:::

詳目顯示

回上一頁
題名:The Use of a Diagnostic Profile in Assessing the Art Understandings of Taiwanese ESL Students
書刊名:藝術教育研究
作者:馬丁‧福客
作者(外文):Forker, Martin
出版日期:2014
卷期:27
頁次:頁101-142
主題關鍵詞:藝術評量藝術教育診斷剖析跨領域課程Art assessmentArt educationDiagnostic profileInterdisciplinary course
原始連結:連回原系統網址new window
相關次數:
  • 被引用次數被引用次數:期刊(0) 博士論文(0) 專書(0) 專書論文(0)
  • 排除自我引用排除自我引用:0
  • 共同引用共同引用:1
  • 點閱點閱:12
本論文採用 Stavropoulos(1992)「以口頭回應藝術作品的藝術認識診斷剖析」(DP)做為評量英文系學生修一學期西方和亞洲藝術的跨領域課程後之藝術認識。運用DP 評量四向度(描述、形式、詮釋和歷史)分析學生對圖像的書面回應,結果顯示學生多種較低階的藝術認識。形式向度方面,許多學生成功運用藝術知識,以設計元素和原理來分析藝術品;詮釋向度,許多學生使用知識尋找策略尋找藝術認識;大部份學生在歷史向度並未取得高分;每個向度皆發現回應錯誤、不合邏輯或藝術判斷能力幼稚、模糊地描述畫作;亦明顯缺乏支持性判斷、美學推論、描述性訊問、延伸或挑戰藝術歷史家、有力的論調評論藝術等。有幾位學生的圖畫則印證了Howard Gardner 的空間智能觀念。總之,研究結果建議跨領域課程可提供給學生有用的知識庫來發展藝術教育。
This study uses Stavropoulos’ (1992) “A Diagnostic Profile of Art Understandings Based on Verbal Responses to Works of Art (DP)” to evaluate ESL students’ understandings of Western and Asian art during a one-semester interdisciplinary course. Stavropoulos’ DP uses four dimensions to assess student’s verbal and written responses to imagery: descriptive, formal, interpretative, and historical. The findings reveal that the students gave multiple lower-order descriptive art understandings. Within the formal dimension, many students successfully developed their formal art knowledge-base as many analyzed artworks in terms of elements and principles of design. Within the interpretative dimension, many students employed knowledgeseeking strategies in their search for understanding. Most students’ responses did not score highly within the historical dimension. There is evidence of students giving incorrect appraisals, illogical findings, immature judgment, and nebulous or unclear statements within each dimension. It is also palpable that there is a scarcity of responses which provide supported judgment or aesthetic reasoning, descriptive questioning, extending or challenging the art historian’s or the art critic’s description of the work through convincing argument. Several of the students’ drawings demonstrate Howard Gardner’s (1983) notion of spatial intelligence. Overall, the findings suggest that the interdisciplinary course provided students with a useful knowledge-base for developing their art education.
期刊論文
1.Short, G.(1996)。Incorporating a depth of understanding model into a high school studio curriculum。Arts and Learning Research,12(1),18-32。  new window
2.Stavropoulos, Carol Susann(1995)。Assessing Student Learning in the Arts: Building a Bridge between Theory and Practice。Arts and Learning Research Journal,12(1),18-32。  new window
3.馬丁‧福客(20121200)。Achieving Visual Literacy: Prior Knowledge of Spiritual Symbolism in Modern Art。藝術教育研究,24,111-147+149-150。new window  new window
4.Alexander, P.、Schallert, D.、O'Hare, V.(1991)。Coming to terms: How researchers in learning and literacy talk about knowledge。Review of Educational Research,61(3),315-345。  new window
5.Alvermann, D. E.、Smith, L. C.、Readence, J. E.(1985)。Prior knowledge activism and the comprehension of compatible and incompatible text。Reading Research Quarterly,20(4),421-436。  new window
6.Blair, L.、Morbey, M. L.(1993)。Arts and learning research, 1992-1993。The Journal of the Arts and Learning,10(1),1-15。  new window
7.Davis, D. J.(1993)。Art education in the 1990s: Meeting the challenges of accountability。Studies in Art Education,34(2),82-90。  new window
8.Forker, M.(2008)。Assessing the written responses to conflict imagery by Northern Ireland art and non-art students。Journal of Taipei Municipal University of Education,39(1),137-178。  new window
