:::

詳目顯示

回上一頁
題名:論信用狀的Negotiation
書刊名:臺北大學法學論叢
作者:康蕙芬
作者(外文):Kang, Hui-fen
出版日期:2007
卷期:64
頁次:頁25-84
主題關鍵詞:讓購可轉讓票據追索權善意執票人支付對價信用狀統一慣例美國統一商法第五篇NegotiationNegotiable instrumentsRecourseHolder in due courseGive valueUCPUCC 5
原始連結:連回原系統網址new window
相關次數:
  • 被引用次數被引用次數:期刊(0) 博士論文(0) 專書(0) 專書論文(0)
  • 排除自我引用排除自我引用:0
  • 共同引用共同引用:0
  • 點閱點閱:48
儘管貿易商或銀行對信用狀的Negotiation並不陌生,UCP的條文也 一再出現Negotiation一詞,但是對信用狀當事人而言,Negotiation的意義,或不夠明確,或難以理解,與之有關的爭議和糾紛時有所聞。尤其Negotiation的概念係源自於匯票的轉讓(Negotiation),故Negotiation L/C的種種問題往往與票據法的規定糾葛不清,造成更棘手的難題。本文首先釐清信用狀Negotiation與匯票Negotiation的差異,同時列舉各地銀行關於信用狀Negotiation的不同做法,以及各國法院對信用狀Negotiation的見解,接著探討Negotiating Bank可能面臨的風險、追索權的行使,以及 開狀銀行提出詐欺抗辯時,Negotiating Bank的權益維護等問題,最後以我國銀行界慣常辦理的「出口押匯」與Negotiation作比較,兼論出口押匯在實務上可能衍生的問題,並提出建議。
The term “Negotiation” under letters of credit is widely known in international trade and is defined and/or mentioned in various articles of the UCP. However, it often seems that bankers and other parties to letters of credit transactions do not understand the term well or consider it to be somewhat obscure, and therefore use it in the wrong sense. The concept of negotiation credit derives from the “Negotiable Instruments” under letters of credit. In many cases, it involves two branches of commercial law: the law of letters of credit and the law of negotiable instruments. Rules of these laws do not always accord with each other. The first part of this article differentiates the negotiation credit from negotiable instruments. The second part of this article examines the inconsistency of practices among negotiating banks. The third part of this article reviews different decisions in nearly same cases. The fourth part of this article gives an analysis on the risks and rights of recourse of negotiating banks, and the immunity of negotiating banks in letter of credit fraud cases. The fifth part of this article clarifies the relations among the issuing bank, the negotiating bank and the beneficiary. The sixth part of this article discusses some practical issues about negotiation credit in Taiwan. Finally, this article ends up in some suggestions.
期刊論文
1.Kozolchyk, Boris(1998)。The UNIDROIT Principles as a Model for the Unification of the Best Contractual Practices in the Americas。AM. J. COMP. L.,46(1),151。  new window
2.Ford, Mark(2005)。What Traders Expect from the New UCP。Documentary Credit Insight,11(1),22-23。  new window
3.邱秋芳(2000)。融資融券授信機構債權之擔保。證交資料,464。  延伸查詢new window
4.Längerich, Reinhard(2004)。"Negotiation" Seen to Be No Benefit to Beneficiaries。Documentary Credit Insight,10(2)。  new window
5.Dolan, John F.(2001)。Financing for Commercial Hoi Poloi - Negotiable Drafts and Letters of Credit。Banking Law Journal,118。  new window
6.Zidar, Bojan(2005)。Another take on negotiation。Documentary Credit Insight。  new window
7.Fung, King Tak(2006)。Availability of credit and negotiation。Documentary Credit Insight,12-1。  new window
8.Dolan, John F.(1992)。Commentary on Legislative Developments in Letters of Credit Law: An Interim Report。Banking & Finance Law Review,8。  new window
9.O'Brien(2001)。DOC Clinic。LC Monitor。  new window
10.Karni, Chaim、Turner, Paul S.(2001)。Documentary Dialogue: Two Commentators Discuss How the Term "Negotiation" is Used - or Misused。Documentary Credit Insight,7(3)。  new window
11.Hertl, Heinz(2000)。Draft: A Mandatory Document or a Reason for a Discrepancy。LC Monitor。  new window
12.Graham, Roger(2005)。Expert Commentary: An Argument for smaller-Scale UCP Revisions。Documentary Credit Insight,11(3)。  new window
13.Ellinger, E. P.(1981)。Fraud in Documentary Credit Transactions。Journal of Business Law。  new window
