臺灣人文及社會科學引文索引資料庫系統

:::

詳目顯示

回上一頁
第 1 筆 / 總合 1 筆   第一頁 上一頁 下一頁 最後一頁
/1頁
題名：勝利者的正義?--反思東京審判、政體改造及其相關爭議
書刊名：臺灣社會研究季刊
作者：陳宜中 引用關係
作者(外文)：Chen, I-chung
出版日期：2009
卷期：75
頁次：頁3-44
主題關鍵詞：日本；美國；東京審判；政體改造；邁尼爾；華瑟；正義；Japan；The US；The Tokyo Trial；Regime change；Minear；Walzer；Justice
原始連結：連回原系統網址new window
相關次數：
  • 被引用次數被引用次數:期刊(2) 博士論文(0) 專書(0) 專書論文(0)
  • 排除自我引用排除自我引用:0
  • 共同引用共同引用:193
  • 點閱點閱:175
東京審判只不過是「勝利者的正義」嗎？我們該從何種角度去反思東京審判，以及美國對日本的政體改造？本文針對邁尼爾（Richard H. Minear）與華瑟（Michael Walzer）的相關論說進行探討，藉此開展出有別於既存觀點的另一些思考方向。本文認為，東京審判並非孤立的法律事件，而必須理解為美國戰後東亞戰略之一環；在這一意義上，要徹底釐清東京審判的正當性問題，便必須從根本重新檢討美國對日政體改造行動是否正當。本文指出，促使戰敗國日本歸正，使其承擔起戰爭責任，使其不再發動侵略，無疑是正當的、起碼的國際正義要求；但「政體改造」（亦即「通過戰爭，以軍事佔領為手段，對戰敗國施行強制性的政治體制改造」）既未必是促使日本歸正的必要或唯一方式，亦未必是其最佳或較佳方式。美國的政體改造行動係以扶植親美反共政權與獲得穩固軍事基地，而非以「促使日本歸正」作為其主要動機；就其實際效果而言，也並未有效地趨近「促使日本歸正」之目標。由此觀之，美國對日本的政體改造，連同美國所主導的東京審判，的確是一種多方面受制於美國特殊利益、但正當性嚴重短缺的「勝利者的正義」。
Richard Minear criticizes the Tokyo Trial as mere ‘victors’ justice’, while Michael Walzer questions the legitimacy of the US policy of ‘regime change’that had been imposed upon Japan. Through a critique of Minear’s and Walzer’s arguments, this paper aims to shed some new light on these controversial issues. Drawing on Walzer, this paper suggests that the Tokyo Trial be conceived as part and parcel of the US strategy of regime change. To indict the former as ‘victors’ justice’, thus, is to cast doubt on the legitimacy of the latter. What, then, was wrong with regime change in the case of Japan? This paper rejects Walzer’s contention that Japan and Germany should in principle be treated differently. It is argued, instead, that the US policy of regime change was morally deficient not only because it involved political motivations other than justice, but because it therefore failed to take seriously the task of facilitating the transformation of Japan into a responsible stakeholder. To the very extent that today’s Japan remains ‘unreconstructed’ with respect to its war history and responsibility, the claim that regime change was just and successful in Japan must be turned on its head.
期刊論文
1.Jeans, R. B.(2005)。Victims or Victimizers? Museums, Textbooks, and the War Debate in Contemporary Japan。Journal of Military History，69，149-195。  new window
2.陳宜中、蔡孟翰(2005)。國族復興運動在日本。二十一世紀，89，128-132。  延伸查詢new window
3.高橋哲哉、孫軍悅(20070400)。靖國問題和歷史認識。文化研究，4，178-187。new window  延伸查詢new window
4.陳宜中(20040300)。羅爾斯的國際正義論與戰爭的正當性。政治與社會哲學評論，8，181-212。new window  延伸查詢new window
5.高橋哲哉(2007)。BC級戰犯和「法」的暴力。文化研究，4，188-199。new window  延伸查詢new window
6.Dudden, A.、Mizoguchi, K.(2007)。Abe's Violent Denial: Japan’s Prime Minister and the "Comfort Women"。Japan focus。  new window
7.Hirofumi, H.(2006)。Government, the Military and Business in Japan's Wartime Comfort Woman System。Japan focus。  new window
8.Koshiro, Y.(2005)。Eurasian Eclipse: Japan's End Game in World II。The American Historical Review，109(2)。  new window
