂經常出現政策癱瘓(policy paralysis)或政策停滯(policy stagflation)的現象,乃成為當代政府機關必須積極面對的公共課題。本研究旨在探討鄰避設施中鄰避情結現象的因素結構與因應策略。本文以六家民營化發電廠為研究對象,依文獻分析結果,歸納出六項構成鄰避情結的因素:(一)健康與財產問題;(二)環保回饋問題;(三)生活品質問題;(四)專家決策獨裁問題;(五)信任差距問題;(六)黑白道介入問題。研究方法首先就電廠管理者與附近社區民眾進行深度訪問,受訪廠商涵蓋台灣全島,從北部的長生與新桃電廠、中部的海渡電廠、南部的麥寮與嘉惠電廠、以及東部的和平電廠等。社區民眾則以電廠附近的村長及自力救濟團體的領導人為訪問對象,總計約三十人;最後針對電廠所屬鄉鎮居民隨機選取二百六十人進行電話調查。本研究建議:成功的廠址設定必須從政府管制、社區參與、市場基礎三大類策略著手,以化解民營電廠興建過程中的鄰避現象。
In public facility construction procedures, NIMBY (not in my backyard) syndrome has always been a focus of planning practitioners and researchers. By focusing the study on the procedures related to site location of Taiwan's privatized electric power plants, the author examines factors leading to NIMBY and how, it was settled. These include: health and property problems, environmental compensation, impact on living standard, expert-centered participation, credibility gap, and local politics. The author proceeded to frequently and intensively visit both representatives of six power plants and the people of the neighborhood of the sites. At each site we interviewed either the factory manager or the person in charge of community relations for the plant. For the local people we interviewed the community leader and the self-help group representative of the community. A total of 30 individuals participated in the survey. Next, through the Computer-Assisted-Telephone-Interview (CATI) system, the author also conducted phone interviews with an additional 260 persons, using the local phone directories as a sample source. The paper concluded that in order for a plant location proposal to be executed smoothly, it has to comply with government restrictions, actively involve the community, take into account market research and go through policy debate.
期刊論文
1.Hunter, Susan、Leyden, Kevin M.(1995)。Beyond NIMBY: Explaining Opposition to Hazardous Waste Facilities。Policy Studies Journal,23(4),601-619。  new window
2.Sechrest, D. K.(1992)。Locating Prisons: Open Versus Closed Approaches to Siting。Crime and Delinquency,38(1),88-104。  new window
3.Sellers, Martin P.(1992)。NIMBY: A Case Study in Conflict Politics。Public Administration Quarterly,16(4),460-477。  new window
4.Takahashi, Lois M.(1997)。The Socio-Spatial Stigmatization of Homelessness and HIV/AIDS: Toward an Explanation of the NIMBY Syndrome。Social Science Medicine,45(6),903-914。  new window
5.Vittes, M. E.、Pollock, P. H. III、Lilie, S. A.(1993)。Factors Contributing to NIMBY Attitudes。Waste Management,13,125-129。  new window
6.Young, Stewart(1990)。Combating NIMBY With Risk Communication。Public Relations Quarterly,35(2),22-26。  new window
7.Halvorsen, J. V.(1999)。Understanding NIMBY: A Study of Protests against Gas Pipeline Projects。Public Utilities Fortnightly,137(16),70。  new window
8.Shanoff, Barry(2000)。Not in My Backyard: The Sequel。Waste Age,31(8),16-17。  new window
9.Kreidler, M.(200009)。NIMBY Wins Again。Wallace's Farmer,2000(Sep.)。  new window
10.Dear, Micheal(1992)。Understanding and Overcoming the NIMBY Syndrome。Journal of the American Planning Association,58(3),288-300。  new window
11.Barthold, Jim(20000904)。Convergence Faces NIMBY。Cable World,2000(Sep.)。  new window
12.Bodensteiner, P.(2000)。Just ask。Builder,2000(Mar.),81-82。  new window
13.Chen, J-H.(1999)。NIMBY Syndrome, Expert Politics, and Deliberative Democracy。Soochow Journal of Political Science,10,97-132。  new window
