:::

詳目顯示

回上一頁
題名:當科學家與記者相遇:探討兩種專業對於科學新聞的看法差異
書刊名:中華傳播學刊
作者:陳憶寧 引用關係
作者(外文):Chen, Katherine Yi-ning
出版日期:2011
卷期:19
頁次:頁147-187
主題關鍵詞:科學記者科學家科學新聞深度訪談調查法Science journalistsScientistsScience newsIn-depth interviewSurvey
原始連結:連回原系統網址new window
相關次數:
  • 被引用次數被引用次數:期刊(11) 博士論文(0) 專書(0) 專書論文(0)
  • 排除自我引用排除自我引用:11
  • 共同引用共同引用:34
  • 點閱點閱:167
本研究檢視科學家與記者等兩個專業社群在對新聞媒體功能、科學新聞製作與呈現,以及彼此互動的看法。經問卷調查1,046位科學家以及67位記者,以及共6位深度訪談後有以下發現:第一,記者比科學家更認同新聞的正功能;第二,科學家更認為科學新聞戲劇化且過度簡化,以及產生誤解;第三,在互動時上雙方最大的差異顯現在記者不同意刊登前先給科學家過目。正確性對記者來說不見得重要,但正確性對科學家卻是最重要的原則。此外,記者認為科學家應更瞭解新聞媒體。
This study examines the perceptions of the two professional community's of scientists and journalists towards (1) the functions of journalism in general; (2) methods of science reporting; and (3) expectations concerning interactions between journalists and scientists. Exploratory surveys on 1,046 scientists and 67 reporters, and six in-depth interviews were conducted. In general, the scientists and journalists surveyed agreed on most of the positive functions of news media although journalists tended to be even more positive. Scientists in general felt science news was too superficial, overly dramatic, and easily caused misunderstanding. When asked about their interaction, journalists were less likely than scientists to agree to allow scientists they have interviewed to check copy before publication. Scientists agreed more than journalists that science news should place a high emphasis on accuracy. It is suggested that scientists need to know more about the news media in order to facilitate more effective communication with journalists and the public.
期刊論文
1.McCall, R. B.(1988)。Science and the press: Like oil and water。American Psychologist,43(2),87-94。  new window
2.Peters, H. P.(1994)。Mass media as an information channel and public arena。Risk: Health, Safety & Environment,5,241-250。  new window
3.Gerbner, G.、Gross, L.、Morgan, M.、Signorielli, N.(1981)。Scientists on the TV screen。Society,18(4),41-44。  new window
4.Dunwoody, S.、Ryan, M.(1985)。Scientific barriers to the popularization of science in the mass media。Journal of Communication,35(1),26-42。  new window
5.Peters, Hans Peter(1995)。The interaction of journalists and scientific experts: Co-operation and conflict between two professional cultures。Media, Culture & Society,17(1),31-48。  new window
6.黃俊儒、簡妙如(20060100)。科學新聞文本的論述層次及結構分佈:構思另個科學傳播的起點。新聞學研究,86,135-170。new window  延伸查詢new window
7.王小惠(2010)。發展網路科學傳播:採用科普知識之信念與態度初探性硏究。科學傳播論文集,2,69-104。  延伸查詢new window
8.Ankney, R. N.、Heilman, P.、Kolff, J.(1996)。Newspaper coverage of the coronary artery bypass grafting report。Science Communication,18,153-164。  new window
9.Condit, C. M.(2004)。Science reporting to the public: Does the message get twisted?。Canadian Medical Association Journal,170,1415-1416。  new window
10.DiBella, S. M.、Ferri, A. J.、Padderud, A. B.(1991)。Scientists’reasons for consenting to mass media interviews: A national survey。Journalism Quarterly,68,740-749。  new window
11.Dunwoody, S.、Scott, B. T.(1982)。Scientists as mass media sources。Journalism Quarterly,59,52-59。  new window
12.Fahnestock, J.(1986)。Accommodating Science: The Rhetorical Life of Scientific Facts。Written Communication,3(3),275-296。  new window
13.Gascoigne, T.、Metcalfe, J.(1997)。Incentives and impediments to scientists to communicating through the media。Science Communication,18,265-282。  new window
14.Peters, H. P.(1992)。The credibility of information sources in west Germany after the Chernobyl disaster。Public Understanding of Science,1,325-343。  new window
15.Gunter, B.、Kinderlerer, J.、Beyleveld, D.(1999)。The media and public understanding of biotechnology。Science Communication,20,373-394。  new window
16.Jenkins, E. W.(1999)。School science, citizenship and the public understanding of science。International Journal of Science Education,21,703-710。  new window
17.Koolstra,C. M.、Bos, M. J. W.、Vermeulen, I. E.(2006)。Through which medium should science information professionals communicate with the public: Television or the Internet?。Journal of Science Communication,5(3),1-8。  new window
18.Martin, M. J.、Garzon-Garcia, B.、Rey-Rocha, J.(2008)。Scientists’motivation to communicate science and technology to the public: Surveying participants at the Madrid Science Fair。Public Understanding of Science,17,349-367。  new window
19.Nowotny, H.(1981)。Experts and their expertise: On the changing relationship between experts and their public。Bulletin of Science, Technology & Society,1,235-241。  new window
20.Valenti, J. M.(1999)。Commentary: How well do scientists communicate to media?。Science Communication,21,172-178。  new window
21.Viswanath, K.、Blake, K. D.、Meissner, H. I.、Saiontz, N. G.、Mull, C.、Freeman, C. S.(2008)。Occupational practices and the making of health news: A national survey of U.S. health and medical science journalists。Journal of Health Communication,13,759-777。  new window
22.Peters, H. P.、Brossard, D.、de Cheveigne, S.、Dunwoody, S.、Kallfass, M.、Miller, S.(2008)。Science-media interface: It’s time to reconsider。Science Communication,30(2),266-276。  new window
