:::

詳目顯示

回上一頁
題名:獨立機關治理結構與過程之研究
書刊名:中國行政評論
作者:王曉麟
作者(外文):Wang, Hsiao-lin
出版日期:2017
卷期:23:1
頁次:頁1-33
主題關鍵詞:管制型國家獨立管制委員會獨立機關治理結構治理過程Regulatory stateIndependent regulatory commissionIndependent agencyGovernance structureGovernance process
原始連結:連回原系統網址new window
相關次數:
  • 被引用次數被引用次數:期刊(0) 博士論文(1) 專書(0) 專書論文(0)
  • 排除自我引用排除自我引用:0
  • 共同引用共同引用:369
  • 點閱點閱:34
自美國於1887年創設州際商務委員會以來,歷經20世紀歐洲管制型國家的興起,此種以美國獨立管制委員會為發展原型的獨立機關,業已成為世界各國管制革新與政府再造之主要制度設計與制度選擇。我國以行政院組織改造為主軸的政府再造亦襲用之,成立國家通訊傳播委員會、公平交易委員會、中央選舉委員會等三個獨立機關,確立通訊傳播、公平交易、選舉行政為我國三大獨立管制行政領域。獨立機關在全球發展已有超過百年的歷史,但是研究者迄今仍在試圖瞭解其與政府行政機關間之關係,而且獨立機關主要任務為進行政治、經濟、社會管制,各種管制之性質與對象皆不相同,如何選擇與設計組織之結構與過程,對於組織特定功能的發揮極為重要。鑒於獨立機關研究之方興未艾,本文爰探討獨立機關之治理結構與治理過程,並省思我國獨立機關之發展經驗。
Independent Agency which take United States Independent Regulatory Commission as developmental prototype already became the main institutional design and institutional choice of regulatory reform and reinventing government all over the world since United States set up Interstate Commerce Commission in 1887 and gone through the rise of regulatory state of European countries in 20th century. The reinventing government which take Executive Yuan organizational reform as principal axis take over it and established three independent agencies that are National Communication Commission, Fair Trade Commission and Central Election Commission, identify communication, fair trade and election administration are three independent administration governance domains in Taiwan. The independent agency has been around for 100 years now, but we are still trying to understand how it best relates to the administration of government and the main tasks of independent agencies to carry out political, economic and social control. The objects and natures are various neither the same on structures and processes. How to select and design organizations are very important to specific functions of organizations. In view of the research of independent agencies are still growing, this article discuss the governance structures and processes of independent agency, and reflection off the development experience of our independence agencies in Taiwan.
期刊論文
1.Caulfield, J.、Peters, B. G.、Bouckaert, G.(2006)。Symposium on the Diffusion of the Agency Model: Guest Editors' Preface。Public Administration and Development,26(1),1-2。  new window
2.Thatcher, M.、Sweet, A. Stone(2002)。Theory and Practice of Delegation to Non-majoritarian Institutions。West European Politics,25(1),1-22。  new window
3.Yesilkagit, K.(2004)。The design of public agencies: Overcoming agency costs and commitment problems。Public Administration and Development,24(2),119-127。  new window
4.Sunstein, Cass R.(1990)。Paradoxes of the regulatory state。University of Chicago Law Review,57,407-441。  new window
5.Gilardi, F.(2005)。The Institutional Foundations of Regulatory Capitalism: The Diffusion of Independent Regulatory Agencies in Western Europe。The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science,598(1),84-101。  new window
6.Majone, G.(2001)。Two Logics of Delegation: Agency and Fiduciary Relations in EU Governance。European Union Politics,2(1),103-122。  new window
7.Sudo, S.(2003)。Regional Governance and East and Southeast Asia: Towards the Regulatory State?。Japanese Journal of Political Science,4(2),331-347。  new window
8.Thatcher, M.(2002)。Analysing Regulatory Reform in Europe。Journal of European Public Policy,9(6),859-872。  new window
