:::

詳目顯示

回上一頁
題名:考慮屬性門檻與變異資料之多屬性效用方案評選模式
作者:周宏彥
作者(外文):Hung-Yen Chou
校院名稱:國立成功大學
系所名稱:交通管理學系碩博士班
指導教授:段良雄
學位類別:博士
出版日期:2003
主題關鍵詞:多屬性效用方案評選變異資料屬性門檻multi-attribute utilityproject evaluationvariability dataattribute thresholds
原始連結:連回原系統網址new window
相關次數:
  • 被引用次數被引用次數:期刊(0) 博士論文(1) 專書(0) 專書論文(0)
  • 排除自我引用排除自我引用:0
  • 共同引用共同引用:0
  • 點閱點閱:37
本研究利用敘述偏好數據建立多屬性效用模式進行運輸替選方案之評選,在模式的構建過程同時探討屬性的可接受門檻與無異門檻問題。研究結果發現利用線性羅機模式所建立之多屬性效用函數解釋能力尚可,大部分屬性均相當顯著。此結果表示利用敘述偏好數據建立多屬性效用模式確實可找出各屬性間的交互損益關係。
在考慮同一決策者之決策具一致性,而不同決策者間具異質性之假設下,所建立的可接受門檻或無異門檻模式均可大幅增加模式的解釋能力,由於大部分的屬性都有適用於部分決策者的可接受門檻或無異門檻,故對各屬性間的交互損益關係有相當大的影響。無異門檻模式的解釋能力優於可接受門檻模式。同時考慮兩種門檻的整合模式的解釋能力最佳,所有係數均相當顯著且符號正確,各屬性係數值間之交互損益關係也相當合理。
本研究對於具有變異資料之屬性以期望效用函數方式建立模式。當以全部樣本數建立模式時,發現考慮有變異資料之非線性函數型態並沒有較中間值線性函數佳。
依資料變異特性將樣本數分成不同群組,分別建立平均數及標準差指數模式與機率分配模式,實證發現分群後所建立之多屬性效用模式之解釋度較好。最後本研究以機率分配模式為基礎,考慮不同屬性間之資料變異特性,建立分群組後之多屬性效用方案評估模式,解釋能力非常好。但實際之決策偏好行為而言,決策者是否能依各個屬性之變異資料特性區分出風險偏好,需進一步探討。
本研究發現屬性門檻與不確定性資料均會影響決策之偏好選擇,對於兩者之處理方式本研究係採分開處理。未來可考慮兩者模式整併處理,以增加模式之解釋能力與應用價值。也就是屬性變異資料與屬性門檻整合模式之構建與處理問題,值得後續之研究。
This research established multi-attribute utility models with stated preference data to evaluate transportation projects. We discussed the attribute thresholds of acceptance and indifference. The results showed that the multi-attribute utility function of linear logit model had relatively good explanatory ability and most attributes were significant. This means that multi-attribute utility model established with stated preference data can indeed find the tradeoff between attributes.
Assuming that an individual should behave consistently and different individuals may behave heterogeneously, we found that the threshold models could greatly increase explanatory power. Due to the fact that most attributes had threshold of acceptance and/or indifference, the tradeoff between attributes were greatly affected. Of the two threshold models, the threshold of indifference model had better explanatory power. The integrated model with both thresholds had best explanatory power. Its coefficients of all attributes were significant and had the correct signs. The tradeoffs between attributes were reasonable.
The research also consider the variability data to estabilished the expected utility model. When using all the observation data to construct the utility models, we find several nonlinear models with variability data are not better than the linear model.
Assumption the observation samples can divide from several group using the senna theory and probability distribution model. The two multi-attribute utility models which be classified to several groups can increase the explanatory power. Finally, we take the probability distribution model as a foudation model that consider different attribute variability characteristics. The results show the model explanatory power is very well, but the decision-maker who can consider with several different attribute variability problem or not is the question for the further study.