14.Ellinger, E. P.(1995)。Has UCP500 Article 10(b)Clarified the Nature of Negotiation for Bankers and Traders? Two Commentators Take Different Views。Documentary Credit Insight,1(1)。  new window
15.Dolan, John F.(1999)。Letter of Credit: A Comparison of UCP 500 and the New U.S. Article。Journal of Business Law,5。  new window
16.Pawlowic, D.(1992)。Letters of Credit: A Framework for Analysis of Transfer, Assignment, Negotiation, and Transfer by Operation of Law。Wayne Law Review,39。  new window
17.Rosenblith, Robert M.(2000)。Litigation the Letter of Credit Case: Liability of Banks under the Current and Revised Uniform Commercial Code。Uniform Commercial Code Law Journal,33。  new window
18.Dolan, John F.(2007)。Negotiation Credit under UCP。Documentary Credit Insight,600。  new window
19.Smith, Donald(2006)。Negotiation Is Not Always What Bankers Think It Is。Documentary Credit Insight。  new window
20.Glenn(2001)。Negotiation versus Presentation。LC Monitor。  new window
21.UCP Drafting Group Members(2005)。Notes from the UCP Drafting Group。Documentary Credit Insight,11(2)。  new window
22.Seng, Soh Chee(2001)。Recourse and Discrepancies: Problems Around。Documentary Credit World。  new window
23.Robert, M.(1988)。Rosenblith, Current Developments in Letter-of-Credit Law。Uniform Commercial Code Law Journal,21。  new window
24.McLaughlin, G.(1990)。Should Deferred Payment Letters of Credit be Specially Treated in a Revision of Article 5?。Brooklyn Law Review,56。  new window
25.Kozolchyk, Boris(2007)。Should Future UCP Revisions be Carried out Differently?。Documentary Credit Insight。  new window
26.Fung, King-Tak(2001)。The "Availability" of Credits。Documentary Credit Insight,7(4)。  new window
27.Kozolchyk, Boris(1992)。The Immunization of Fraudulently Procured Letter of Credit Acceptance: All Services Exportacao, Importacao Comercio, S.A. v. Banco Bamerindus Do Brazil, S.A. and First Commercial v. Gotham Originals。Brooklyn Law Review,58。  new window
28.Busto, Charles Del(1995)。The Insight Interview。Documentary Credit Insight,1(1)。  new window
29.(2004)。The Insight Interview: Candid Views from a Member of the UCP Drafting Group。Documentary Credit Insight,10(4)。  new window
30.(2005)。The Insight Interview: René Müller, Confronting the key issues in the UCP Revision。Documentary Credit Insight,11(4)。  new window
31.Bacon, Laurence A. J.(2005)。The Insight Interview: Some Key Issue in the UCP Revision。Documentary Credit Insight,11(1)。  new window
32.Malmqvist, Ole(2006)。UCP600 "Key issues" Reconsidered。Documentary Credit Insight。  new window
33.(2006)。UCP600 Nears Completion。Documentary Credit World。  new window
34.(2006)。UCP600: 25 Important Point to Consider. 6. "NEGOTIATUON"。Documentary Credit World,11/ 12。  new window
35.Ryan, R. H.(1990)。Who Should Be Immune from the Fraud in the Transaction Defense in a Letter of Credit Transaction。Brooklyn Law Review,56。  new window
圖書
1.倪成彬(1993)。信用狀統一慣例UCP500註釋。信用狀統一慣例UCP500註釋。臺北市:財團法人金融研訓中心。  延伸查詢new window
2.D'arcy, Leo、Cleave, Barbara、Murray, Carole、Schmitthoff, Clive M.(2000)。Schmitthoff's Export Trade: The Law and Practice of International Trade。London:Sweet & Maxwell。  new window
3.Collyer, Gary(2000)。Opinions of the ICC Banking Commission, 1998-1999, Queries & Responses on UCP 500, 400, URC 522, ICC Publication No. 613。Paris, France。  new window
4.Byrne, James E.(2000)。ISP98 & UCP500 Compared。USA:Institute of International Banking Law & Practice/ George Mason University School of Law。  new window
5.Dolan, John F.(1996)。The Law of Letters of Credit - Commercial and Standby Credits。USA:Warren, Gorham & Lamont。  new window