9.廖俊松(2009)。全球化觀點下的政府治理。T&D飛訊,79,1-31。  延伸查詢new window
10.Aaken, A. V.(2009)。Independent Electoral Management Bodies and International Election Observer Missions: Any Impact on the Oservered Level of Democracy ? A Conceptual Framework。Constitutional Political Economy,20(3/4),296-322。  new window
11.Coen, D.、Thatcher, M.(2005)。The New Governance of Markerts and Non- Majoritarian Regulators。Governance: An International Journal of Policy, Administration and Institutions,18(3),329-346。  new window
12.Foote, Susan Bartlett(1988)。Independent Agencies Under Attack: A Skeptical View of the Importance of the Debate。Duke Law Journal,1988(2/3),223-237。  new window
13.de Francesco, F.(2012)。Diffusion of Regulatory Impact Analysis Among OECD and EU Member States。Comparative Political Studies,45(10),1277-1305。  new window
14.Glaeser, L. E.、Shleifer, A.(2001)。The Rise of the Regulatory State。Journal of Economic Literature,41(2),401-425。  new window
15.Jordana, Jacint、Levi-Faur, David、Fernández i Marín, Xavier(2011)。The Global Diffusion of Regulatory Agencies: Channels of Transfer and Stages of Diffusion。Comparative Political Studies,44(10),1343-1369。  new window
16.Majone, G.(1997)。Frome the Positive to the Regulatory State: Causes and Consequences of Changes in the Mode of Governance。Journal of Public Policy,17(2),139-167。  new window
17.McGowan, F.、Wallace, H. H.(1996)。Towards a European Regulatory State。Journal of European Public Policy,3(4),560-576。  new window
18.Miller, G. P.(1986)。Independent Agencies。Supreme Court Review,1986,41-97。  new window
19.Moran, G.(2001)。The Rise of Regulatory State in Britain。Parliamentary Affairs,54(1),19-34。  new window
20.Braithwaite, J.(2000)。The New Regulatory State and the Transformation of Criminology。Biritish Journal of Criminology,40(2),222-238。  new window
21.Esping-Andersen, G.(1997)。Hybrid or Unique?: The Japanese Welfare State between Europe and America。Journal of European Social Policy,7(3),179-189。  new window
22.Levi-Faur, D.(2005)。The Global Diffusion of Regulatory Capitalism。The ANNALS of the American Academy of Political and Social Science,598(1),112-132。  new window
23.Majone, G.(2001)。Nonmajoritarian Institutions and the Limits of Democratic Governance: A Political Transaction-cost approach。Journal of Theoretical and Institutional Economics,157(1),57-78。  new window
24.Stern, J.(1997)。What Makes an Independent Regulatory Independent?。Business Stategy Review,8(2),67-74。  new window
25.Verkuil, P. R.(1988)。The Purposes and Limits of Independent Agencies。Duke Law Journal,1988(2/3),257-279。  new window
26.Viscusi, W. K.(1995)。Careinogen Regulation: Risk Characteristics and the Synthetics Risk Bias。American Economic Review,85(21),50-54。  new window
27.Yamomoto, K.(2006)。Performance of Semi-Autonomous Public Bodies: Linkage Between Autonomy and Performance in Japanese Agencies。Public Administration and Development,26(1),35-44。  new window
28.Posner, Richard A.(1974)。Theories of Economic Regulation。Bell Journal of Economics and Management Science,5(2),335-358。  new window
29.Shapiro, M.(1997)。The Problems of Independent Agencies in the United States and the European Union。Journal of European Public Policy,4(2),276-291。  new window
30.Thatcher, M.(2002)。Regulation after Delegation: Independent Regulatory Agencies in Europe。Journal of European Public Policy,9(6),954-972。  new window
31.鄭為元(19990600)。發展型「國家」或發展型國家「理論」的終結?。臺灣社會研究季刊,34,1-68。new window  延伸查詢new window
