臺灣人文及社會科學引文索引資料庫系統

:::

詳目顯示

回上一頁
第 1 筆 / 總合 1 筆   第一頁 上一頁 下一頁 最後一頁
/1頁
題名：美國法上大規模瑕疵產品的多重懲罰性賠償金責任研究
書刊名：輔仁法學
作者：戴志傑 引用關係
作者(外文)：Tai, Chih-chieh
出版日期：2015
卷期：50
頁次：頁165-256
主題關鍵詞：消費者保護法；大規模侵權訴訟；多重裁決；產品責任訴訟；集體訴訟；正當程序條款；一次性裁決；Consumer protection law；Mass tort litigation；Multiple punitive damages verdict；Products liability litigation；Class action；Due process clause；One-time award
原始連結：連回原系統網址new window
相關次數：
  • 被引用次數被引用次數:期刊(0) 博士論文(0) 專書(0) 專書論文(0)
  • 排除自我引用排除自我引用:0
  • 共同引用共同引用:13
  • 點閱點閱:96
60年代晚期產品責任制度的確立，促使了懲罰性賠償金法制的日漸發展。然因90年代初期後偶有出現鉅額裁決而引起爭論，故即觸發論者紛紛投入研究，且聯邦最高法院此際亦開始表示關切並對數起鉅額裁決案件予以司法審查。此外，隨著90年代侵權行為改革法案的進行，各州亦藉機而對該賠償金制度作出限制性的立法規範。然在此些司法審查與立法改革的作為與方案中，卻無對於大規模瑕疵產品致害事件面臨多重裁決所生過度扼殺與公平性等問題，提出具體的立法解決方案。而儘管各州法院對於此等重要問題已有所關切並提出看法，但最後均是陳言無能為力並表示唯有透過全國性立法方能解決。從而，此議題於美國法上儼然是產品責任及懲罰性賠償金責任制度中最為重要的研究課題之一。因此，鑑於我國近年大量黑心產品致害事件頻傳，且適用消保法而課予多重懲罰性賠償金責任將是可期，輔以國內迄今對此重要問題仍未有研究性論文出現等情形下，本文即擬研究美國法上此等問題之相關判決及學者間的建議方案，以期作為我國司法實務及未來修法上之參考。
The establishment of product liability system in the late 60's promoted the gradual development of punitive damages system, and surprising award appeared in the early 90's, so scholars have written articles to criticize and research, and the Supreme Court has expressed concerns and started constitutional judicial review on several high punitive damages awards. In addition, with the progress of tort reform in 90 years, each state had also reformed punitive damages system and made restrictive legislative norms. However, if we carefully investigate the actions and programs of the judicial reviews and legislative reforms, there are no concrete solutions and legislation proposed for overkill, fairness concerns, or other serious problems caused by mass defect products for continual litigations and facing multiple punitive damages awards. For the issue of “multiple punitive damages study of mass defect products”, each state court has already concerned and put forward their views, but ultimately they still expressed that they had nothing to do but appealed for the solution of nation-wide legislation. Therefore, in the USA law, this issue has been one of the most important research topics for product liability and the liability system of punitive damages. However, for this emerging and serious problem, there are still no academic research papers in our country's law. In view of the harmful events of a large number of unsafe products in our country in recent years, multiple punitive damages on the application of consumer protection law has already been the matter can be expected. Therefore, through the related judgments of U.S. courts and scholars’ studies, I would like to use this thesis to reflect on the defects of the responsibility of multiple punitive damages and suggestion for amending the law about mass defect products in our country's law.
期刊論文
1.詹森林(20100800)。消保法懲罰性賠償金責任之過失應否限於重大過失？--臺灣高等法院高雄分院九十七年上字第八一號民事判決之評析。月旦裁判時報，4，50-59。  延伸查詢new window
2.Owen, David G.(1994)。Punitive Damages Awards in Product Liability Litigation: Strong Medicine or Poison Pill? : A Punitive Damages Overview: Functions, Problems and Reform。Villanova Law Review，39，363-413。  new window
3.Owen, David G.(1982)。Problems in Assessing Punitive Damages Against Manufacturers of Defective Products。University of Chicago Law Review，49(1)。  new window
