In addition to the Labor Standards Act, the basis of the regulation of minimum years in employment contracts is the Civil Code. The standards of regulation are necessity and rationality. If we want to judge the effects of the agreements, we should recognize essentially whether the employers train the employees and how the employers train the employees. In addition, we should consider the purposes of minimum years in employment contracts and whether the contracts are standard contracts. After the competent authorities make clear regulations about kinds of employment contracts, the contracts shall be regulated by justice. We should domesticate the French and the American concept of voidable contracts. Besides, all-or-nothing approach is inappropnate. So long as the minimum years in employment contracts are effective, the agreed penalties are also effective in the reasonable scopes. The provisions concerning reduction of the penalties can apply, apply mutatis mutandis, or apply by analogy to the agreements of return of the compensation or the training fee. During the minimum years, if the employers terminate employment contracts in accordance with Article 11 of the Labor Standards Act, fair compensation must be paid in order to protect the employees' legitimate reliance.