32.Majone, Giandomenico(1999)。The Regulatory State and Its Legitimacy Problems。West European Politics,22(1),1-24。  new window
33.Moe, T. M.(1990)。Political Institutions: The Neglected Side of the Story。Journal of Law, Economics, and Organization,6,213-261。  new window
34.Williamson, Oliver E.(1988)。Corporate Finance and Corporate Governance。The Journal of Finance,43(3),567-591。  new window
35.Stigler, George J.(1971)。The Theory of Economic Regulation。The Bell Journal of Economics and Management Science,2(1),3-21。  new window
36.Döhler, Marian(2002)。Institutional Choice and Bureaucratic Autonomy in Germany。West Europenan Politics,25(1),101-124。  new window
37.Moe, Terry M.(1984)。The New Economics of Organization。American Journal of Political Science,28(4),739-777。  new window
38.Hall, Richard H.(1963)。The concept of bureaucracy: An empirical assessment。American Journal of Sociology,69(1),32-40。  new window
39.Gilardi, F.(2002)。Policy Credibility and Delegation to Independent Regulatory Agencies: A Comparative Empirical Analysis。Journal of European Public Policy,9(6),873-893。  new window
40.Majone, G.(1994)。The Rise of the Regulatory States in Europe。West Europran Politics,17(3),77-101。  new window
41.Hood, Christopher(1991)。A Public Management for All Seasons?。Public Administration,69(1),3-19。  new window
42.Crawford, Sue E. S.、Ostrom, Elinor(1995)。A Grammar of Institutions。American Political Science Review,89(3),582-600。  new window
43.陳尚懋(20070300)。臺灣金融改革的政治分析:ACTA模型的檢驗。東吳政治學報,25(1),115-160。new window  延伸查詢new window
44.孫煒(20080300)。民主治理與非多數機構:公民社會的觀點。公共行政學報,26,1-35。new window  延伸查詢new window
45.Moe, Terry M.(1991)。Politics and the Theory of Organization。The Journal of Law, Economics, and Organization,7(3),106-129。  new window
會議論文
1.吳秦雯(2009)。從法國法論獨立機關於行政爭訟之地位。行政院98年度法制研討會。臺北:行政院法規委員會。149-206。  延伸查詢new window
2.孫煒(2007)。由授權理論分析獨立機關:兼論對於我國政府改造的啟示。「獨立行政機關之研究」研討會,台大政治系、中華民國憲法學會、台大政府與公共事務研究中心 。臺北。  延伸查詢new window
3.陳淳文(2007)。從法國法論獨立行政機關。獨立行政機關之研究研討會,國立台灣大學政治學系、中華民國憲法學會、台灣大學政治學系政府與公共事務研究中心(合辦) (會議日期: 民國96年9月29日)。臺北。  延伸查詢new window
4.Baudrier, A.(2001)。Independent Regulation and Telecommunications Performance in Developing Countries。Annual Conference of the International Society for New Institutional Economics,(會議日期: 2001/09/13-09/15)。Berkeley。  new window
5.Bugaric, B.(2009)。Toward a New Regulatory State in Europe: Variety of Models or Convergence?。The Aannual Meeting of The Law and Society,(會議日期: May 25, 2009)。Las Vegas。  new window
6.Dacey, P.(2005)。What Do 'Impartiality', 'Independence' and 'Transparency' Mean?- Some Thoughts from Australia。The Improving the Quality of Election Management Conference of Commonwealth Chief Election Officers,(會議日期: 2005/02/24-02/26)。New Delhi。  new window
7.Genoud, C.(2003)。Regulation as a Game: The Role of Independent Regulatory Agencies in the Regulatory Process。The CARR Risk and Regulation Research Student Conference at the London School of Economics and Political Science,(會議日期: 2003/09/18-09/19)。London。  new window
8.Gilardi, F.(2001)。Delegation of Regulatory Competencies to Independent Agencies: A Comparative Empirical Consideration。The ECPR Joint Sessions of Workshops,(會議日期: 2001/04/06-04/11)。Grenoble。  new window
9.Gilardi, F.(2003)。Spurious and Symbolic Diffusion of Independent Regulatory Authories in Westetn Europe。Workshop for The Internationalization of Regulatory Reforms,(會議日期: 2003/04/25-04/26)。University Califomia Berkeley。  new window