The empirical results show each threshold or variability factor really influenced the decision preference choice. The research analyzed separately the two factor models. In the further, we can develop the integration model to increase the model explatory power and its values. In other words, developing the integration multi-attribute utility project evaluation model with both attribute threshold and variability problem is the direction for the next research.
國內文獻
1.王震武,訊息不確定性對選擇行為的影響,應用心理學報,第一期,頁1-20,民國81年.
2.江榮吉,不確定性經濟學,正大書局,民60年.
3.呂輝堂,投資計畫可行性評估原則與實務之探討,今日會計,第二十九期,頁58-83,民國75年.
4.李素凡,社會成本及社會效益衡量之方法,今日會計,第三十三期,頁77-84,民國76年.
5.林元興、劉文棚,地下水資源價值之研究-條件評價法之應用,臺灣土地金融季刊,第三十五卷,第三期,頁33-67,民國87年.
6.周宏彥,鐵路運輸投資政策之探討-以臺鐵購車計畫為例,臺灣經濟,第232期,頁42-59,民國85年.
7.段良雄、李奇,敘述偏好與顯示偏好模式之比較,運輸計劃季刊,第二十五卷,第二期,頁189-208,民國85年.new window
8.段良雄、劉慧燕,敘述偏好模式之實驗設計與校估方法,運輸計劃季刊,第二十五卷,第一期,頁1-44,民國85年.new window
9.段良雄、吳英亮,不可補償性運具選擇模式之研究,運輸計劃季刊,第十四卷,第二期,頁169-186,民國74年.new window
10.段良雄、張文中、楊志文,旅行時間不確定性對運具選擇之影響,Proceedings of the National Science Council (Part C),第8卷,第三期,頁435-449,民國87年.
11.段良雄、張淳智,結合可補償與不可補償決策規則的個體運具選擇模式,運輸計劃季刊,第二十卷,第四期,頁341-372,民國80年.new window
12.段良雄、張淳智、胡琬珮、劉怡慧,運具選擇無異門檻模式,運輸計畫季刊,第二十五卷,第四期,頁565-595,民國85年.new window
13.高凱聲,不確定情況下之決策,管理與資訊學報,第二期,頁23-53,民國86年.new window
14.姜渝生、王小娥、馮兆興,運輸投資使用者效益概估法與精確估計法之比較分析,運輸計劃季刊,第二十四卷,第二期,頁125-154,民國84年.new window
15.夏學理,分析式決策制定之量化研究,空大行政學報,五期,頁273-300,民國85年.
16.徐村和,運輸計劃評估─模糊量度AHP法,國家科學委員會,人文及社會科學,第七冊,第一期,頁26-34,民86年.
17.張新立、鍾志成,屬性門檻多項羅吉特模式之研究,運輸計劃季刊,第二十卷,第二期,頁103-126,民國80年.new window
18.張有恆,運輸經濟學-理論與實務,華泰,民國80年.
19.張有恆,運輸計畫評估與決策:模糊理論之探討與應用,華泰,民國87年.new window
20.張有恆、林秀璘、沈進成,應用模糊多目標規劃法於公車營運計劃之研究,模糊系統學刊,第三卷,第一期,頁65-80,民國86年.new window
21.康照宗、馮正民,交通基礎建設BOT契約之風險集合研究-多屬性風險效用函數之構建,交通運輸,第十七期,頁163-177,民國87年.
22.陳彥仲,結合不連續選擇理論及模糊集合論對住宅消費決策行為之研究,國科會專題研究計畫,民88年.
23.陳淑賢,群體決策在多項方案排序法之探討,臺中商專學報,二十九期,頁33-46,民國86年.
24.曾國雄、李穗玲,路線方案評選多目標決策之應用-以桃園都會區捷運路網選線為例,運輸計劃季刊,二十四卷三期,頁299-322,民國84年.new window
25.曾國雄、蕭再安,運輸路線選擇行為之研究-多屬性效用理論之應用,地理學研究,第十二期,頁173-188,民國77年.