9.Holyoak, K.、Spellman, B. A.(1993)。Thinking。Annual Review of Psychology,44,265-315。  new window
10.Ives, W.、Pond, J.(1980)。The arts and cognitive development。The High School Journal,63(8),335-340。  new window
11.Koroscik, J. S.(1982)。The effects of prior knowledge, presentation time and task demands on visual art processing。Studies in Art Education,23(3),13-22。  new window
12.Koroscik, J. S.(1990)。Novice-expert differences in understanding art and their implications for student assessment in art education。Arts and Learning Research,8(1),2-29。  new window
13.Koroscik, J. S.、Short, G.、Stavropoulos, C.、Fortin, S.(1992)。Frameworks for understanding art: The function of comparative art contexts and verbal cues。Studies in Art Education,33(3),154-164。  new window
14.Parsons, M. J.(1990)。A comparison of novice-expert and developmental paradigms in terms of their use in work on the assessment of student learning in art education。Arts and Learning Research,8(1),30-49。  new window
15.Perkins, D. N.、Salomon, G.(1989)。Are Cognitive Skills Context-Bound?。Educational Researcher,18(1),16-25。  new window
16.Short, G.(1995)。Understanding domain knowledge for teaching: Higher-order thinking in pre-service art teacher specialists。Studies in Art Education,36(3),154-169。  new window
17.Stavropoulos, C. S.(1992)。A diagnostic profile of art understandings based on verbal responses to works of art。Marilyn Zurmuehlen Working Papers in Art Education,11(1),48-53。  new window
18.Stavropoulos, C. S.(1994)。Distinguishing the effectiveness of a writing-intensive DBAE curriculum: A quasi-experimental study comparing three elementary classrooms' written responses to a work of art。Arts and Learning Research,11(1),25-44。  new window
19.Wilson, B.(1986)。Testing and the process of change. Design for Arts in。Education,8(12),6-11。  new window
20.Cason, N.(1998)。Interactive Multimedia: An Alternative Context for Studying Works of Art。Studies in Art Education,39(4),336-349。  new window
21.Koroscik, J. S.(1992)。Assessing student learning in the visual arts: Application of a theoretical model。Arts and Learning Research,10(1),5-15。  new window
22.Vosniadou, S.、Brewer, William F.(1987)。Theories of knowledge restructuring in development。Review of Educational Research,57(1),51-67。  new window
23.Holyoak, Keith J.、Gick, Mary L.(1983)。Schema Induction and Analogical Transfer。Cognitive Psychology,15(1),1-38。  new window
24.Bransford, J. D.、Johnson, M. K.(1972)。Contextual prerequisites for understanding: Some investigations of comprehension。Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior,11(6),717-726。  new window
25.Prawat, R. S.(1989)。Promoting access to knowledge, strategy, and disposition in students: A research synthesis。Review of Educational Research,59(1),1-41。  new window
26.Bransford, J. D.、Sherwood, R. D.、Vye, N.、Rieser, J.(1986)。Teaching thinking and problem solving: Suggestions from research。American Psychologist,41(10),1078-1089。  new window
27.Perkins, D. N.、Simmons, R.(1988)。Patterns of Misunderstanding: An Integrative Model for Science, Math, and Programming。Review of Educational Research,58(3),303-326。  new window
會議論文
1.Confrey, J.(1987)。Misconceptions across subject matters: Science, mathematics, and programming。New York, NY:Cornell University。81-106。  new window
學位論文
1.Forker, M.(2002)。A Diagnostic Profile of Art Understandings and Social Attributions Based on Written Responses to Conflict Imagery(博士論文)。Queens University of Belfast,Northern Ireland。  new window