10.Gilardi, F.(2003)。Delegation to Independent Regulatory Agencies in Western Europe: A Cross-Sectional Comparison。Delegation in Contemporary Democracies, ECPR Joint Sessions of Workshops,(會議日期: 2003/03/29-04/02)。Edinburgh。  new window
11.Gilardi, F.(2003)。Evaluating Independent Regulators。Paris:OECD。  new window
12.Jacobzone, S.(2005)。Independent Regulatory Authorities in OECD Countries: An Overview。OECD。  new window
13.Laegreid, P.、Rolland, V. W.、Roness, P. G.、Agotnes, E.(2003)。The Structural Autonomy of the Norwegian State 1947-2003。The Seminar on Organizational Forms, Autonomy and Control in the Public Sector,(會議日期: 2003/12/01-12/02)。Bergen。  new window
14.胡至沛(2007)。建構良善的政府管制治理。「2007,TASPAA年會暨第三屆兩岸四地公共管理」學術研討會,世新大學行政管理學系(主辦) 。臺北。  延伸查詢new window
15.Sosay, G.(2007)。Embedding Independent Regulatory Agencies into Administrative Traditions: Acceptance or Resistance?。2007 Annual Conference of the European Consottium for Political Research,(會議日期: 2007/09/06-09/08)。Pisa。  new window
16.Gilardi, F.(2003)。Functionalists and Non-Functionalist Logics of Diffusion: Delegation to Indeprndrnt Regulatory Agencies in Western Europe。Workshop for The Politics of Regulation,(會議日期: 2003/11/29-11/30)。Barcelona。  new window
研究報告
1.劉孔中(2009)。美、英、德、新獨立機關之研究。行政院研究發展考核委員會。  延伸查詢new window
2.張其祿(2009)。獨立管制機關「獨立性」與「課責性」之研究。  延伸查詢new window
3.Andres, L.、Guasch, J. L.、Diop, M.、Azumendi, S. L.(2007)。Assessing the Governance of Electricity Regulatory Agencies in Latin America and Caribbean Region: A Benchmarking Analysis。Washington, D.C.:World Bank。  new window
4.Gilardi, F.、Jordana, J.、Levi-Faur, D.(2006)。Regulation in the Age of Globalization: The Diffusion of Regulatory Agencies Across Europe and Latin America。  new window
5.Stern, J.、Cubbin, J.(2005)。Regulatory Effectiveness: The Impact of Regulation and Regulatory Governance Arrangements on Electricity Industry Outcomes。Washington D.C.:The World Bank。  new window
學位論文
1.Gheventer, A.(2003)。Autonomia versus Controle: Origens do novo marco regulatório antitruste na América Latina e seus efeitos sobre a democracia(博士論文)。Instituto Universitário de Pesquisas do Rio de Janeiro。  new window
圖書
1.Pierce, Richard J.、Shapiro, Sidney A.、Verkuil, Paul R.(1992)。Administrative Law and Process。Foundation Press。  new window
2.Morrison, Ken(1995)。Marx, Durkhem Weber: Formations of Modern Social Thought。Sage Publications。  new window
3.余雪明(2006)。司法院釋字第613號解釋余雪明大法官之協同意見書。臺北:司法院。  延伸查詢new window
4.國家通訊傳播委員會(2010)。99年度獨立機關運作之回顧與前瞻研討會會議資料。臺北:國家通訊傳播委員會。  延伸查詢new window
5.張世賢、陳恆鈞(2010)。比較政府。臺北:五南圖書出版股份有限公司。  延伸查詢new window
6.Knot, J. H.、Miller, G. J.、黃榮護(2006)。政府改造:公共組織選擇的政治。臺北:雙葉書廊有限公司。  延伸查詢new window
7.Alston, L. J.(1996)。Empirical Studies in Institutional Change。Cambridge:Cambridge University Press。  new window
8.Bond, J. R.、Smith, K. B.(2010)。The Promise and Performance of American Democracy。Moston:Wadsworth。  new window
9.Breyer, S.(1990)。Regulation and its Reform。Cambridge MA:Harvard University Press。  new window
10.Havard, W. C.(1965)。Government and Politics of the United States。New York:Haper and Row。  new window
11.Jordana, J.、Levi-Faur, D.(2004)。The Politics for Regulation: Institutions and Regulatory Reforms for the Age of Governance。New York:Edward Elgar Publishing。  new window
12.McConkey, M.(2003)。Thinking Regulation: A Roadmap to the Recent Periodical Literature。Tornto:Institute of Public Administration in Canada。  new window