23.Petersen, A.、Anderson, A.、Allan, S.、Wilkinson, C.(2009)。Opening the black box: Scientists’ views on the role of the new media in the nanotechnology debate。Public Understanding of Science,18,512-530。  new window
24.Reed, R.(2001)。(Un-)Professional discourse? Journalists’ and scientists’stories about science in the media。Journalism,2,279-298。  new window
25.Wilcox, S. A.(2003)。Cultural context and the conventions of science journalism: Drama and contradiction in media coverage of biological ideas about sexuality。Critical Studies in Media Communication,20,225-247。  new window
26.Salomone,K. L.、Greenberg, M. R.、Sandman, P. M.、Sachsman, D. B.(1990)。A question of quality: How journalists and news sources evaluate coverage of environmental risk。Journal of Communication,40,117-130。  new window
27.Sandman, P. M.(1988)。Review of the book Selling science: How the press covers science and technology。Journal of Communication,38,165-167。  new window
28.Treise,D.、Weigold,M. F.(2002)。Advancing science communication: A survey of science communication。Science Communication,23,310-322。  new window
29.Trumbo, C. W.、Dunwoody, S.、Griffin, R. J.(1998)。Journalists, cognition, and the presentation of an epidemiological study。Science Communication,19,238-265。  new window
圖書
1.LaFollette, Marcel C.(1990)。Making science our own: Public images of science, 1910-1955。University of Chicago Press。  new window
2.Goodsell, R.(1977)。The Visible Scientists。Boston:Little Brown。  new window
3.Friedman, S. M.、Dunwoody, S.、Rogers,C. L. Eds..(1986)。Scientists and journalists: Reporting science as news。New York, NY:Free Press。  new window
4.Nelkin, Dorothy(1995)。Selling science: How the press covers science and technology。W. H. Freeman and Company。  new window
5.Lundgren, R. E.、McMakin, A. H.(1998)。Risk Communication: A Handbook for Communicating Environmental, Safety, and Health Risks。Columbus, Ohio:Battelle Press。  new window
6.謝瀛春(1991)。科學新聞的傳播:理論與個案。臺北市:黎明文化。new window  延伸查詢new window
7.Bucchi, M.(1998)。Science and the media: Alternative routes to scientific communications。London:Routledge。  new window
8.Allan, S.(2009)。Making science newsworthy: Exploring the conventions of science journalism。Investigating science communication in the information age: Implications for public engagement and popular media。Oxford, UK。  new window
9.Bauer, M. W.、Bucchi,M.(2007)。Journalism, science, and society: Science communication between news and public relations。  new window
10.Friedman, S. M.(1986)。The journalist’s world。Scientists and journalists: Reporting science as news。New York。  new window
11.Goodfield, J.(1981)。Reflections on science and the media。Washington, DC。  new window
12.Levi, Ragnar(2001)。Medical journalism: Exposing fact, fiction, fraud。Ames, IA:Iowa State University Press。  new window
13.Gregory ,J.、Miller, S.(2000)。Science in public: Communication, culture, and credibility。Cambridge, MA。  new window
14.Hartz, J.、Ghappel, R.(1997)。Worlds apart: How the distance between science and journalism threatens America’s future。Nashville, TN。  new window
15.Irwin, A.(2009)。Moving forwards or in circles? Science communication and scientific governance in the age of innovation。Investigating science communication in the information age: Implications for public engagement and popular media。Oxford, UK。  new window
16.Nelsin, D.(1984)。Science in the streets: Report of the twentieth century fund task force on the communication of scientific risk。New York。  new window
17.Palen, J. A.(1994)。A map for science reporters: Science, technology, and society studies concepts in basic reporting and newswriting textbooks。Alma, MI。  new window
18.Rogers, C. L.(1999)。The importance of understanding audiences。Communicating uncertainty: Media coverage of new and controversial science。Mahwah, NJ。  new window
19.Sharlin, H. I.(1987)。Macro-risks, micro-risks, and the media: The EDB case.。The social and cultural construction of risk: Essays on risk selection and perception。Boston。  new window
20.Shortland, M.、Gregory, J.(1991)。Communicating science: A handbook。New York。  new window
21.Snow, C. P.(1980)。The two cultures and a second look。London。  new window
22.Trench, B.(2009)。Science reporting in the electronic embrace of the Internet。Investigating science communication in the information age: Implications for public engagement and popular media。New York。  new window
23.Peters, H. P.、Kruger, J.(1985)。Der transfer wissenschaftlichen wissens in die offentlichkeit aus der sicht von wissenschaftlern: Ergebnisse einer befragung der wissenschaftlichen mitarbeiter der kernforschungsanlage。Julich, Germany。  new window
24.Kruger, J.(1987)。Wissenschaftsberichterstattung in aktuellen massenmedien aus der sicht der wissenschaftler。Moral und verantwortung in der wissenschaftsvermittlung: Die aufgaben von wissenschaftler und journalist。Mainz, Germany。  new window
 
 
 
 
第一頁 上一頁 下一頁 最後一頁 top
:::
無相關著作
 
QR Code
QRCODE