圖書
1.Chapman, L. H.(1985)。Discover art。Worcester, MA:Davis。  new window
2.Efland, A. D.、Koroscik, J.、Parsons, M.(1991)。Assessing art learning based on the novice-expert paradigms: A progress report。Atlanta, GA:National Art Education Association。  new window
3.Feldman, E. B.(1967)。Varieties of visual experience。New York, NY:Harry N. Abrams。  new window
4.Herberholz, B.、Hanson, L.(1990)。Early childhood art。Dubuque, IA:W. C. Brown。  new window
5.Hubbard, G.、Rouse, M. J.(1981)。Art: Meaning, method, and media。Chicago, CH:Benefic Press。  new window
6.Koster, J.(1981)。Bringing art into the elementary classroom。Belmont, CA:Wadworth。  new window
7.McKenzie, W.(2005)。Multiple intelligences and instructional technology。Oregon, OR:International Society for Technology Education (ISTE)。  new window
8.Piaget, J.、Inhelder, B.(1967)。A child's conception of space。New York, NY:Norton。  new window
9.Sless, D.(1981)。Learning and visual communication。London, UK:Croom Helm。  new window
10.Winslow, L.(1939)。The integrated school art program。New York, NY:McGraw-Hill。  new window
11.Catto, M.(1977)。Art in Ulster。Belfast, NI:Black Staff Press。  new window
12.Compton, S. P.(1985)。Chagall。New York, NY:Harry N. Abrams。  new window
13.Hobbs, J.、Salome, R.(1991)。The visual experience。Worcester, MA:Davis。  new window
14.Hurwitz, A.、Day, M.(1991)。Children and their art。New York, NY:Harcourt Brace Jovanovich。  new window
15.Makarius, M.(1988)。Chagall。New York, NY:Portland House。  new window
16.Sweeney, J. J.(1946)。Marc Chagall。New York, NY:Museum of Modern Art。  new window
17.Guba, E. G.(1978)。Toward a methodology of naturalistic inquiry in educational evaluation。Los Angeles, CA:Center for the Study of Evaluation, UCLA Graduate School of Education, University of California。  new window
18.Paivio, A.、Sadoski, M.(2001)。Imagery and text: A dual coding theory of reading and writing。Mahwah, NJ:Lawrence Erlbaum Associates。  new window
19.Chi, M. T. H.、Glaser, R.、Farr, M. J.(1988)。The nature of expertise。Hillsdale, NJ:Lawrence Erlbaum Associates。  new window
20.Efland, A. D.(1990)。A history of art education: Intellectual and social currents in teaching the visual arts。New York:Teachers College Press, Columbia University。  new window
21.Resnick, Lauren B.(1987)。Education and learning to think。National Academies Press。  new window
22.Arnheim, Rudolf(1969)。Visual Thinking。Berkeley:Los Angeles:California, CA:University of California Press。  new window
23.Bruner, J.(1973)。Going Beyond the Information Given。New York, NY:Norton & Company。  new window
24.Frankel, J. R.、Wallen, N. E.(1990)。How to design and evaluate research in education。New York, NY:McGraw-Hill。  new window
25.Gardner, H.(1983)。Frames of mind: The theory of multiple intelligences。NY:Random House。  new window
其他
1.Graves, D.(2013)。Copying the masters,http://www.florenceacademyofart.com/news.php?id=10&r=f。  new window
2.New York State Education Department Office of Bilingual Education and Foreign Languages Studies(2010)。Art as a tool for teachers of English language learners,http://www.p12.nysed.gov/biling/docs/Art_as_a_Tool-for_Teachers.pdf。  new window
圖書論文
1.Feltovich, P. J.、Spiro, R. J.、Coulson, R. L.(1989)。The nature of conceptual understanding in biomedicine: The deep structure of complex ideas and the development of misconceptions。The Cognitive sciences in medicine。Cambridge, MA:MIT Press。  new window
 
 
 
 
第一頁 上一頁 下一頁 最後一頁 top
:::
無相關博士論文
 
無相關書籍
 
無相關著作
 
QR Code
QRCODE