6.Collyer, Gary(1997)。Opinions of the ICC Banking Commission, 1995-1996, ICC Publication No. 565。Paris, France。  new window
7.金賽波(2003)。信用證法律。信用證法律。北京市。  延伸查詢new window
8.Busto, Charles Del(1995)。Case Studies on Documentary Credits under UCP 500, ICC Publication No. 535。Case Studies on Documentary Credits under UCP 500, ICC Publication No. 535。Paris, France。  new window
9.Byrnes, Christopher S.、Byrne, James E.(2000)。2000 Annual Survey of Letter of Credit Law & Practice。2000 Annual Survey of Letter of Credit Law & Practice。Montgomery Village, MD。  new window
10.Byrnes, Christopher S.、Byrne, James E.(2001)。2001 Annual Survey of Letter of Credit Law & Practice。2001 Annual Survey of Letter of Credit Law & Practice。Montgomery Village, MD。  new window
11.Byrne, James E.、Byrnes, Christopher S.(2002)。2002 Annual Survey of Letter of Credit Law & Practice。2002 Annual Survey of Letter of Credit Law & Practice。Montgomery Village, MD。  new window
12.Byrne, James E.、Byrnes, Christopher S.(2003)。2003 Annual Survey of Letter of Credit Law & Practice。2003 Annual Survey of Letter of Credit Law & Practice。Montgomery Village, MD。  new window
13.Barnes, James G.、Byrne, James E.、Boss, Amelia H.(1998)。The ABCs of the UCC Article 5: Letter of Credit。The ABCs of the UCC Article 5: Letter of Credit。0。  new window
14.Jack, Raymond(1993)。Documentary Credits。Documentary Credits。London, UK。  new window
15.Ellinger, E. P.(1976)。Documentary Letter of Vredit, A Comparative Study。Documentary Letter of Vredit, A Comparative Study。Singapore。  new window
16.(1980)。Decisions (1975-1979) of the ICC Banking Commission, ICC Publication No.371。Decisions (1975-1979) of the ICC Banking Commission, ICC Publication No.371。Paris, France。  new window
17.Wheble, Bernard S.(1982)。Opinions (1980-1981) of the ICC Banking Commission on Queries Relating to UCP。Opinions (1980-1981) of the ICC Banking Commission on Queries Relating to UCP。Paris, France。  new window
18.(1984)。信用狀統一慣例問題研究。信用狀統一慣例問題研究。0。  延伸查詢new window
19.Wheble, B.(1984)。UCP1974/1983 Revisions Compared and Explained, ICC Publication No.411。UCP1974/1983 Revisions Compared and Explained, ICC Publication No.411。Paris, France。  new window
20.陳沖(1985)。信用狀基本法律理論。財團法人金融研訓中心。  延伸查詢new window
21.ICC(1985)。Guide to Documentary Vredit Operations。Guide to Documentary Vredit Operations。Paris, France。  new window
22.(1996)。信用狀統一慣例問題解析。信用狀統一慣例問題解析。0。  延伸查詢new window
23.(1988)。International Trade Law and Private International Law。International Trade Law and Private International Law。London, UK。  new window
24.Dekker, Jan(1989)。Case Studies on Documentary Credit (for UCP400) (Vol. 1), ICC Publication No.459。Case Studies on Documentary Credit (for UCP400) (Vol. 1), ICC Publication No.459。Paris, France。  new window
25.Dekker, Jan(1991)。More Case Studies on Documentary Credits, ICC Publication No.489。More Case Studies on Documentary Credits, ICC Publication No.489。Paris, France。  new window
26.沈榮嘉、劉鴻益、孫蘭英、楊安和(1993)。信用狀統一慣例。信用狀統一慣例。0。  延伸查詢new window
27.Busto, Charles Del(1993)。Documentary Credits/ UCP500 & 400 Compared, ICC Publication No.511。Documentary Credits/ UCP500 & 400 Compared, ICC Publication No.511。Paris, France。  new window
28.Busto, Charles Del(1993)。The New Standard Documentary Credit Forms for the UCP500, ICC Publication No. 516。The New Standard Documentary Credit Forms for the UCP500, ICC Publication No. 516。Paris, France。  new window
29.Busto, Charles Del(1994)。ICC Guide to Documentary Credit Operations for the UCP500, ICC Publication No.515。ICC Guide to Documentary Credit Operations for the UCP500, ICC Publication No.515。Paris, France。  new window
