:::

詳目顯示

回上一頁
題名:馬克思與政治經濟學批判: 系統性辯證作為解讀《資本論》底基本架構
作者:史豐榮
作者(外文):Feng-Jung Shih
校院名稱:國立臺灣大學
系所名稱:國家發展研究所
指導教授:洪鎌德
學位類別:博士
出版日期:2001
主題關鍵詞:馬克思資本論政治經濟學批判系統性辯證勞動價值論生產要素說
原始連結:連回原系統網址new window
相關次數:
  • 被引用次數被引用次數:期刊(0) 博士論文(1) 專書(0) 專書論文(0)
  • 排除自我引用排除自我引用:0
  • 共同引用共同引用:0
  • 點閱點閱:92
摘要
本論文試圖由《資本論》底「方法」─即辯證(dialectic(s))─著手,一來闡明該書內容中各主要部分(或範疇)間的關聯所在,並由之探出馬克思批判政治經濟學的理據所在,進而順勢延伸到對馬克思學之內、外諸說的檢討與批評;二來則探討馬克思作為一黑格爾式之馬克思(a Hegelian Marx)底可能性;其目的不外乎再次證明:馬克思的確是主流經濟學界不得不時時提防、卻又不得不費神應付的異類與燙手山芋。在上述標舉的目的之下,筆者乃試驗性地以馬克思學內的新近支派─新辯證(New Dialectics)─為主要基礎,針對下述課題逐一鋪陳:一,就政經批判而言,傳統以來對唯心、唯物辯證的區分與觀點,是否影響吾人試圖形塑─或強烈一點地說,重建─《資本論》之整體架構的努力。二,辯證如何能作為《資本論》一書底方法,而此一不尋常的方法義是否具有合理性?吾人又能如何由其推衍出政經批判底重要特點呢?三,以辯證為基礎的政經批判,是否能展現其內外於馬克思學界的獨特性?
以上該課題為焦點,本文首先便從馬克思與其先行者間之歷史關係下手,討論「黑格爾式的馬克思」是否屬於誤判,進而由論題相似性底面向主張:馬克思底辯證方法的確與黑格爾息息相關,而對後者的讀法實際上影響到如何解讀與評價黑格爾式的馬克思;筆者並因此順勢引入新辯證派對系統性辯證的主張。進入第二章後,本文以兩位馬克思學(\主義)者底論點為批評重心,分別觸及:馬克思所謂的研究法究竟能否證成「康德式的馬克思」、黑格爾底體系與方法是否混淆範疇底歷史與系統順序、辯證法是否排斥「同一與非矛盾律」;該章最後並進入一個馬克思學內較少處理的問題:對異化之一般唯物論式的讀法,是否對黑格爾公允,而黑格爾又是否混淆了異化與客體化?
至於第三章起則為對《資本論》之系統性(辯證)讀法的開展。就該書全三卷來說,筆者並未一昧地針對其中的組織架構作推衍,而試圖兼顧及馬克思本身所導致的疑點、與系統性的讀法究竟在那麼範疇底前後關聯─即定位─上出現遺漏或疏忽。就該書第一卷來說,在商品與貨幣形態之後的篇幅中,本文並稍作「離題」,而以思想例證來挖掘主流之生產要素說底矛盾之處,並論證該要素說無法在要素數目與所得歸屬對象上兼而並顧;而這無疑為勞動力作為商品的重要性作了背書,因為要素說根本就預設了此一資本主義式的社會關係。接著在第一卷底資本形態裡,筆者並由馬克思所稱之資本聚集與資本集中出發,藉由討論當今經濟學標準教科書中所用之供需均衡分析底誤失之處,回過頭來建立讀《資本論》的持續攸關性;不過本章最後雖然依舊鎖定於第一卷底內容,但由馬克思寫作史底角度著手,我們將檢驗原始積累這個主題在該書與政經批判寫作努力中的地位與定位上的變化。
接下來的第四章除了將利潤率趨勢底問題留待最後處理外,其餘的篇幅仍跟隨《資本論》現行第二、三卷底安排,依序觸及資本流通中再生產圖示底複雜內容、價值轉化是否遺漏成本投入項、剩餘價值之流洩於其他非產業的資本形態;這當中除了指出簡單再生產與擴大再生產間是否遺漏某項中介範疇外,並重複地說明生產底同時模型無法證實馬克思在價值轉化上犯錯,同時該模型也無法運用在因利潤率是否下降所引發的詮釋與爭議之中。本文最後結論底一章除了回溯本文底若干重點外,並會略加說明由前言延宕下來的社經範疇底總體定位問題,而這足以釐清黑格爾式的馬克思之強調何在。
主要參考書目
中文著作
史豐榮
2000〈「轉化問題」與馬克思價值理論之評析〉, 中山學術論叢, 第十八
期, 頁75-124。
李明輝
1991《儒學與現代意識》, 台北: 文津。
李英明
1990《馬克思社會衝突論》, 台北: 時報文化。
洪鎌德
1986《傳統與反叛: 青年馬克思思想的探索》, 台北: 商務。
1988《新馬克思主義和現代社會科學》, 台北: 森大, 頁27-40。
1990〈西方馬克思主義是什麼?〉, 收錄於氏編, 《西方馬克思主義論
戰集》, 台北: 森大, 頁27-40。
1996《跨世紀的馬克思主義》, 台北: 月旦。
1997a《馬克思》, 台北: 東大。
1997b《馬克思社會學說之析評》, 台北: 揚智。
1997c《社會學說與政治理論: 當代尖端思想之介紹》, 台北: 揚智。
1999《當代政治經濟學》, 台北: 揚智。
2000《人的解放: 21世紀馬克思學說新探》, 台北: 揚智。
陳文團
1995,〈基督宗教與馬克思主義間的衝突〉, 哲學與文化, 二十六卷第六
期, 頁489-501。
黃瑞祺
1994〈馬克思的方法及方法論--編者導言〉, 收錄於氏編,《馬克思論方
法》, 台北: 巨流, 頁1-67。
1996《批判社會學: 批判理論與現代社會學》, 台北: 三民。
1994〈理性選擇與馬克思主義〉, 收錄於氏編,《馬學新論: 從西方馬克
思主義到後馬克思主義》, 台北: 中研院歐美所, 頁1-28。
張柯圳
1998《黑格爾辨證法與文化哲學》, 台北: 五南。
張清溪、吳聰敏、許嘉棟與劉鶯釧
1987a《經濟學: 理論與實際\上冊》, 台北: 雙葉。
1987b《經濟學: 理論與實際\下冊》, 台北: 雙葉。
楊世雄
2001《馬克思的經濟哲學》, 台北: 五南。
賀瑞麟
1997〈人與自然的和解: 黑格爾的自然哲學及其當代意義〉, 國立屏東
師院學報, 第十期, 頁259-282。
中文譯著
柯林尼可斯(Callinicos, Alex)
1990《阿圖塞的馬克思主義》, 杜章智譯, 台北: 遠流。
馬克思
1990《資本論》, 全三卷, 吳家駟譯, 台北: 時報文化。
1994《馬克思論方法》, 黃瑞祺編, 台北: 巨流。
黑格爾
1979《精神現象學》, 上下兩卷, 賀麟、王玖興譯, 北京: 商務。
1981《歷史哲學》, 王造時與謝詒徵譯, 台北: 里仁書局。
1983a/b《自然哲學》, 上/下, 譯者不詳, 新竹: 仰哲。
1985《法哲學原理》, 范揚、張企泰譯, 台北: 里仁。
1987《大邏輯》, 楊一之譯, 新店: 谷風。
1998《小邏輯》, 賀麟譯, 台北: 商務。
董特(D''Hondt, Jacques)
1994《黑格爾與黑格爾主義》, 欒棟譯, 台北: 唐山。
