:::

詳目顯示

回上一頁
題名:道德經濟在消費社會中還有機會嗎?一個實質與形式分析雙軌並進的理論重構
書刊名:臺灣社會學刊
作者:鄭陸霖 引用關係
作者(外文):Cheng, Lu-lin
出版日期:2014
卷期:54
頁次:頁181-232
主題關鍵詞:經濟社會學道德經濟社群倫理經濟衝突倫理消費ConsumptionMoral economyEthicsEconomic conflict
原始連結:連回原系統網址new window
相關次數:
  • 被引用次數被引用次數:期刊(0) 博士論文(0) 專書(0) 專書論文(0)
  • 排除自我引用排除自我引用:0
  • 共同引用共同引用:0
  • 點閱點閱:73
在Polanyi批判的鑲嵌視野下,道德經濟一直是與主流經濟學相抗詰的重要研究傳統。本文認為它最有力的貢獻在於,提供市場經濟的核心衝突一個以倫理認知轉換為中介的因果解釋;具體而言,揭櫫常民如何在經濟衝突中看穿「自律市場」的不義,繼而發出以社群倫理為本的抗爭。然而就在大量的消費衝突展示了(即便在高度個體化的消費社會中),倫理感知作為抗爭動力的持續存在,道德經濟因自縛於「實質vs.形式」爭議中的實質論立場,卻逐漸失去與此當代經濟核心衝突的關連性。另一面,主流經濟學的霸權卻已跨過形式分析,藉著以對價的交易理性為本的實質倫理框架來掩蓋、模糊、甚至扭曲消費者的社群倫理訴求。對此,本文提出一個符合道德經濟初衷與優勢的理論重構提案:(1)在後設的道德視域中擺置道德人的理論先設;(2)確認「交易理性」作為一規範聲稱的實質認知架構;(3)發展足以與「交易理性」並置觀察兩者間折衝動態的「社群倫理」形式表述。我們藉著重訪Scott道德經濟經典著作,展示實質與形式分析雙軌並進如何早是道德分析的優良傳統。此提案將使得道德經濟在「消費如何由不滿轉轍至抗爭」的關鍵課題上發揮其聚焦倫理認知轉換的分析優勢,並藉著填補Miller的日常化商品消費與Barnett的政治化倫理消費間的消費研究文獻缺口,重新介入此當代經濟衝突的核心。本文最後延伸演繹此重構提案,透過連結商品在質價分布平面上的位置與市場競爭的不同效應,展示其與主流經濟學的新衝突觀點間針鋒相對的抗詰潛力。「倫理在消費社會中還有機會嗎?」Bauman對此自問的悲觀回答固然充滿理論魅力,卻無法準確回應消費不滿與抗爭風起雲湧的現實。如果道德經濟繼續堅持「去鑲嵌的個體化市場中沒有倫理感知的存在空間」,那它確實將失去參與當代關鍵戰役的機會。本文希望證明,慶幸的是,道德經濟可以不必付出那樣的代價。
Though theoretically charming, Bauman's pessimistic answer to the question, "Does ethics have a chance in a world of consumers?" fails to explain widespread global conflicts that are triggered by ethical concerns of consumers. Instead, Miller and Barnett's empirical researches, both based on the assumption that economic actors are consistently moral beyond specific contexts, support a better grasp of these phenomena. However, the luminal status between Miller's "ordinary consumption" and Barnett's "politicized consumption" remains under-explained, which unfortunately weakens an alternative vision of moral consumption against the neo-liberal establishment. In this paper we argue that here is exactly where moral economy could play a critical role in contemporary debates. However, to build on this potential, the standard moral economy framework requires three theoretical adjustments. This theoretical reconfiguration will also help to embed moral economy in an updated family of literature that improves its inner consistency and external validity. We end the article by demonstrating how a deductive extension of this updated framework supports moral economy to re-engage in controversies involving contemporary consumer conflicts.
