:::

詳目顯示

回上一頁
題名:National Consciousness and the Evolution of the Civil/Martial Binary in East Asia
書刊名:臺灣東亞文明研究學刊
作者:Benesch, Oleg
出版日期:2011
卷期:8:1=15
頁次:頁129-171
主題關鍵詞:文武武士道日本中國朝鮮民族主義梁啟超朴殷植Bun-buWen-wuBushidoMartial and civilJapanChinaKoreaNationalismLiang QichaoPak Un-sik
原始連結:連回原系統網址new window
相關次數:
  • 被引用次數被引用次數:期刊(0) 博士論文(0) 專書(0) 專書論文(0)
  • 排除自我引用排除自我引用:0
  • 共同引用共同引用:0
  • 點閱點閱:67
文、武二分法是東亞思想中最古老且最為普遍的概念之一。本文檢視中國文武思想傳至日本,及其在該國的後續獨立發展。「文」在中國和韓國傳統上位於「武」之上,居首位,而日本因發展出以武士為中心的獨特社會與政治結構,使其思想家特別強調「武」。因此,至少在文、武的脈絡下,許多日本人願意接受,而非轉化,標誌著大陸解釋的華夷之辨。相較而言,許多日本儒家及相關學派的思想卻傾向於將自中國傳入的思想以將其與源頭分離,並將道德中心重置於日本的方式,加以修訂。日本等同「武國」,中國和韓國等同「文國」為三個社會的知識分子廣泛接受。與此同時,各思想家對於日本「武」的真正內涵卻有極為不同的見解,其間的歧異往往到對該概念的定義可以完全相反的程度。本文主張,便是這種對文武二分法的含糊不清與彈性,確保其在適應新形勢時能持續突顯,並進而導致中國和韓國思想家於二十世紀初將日本的「武」介紹給其祖國的運動。在此過程中,日本的文武理論與王陽明的學說、武士道的現代武術倫理有各種不同程度的結合。本文分別討論改革家梁啟超和朴殷植於文武思想在中國與韓國傳布上的角色。
The binary of martial and civil virtues (wen-wu) is one of the oldest and most pervasive concepts in East Asian thought. This paper examines the transmission of Chinese wen-wu thought to Japan, and its subsequent independent development in that country. Whereas in China and Korea, primacy has traditionally been given to civil virtues over martial ones, the unique warrior-centered social and governmental structure that developed in Japan led its thinkers to more strongly emphasize the martial. As a result, at least in the context of wen-wu, many Japanese were willing to accept, rather than invert, the China/barbarian binary that marked continental interpretations. In comparison, many Japanese Confucians and related schools of thought had otherwise tended to revise ideas imported from China in ways that removed them from their source and relocated the moral center to Japan. The identification of Japan as the "martial country" and China/Korea as the "civil countries" came to be broadly accepted by intellectuals in all three societies. At the same time, the exact nature of Japanese "martiality" varied greatly among different thinkers, often to the extent that definitions of the concept could be polar opposites. This paper argues that it was this vagueness and flexibility of the wen-wu binary that ensured its continued prominence as the concepts were adapted to new situations, and further led to movements by Chinese and Korean thinkers to introduce Japanese martiality into their own nations around the turn of the twentieth century. In this process, Japanese bun-bu (wen-wu) theories were variously packaged with the teachings of Wang Yangming and the modern martial ethic of bushido (the way of the warrior), and this paper considers the roles of the reformers Liang Qichao and Pak Un-sik in the dissemination of bun-bu thought in China and Korea, respectively.
期刊論文
1.Palais, James B.(1984)。Confucianism and the Aristocratic/Bureaucratic Balance in Korea。Harvard Journal of Asiatic Studies,44(2),427-468。  new window
