:::

詳目顯示

回上一頁
題名:認知腳本失驗歸因過程:對等推論之干擾效果
書刊名:管理學報
作者:凌儀玲 引用關係周逸衡楊俊明 引用關係
作者(外文):Ling, I-lingJou, Jacob Y. H.Yang, Chun Ming
出版日期:2007
卷期:24:3
頁次:頁277-288
主題關鍵詞:失驗認知腳本歸因對等推論DisconfirmationCognitive scriptAttributionCorrespondent inference
原始連結:連回原系統網址new window
相關次數:
  • 被引用次數被引用次數:期刊(1) 博士論文(1) 專書(0) 專書論文(0)
  • 排除自我引用排除自我引用:1
  • 共同引用共同引用:8
  • 點閱點閱:39
本研究檢測認知腳本失驗與對等推論對消費者反應之影響。研究-以腳本分析法瞭解受試者對熟悉之消費情境是否存有認知腳本,研究二透過實驗設計操弄認知腳本失驗與對等推論,藉以分析受試者情感與行為意圖反應程度。研究結果顯示,對於熟悉之消費情境確實可引出消費者之核心腳本,而操弄不同腳本對受試者情感與行為意圖反應發現,正向失驗帶來較高評價,負向失驗反應出較負面評價,結論符合傳統失驗理論。對等推論則在歸因過程中形成干擾效果,並對正負向失驗腳本產生擴大作用,形成「高者愈高、低者愈低」效果,但對標準腳本情境則不會產生干擾作用。
This article applies the underlying reason behind disconfirmation model and correspondent inference theory. The reason was supported by Binter, Booms, and Tetreault' (1990) result. Disconfirmation leads to attribution, which leads to judgment of satisfaction. The authors propose those consumers' feelings and judgments in case of disconfirmed expectations will be different, and conjecture there is an interactive effect between the cognitive script of disconfirmation and correspondent inference. The attribution effect of correspondent inference may impose a significant moderating effect on consumer responses. After reviewing related literature, the authors advocate that the script-theoretic approach provides an opportunity to clarify the expectation components of consumer behavior models. Two studies examine whether the consumer responses depend in part on the cognitive script of disconfirmation and correspondent inference. Study 1 elicits consumers' general script of a familiar professional service. Study 2 shows that the cognitive script of disconfirmation and correspondent inference has an interactive effect on participant's responses. Script theory is more applicable to industries with high interpersonal contact (Anderson, 1983), so the authors chose hairstyling as the context in this study because of its high familiarity and consumption frequencies. In Study 1, one hundred twenty-six samples from several hair salons participated in this study. Their average age was 31.23 years (SD=7.6). Participants who were asked about a social interaction phenomenon they had experienced at a hair salon. Participants wrote down all the events involved in the service encounter in sequential order. According to script analysis (Bower et al., 1979), it takes three steps to obtain a standardized script (i.e., neutral script). The result of elicitation of a hairstyling script shows that totally fifty-three actions were mentioned by participants. Second, the authors retained sixteen actions, those with a mention frequency of 40% or above, to comprise the core script. Third, by using paired-comparisons, the authors constructed a general hairstyling script (i.e., neutral script). The purpose of Study 2 was to investigate the strength of the moderating effect of correspondent inference on the relationship between cognitive script of disconfirmation and consumer’s responses. In order to obtain a better understanding about the disconfirmation script occurring during the consumption process and their outcomes, the authors executed a pilot study with the critical incident technique (CIT). The authors collected one hundred thirty-one satisfactory and one hundred nine dissatisfactory incidents. The authors used these incidents to explore the most realistic positive/negative disconfirmation situations for further experiment. The positive script was named ”warm treatment script” and the negative script was labeled as ”blame-sidestepping script”. They will be used as the treatments for the experiment of Study 2. Study 2 manipulated the disconfirmation script and correspondent inference to display variety and demonstrates the interaction effect on the consumer's judgment. A total of one hundred sixty-eight undergraduate students participated in the experiment for course credit and were assigned randomly to one of the three between-subjects cells. Each respondent filled out one kind of situational script questionnaire. A 3 X 2 (script(S): positive/neutral/negative X correspond inference score (CI): high /low) mixed design was employed in this experiment. The first factor