13.OECD(2002)。Regulatory Policies in OCDE Countries: From Interventionism to Regulatory Governance。Paris:OECD。  new window
14.OECD(2005)。Desiging Independent and Accountable Regulatory Authorities for High Quality Regulation。Paris:OECD。  new window
15.Oliveira, G.、Machado, E. L.、Novaes, L. M.、Ferreira, C. B. G.(2005)。Aspects of the Independence of Regulatory Agencies and Competition Advocacy。Sao Paulo:The Competition Policy Implementation Working Group。  new window
16.Brinton, Mary C.、Nee, Victor(1998)。The New Institutionalism in Sociology。New York:Russell Sage Foundation。  new window
17.Dietrich, Michael(1994)。Transaction Cost Economics and Beyond: Towards a New Economics of the Firm。London:Routledge。  new window
18.Hassard, John、Parker, Martin(1993)。Postmodernism and Organizations。SAGE Publications。  new window
19.Majone, G.(1990)。Deregulation or Re-regulation? Regulatory Reform in Europe and the United States。New York:St. Martin's Press。  new window
20.Thatcher, M.(2002)。Delegation to Independent Regulatory Agencies in Western Europe。Massachusetts:Edward Elgar Publishing, Inc。  new window
21.Verhoest, K.、Roness, P. G.、Verschuere, B.、Rubecksen, K.、MacCarthaigk, M.(2010)。Autonomy and Control of State Agencies: Comparing States and Agencies。New York:Palgrave MacMillan。  new window
22.Hood, C.、Scott, C.、James, O.、Travers, T.、Jones, G.(1999)。Regulation Inside Government。Oxford:Oxford University Press。  new window
23.Christensen, T.、Lӕgreid, P.(2006)。Autonomy and Regulation Coping with Agencies in the Modern State。Edward Elgar。  new window
24.Jessop, Bob(2002)。The Future of the Capitalist State。Polity Press。  new window
25.Pfiffner, J. M.、Presthus, R. V.(1967)。Public Administration。New York:Ronald。  new window
26.Horn, Murry J.(1995)。The Political Economy of Public Administration。Cambridge University Press。  new window
27.Rhodes, R. A. W.(1997)。Understanding governance Policy networks, government, reflexivity and accountability。Buckingham, England:Open University Press。  new window
28.Williamson, Oliver E.(1975)。Markets and hierarchies: Analysis and antitrust implication。New York:Free Press。  new window
29.Pierre, Jon、Peters, B. Guy、謝宗學、孫本初(2002)。治理、政治與國家。台北市:智勝文化事業公司。  延伸查詢new window
30.Pierre, Jon、Peters, Brainard Guy(2000)。Governance, Politics and the State。Palgrave Macmillan。  new window
31.Johnson, Chalmers(1982)。MITI and the Japanese Miracles: The Growth of Industrial Policy, 1925-1975。Stanford University Press。  new window
32.Williamson, Oliver E.(1986)。Economic Organization: Firms, Markets, and Policy Control。New York:New York University Press。  new window
33.Brown, A. C.、Stern, J.、Tenenbaum, B.、Gencer, D.(2006)。Handbook for Evaluating Infrastructure Regulatory Systems。Washington, D.C.:World Bank Publications。  new window
34.Levy, B.、Spiller, P.(1996)。Regulations, Institutions, and Commitment: Comparative Studies in Telecommunications。London:Cambridge University Press。  new window
35.Rosenbloom, D. H.、Kravchuk, R. S.(1998)。Public administration: understanding management, politics, and law in the public sector。New York:McGraw-Hill Companies。  new window
36.Williamson, Oliver E.(1985)。The Economic Institutions of Capitalism。Free Press。  new window
37.吳瓊恩(1998)。行政學。台北:三民書局。  延伸查詢new window
38.Eggertsson, Thráinn(1990)。Economic Behavior and Institutions。Cambridge University Press。  new window