2.Scalapino, Robert A.、Schiffrin, Harold(1959)。Early Socialist Currents in the Chinese Revolutionary Movement: Sun Yat-sen versus Liang Ch'i-ch'ao。Journal of Asian Studies,18(3),321-342。  new window
3.Gregor, A. James、Chang, Maria Hsia(1980)。Wang Yang-ming and the Ideology of Sun Yat-sen。The Review of Politics,42(3),388-404。  new window
4.Izawa, Nagahide(1942)。Bushi kun (A Guide for Warriors)。Bushido zensho,vol. 4。  new window
5.Shibata, Mikio(1997)。Ko Yui no Nihon ninshiki: Nihon hen sei ko wo chushin ni shite。Ryukoku shitan,108。  new window
6.Tokugawa, Nariaki(1942)。Kokushi hen (Pronouncement of Ambition(Pronouncement of Ambition, 告志篇)。Bushido zensho,vol. 7。  new window
7.Tomobayashi, Mitsuhira(1942)。Omoide gusa (Reminiscences, おもひ出草)。Bushido zensho,vol. 7。  new window
8.Shiraki, Yutaka(1962)。Bunbu kakusho。Jissen joshi daigaku kiyo,vol. 7。  new window
9.Allen, Chizuko(1990)。Northeast Asia Centered Around Korea: Ch'oe Namson's View of History。The Journal of Asian Studies,vol. 49,no.4。  new window
10.Benesch, Oleg(2009)。Wang Yangming and Bushido。Japanese Nativization and its Influences in Modern China,vol.36,no. 3。  new window
11.Gillin, Donald G.(1970)。Problems of Centralization in Republican China: The Case of Ch'en Ch'eng and the Kuomintang。The Journal of Asian Studies,vol.29,no.4。  new window
12.Peng, Guoxiang(2003)。Contemporary Chinese Studies of Wang Yangming 王陽明 and His Followers in Mainland China。Dao: A Journal of Comparative Philosophy,vol. 1, no. 2。  new window
13.Gillin, Donald G.(1960)。Portrait of a Warlord: Yen Hsi-shan in Shansi Province, 1911-1930。The Journal of Asian Studies,vol. 19,no. 3。  new window
14.Tsu, Jing(2006)。Extinction and Adventures on the Chinese Diasporic Frontier。Journal of Chinese Overseas,2,2。  new window
15.Gregor, James(1981)。Confucianism and the Political Thought of Sun Yat-sen。Philosophy East and West,vol.31,no.1。  new window
圖書
1.Bol, Peter K.(1997)。Examinations and Orthodoxies: 1070 and 1313 Compared。Culture & State in Chinese History: Conventions, Accommodations, and Critiques。Stanford:Stanford University Press。  new window
2.Crossley, Pamela Kyle(1999)。A Translucent Mirror: History and Identity in Qing Imperial Ideology。University of California Press。  new window
3.Reinhold, C. I.(2001)。Studying the Enemy: Japan Hands in Republican China and Their Quest for National Identity。London:Routledge。  new window
4.Reynolds, Douglas R.(1993)。China, 1898-1912: the Xinzheng Revolution and Japan。Cambridge, Mass.:Council on East Asian Studies, Harvard University。  new window
5.Wakabayashi, Bob Tadashi(1986)。Anti-foreignism and western learning in early modern Japan: The new theses of 1825。Cambridge:Harvard University Council on East Asian Studies。  new window
6.Bol, Peter K.(1992)。"This culture of ours": intellectual transitions in T'ang and Sung China。Stanford, California:Stanford University Press。  new window
7.Matsumoto, Aiju(1905)。Bushido。Bushido soron。Tokyo。  new window
8.Daidoji, Yuzan(1942)。Budo shoshinshu (A Primer on the Martial Way)。Bushido zensho。Tokyo。  new window