26.曾國雄、鄧振源,運輸系統之評估:多屬性效用理論之應用,工程,第六十二卷,第四期,頁8-26,民國78年.
27.曾國雄、王日昌、邱怡璋,基準不一致個體資料之群落分析─多目標決策與模糊理論之應用,交通運輸,第十五期,頁1135-150,民國82年.
28.馮正民、江俊良,計畫評估方法之評述,規劃學報,第十五期,頁65-86,民國77年.new window
29.馮正民、呂秀玉,模糊方法在質化評估準則之運用,都市與計劃,第二十四卷,第一期,頁1-21,民國86年.
30.鄒克萬,屬性效用評估模式(EBAU)之發展,規劃學報,第十五期,頁117-134,民國77年.new window
31.衛婉倩,成本效益分析之研究,審計季刊,第7卷,第二期,頁20-23,民國76年.
32.鄧振源,多評準決策規劃方法之概念性分析,交通運輸,第十二期,頁131-163,民國79年.
33.鄧振源、曾國雄,多屬性效用理論之回顧及其在運輸投資規劃之應用,交通運輸,第十三期,頁173-200,民國80年.
34.賴世剛、許仁成,多屬性決策方法評估基礎之設計,建築與城鄉研究學報,八期,頁105-115,民國85年.new window
35.魏健宏、王勝石,多準則方案之評選─模糊集合理論與人工神經網路的應用,規劃學報,第二十二期,頁99-121,民國84年.new window
36.顏月珠,商用統計學,三民書局,民國74年.
37.高速鐵路工程籌備處,高速鐵路路線多元評析之研究,民國83年.
38.住都局,台南都會區大眾捷運系統規劃報告,民國82年,87年修訂版.
國外文獻
1.Adamowicz,W.,Swait,J.,Louviere,J. and Williams,M.(1997).Perceptions Versus Objective Measures of Environmental Quality in Combined Revealed and Stated Preference Models of Environmental Valuation, Journal of Environmental Economics and Management,32,65-84.
2.Alberinui,A.(1995).Testing Willingness-to-Pay Models of Discrete Choice Contingent Valuation Survey Data,Land Economics,83-95.
3.Analytics,H.(1994).Evaluating Core Values Regarding Transportation and Urban Form in Calgary Final Report on the Core Values Tradeoff Study,Report for the City of Calgary.
4.Azis,I.J.(1990).Analytic Hierarchy Process in The Benefit-Cost Framework:A Post-Evaluation of The Trans-Sumatra Highway Project,European of Operational Research,48,38-48.
5.Baird,B.F.(1989).Mamagerial Decision Under Uncertainty, John Wiley & Sons, New York.
6.Bates,J.(1988).Econometric Issues in States Preference Analysis,Journal of Transport Economics and Policy,22,59-69.
7.Barr,D.R. and Zehna,P.W.(1983).Probability:Modeling Uncertainty. Addison- Wesley, Reading,Mass.
8.Beggs,S.D. and Cardell,N.S.(1980).Choice of Smallest Car by Multi-Vehicle Households and The Demand for Electric Vehicles,Transportation Research 14A, 389-404.
9.Belton,V.(1986).A Comparison of The Analytic Hierarchy Process and a Simple Multi-attribute Value function, European Journal of Operational Research, 26, 7-21.
10.Ben-Akiva,M.E. and Lerman,S.R.(1985).Discrete Choice Analysis Theory and Application to Travel Demand,The MIT Press,Cambridge.
11.Bit,A.K.,Biswal,M.P. & Alam,S.S.(1992).Fuzzy Programming Approach to Multicriteria Decision Making Transportation Problem,Fuzzy Sets and Systems, 50,135-141.
12.Black,I.G. and Towriss,J.G.(1990).Quantifying The Value of Uncertainty in Travel Time, PTRC 18th Summer Annual Meeting,259-268.
13.Brans,J.P. and Mareschal,B.and Vincke,P.(1984).PROMETHEE:A New Family of Outranking Methods in Multicriteria Analysis Operational Research,North- Holland, Amsterdam.