9.Lee, W. D.(2001)。A Normal State without Remorse: The Textbook Controversy and Korea-Japan Relation。East Asian Review，13(3)，21-40。  new window
10.McCormack, G.(2004)。Community and Identity in Northeast Asia: 1930s and Today。Japan focus。  new window
11.Selden, M.(2007)。A Forgotten Holocaust: US Bombing Strategy, the Destruction of Japanese Cities and the American Way of War from the Pacific War to Iraq。Japan focus。  new window
12.Shalom, S. R.(1996)。The Obliteration of Hiroshima。New Politics，6(1)。  new window
13.Walzer, M.(2006)。Regime Change and Just War。Dissent。  new window
圖書
1.陳光興、李朝津(2005)。反思《台灣論》 : 台日批判圈的內部對話。臺北：臺灣社會研究雜誌社。  延伸查詢new window
2.Walzer, Michael(1992)。Just and unjust wars: A moral argument with historical illustrations。Just and unjust wars: A moral argument with historical illustrations。New York。  new window
3.丸山真男(1984)。現代政治的思想與行動。現代政治的思想與行動。臺北。  延伸查詢new window
4.Seraphim, Franziska(2006)。War Memory and Social Politics in Japan, 1945-2005。Cambridge, Mass.：Harvard University Asia Center。  new window
5.Johnson, Chalmers A.(2000)。Blowback: The Costs and Consequences of American Empire。New York, NY：Metropolitan Books/Henry Holt and Company。  new window
6.Hein, Laura E.、Selden, Mark(2000)。Censoring history: Citizenship and memory in Japan, Germany, and the United States。New York, NY：M. E. Sharpe。  new window
7.東亞三國的近現代史共同編寫委員會(2005)。東亞三國的近現代史。北京：社會科學文獻出版社。  延伸查詢new window
8.Harootunian, Harry D.(2000)。Overcome by Modernity: History, Culture, and Community in Interwar Japan。Princeton, New Jersey：Princeton University Press。  new window
9.孫歌(20010000)。亞洲意味著什麼：文化間的「日本」。臺北：巨流。new window  延伸查詢new window
10.Judt, Tony(2005)。Postwar: A History of Europe Since 1945。London：Penguin Books Ltd.。  new window
11.Rawls, John(1999)。The Law of Peoples: With "the Idea of Public Reason Revisited"。Cambridge：Harvard University Press。  new window
12.Arendt, Hannah、Kohn, Jerome(2003)。Responsibility and Judgment。Schocken。  new window
13.陳光興(20060000)。去帝國：亞洲作為方法。臺北：行人出版社。new window  延伸查詢new window
14.竹內好、孫歌、李冬木、趙京華(2005)。近代的超克。生活．讀書．新知三聯書店。  延伸查詢new window
15.Arendt, Hannah(1998)。The Human Condition。University of Chicago Press。  new window
16.Orend, B.(2000)。Michael Walzer on War and Justice。Michael Walzer on War and Justice。Montreal/London。  new window
17.Walzer, Michael(2004)。Arguing about war。Arguing about war。New Haven, CT。  new window
18.丸山真男(1997)。日本近代思想家：福澤諭吉。日本近代思想家：福澤諭吉。北京。  延伸查詢new window
19.Minear, Richard H.(2001)。Victors' Justice: The Tokyo War Crimes Trial。Victors' Justice: The Tokyo War Crimes Trial。Ann Arbor, Michigan。  new window
20.三島康雄(1976)。総合商社戦後における研究史。日本の財閥。東京。  延伸查詢new window
21.丸川哲史、鈴木將久(2006)。アジアへの/ からのまなざし。アジアへの/ からのまなざし。東京。  延伸查詢new window
22.中野敏男(2006)。何為「責任」？何為「主體」？。差異。開封。  延伸查詢new window
23.石川真澄(1978)。戰後政治構造史。戰後政治構造史。東京。  延伸查詢new window