期刊論文
1.MacKenzie, Donald(2004)。The Big, Bad Wolf and the Rational Market: Portfolio Insurance, the 1987 Crash and the Performativity of Economics。Economy and Society,33(3),303-334。  new window
2.黃應貴(19730300)。Tiv與Siane經濟--經濟人類學的實質論派與形式論派之比較。中央研究院民族學研究所集刊,35,145-162。  延伸查詢new window
3.鄭陸霖(2000)。是誰惹毛了沈睡的貓?台灣有線電視市場場域中的權力競爭。台灣產業研究,3,221-256。  延伸查詢new window
4.Arnsperge, Christian、Yanis Varoufakis(2006)。What is Neoclassical Economics? The Three Axioms Responsible for Its Theoretical Oeuvre, Practical Irrelevance and, Thus, Discursive Power。Panoeconomicus,53,5-18。  new window
5.Arnol, Thomas C.(2001)。Rethinking Moral Economy。American Political Science Review,95(1),85-95。  new window
6.Barnett, Clive、Paul Cloke、Nick Clarke、Alice Malpass(2005)。Consuming Ethics: Articulating the Subjects and Spaces of Ethical Consumption。Antipode,37(1),23-45。  new window
7.Caldwell, Bruce J.(1980)。A Critique of Friedman’s Methodological Instrumentalism。Southern Economic Journal,47,366-374。  new window
8.Cheng, Lu(1990)。Strategy and Structure of Market Competition: Taiwanese Cable TV, Industry in the 1990s。Developing Economies,3,252-283。  new window
9.Cook, Scott(1966)。The Obsolete ‘Anti-Market’ Mentality: A Critique of Substantive Approach to Economic Anthropology。American Anthropologist,68,1494-1498。  new window
10.Fehr, Ernst、George Kirchsteiger、Arno Riedl(1993)。Does Fairness Prevent Market Clearing? An Experimental Investigation。The Quarterly Journal of Economics,108(2),437-459。  new window
11.Kaplan, David(1968)。The Formal-Substantive Controversy in Economic Anthropology: Reflections on Its Wider Implications。Southwestern Journal of Anthropology,24(3),228-251。  new window
12.McCloskey, Deirdre N.(1985)。The Loss Function Has Been Mislaid: The Rhetoric of Significance Tests。American Economic Review,75(2),201-205。  new window
13.Miller, Daniel(2001)。The Poverty of Morality。Journal of Consumer Culture,2,225-243。  new window
14.Sayer, Andrew(2000)。Moral Economy and Political Economy。Studies in Political Economy,61,79-104。  new window
15.Kahneman, D.、Knetsch, J. L.、Thaler, H. R.(1986)。Fairness as a constraint on profit seeking: Entitlement in the market。American Economic Review,76(4),728-741。  new window
16.Fligstein, Neil(1996)。Markets as Politics: A Political-Cultural Approach to Market Institutions。American Sociological Review,61(4),656-673。  new window
17.Tversky, Amos、Kahneman, Daniel(1986)。Rational choice and the framing of decisions。The Journal of Business,59(4 Part 2),S251-S278。  new window
18.Thaler, Richard H.(1980)。Toward a positive theory of consumer choice。Journal of Economic behavior and Organization,1(1),39-60。  new window
19.Kahneman, Daniel、Knetsch, Jack L.、Thaler, Richard H.(1986)。Fairness and the assumptions of economics。The Journal of Business,59(4),285-300。  new window
20.Frankfurt, Harry G.(1971)。Freedom of the Will and the Concept of a Person。The Journal of Philosophy,68(1),5-20。  new window
21.Granovetter, Mark S.(1985)。Economic Action and Social Structure: The Problem of Embeddedness。American Journal of Sociology,91(3),481-510。  new window
22.Booth, W. J.(1994)。On the Idea of the moral economy。American Political Science Review,88(3),653-667。  new window
23.Sayer, Andrew(2003)。(De)commodification, Consumer Culture, and Moral Economy。Environment and Planning D: Society and Space,21(3),341-357。  new window