30.Jahn, Drjur Uwe(1995)。Bills of Exchange - A Guide to Legislation in European Countries, ICC Publication No.531。Bills of Exchange - A Guide to Legislation in European Countries, ICC Publication No.531。Paris, France。  new window
31.Taylor, Dan(1997)。ICC Guide to Documentary Credit Operations for the UCP500, ICC Publication No.575。ICC Guide to Documentary Credit Operations for the UCP500, ICC Publication No.575。Paris, France。  new window
32.Rowe, Michael(1997)。Letters of Credit。Letters of Credit。London, UK。  new window
33.(1998)。More Queries and Responses on UCP500, Opinions of the ICC Banking Commission 1997, ICC Publication No. 596。More Queries and Responses on UCP500, Opinions of the ICC Banking Commission 1997, ICC Publication No. 596。Paris, France。  new window
34.(1999)。UCP500問答篇-國際商會銀行委員會之見解。UCP500問答篇-國際商會銀行委員會之見解。0。  延伸查詢new window
35.張錦源(2001)。國際貿易法。三民。  延伸查詢new window
36.(2001)。國際擔保函慣例中英對照ISP98。國際擔保函慣例中英對照ISP98。0。  延伸查詢new window
37.余森林(2002)。出進口押匯。出進口押匯。臺北市。  延伸查詢new window
38.張錦源(2002)。信用狀理論與實務。信用狀理論與實務。臺北市。  延伸查詢new window
39.(2003)。國際標準銀行實務。國際標準銀行實務。0。  延伸查詢new window
40.(2002)。Benjamin's Sale of Goods。Benjamin's Sale of Goods。London, UK。  new window
41.Collyer, Gary(2002)。ICC Banking Commission Collected Opinio 1995-2001 on UCP500, UCP400, URC522 & URDG 458 Queries and Pesponses。ICC Banking Commission Collected Opinio 1995-2001 on UCP500, UCP400, URC522 & URDG 458 Queries and Pesponses。Paris, France。  new window
42.李金澤(2004)。信用证:法律风险防范。信用证:法律风险防范。北京市。  延伸查詢new window
43.臺灣金融研訓院(2005)。出口外匯業務。出口外匯業務。0。  延伸查詢new window
44.Taylor, Dan(1995)。UCP Position Paper - A Look at the Process。Annual Survey of Letter of Credit Law & Practice - Survey Handbook。Montgomery Village, MD。  new window
45.Todd, Robyn(1995)。Why Negotiate。1995 Annual Survey of Letter of Credit law & Practice - Survey Handbook。Montgomery Village, MD。  new window
46.Barnes, James G.、Byrne, James E.(1999)。Letters of Credit: 1997 Cases。1999 Annual Survey of Letter of Credit Law & Practice。Montgomery Village, MD。  new window
47.Ward, Alan(1999)。The Nature of Negotiation under Documentary Credits。Annual Survey of Letter of Credit Law & Practice。Montgomery Village, MD。  new window
48.Byrne, James E.(2000)。Overview of Letter of Credit Law & Practice 1999。Annual Survey of Letter of Credit Law & Practice。Montgomery Village, MD。  new window
49.Rosenblith, Robert M.(2001)。To Negotiate or Not to Negotiate, Does It Make a Difference?。2001 Annual Survey of Letter of Credit Law & Practice。Montgomery Village, MD。  new window
50.Seng, Soh Chee(2002)。Deferred Payment LCs Re-Visited。2002 Annual Survey of Letter of Credit Law & Practice。Montgomery Village, MD。  new window
51.Dolan, John F.(2002)。How Negotiation Letters of Credit Can Go Wrong: Pan Pacific Specialties Ltd v. Shandong Machinery & Equipment I/E Corp.。2002 Annual Survey of Letter of Credit Law & Practice。Montgomery Village, MD。  new window
52.Ellinger, E. P.(2002)。Silent Confirmation and àForfait Discounting( Law and Practice)。Annual Survey of Letter of Credit Law & Practice。Montgomery Village, MD。  new window
53.Stoufflet, Jean(2003)。Fraud in Documentary Credit, Letter of Credit and Demand Guaranty。2003 Annual Survey of Letter of Credit Law & Practice。Montgomery Village, MD。  new window
54.Dolan, John F.(2003)。Negotiation Letters of Credit。2003 Annual Survey of Letter of Credit Law & Practice。Montgomery Village, MD。  new window
55.Gao, Xiang(2003)。Presenters Immune from the Fraud Rule in the Law of Letters of Credit。2003 Annual Survey of Letter of Credit Law & Practice。Montgomery Village, MD。  new window
 
 
 
 
第一頁 上一頁 下一頁 最後一頁 top
QR Code
QRCODE