24.西尾幹二(1999)。國民の歷史。國民の歷史。東京。  延伸查詢new window
25.後藤基夫、內田健三、石川真澄(1982)。戦後保守政治の軌跡─吉田內閣から鈴木內閣まで。戦後保守政治の軌跡─吉田內閣から鈴木內閣まで。東京。  延伸查詢new window
26.高橋哲哉(2005)。靖國問題。靖國問題。東京。  延伸查詢new window
27.猪野健治(2005)。日本の右翼。日本の右翼。東京。  延伸查詢new window
28.Anderson, P.(1993)。The Prussia of the East?。Japan in the World。North Carolina。  new window
29.Auer, J. E.(2006)。From Marco Polo Bridge to Pearl Harbor: Who was Responsible?。From Marco Polo Bridge to Pearl Harbor: Who was Responsible?。Tokyo。  new window
30.Barber, B. R.(2003)。Fear's Empire: War, Terrorism, and Democracy。Fear's Empire: War, Terrorism, and Democracy。New York。  new window
31.Bauman, Zygmunt(1991)。Modernity and the Holocaust。Cambridge：Cornell University Press。  new window
32.Chomsky, Noam(1970)。At War with Asia。At War with Asia。Edinburgh。  new window
33.Chomsky, Noam(2003)。Hegemony or Survival。Hegemony or Survival。New York。  new window
34.Coox, A. D.(1988)。The Pacific War。The Cambridge History of Japan (Vol. 6)。Cambridge。  new window
35.Cumings, B.(1990)。The Origins of the Korean War (Vol. 1)。The Origins of the Korean War (Vol. 1)。Princeton。  new window
36.Cumings, B.(1990)。The Origins of the Korean War (Vol. 2)。The Origins of the Korean War (Vol. 2)。Princeton。  new window
37.Dore, R. P.(1997)。Japan, Internationalism and the UN。Japan, Internationalism and the UN。London。  new window
38.Dore, R. P.(1998)。Textbook Censorship in Japan: The Ienaga Case。Education and Schooling in Japan since 1945。New York。  new window
39.Duus, Peter(1988)。The Cambridge History of Japan (Vol. 6)。The Cambridge History of Japan (Vol. 6)。Cambridge。  new window
40.Fukui, H.(1988)。Postwar Politics, 1945-1973。The Cambridge History of Japan (Vol. 6)。Cambridge。  new window
41.Hata, I.(1988)。Continental Expansion, 1905-1941。The Cambridge History of Japan (Vol. 6)。Cambridge。  new window
42.Hawthorn, G.(1991)。Plausible Worlds: Possibility and Understanding in History and the Social Sciences。Plausible Worlds: Possibility and Understanding in History and the Social Sciences。Cambridge。  new window
43.Hook, G. D.、McCormack, G.(2001)。Japan's Contested Constitution: Documents and Analysis。Japan's Contested Constitution: Documents and Analysis。London。  new window
44.入江昭(1987)。The Origins of the Second World War in Asia and the Pacific。London。  new window
45.入江昭(1999)。Pearl Harbor and the Coming of the Pacific War: A Brief with Documents and Essays。Pearl Harbor and the Coming of the Pacific War: A Brief with Documents and Essays。Boston。  new window
46.Johnson, C.(1999)。Okinawa: Cold War Island。Okinawa: Cold War Island。Cardiff, CA。  new window
47.McCormack, G.(2001)。The Emptiness of Japanese Affluence。The Emptiness of Japanese Affluence。New York。  new window
48.Maruyama, M.(1963)。Thought and Behaviour in Modern Japanese Politics。Thought and Behaviour in Modern Japanese Politics。London。  new window