14.Chiou, C-T.(2002)。From NIMBY to YIMBY: problems and solutions of environmental movement in Taiwan。Political Science Review,17,33-56。  new window
15.Chiou, C-T.、Chen, C-C.(2001)。The bottleneck and vision of communitarianism in Taiwan: from self-help action to selfrconscious community。Administrative and Policy Review,33,1-44。  new window
16.Chiou C-T.、Su Y-S.(1999)。Breaking through the dilemma among local politics, compensation syndrome and public policy in Taiwan: a case study in environmental facilities。Journal of Law and Commerce,35,147-185。  new window
17.Halstead, J. M.、Luloff, A. E.、Myers, S. D.(1993)。An examination of the NIMBY syndrome: why not in my backyard?。Journal of the Community Development Society,24,88-102。  new window
18.Lee, Y-T.(1997)。An Analysis of NIMBY Syndrome。Urban and Planning,24(1),69-79。  new window
19.Piat, M.(2000)。The NIMBY Phenomenon: Community Residents’ Concerns About Housing For Deinstitutionalized People。Health and Social Work,2000(May),127-138。  new window
20.Levinson, Arik(1999)。NIMBY Taxes Matter: The Case of State Hazardous Waste Disposal Taxes。Journal of Public Economics,74,31-51。  new window
21.Takahashi, Lois M.、Dear, Michael J.(1997)。The Changing Dynamics of Community Opposition to Human Service Facilities。Journal of the American Planning Association,63(1),79-93。  new window
圖書
1.McAvoy, G. E.(1999)。Controlling Technology: Citizen Rationality and the NIMBY Syndrome。Washington, DC:Georgetown University Press。  new window
2.Inhaber, Herbert(1998)。Slaying the NIMBY Dragon。New Brunswick, New Jersey:Transaction Publishers。  new window
3.Lesbirel, Hayden(2000)。NIMBY Politics in Japan。Ithaca, NY:Cornell University Press。  new window
4.O'Hare, M. Bacow、Sanderson, D.(1988)。Facility Siting And Public Opposition。New York:Nostrand Reinhold Company。  new window
5.Hall, R.(1980)。Great Planning Disasters。Berkeley, CA:University of California Press。  new window
6.Bryant, B. I.、Mohai, P.(1992)。Race and The Incidence of Environmental Hazards: A Time for Discourse。Boulder, CO。  new window
7.Rabe, Barry George(1994)。Beyond Nimby: Hazardous Waste Siting in Canada and the United States。Washington, DC:Brookings Institution。  new window
8.Putnam, Robert D.、Leonardi, Robert、Nanetti, Raffaella Y.(1993)。Making Democracy Work: Civic Traditions in Modern Italy。Princeton University Press。  new window
9.Putnam, Robert D.(2000)。Bowling Alone: The Collapse and Revival of American Community。Simon & Schuster。  new window
其他
1.Environmental Protection Agency, Executive Yuan(2003)。National Environmental Protection Program,http://www.epa.gov.tw/policy/nationproj/7-17.doc.。  new window
2.Kotsopoulos, Nick(20000616)。Group Seeks Scaled-Back DPW Garage。  new window
圖書論文
1.Mazmanian, Daniel A.、Morell, David(1994)。The NIMBY Syndrome: Facility Siting and the Failure of Democratic Discourse。Environmental Policy in The 1990s: Toward a New Agenda。Washington, DC:CQ Press。  new window
2.Stallen, Pieter Jan M.(1991)。Developing Communications About Risks of Major Industrial Accidents in the Netherlands。Communicating Risks to the Public。Dordrecht。  new window
3.Paehlke, Robert、Torgerson, Douglas(1990)。Toxic Waste and the Administrative State: NIMBY Syndrome or Participatory Management。Managing Leviathan。London:Belhaven Press。  new window
 
 
 
 
第一頁 上一頁 下一頁 最後一頁 top
QR Code
QRCODE