39.North, Douglass C.(1981)。Structure and Change in Economic History。W. W. Norton & Company, Inc.。  new window
40.孫本初(2005)。公共管理。台北:智勝。new window  延伸查詢new window
41.蘇永欽(20080000)。尋找共和國。臺北市:元照出版社。new window  延伸查詢new window
42.North, Douglas C.(1990)。Institutions, Institutional Change And Eccnomic Performance。Cambridge:Cambridge University Press。  new window
單篇論文
1.李英明(2002)。資訊時代下的「國家」與「社會」,臺北:財團法人國家政策研究基金會。(內政(研)091-024號)。  延伸查詢new window
2.Estache, A.,Rossi, M.(2007)。Regulatory Agencies: Impact on Firm Performance and Consumer Welfare,Washington, D.C.:The World Bank。  new window
其他
1.Center for Competition, Investment and Economic Regulation(2007)。Political Economy Constraints in Regulatory Regime in Developing Countries,http://www.cuts-ccier.org/pdf/RL-INSERT-1-07.pdf, 2012/09/01。  new window
2.Center for Competition, Investment and Economic Regulation(2008)。Constraints Faced by Competition and Regulatory Agencies,http://www.circ.in/pdf/PolicyBrief1.pdf, 2012/09/01。  new window
3.Johannsen, K. S.(2003)。Regulatory Independence in Theory and Practice--A Survey of Independent Energy Regulators in Eight European Countries,http://www.akf.dk/eng2003/regulatory_indepencence.htm, 2012/09/15。  new window
圖書論文
1.Bouckaert, G.、Peters, G. B.(2004)。What is Available and What is Missing in the Study of Quangos?。Unbundled Government: A Critical Analysis of the Global Trend to Agencies, Quangos and Contractualisation。New York:Routledge。  new window
2.Gilardi, F.(2003)。Institutional Change in Regulatory Policies: Regulation Through Independent Agencies and the Three New Institutionalism。The Politics of Regulation: Examining Regulatory Institutions and Instrumenta in the Age of Governance。Cheltenham:Edward Elgar, Inc。  new window
3.Jabko, N.(2004)。The Political Foundations of the European Regulatory State。The Politics of Regulation: Institutions and Regulatory Reforms for the Age of Governance。New York:Edward Elgar Publishing。  new window
4.Loughlin, J.(1994)。Nation, State, and Region in Western Europe。Culture: The Building Stone of Europe。Brussels:Presses Interuniversitaires。  new window
5.Nicolaides, P.(2005)。Regulation of Liberalised Markets: A New Role for the State?。Regulation through Agencies in the EU: A New Paradigm of European Governance。Vheltenham:Edward Elgar Publishing Limited。  new window
6.Pierre, J.(1995)。Comparative Public Administration: The State of the Art。Bureaucy in the Modern State: An Introduction to Comparative Public Administration。New York:Edward Elgar。  new window
7.Quirk, P. J.(1985)。Dergulation and the Politics of Ideas in Congress。Beyond Self-Interest。Chicago:University of Chicago Press。  new window
8.Scott, B. R.、Hood, C.(1998)。[A Reader on Regulation] Introduction。A Reader on Regulation。Oxford:Oxford University Press。  new window
9.Sirtaine, S.、Pinglo, M. E.、Foster, V.、Guasch, J. L.(2004)。How Profitable are Private Infrastructure Concessions in Latin America?。Empirical Evidence and Regulatory Implications。Washington DC:The World Bank。  new window
10.Tenbucken, M.、Schneider, V.(2004)。Divergent Convergence: Structures and Functions of National Regulatory Authorities in the Telcommunications Sectors。The Politics of Regulation: Institutions and Regulatory Reforms for the Age of Governance。Massachusettes:Edward Elgar Publishing, Inc。  new window
11.Loughlin, M.、Scott, C.(1997)。The Regulatory State。Developments in British Politics。Macmillan。  new window
 
 
 
 
第一頁 上一頁 下一頁 最後一頁 top
:::
無相關著作
 
QR Code
QRCODE