4.Jeffries, John Calvin Jr.(1986)。A Comment on the Constitutionality of Punitive Damages。Virginia Law Review，72，139-158。  new window
5.Richard, C. Ausness(1985)。Retribution and Deterrence: The Role of Punitive Damages in Products Liability Litigation。Ky. L.J.，74，1。  new window
6.Sales, James B.、Cole, Kenneth B. Jr.(1984)。Punitive Damages: A Relic That Has Outlived Its Origins。Vand. L. Rev.，37。  new window
7.Gotanda, John Y.(2003)。Punitive Damages: A Comparative Analysis。Columbia Journal of Transnational Law，42(2)，391-396。  new window
8.Grube, E. Jeffrey(1993)。Punitive Damages: A Misplaced Remedy。Southern California Law Review，66。  new window
9.Kirgis, Paul F.(1993)。The Constitutionality of State Allocation of Punitive Damage Awards。Washington and Lee Law Review，50。  new window
10.Pace, Kimberly A.(1997)。Recalibrating the Scales of Justice through National Punitive Damage Reform。Am. U. L. Rev.，46，1573。  new window
11.Sharkey, Catherine M.(2003)。Punitive Damages as Societal Damages。Yale Law Journal，113。  new window
12.Galanter, Marc、Luban, David(1993)。Poetic Justice: Punitive Damages and Legal Pluralism。American University Law Review，42(4)，1393-1463。  new window
13.Eisenberg, Theodore、LaFountain, Neil、Ostrom, Brian、Rottman, David、Hannaford, Paula L.、Heise, Michael(2001)。Juries, Judges, and Punitive Damages: An Empirical Study。Cornell Law Review，87，743-782。  new window
14.戴志傑(20150300)。美國法上懲罰性賠償金數額分享制度之研究。政大法學評論，140，287-371。new window  延伸查詢new window
15.Abramson, Albert R.(1975)。Punitive Damages in Aircraft Accident Cases--A Debate。Forum，11，50。  new window
16.Albers, John A.(1994)。State of Confusion: Substantive and Procedural Due Process with Regard to Punitive Damages After TXO Production Corp. v. Alliance Resources Corp.。U. Tol. L. Rev.，26，159。  new window
17.American Bar Assoc.(2006)。Contingent Fees in Mass Tort Litigation。Tort &Ins.L.J.，42，105。  new window
18.Arnold, Robert H.(1983)。Punitive Damages in Products Liability Litigation: Redirecting the Windfall。J. Prods. Liab.，6，367。  new window
19.Beasley, Brian Timothy(1996)。North Carolina's New Punitive Damages Statute: Who's Being Punished, Anyway?。N.C. L. Rev.，74，214。  new window
20.Borowsky, Philip、Nicolaisen, Lee K.(1983)。Damages in California: The Integrity of Jury Verdicts。U.S.F. L. Rev.，17，147。  new window
21.Cabraser, Elizabeth J.、Sobol, Thomas M.(2000)。Equity for the Victims, Equity for the Transgressor: The Classwide Treatment of Punitive Damages Claims。Tul. L. Rev.，74，2005。  new window
22.Clements, Jr., Jimmie O.(1992)。Punitive Damages: A Placebo for America's Ailing Competitiveness。St. Mary's L.J.，24，197。  new window
23.Cordray, Margaret Meriwether(1999)。The Limits of State Sovereignty and the Issue of Multiple Punitive Damages Awards。Or. L. Rev.，78，275。  new window
24.Davis, Mary J.(1998)。Toward the Proper Role for Mass Tort Class Actions。Or. L. Rev.，77，157。  new window
25.Demarest, Sylvia M.、Jones, David E.(1987)。Exemplary Damages as an Instrument of Social Policy: Is Tort Reform in the Public Interest?。St. Mary's L. J.，18，797-825。  new window
26.Dobbs, Dan B.(1989)。Ending Punishment in "Punitive" Damages: Deterrence-Measured Remedies。Alabama Law Review，40。  new window
27.Dougherty, Francis M.(1985)。Excessiveness or Inadequacy of Punitive Damages Awarded in Personal Injury or Death Cases。A.L.R. 4th，35，441。  new window