49.Mendl, W.(1995)。Japan's Asia Policy。Japan's Asia Policy。London。  new window
50.Miyoshi, Masao、Harootunian, H.(1993)。Japan in the World。Japan in the World。North Carolina。  new window
51.Najita, Tetsuo、Harootunian, H.(1988)。Japanese Revolt against the West: Political and Cultural Criticism in the Twentieth Century。The Cambridge History of Japan (Vol. 6)。Cambridge。  new window
52.Newman, R. P.(1995)。Truman and the Hiroshima Cult。Truman and the Hiroshima Cult。Michigan。  new window
53.Norman, R.(1995)。Ethics, Killing and War。Ethics, Killing and War。Cambridge。  new window
54.Pendas, D. O.(2006)。The Frankfurt Auschwitz Trial. 1963-1965: Genocide, History, and the Limits of the Law。The Frankfurt Auschwitz Trial. 1963-1965: Genocide, History, and the Limits of the Law。Cambridge。  new window
55.Rawls, J.(1995)。Fifty Years after Hiroshima。John Rawls: Collect Papers。Cambridge, Mass.。  new window
56.Renwick, N.(1995)。Japan's Alliance Politics and Defence Production。Japan's Alliance Politics and Defence Production。Basingstoke and London。  new window
57.Selden, M.(2006)。Nationalism, Historical Memory and Contemporary Conflicts in the Asia Pacific: The Yasukuni Phenomenon, Japan, and the United States。Looking at Yasukuni through Eyes of the World: Between Civilization and Savagery。Seoul。  new window
58.Sereny, Gitta(2001)。The Healing Wound: Experiences and Reflections on Germany, 1938-2001。The Healing Wound: Experiences and Reflections on Germany, 1938-2001。New York。  new window
59.Tsurumi, S.(1986)。An Intellectual History of Wartime Japan, 1931-1945。An Intellectual History of Wartime Japan, 1931-1945。London/New York。  new window
60.Tsurumi, S.(1987)。A Cultural History of Postwar Japan, 1945-1980。A Cultural History of Postwar Japan, 1945-1980。London/New York。  new window
61.Welch, J. M.(2002)。The Tokyo Trial: A Bibliographic Guide to English-Language Sources。The Tokyo Trial: A Bibliographic Guide to English-Language Sources。Westport, CT。  new window
62.Yoshida, T.(2006)。The Making of the "Rape of Nanking": History and Memory in Japan, China, and the United States。The Making of the "Rape of Nanking": History and Memory in Japan, China, and the United States。Oxford。  new window
63.Yoshima, I.(1998)。The History of the Textbook Controversy。Education and Schooling in Japan since 1945。New York。  new window
其他
1.McCormack, G.(1997)。Holocaust Denial à la Japonaise。  new window
2.Koseki, Shichi，Maeda, Tetsuo，Suzuki, Yji，Takahashi, Susumu，Takayanagi, Sakio，Tsuboi, Yoshiharu，Wada, Haruki，Yamaguchi, Jir，Yamaguchi, Sadamu(2005)。Peace and Regional Security in the Asia-Pacific。  new window
 
 
 
 
第一頁 上一頁 下一頁 最後一頁 top
:::
無相關著作
 
無相關點閱
 
QR Code
QRCODE

臺灣人文及社會科學引文索引資料庫

目前上線人數：786（臺灣：769，外國：17） ／ 本年度總使用人次：1931025 ／ 訪客人次（自102年09月）：67741658
國家圖書館著作權聲明 Copyright © 2013 All rights reserved.
本館地址: 100201臺北市中山南路20號． 本館地圖及交通資訊．
總機：(02)23619132．最佳瀏覽解析度為1024x768以上