9.Han, Chun-sok(1989)。Bun no bunka to bu no bunka: tonari no kuni no do to i。Tokyo。  new window
10.Inoue, Tetsujiro(1901)。Bushido。Tokyo。  new window
11.Kang, Duksang(1972)。Kaisetsu。Chosen dokuritsu undo no kesshi。Tokyo。  new window
12.Kanno, Kakumyo(2004)。Bushido no gyakushu。Tokyo。  new window
13.Todo, Akiyasu(1977)。Bu. no kanji . bun. no kanji: sono kigen kara shiso he。Tokyo。  new window
14.Wang, Wan(2004)。Jindai Zhongguoren dui 'wen-wu heyi' jiaoyu de renshi guocheng。Kyoritsu joshi daigaku sogo gunka kenkyujo kiyo。Tokyo。  new window
15.Watanabe, Manabu(1968)。Chosen kindai shi。Tokyo。  new window
16.Wu, Anlong、Xiaong, Dayun(1989)。Chugokujin no nihon kenkyu shi (A History of Chinese Japan Studies。Tokyo。  new window
17.Yamaga, Soko(1970)。Yamaga Soko。Nihon shiso taikei。Tokyo。  new window
18.Yang, Hyunhea(1996)。Yun Chiho to Kimu Kyoshin sono shinnichi to konichi no ronri。Tokyo。  new window
19.Pak, On-sik(1975)。Pak On-sik chonso。Seoul。  new window
20.Chandra, Vipan(1988)。Imperialism, Resistance, and Reform in Late Nineteenth-Century Korea: Enlightenment and the Independence Club。Berkeley。  new window
21.Harrell, Paula(1992)。Sowing the Seeds of Change: Chinese Students, Japanese Teachers 1895-1905。Stanford:Stanford University Press。  new window
22.Hwang, In K.(1978)。The Korean Reform Movement of the 1880s: A Study of Transition in Intra-Asian Relations。Cambridge, MA。  new window
23.Saito, Setsudo(1942)。Shido yoron (Essential Theories of the Way of the Samurai)。Bushido zensho。Tokyo。  new window
24.Keene, Donald(2003)。Yoshimasa and the Silver Pavillion: The Creation of the Soul of Japan。New York。  new window
25.Keum, Jang-tae(2000)。Confucianism and Korean Thoughts, in Korean Studies Series。Seoul。  new window
26.Banzan, Kumazawa(1942)。Shugi washo (shoroku) (Japanese Writings on Gathered Virtues )。Bushido zensho。Tokyo。  new window
27.Nakamura, Mototsune(1942)。Shobu ron (Theories of Valuing Martiality, 尚武論)。Bushido zensho。Tokyo。  new window
28.Nakae, T oju(1942)。Bunbu mondo (Dialogues on Bunbu)。Bushido zensho。Tokyo。  new window
29.Yokoi, Shonan(1971)。Kokuze sanron. Watanabe Kazan, Takano Choei, Sakuma Shozan, Yokoi Shonan, Hashimoto Sanai。Nihon shiso taikei。Tokyo。  new window
30.Chung, Chai-sik(1997)。T he Case of Neo-Confucian Yangban Intellectuals。New Directions in the Study of Meiji Japan。Leiden。  new window
31.Duncan, John B.(2006)。The Confucian Context of Reform。Reform and Modernity in the Taehan Empire。Seoul。  new window
32.Hurst, G. Cameron III(1997)。The Warrior as Ideal for a New Age。The Origins of Japan's Medieval World。Stanford。  new window
33.Kim, Dong-no(2006)。Views of Modern Reforms as Depicted in the Hwangsong sinmun during the Taehan Empire。Reform and Modernity in the Taehan Empire。Seoul。  new window
34.Minamoto, Ryoen(2000)。Yokoi Shonan ni okeru joi ron kara kaikoku ron he no tenkai。Ajia bunka kenkyu。Kokusai Kirisutokyo。  new window
其他
1.Liang, Qichao(1904)。Zhongguo zhi wushi dao,Shanghai。  new window
 
 
 
 
第一頁 上一頁 下一頁 最後一頁 top
:::
無相關著作
 
無相關點閱
 
QR Code
QRCODE