28.Ellis, Dorsey D. Jr.(1989)。Punitive Damages, Due Process, and the Jury。Ala. L. Rev.，40，975。  new window
29.Gash, Jim(2005)。Solving the Multiple Punishments Problem: A Call for A National Punitive Damages Registry。Nw. ILL. Rev.，99，1613。  new window
30.Gilden, Richard H.(1970)。Punitive Damages in Implied Private Actions for Fraud Under the Securities Laws。Cornell L. Rev.，55，646。  new window
31.Glasscock, Judith Gamile(1987)。Emptying the Deep Pocket in Mass Tort Litigation。St. Mary's L.J.，18，977。  new window
32.Hans, Valerie P.(2003)。Empirical Research and Civil Jury Reform。Notre Dame L. Rev.，78，1497。  new window
33.Hines, Laura J.(2001)。Obstacles to Determining Punitive Damages in Class Actions。Wake Forest L. Rev.，36，889。  new window
34.Janutis, Rachel M.(2006)。Fair Apportionment of Multiple Punitive Damages。Miss. L.J.，75，367。  new window
35.Janutis, Rachel M.(2004)。The Continued Viability of Multiple Punitive Damages After State Farm v. Campbell。San Diego L. Rev.，41，1465。  new window
36.Jones, Dennis Neil、Sutton, S. Brett、Greenwald, Barbara D.(1991)。Punitive Damage Awards for a Single Course of Wrongful Conduct: The Need for a National Policy to Protect Due Process。Ala. L. Rev.，43，1。  new window
37.Kemp, Janice(1995)。The Continuing Appeal of Punitive Damages: An Analysis of Constitutional and Other Challenges to Punitive Damages, Post-Haslip and Moriel。Tex. Tech L. Rev.，26，1。  new window
38.Koenig, Jonathan H.(1995)。Punitive Damage "Overkill" After TXO Production Corp. v. Alliance Resources: The Need for a Congressional Solution。Wm. & Mary L. Rev.，36，751。  new window
39.Koenig, Thomas H.、Rustad, Michael L.(1993)。The Quiet Revolution Revisited: An Empirical Examination of State Tort Reforms of Punitive Damages。Just. Sys. J.，16，23。  new window
40.Kreindler, Lee S.(1978)。Punitive Damages in Aviation Litigation--An Essay。Cumb. L. Rev.，8，607。  new window
41.Mallor, Jane、Roberts, Bany(1980)。Punitive Damages: Toward a Principled Approach。Hastings L. J.，31，639。  new window
42.Mead, Susanah(1995)。Punitive Damages and the Spill Felt Round the World: A U.S. Perspective。Loy. L.A. Inf'l & Comp. L.J.，17，829。  new window
43.Meredith, John L.(1995)。Taking Cover: Preserving Error when Hit with a Claim for Punitive Damages。Baylor L. Rev.，47，942。  new window
44.Meros, Jr., George N.(1998)。Toward a More Just and Predictable Civil Justice System。Fla. St. U. L. Rev.，25，141。  new window
45.Mesulam, Semra(2004)。Collective Rewards and Limited Punishment: Solving the Punitive Damages Dilemma with Class。Colum. L. Rev.，104，1114。  new window
46.Nadel, Andrea G.(1982)。Propriety of Awarding Punitive Damages to Separate Plaintiffs Bringing Successive Actions Arising Out of Common Incident or Circumstances Against Common Defendant or Defendants ("One Bite" or "First-Comer" Doctrine)。A.L.R. 4th，11，1261。  new window
47.Nagareda, Richard A.(2001)。Punitive Damage Class Actions and the Baseline of Tort。Wake Forest L. Rev.，36，943。  new window
48.(1983)。Note, Class Actions for Punitive Damages。Mich. L. Rev.，81，1787。  new window
49.(1983)。Note, Class Certification in Mass Accident Cases Under Rule 23(b)。Harv. L. Rev.，96，1143。  new window
50.(1980)。Note, In Defense of Punitive Damages。N.Y.U. L. Rev.，55，303。  new window