14.Brent,R.J.(1996).Applied Cost-Benefit Analysis,Edward Elgar, Great Britain.
15.Briggs,T.,Kunsch,P. and Mareachaal,B.(1990).Nuclear Waste Management:An Application of the Multicriteria PROMETHEE Methods, European Journal of Operational Research,4,1-10.
16.Brucker,K.,Winne,N.,Peeters,C.,Verbeke,A. and Winkelmans,W.(1995).The Economic Evaluation of Public Investments in Transport Infrastructure:The Use of Multicriteria Analysis,International Journal of Transport Economics,12,3, 261-281.
17.Buede,D M.(1986).Structuring Value Attributes,Interfaces,16,2,52-62.
18.Chapman,R.G. and Staelin,R.(1982).Exploiting Rank Ordered Choice Set Data Within the Stochastic Utility Model,Journal of Marketing Research,288-301.
19.Chun,Y.H.(1996).On the Rank-Based Selection Strategy for the Group Interview Problem,Decision Sciences,27,4,801-815.
20.Currie,J.M.,Murphy,J.A. and Schmitz,A.(1971).The Concept of Economic Surplus and Its Use in Economic Analysis,The Economic Journal,81,741-799.
21.Daniels,R.F. and Hensher,D.A.(2000).Valuation of Environmental Impacts of Transport Projects,Journal of Transport Economics and Policy,34,2,189-214.
22.Danielson,M. and Ekenberg,L.(1998).A Framework for Analysing Decision Under Risk,European Journal of Operational Research,104,474-484.
23.Dequech,D.(1999).Expectations and Confidence Under Uncertainty, Journal of Post Keynesian Economics,21,3,415-430.
24.Dyer,J.S and Sarin,R.K.(1979).Measurable Multiattribute Value Function, Operations Research,27,4,811-821.
25.Dyer,J.S.(1990).Remarks on The Analytic Hierarchy Process, Management Science, 36,3,249-258.
26.Dyer,J.S.(1992).Multiple Criteria Decision Making,Multiattribute Utility Theory: The Next Ten Years, Management Science,38,5,645-654.
27.Dyer,J.S. and Jia,J.(1997).Relative Risk-Value Models,European Journal of Operational Research,103,170-185.
28.Edwards,W.(1992).Utility Theories:Measurements and Applications, Kluwer Acadmic, Boston.
29.Fandel,G. and Gal,T.(1997).Multiple Criteria Decision Making,Springer, Berlin.
30.Fishburn,P.C.(1970).Utility Theory for Decision Making,John Wiley & Sons,New York.
31.Fowkes,T. and Wardman,M.(1993).Non-orthogonal Stated Preference Design, Proceedings of PTRC 21st Summer Annual Meeting, Seminar D,91-97.
32.Gastaldi, M., Pradayrol, J.P., Quinet,E and Rega, M.(1996). Valuation of nvironmental Externalities: From Theory to Decision-Making, Transportation Planning and Technology,19,207-219.
33.Garrido,R.A. and Ortuzar,J.D.(1994).Deriving Public Transport Level of Service Weights from a Multiple Comparison of Latent and Observable Variables, Operational Research Society,45,10,1099-1107.
34.Glazer,A. and Niskanen,E.(1991).Measuring the Benefits Derived From a Transportation Investment—a Comment,Transportation Research, 25B,6,413-419.
35.Goicoechea,A.,Hansen,D.R. and Duchstein,L.(1982).Multiobjective Decision Analysis with Engineering and Business Applications,John Wiley and Sons,New York.
36.Gomes,L.A.(1989).Multicriteria Ranking of Urban Transportation System Alternatives,Journal of Advanced Transportation,23,1,43-52.
37.Gomes,L.A.(1990).Eliminating Rank Reversal in Multicriteria Analysis of Urban Transportation System Alternatives,Journal of Advanced Transportation,24,2, 181-184.
38.Hayashi,Y. and Morisugi,H.(2000).International Comparison of Background Concept and Methodology of Transportation Project Appraisal, Transport Policy, 7,73-88.