研究報告
1.Callon, Michel(2006)。What Does It Mean to Say that Economics is Performative?。  new window
學位論文
1.鄭禮忠(2000)。「唯經濟論謬誤」扭曲下的收視戶抗爭:1999年台北市有線電視費率爭議的道德經濟分析(碩士論文)。國立清華大學。  延伸查詢new window
圖書
1.Fligstein, N.(2001)。The architecture of markets: An Economic Sociology of Capitalist Societies。Princeton, NJ:Princeton University Press。  new window
2.Zelizer, Viviana A.(2010)。Economic Lives: How Culture Shapes the Economy。Princeton:Princeton University Press。  new window
3.金子勝(1999)。市場(思考のフロンティア)。東京:岩波書店。  延伸查詢new window
4.Barnett, Clive、Paul Cloke、Nick Clarke、Alice Malpass(2010)。Globalizing Responsibility: The Political Rationalities of Ethical Consumption。NJ:Wiley-Blackwell。  new window
5.Block, Fred L.(1996)。The Vampire State: And Other Myths and Fallacies About the U.S。Economy. NY:The New Press。  new window
6.Hirshleifer, Jack(2001)。Dark Side of the Force。Cambridge:Cambridge University Press。  new window
7.McCloskey, Deirdre N.(2002)。The Secret Sins of Economics。Cambridge:Prickly Paradigm Press。  new window
8.McCloskey, Deirdre N.(2006)。The Bourgeois Virtues: Ethics for An Age of Commerce。Chicago:University Of Chicago Press。  new window
9.McCloskey, Deirdre N.(2010)。Bourgeois Dignity: Why Economics Can’t Explain the Modern World。Chicago:University Of Chicago Press。  new window
10.Reddy, William(1987)。The Rise of Market Culture: The Textile Trade and French Society, 1750-1900。Cambridge:Cambridge University Press。  new window
11.Sassatelli, Roberta(2007)。Consumer Culture: History, Theory and Politics。California:Sage Publications L。  new window
12.Smith, Adam(2009)。An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations。Lawrence, Kansas:Digireads.com Publishing。  new window
13.Wright, Anthony(1987)。R. H. Tawney。Manchester:Manchester University Press。  new window
14.Burt, Ronald S.(2010)。Networks: Competitive Advantage Local and Personal。Oxford:Oxford University Press。  new window
15.Hirschman, A. O.(1982)。Shifting Involvements: Private Interest and Public Action。Oxford:Basil Blackwell。  new window
16.Marcuse, H.(1966)。One dimensional man。Boston:Beacon Press。  new window
17.Marx, Karl、Moore, Samuel、Aveling, Edward(1906)。Capital: a critique of political economy。New York。  new window
18.Sen, Amartya K.(1987)。On ethics and economics。Blackwell Publishers。  new window
19.MacKenzie, Donald A.(2008)。An Engine, Not a Camera: How Financial Models Shape Markets。MIT Press。  new window
20.MacKenzie, Donald、Muniesa, Fabian、Siu, Lucia(2007)。Do economists make markets?: On the performativity of economics。Princeton University Press。  new window
21.Friedman, Milton、Friedman, Rose D.(1979)。Free to Choose: A Personal Statement。New York。  new window
22.Friedman, Milton(1953)。Essays in Positive Economics。Chicago, Illinois:University of Chicago Press。  new window
23.Callon, Michel(1998)。The Laws of the Markets。Blackwell。  new window
24.Mintz, Sidney Wilfred(1986)。Sweetness and Power: The Place of Sugar in Modern History。Penguin Books。  new window
25.Baudrillard, Jean(1998)。The Consumer Society--Myths & Structures。London:Sage Publications。  new window
26.Beck, Ulrich(1992)。Risk society: Toward a new modernity。London:Sage。  new window
27.Olson, Mancur(1965)。The Logic of Collective Action: Public Goods and the Theory of Groups。New York:Mcgraw-Hill College。  new window