was manipulated as a between-subject factor. The neutral script derived from Study 1. The positive and negative scripts differing on expectation were chosen on the result of the pilot study (described earlier). Correspondent inference was manipulated by within-subjects. The median split (M(subscript median)= 35) of CI divided the respondents into two levels for low and high. Two manipulation checks were handled. The first was for script manipulation. Its purpose was to find out whether the participants all activated from the same controlled cognitive script (i.e. core script) prior to the experiment. Manipulation was implemented by adding several irrelevant actions (Smith and Houston 1985) to the core scripts from Study 1. No significant difference was shown in script scores among the participants. In other words, the three groups (positive/neutral/negative) of participants all activated from the same core script. The second manipulation was to check the level of the perceived upper or low disconfirmation expectations. The participants were asked to anchor the matching level using a five-point Likert scale. As expected, negative script was perceived to be more unexpected than neutral script and positive script. The two studies expounded in this article converge on several conclusions. First, the results clearly indicate the consumer expectation can be elicited through cognitive script because we found that the general public has a cognitive script for the specific service(e.g. hairstyling) s/he is familiar with. Second, disconfirmation is a robust phenomenon, as it can be conducted by cognitive script analysis. Higher positive responses come from positive disconfirmation script; in contrast, negative script leads to more negative responses. Finally, attributing effect of correspondent inference may moderate disconfirmation cognitive script on the participant's perception and behavioral intention. The augmenting effect is strongly proved. Given a positive disconfirmation script, respondents with higher correspondent inference feel even more satisfied than in neutral circumstances; in the same vein, given a negative unexpected script, their dissatisfaction exceeds that felt by those with low correspondent inference. Moreover, correspondent inference only has the moderating effect in case of disconfirmation cognitive script. It has no bearing in neutral circumstances.
期刊論文
1.Shostack, G. Lynn(1987)。Service Positioning through Structural Change。Journal of Marketing,51,34-43。  new window
2.凌儀玲(20050800)。服務補救二次滿意之研究。管理學報,22(4),449-465。new window  延伸查詢new window
3.Smith, Ruth Ann、Houston, Michael J.(1985)。A Psychometric Assessment of Measures of Scripts in Consumer Memory。Journal of Consumer Research,12(2),214-224。  new window
4.Alford, B. L.(1998)。Using cognitive scripts to assess the process of professional service delivery。Journal of Professional Service Marketing,17(1),77-102。  new window
5.Bower, Gordon H.、Black, John B.、Turner, Terrence J.(1979)。Scripts in memory for text。Cognitive Psychology,11(2),177-220。  new window
6.Abelson, Robert P.(1981)。Psychological Status of the Script Concept。American Psychologist,36(7),715-729。  new window
7.Bitner, Mary Jo、Booms, Bernard H.、Tetreault, Mary Stanfield(1990)。The Service Encounter: Diagnosing Favorable & Unfavorable Incidents。Journal of Marketing,54(1),71-84。  new window
8.Flanagan, John C.(1954)。The Critical Incident Technique。Psychological Bulletin,51(4),327-358。  new window
9.Carman, James M.(1990)。Consumer Perceptions of Service Quality: An Assessment of the SERVQUAL Dimensions。Journal of Retailing,66(1),33-55。  new window
10.Shoemaker, Stowe(1996)。Scripts: Precursor of consumer expectations。Cornell Hotel and Restaurant Administration Quarterly,37(1),42-53。  new window
11.Zeithaml, Valarie A.、Berry, Leonard L.、Parasuraman, Ananthanarayanan Parsu(1996)。The behavioral consequences of service quality。Journal of Marketing,60(2),31-46。  new window
12.Spreng, Richard A.、Mackenzie, Scott B.、Olshavsky, Richard W.(1996)。A Reexamination of the Determinants of Consumer Satisfaction。Journal of Marketing,60(3),15-32。  new window
13.Grönroos, Christian A.(1984)。A Service Quality Model and its Marketing Implications。European Journal of Marketing,18(4),36-44。  new window