39.Green,P.E. and Srinivasan,V.(1978).Conjoint Analysis in Consumer Research: Issues and Outlook,Journal of Consumer Research,5,103-123.
40.Hensher,D.A.,Barnard,P.O. and Troung,T.P.(1988).The Role of Stated Preference Methods in Studies of Travel Choice,Journal of Transport Economics and Policy, 22,45-58.
41.Hensher,D.A.(1994).Stated Preference Analysis of Travel Choice:the State of Practice, Transportation,21,107-133.
42.Hill,M.(1968).A Goals-Achievement Matrix for Evaluating Alternative Plans, Journal of the American Institute of Planners,34,1,19-29.
43.Hill,M.(1973).Planning for Multiple Objectives:An Approach to the Evaluation of Transportation Plans,Regional Science Research Institute.
44.Hwang,C.L. and Yoon,K.(1981).Multiple Attribute Decision Making Methods and Application,Springer-Verlag,New York.
45.Johansson,P.O.(1990).Valuing Environmental Damage,Oxford Review of Economic Policy,61,1,34-50.
46.Jones-Lee,M.W.(1989).The Economics of Safety and Physical Risk,Oxford,Basil Blackwell.
47.Kain,J.F.(1997).Cost-Effective Alternatives to Atlanta’s Rail Rapid Transit System,Journal of Transport Economics and Policy,32,25-49.
48.Keeney,R.L.(1973).A Decision Analysis with Multiple Objectives:the Mexico City Airport,The Bell Journal of Economics and Management Science, 4,1,101-117.
49.Keeney,R.L. & Raiffa,H.(1976).Decision with Multiple Objectives:Preference and Value Trade Offs,John Wiley & Sons,New York.
50.Keeney,R.L.(1994).Using Values in Operations Research,Operations Research Society of America,42,5,793-813.
51.Kohli,K.N.(1993).Economic Analysis of Investment Projects — A Practical Approach ,Oxford University Press,Hong Kong.
52.Kolfoort,P. and Nijkamp,P.(1977).Multiple-Criteria Interview Method in de Ruintelijke Planning, Research Memorandum, 60, Economic Faculty, free University, Amsterdam.
53.Koppelman,F.S.(1981),Non-Linear Utility Function in Models of Travel Choice Behavior,Traansportation,10,127-146.
54.Krishnan,K.S.(1977).Incorporating Thresholds of Indifference in Probabilistic Choice Models, Management Science,23,11,1224-1233.
55.Kroes,E.P. and Sheldon,R.J.(1988).Stated Preference Methods:An Introduction, Journal of Economics and Policy, 22,11-25.
56.Layard,R. and Glaister,S.(1996).Cost-Benefit Analysis,Cambridge University Press.
57.Lee Jr,D.B.(2000).Methods for Evaluation of Transportation Projects in the USA,Transport Policy,7,41-50.
58.Lioukas,S.K.(1984)Threshold and Transitivity in Seo-chastic Consumer Choice:A Multinomial Logit Analysis,Management Science,30,1,110-122.
59.Louviere,J.J.(1988).Conjoint Analysis Modelling of Stated Preference:a Review of Theory,Methods,Recent Developments and External Validity,Journal of Transport Economics and Policy,22,93-119.
60.Louriere,J.J. and Hensher,D.A.(1982).On the Deign and Analsis of Simulated Choice or Allocation Experiment in Travel Choice Modeling,Transportion Research Record,890,11-17.
61.Louviere,J.J. and Woodeorth,G.(1983).Design and Analysis of Simulated Consumer Choice or Allocation Experiments:an Approach Based On Aggregate Data,Journal of Marketing Research,20,350-367.
62.McFadden,D.(1973).Conditional Logit Analysis and Qualitative Choice Behavior, Zarembka Academic,New York.
63.McFadden,D.(1975).The Revealed Preference of a Government Bureaucracy:Theory, The Bell Journal of Economics,6,2,401-716.