28.Galbraith, John Kenneth(1967)。The New Industrial State。Houghton Mifflin Press。  new window
29.Sen, Amartya K.(1999)。Development as Freedom。New York:Random House。  new window
30.Polanyi, Karl、黃樹民、石佳音、廖立(1944)。The Great Transformation: the Political and Economic Origins of Our Time。Boston:Beacon Press。  new window
31.Giddens, Anthony(1991)。Modernity and Self-Identity: Self and Society in the Late Modern Age。Cambridge:Blackwell Publishers。  new window
32.Taylor, Charles(1991)。The Ethics of Authenticity。Cambridge , MA。  new window
33.Sen, Amartya K.(1985)。Commodities and Capabilities。Oxford:Oxford University Press:Elsevier Science。  new window
34.Rawls, John(1973)。A Theory of Justice。Oxford:Clarendon Press:Oxford University Press。  new window
35.Block, F.(1990)。Postindustrial Possibilities: A Critique of Economic Discourse。Berkeley:Los Angeles:University of California Press。  new window
36.Hirschman, Albert O.(1970)。Exit, Voice, and Loyalty: Responses to Decline in Firms, Organizations, and States。Harvard University Press。  new window
37.Scott, James C.、程立顯、劉建(2001)。農民的道義經濟學:東南亞的反叛與生存。譯林出版社。  延伸查詢new window
38.Taylor, Charles(2004)。Modern Social Imaginaries。Duke University Press。  new window
39.Bourdieu, Pierre、Wacquant, Loïc J. D.(1992)。An invitation to reflexive sociology。Polity Press。  new window
40.Bauman, Zygmunt(2000)。Liquid Modernity。Polity Press:Blackwell。  new window
41.Veblen, T.(1970)。The Theory of the Leisure Class: An Economic Study of Institutions。London:Unwin Books。  new window
42.Bauman, Z.(2008)。Does ethics have a chance in a world of consumers。Cambridge:Polity Press。  new window
其他
1.ETtoday(2013)。統一總經理羅智先:消費者只想買便宜貨 食安難進步,http://www.ettoday.net/news/20130626/230676.htm, 20131224。  延伸查詢new window
2.Upaper(20110524)。多家運動飲料塑化劑污染。  延伸查詢new window
3.Upaper(2013117)。大統特級橄欖油 染色低價油混充。  延伸查詢new window
4.聯合報(20120816)。牲畜奶粉製黑心飲品10噸流市面。  延伸查詢new window
5.聯合晚報(20130514)。毒澱粉攻腎 毒粄條吃一碗就過量。  延伸查詢new window
6.聯合晚報(20130823)。衛生局證實:胖達人用人工香精。  延伸查詢new window
7.聯合晚報(20130827)。山水米爆摻劣米 苗檢查詐欺。  延伸查詢new window
圖書論文
1.Carrier, James G.(2009)。Simplicity in Economic Anthropology: Persuasion, Form, and Substance。Economic Persuasions: Studies in Rhetoric + Culture。NY:Berghahn Books。  new window
2.Cochoy, Franck(2007)。A Sociology of Market Thing: on Tending the Garden of Choices in Mass Retailing。Market Device。Oxford:Blackwell。  new window
3.Frankfurt, Harry(1986)。Freedom of the Will and the Concept of A Person。Moral Responsibility. Ithaca: Cornell University Press。  new window
4.Gudeman, Stephen。Introduction。Economic Persuasion: Studies in Rhetoric + Culture。NY:Berghahn Books。  new window
5.Polanyi, Karl(1957)。Aristotle Discovers the Economy。Trade and Market in the Early Empires: Economies in History。Free Press。  new window
6.Thompson, Edward P.(1993)。The Moral Economy of the English Crowd in the Eighteenth Century。Customs in Common: Studies in Traditional Popular Culture。NY:The New Press。  new window
7.Adorno, T. W.(1991)。Culture industry reconsidered。The culture industry: selected essays on mass culture。Routledge。  new window
8.Garfinkel, Michelle R.、Skaperdas, Stergios(2007)。Economics of Conflict:An Overview。Handbook of Defense Economics:Defense in A Globalized World。NY:Elsevier。  new window
 
 
 
 
第一頁 上一頁 下一頁 最後一頁 top