Narratives of origins are part of the ethnic history. Although in the process of multiple generational transmission, non-historical based plots and contexts might arise in community narratives, wide-spreading mythology, and legends, historical memories presented in mythologies and legends are both selective and reconstructive. Reviewing the Hualien Amis' narratives of origins during the Japanese Colonial Period, it reveals that in the period of mixed habitation between Amis and Sakizaya, "fictive genealogy" had once appeared in the narratives. For example, the ancestor of Nan-Shih seventh village and brother ancestors Hsiuguluan Tavarong Amis were connected in the legends. Probably because of language diversification, there is a weaker context in "structural amnesia." Based on the current literature, it cannot be known for certain that Na-raratsan-an and the offshore islands in the Sakizaya legend were the ethnic origins, though this statement had prevailed a long period of time. In the discussion of narratives of Amis origins, Sakizaya might not belong to Amis or even relate to it. These two ethnic groups might diverse into two distinct groups a long time ago.