64.McFadden,D.(1976).The Revealed Preference of a Government Bureaucracy: Empirical Evidence, The Bell Journal of Economics,7,2,55-72.
65.Mekky,A.(1998).Using Travel Demand Models and Pairwise Comparisons to Evaluate Alternative Transportation Networks in Niagara, Transportation Research Record,1645,41-51.
66.Menashe,E. and Guttman,J.M.(1986).Uncertainty,Continuous Modal Split and the Value of Travel Time in Israel,Journal of Transport Economics and Policy, 20,368-375.
67.Mishan,E.J.(1988).Cost-Benefit Analysis:An Informal Introduction,4th ed,Unwin Hyman,London.
68.Mollaghasemi,M. and Pet,E.J.(1997).Making Multiple-Objective Decision, IEEE Computer Society Press,LA.
69.Morisugi,H.,Miyatake,N. and Katoh,A.(1981).Measurement of Road User Benefits by Means of Multi-Attribute Utility Function,Papers of the Regional Association, 46,31-34.
70.Morisugi,H.(2000).Evaluation Methodologies of Transportation Projects in Japan, Transport Policy,7,35-40.
71.Morgan,M.G. and Henrion,M.(1990).Uncertainty:A Guide to Dealing with Uncertaainty in Quantitative Risk and Policy Analysis,Cambridge university Press,New York.
72.Nijkamp,P. and Voogd.(1983).An Informal Introduction to Multicriteria Evalution.
73.Nwaneri,V.C.(1970).Equity in Cost-Benefit Analysis:A Case Study of the Third London Airport,Journal of Transport Economics and Policy,4,3,235-254.
74.Odeck,J.(1996).Ranking of Regional Road Investment in Norway, Transportation, 23,123-140.
75.Oppewal,H.,Louviere,J.J. and Timmermans,H.J.P.(1994).Modeling Hierarchical Conjoint Processes With Integrated Choice Experiments, Journal of Marketing Research,16,92-105.
76.Paelinck,J.H.P.(1977).Qualitative Multiple Criteria Analysis:An Application to Airport Location Environment and Planning,9,883-895.
77.Pearman, A.D.,Mackie, P.J.,May, A.D. and Simon, D.(1989).The Use of Multicriteria Techniques to Rank Highway Investment Proposals,in Lockett,A.G. and Islei,G.(eds.),Improving Decision Making in Organizations, Springer-Berlag, London, 157-165.
78.Quinet,E.(2000).Evaluation Methodologies of Transportation Projects in France, Transport Policy,7,27-34.
79.Randall,A.,Hoehn,J.P.,and Brookshire,D.S.(1983).Contingent Valuation Surveys for Evaluating Environmental Assets,Natural Resources Journal,23,635-648.
80.Restle,F.(1961).Psychology of Judgement and Choice,Wiley,New York.
81.Roe,M.(1987).Evaluation Methodoligies for Transport Investment, Avebury, Aldershot.
82.Rothengatter,W.(2000).Evaluation of Infrastructure in Germany, Transport Policy, 7,17-25.
83.Roy, B. and Vincke, P.(1984).Relational Systems of Preference with One or More Pseudo-Criteria: Some New Concepts and Results, Management Science, 30, 1325-1335.
84.Roy,B.(1971).Problems and Methods with Multiple Objective Functions, Mathematical Programming,1,2,239-266.
85.Saaty,T.L.(1977).Ascaling Method for Priorities in Hierarchical Structure, J.Math.Psychology,115,234-281.
86.Saaty,T.L.(1986).Axiomatic Foundation of the Analytic Hierarchy Process, Management Science,32,841-855.
87.Saaty,T.L.(1994).How to Make a Decision: The analytic Hierarchy Process, Interfaces, 24,6,19-43.
88.Salminen,P.,Hokkanen,J. and Lahdelma,R.(1998).Comparing Multicriteria Methods in the Context of Environmental Problems,European Journal of Operational Research,104,485-496.