51.Panzer, Irving R. M.、Patton, Thomas Earl(1986)。Utilizing the Class Action Device in Mass Tort Litigation。Tort & Ins. L.J.，21，560。  new window
52.Phillips, Jerry J.(1994)。Multiple Punitive Damage Awards。Vill. L. Rev.，39，433。  new window
53.Pohlman, Jill McKee(1996)。Comment, Punitive Damages in the American Civil Justice System: Jackpot or Justice?。Utah L. Rev.，1996，613。  new window
54.Priest, George L.(1982)。Damages and Enterprise。S. Cal. L. Rev.，56，123。  new window
55.Pritchard, Robert W.(1994)。The Due Process Implications of Ohio's Punitive Damages Law--A Change Must Be Made。Dayton L. Rev.，19，1207。  new window
56.Redish, Martin H.、Matthews, Andrew L.(2004)。Why Punitive Damages Are Unconstitutional。Emory L.J，53，1。  new window
57.Riley, Tom(1978)。Punitive Damages: The Doctrine of Just Enrichment。Drake L. Rev.，27，195。  new window
58.Rustad, Michael、Koenig, Thomas(1995)。Reconceptualizing Punitive Damages in Medical Malpractice: Targeting Amoral Corporations, Not "Moral Monsters"。Rutgers L. Rev.，47，975。  new window
59.Rustad, Michael L.(2005)。Access to Justice: Can Business Co-Exist with the Civil Justice System?: The Closing of Punitive Damages' Iron Cage。Loyola of Los Angeles Law Review，38(3)，1297-1419。  new window
60.Rustad, Michael L.(1998)。Punitive Damages: Current Data and Further Inquiry。Wis. L. Rev.，1998，15。  new window
61.Rustad, Michael(1992)。In Defense of Punitive Damages in Products Liability: Testing Tort Anecdotes with Empirical Data。Iowa L. Rev.，78，1。  new window
62.Saks, Michael J.(1998)。Public Opinion About the Civil Jury: Can Reality Be Found in the Illusions?。Depaul L. Rev.，48，221。  new window
63.Salbu, Steven R.(1997)。Rational Punitive Damages Policies: Beyond the Constitution。Fla. L. Rev.，49，247。  new window
64.Schwartz, Gary T.(1994)。Mass Torts and Punitive Damages: A Comment。Vil. L. Rev.，39，415。  new window
65.Schwartz, Victor E.、Behrens, Mark A.、Silverman, Cary(2003)。I'll Take That: Legal and Public Policy Problems Raised By Statutes That Require Punitive Damages Awards To Be Shared With the State。Missouri Law Review，68。  new window
66.Schwartz, Victor E.、Behrens, Mark A.(1993)。Punitive Damages Reform --State Legislatures Can and Should Meet the Challenge Issued by the Supreme Court of the United States in Halsif。Am. U. L. Rev.，42，1365。  new window
67.Schwartz, Victor E.、Behrens, Mark A.、Mastrosimone, Joseph P.(1999)。Reining in Punitive Damages "Run Wild": Proposals for Reform by Courts and Legislatures。Brooklyn Law Review，65。  new window
68.Schwartzer, William(1991)。Punishment Ad Absurdum。Cal. Law.，11，116。  new window
69.Seltzer, Richard A.(1983)。Punitive Damages in Mass Tort Litigation: Addressing the Problems of Fairness, Efficiency, and Control。Fordham L. Rev.，52，37。  new window
70.Sherman, Edward F.(2004)。Introduction to the Symposium: Complex Litigation: Plagued by Concerns Over Federalism, Jurisdiction and Fairness。Akron L. Rev.，37，589。  new window
71.Shores, Janie L.(1992)。A Suggestion for Limited Tort Reform: Allocation of Punitive Damage Awards to Eliminate Windfalls。Ala. L. Rev.，44，61。  new window
72.Steinman, Joan(2001)。Managing Punitive Damages: A Role for Mandatory "Limited Generosity" Classes and Anti-Suit Injunctions?。Wake Forest L. Rev.，36，1043。  new window
73.Stepanian, Leo M. II(1994)。The Feasibility of Full State Extraction of Punitive Damage Awards。Duquesne Law Review，32。  new window