14.Oliver, Richard L.、DeSarbo, Wayne S.(1988)。Response Determinants in Satisfaction Judgments。Journal of Consumer Research,14(4),495-507。  new window
15.Price, L. L.、Arnould, E. J.、Tierney, P.(1995)。Going to extremes: managing service encounters and assessing provider performance。Journal of Marketing,59(2),83-97。  new window
16.Oliver, Richard L.(1980)。A Cognitive Model of the Antecedents and Consequences of Satisfaction Decisions。Journal of Marketing Research,17(4),460-469。  new window
17.Leigh, Thomas W.、Rethans, Arno J.(1984)。A Script-theoretic Analysis of Industrial Purchasing Behavior。Journal of Marketing,48(4),22-32。  new window
18.Abbot, Valeria、Black, John B.、Smith, Edward E.(1985)。The Representation of Scripts in Memory。Journal of Memory and Language,24(2),179-199。  new window
19.Bozinoff, Lorne(1982)。A Script Theoretic Approach to Information Processing: An Energy Conservation Example。Advances in Consumer Research,9,481-486。  new window
20.Swanson, Scott R.、Kelley, Scott W.(2001)。Attributions and Outcomes of the Service Recovery Process。Journal of Marketing Theory and Practice,35(2),194-211。  new window
21.MacStravic, Robin S.(1985)。Cognitive Commitments in Health Services Marketing。Health Care Marketing Review,10(3),11-18。  new window
22.Chaikin, Alan L.、Cooper, Joel(1973)。Evaluation as a Function of Correspondent and Hedonic Relevance。Journal of Experimental Social Psychology,9,257-264。  new window
23.Leigh, Thomas W.、Rethans, Arno J.(1983)。Experiences with Script Elicitation within Consumer Decision Making Contexts。Advances in Consumer Research,10,667-672。  new window
24.Anderson, Craig A.(1983)。Imagination and Expectation: The Effect of Imagining Behavioral Scripts on Personal Intentions。Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,45(2),293-305。  new window
25.Coye, Ray W.(2004)。Managing Consumer Expectations in the Service Encounter。International Journal of Service Industry Management,15(1),54-71。  new window
26.Bozinoff, Lorne、Roth, Victor J.(1983)。Recognition Memory for Script Activities: An Energy Conservation Application。Advances in Consumer Research,10,655-660。  new window
27.Zeithaml, Valarie A.、Berry, Leonard L.、Parasuraman, A.(1993)。The Nature and Determinants of Consumer Expectations of Service。Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science,21(1),1-12。  new window
28.Hubbert, Amy R.、Sehorn, Annette G.、Brown, Stephen W.(1995)。Service Expectation: The Consumer versus the Provider。International Journal Industry Management,6(1),6-21。  new window
29.Kelly, Harold、Kelley, H.(1973)。The Processes of Causal Attribution。American Psychologist,28(2),107-128。  new window
30.Alford, Bruce L.、Sherrell, Daniel L.(1996)。The Role of Affect in Consumer Satisfaction Judgment of Credence-based Service。Journal of Business Research,37(1),71-84。  new window
會議論文
1.Mandler, George(1982)。The structure of value: Accounting for taste。The seventeenth Annual Carnegie Symposium on Cognition。Hillsdale, NJ:Erlbaum。3-36。  new window
2.John, George、Whitney, John C.(1982)。An Empirical Investigation of the Serial Structure of Scripts。Chicago, IL。75-79。  new window
學位論文
1.Alford, B. L.(1993)。A framework for assessing consumer satisfaction with credence-bases services: A cognitive script approach(博士論文)。The Louisiana State University,Baton Rouge。  new window
圖書
1.Schank, Roger C.、Abelson, Robert P.(1977)。Scripts, plans, goals and understanding。Hillsdale, NJ:Lawrence Erlbaum Associates。  new window
2.Heider, Fritz(1958)。The Psychology of Interpersonal Relations。John Wiley & Sons, Inc.。  new window
3.Abelson, Robert P.(1976)。Script Processing in Attitude Formation and Decision Making。Cognition and Social Behavior。Hillsdale, NJ。  new window
圖書論文
1.Jones, E. E.、McGills, D.(1976)。Correspondent Inferences and the Attribution Cube: A Comparative Appraisal。New Directions in Attribution research。New Hillsdale, NJ:Erlbaum。  new window
2.Jones, E. E.、Davis, K. E.(1965)。From Acts to Dispositions: The Attribution Process in Person Perception。Advances in Experimental Social Psychology。New York:Academic Press。  new window
 
 
 
 
第一頁 上一頁 下一頁 最後一頁 top
:::
無相關書籍
 
無相關著作
 
QR Code
QRCODE