89.Schlager,K.(1968),The Rank Based Expected Value Method of Plan Evaluation, Highway Research Record,238,Washington DC.
90.Schoemaker,P.J.H. and Waid,C.(1982).An Experimental Comparison of Different Approaches to Determining Weights in Additive Utility Models, Management Science, 28,2,182-196.
91.Schofield,J.A.(1987).Cost-Benefit Analysis in Urban & Regional Planning,Allen & Unwin,London.
92.Seiler,K.(1969).Introduction to Systems Cost-effectiveness, Willey-Interscience, New York.
93.Senna,L.A.D.S.(1991).Risk of Delays,Uncertainty and Travellers’ Valuation of Travel Time Variability,PTRC 19th Summer Annual Meeting,265-275.
94.Senna,L.A.D.S.(1994).The Influence of Travel Time Variability on The Value of Time, Transportation,21,203-228.
95.Sheldon,N.W.(1973).The Economic and Social Impact of Investments in Public Transit,Heath and Compancy,D.C.
96.Solymosi,T. and Dombi,J.(1986).A Method for Determining The Weights of Criteria:The Centralized Weights,European Journal of Operational Research, 26,35-41.
97.Souza,P.D.,Everett,J.,Gardner,B. and Culp,M.(1997).Total Cost Analysis:An Alternative to Benefit-cost Analysis in Evaluating Transportation Alternatives, Transportation, 24,107-123.
98.Souza,P.D.,Cohen,H.,Haling,D and Hunt,J.(1998).Using STEAM for Benefit-Cost Analysis of Transportation Alternatives, Transportation Research Record, 1649,63-71.
99.Stam,A. and Silva,A.P.D.(1997).Stochastic Judgments in the AHP:The Measurement of Rank Reversal Probabilities, Decision Sciences,28,3, 655-687.
100.Teng,J.Y. and Tzeng,G.h.(1996).Fuzzy Multicriteria Ranking of Urban Transportation Investment Alternatives,Transportation Planning and Technology, 20,15-31.
101.Tsamboulas,D.,Yiotis,G.S. and Panou,K.D.(1999).Use of Multicriteria Methods for Assessment of Transport Projects,Journal of Transportation Engineering, 125, 5, 407-414.
102.Tversky,A.(1972).Elimination by Aspects:A Theory of Choice, Psychological Review, 79,4,281-299.
103.Tzeng,G.h. and Teng,J.Y.(1993).Transportation Investment Project Selection with Fuzzy Multiobjectives,Transportation Planning and Technology,17,91-112.
104.Vickerman,R.(2000).Evaluation Methodologies for Transport Projects in the United Kingdom,Transport Policy,7,7-16.
105.Voogd,H.(1983).Mlticriteria Evaluation for Urban and Regional Planning,Page Bros,Great Britain.
106.Winkler,R.L.(1990).Decision Modeling and Rational Choice:AHP and Utility Theory, 36,3,247-248.
107.Williams,A.(1983).Cost-Benefit Analysis:Bastard Science?And/Or Insidious Poison in the Body Politick,in Haveman,R.J. and Margolis,J.(eds),Public Expenditures and Policy Analysis(3rd edn),Boston.
108.Willig,R.D.(1976).Consumer’s Surplus Without Apology,American Economic Review,66,589-597.
109.Won,J.(1990).Multicriteria Evaluation Approaches to Urban Transportation Projects,Urban Studies,27,1,119-138.
110.Young,W. and Bertran,D.(1985).Attribute Thresholds and Logit Mode Choice Models,Transportation Research Record,1037,153-170.
111.Zahedi,F(1986).The Analtic Hierarchy Process - a Survey of The Method and its Applications,Interfaces,16,4,96-108.
112.Zhu,S.H. and Anderson,N.H.(1991).Self-Estimation of Weight Parameter in Multiattribute Analysis, Oroganizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 48,36-54.
 
 
 
 
第一頁 上一頁 下一頁 最後一頁 top
:::
無相關著作
 
無相關點閱
 
QR Code
QRCODE