74.Stevens, Clay R.(1994)。Split-Recovery: A Constitutional Answer to the Punitive Damages Dilemma。Pepperdine Law Review，21。  new window
75.Tobin, Briggs L.(1989)。"Limited Generosity" Class Action and a Uniform Choice of Law Rule: An Approach to Fair and Effective Mass-Tort Punitive Damage Adjudication in the Federal Courts。Emory L.J.，38，457。  new window
76.Toy, Amelia J.(1991)。Statutory Punitive Damage Caps and the Profit Motive: An Economic Perspective。Emory L. J.，40，303-335。  new window
77.Wheeler, Malcolm E.(1989)。A Proposal for Further Common Law Development of the Use of Punitive Damages in Modem Product Liability Litigation。Ala. L. Rev.，40，919。  new window
78.Daniels, Stephen、Martin, Joanne(1990)。Myth and Reality in Punitive Damages。Minn. L. Rev.，75，1-27。  new window
79.Denemark, Howard A.(2002)。Seeking Greater Fairness When Awarding Multiple Plaintiffs Punitive Damages for a Single Act by a Defendant。Ohio State Law Journal，63，931-978。  new window
80.Owen, David G.(1976)。Punitive Damages in Products Liability Litigation。Mich. L. Rev.，74，1257+1304-1305。  new window
81.Schwartz, Teresa Moran(1993)。Punitive Damages and Regulated Products。Am. U. L. Rev.，42，1335。  new window
82.Colby, Thomas B.(2003)。Beyond the Multiple Punishment Problem: Punitive Damages as Punishment for Individual, Private Wrongs。Minnesota Law Review，87(3)，583-678。  new window
83.Koenig, Thomas、Rustad, Michael(1998)。"Crimtorts" as Corporate Just Deserts。University of Michigan Journal Law Reform，31。  new window
84.李志峰(20141200)。論美國懲罰性賠償金倍數比例之趨勢--兼評我國之相關規範。世新法學，8(1)，129-166。new window  延伸查詢new window
學位論文
1.王薇葦(201407)。論我國消費者保護法第51條過失之意義-從懲罰性賠償之特性出發(碩士論文)。中原大學。  延伸查詢new window
2.戴志傑(2007)。美國懲罰性賠償金制度之基礎問題研究(博士論文)。國立中正大學。new window  延伸查詢new window
圖書
1.American Bar Assoc.(1986)。Special Comm. On Punitive Damages Of The American Bar Assoc. Section On Litigation, Punitive Damages: A Constructive Examination。  new window
2.American Law Inst.(1991)。Reporters Study, Enterprise Responsibility For Personal Injury。  new window
3.Duffy, Jr., James E.(1969)。A Doctrine Which Should Be Abolished, in Defense Research Institute: The Case Against Punitive Damages: Practice & Procedure。  new window
4.Mauet, Thomas A.(1996)。Trial Techniques。  new window
5.Neely, Richard(1988)。The Product Liability Mess: How Business Can Be Rescued from the Politics of State Courts。  new window
6.Olson, Theodore B.、Boutrous, Jr., Theodore J.(1991)。How To Fight Punitive Damage Awards。  new window
7.Slaughter, Alexander H.(1988)。Punitive Damages, in Products Liability: Pharmaceutical Drug Cases。  new window
8.Sunstein, Cass R.、Hastie, Reid、Payne, John W.、Schkade, David A.、Viscusi, W. Kip(2002)。Punitive Damages: How Juries Decide。University of Chicago Press。  new window
9.Dobbs, Dan B.(1993)。Dobbs Law of Remedies: Damages-Equity-Restitution。West。  new window
10.Schlueter, Linda L.(2005)。Punitive Damages。  new window
其他
1.亞歷山大案提團體訴訟，http://www.appledaily.com.tw/appledaily/article/headline/20080123/30197240/， 2013/05/30。  new window
 
 
 
 
第一頁 上一頁 下一頁 最後一頁 top
:::
無相關博士論文
 
無相關書籍
 
無相關著作
 
QR Code
QRCODE

臺灣人文及社會科學引文索引資料庫

目前上線人數：427（臺灣：412，外國：15） ／ 本年度總使用人次：1348743 ／ 訪客人次（自102年09月）：67147538
國家圖書館著作權聲明 Copyright © 2013 All rights reserved.
本館地址: 100201臺北市中山南路20號． 本館地圖及交通資訊．
總機：(02)23619132．最佳瀏覽解析度為1024x768以上