英文譯著\作
Ameriks, Karl
1991“Hegel and Idealism”, The Monist 74(4), pp.386-402.
2000“Feuerbach, Marx and Kierkegaard”, in Ameriks ed., The
Cambridge Companion to German Idealism, N.Y.: Cambridge
U.P., pp.258-281.
Arthur, Christopher J.
1986 The Dialectics of Labour: Marx and His Relation to Hegel,
Oxford: Basil Blackwell.
1993“Hegel''s Logic and Marx''s Capital”, in F. Moseley ed.,
pp.63-87.
1997“Against the Logical-Historical Method: dialectical
derivation versus linear logic”, in F. Moseley & M. Campbell
eds., pp.9-37.
1998a“Systematic Dialectic”, Science and Society 62(3),
pp.447-459.
1998b“The Infinity of Capital”, Studies in Marxism no.3,
pp.17-36.
2000“From the Critique of Hegel to the Critique of Capital”,
working paper available from Prof. Alan Freeman(
http:\\www.gre.ac.uk\~fa03)。
Arthur, C.J. & G. Reuten eds.,
1998 The Circulation of Capital: Essays in Volume Two of Marx''s
Capital, London: Macmillan.
Beach Edward A.
1990“The Later Schellilng’s Conception of Dialectical Method,
in Contradistinction to Hegel”, The Owl of Minerva 22(1),
pp.99-120.
Bellofiore, Riccardo ed.,
1998a Marxian Economics: a Reappraisal--Essays on Volume Ⅲ
of Capital/Volume 1: Method, Value and Money, London:
Macmillan.
1998b Marxian Economics: a Reappraisal--Essays on Volume Ⅲ
of Capital/Volume I1: Profits, Prices and Money, London:
Macmillan.
Breazeale, Daniel
1988“Fichte in Jena”, editor & translator''s introduction to
Fichte: Early Philosophical Writings, Ithaca: Cornell U.P.,
pp.1-49.
1994“Circles and Grounds in the Jena Wissenschaftslehre”, in
D. Breazeale & T. Rockmore eds., Fichte: Historical Contexts/
Contemporary Controversies, N.J.: Humanities Press,
pp.43-70.
Brown, Andrew
1999“Developing Realistic Methodology: How New Dialectics
Surpasses the Critical Realist Method for Social Science”,
working paper available in http:\ www.criticalrealism.demon.co.uk.
Buchwalter, Andrew.
1991“Hegel, Marx and the Concept of Immanent Critique”,
Journal of the History of Philosophy 29(2), pp.253-279.
Burns, Tony & Ian Fraser eds.,
2000 The Hegel-Marx Connection, London: Macmillan.
Callinicos, Alex
1993“What is Living and What is Dead in the philosophy of
Althusser”, in E.A. Kaplan & M. Sprinker eds., The
Althusserian Legacy, London: Verso, pp.39-49.
1999“The Secret of the Dialectic”, International Socialism
no.78, pp.93-103.
Caravale, Giovanni A.
1989“On Marx’s Interpretation of Ricardo: a note”, Atlantic
Economic Journal 17(4), pp.6-12.
Carchedi, Guglielmo
1991 Frontiers of Political Economy, London: Verso.
1993“Marx''s Logic of Inquiry and Price Formation”, in
F. Moseley ed., pp.185-216.
Carver, Terrell
1980a“Marx''s 1857 Introduction”, Economy and Society
9(2), pp.197-203.
1980b“Marx, Engels and Dialectics”, Political Studies 28(3),
pp.353-363.
1984“Marxism as Method”, in T. Ball & J. Farr eds., After
Marx, N.Y.: Cambridge U.P., pp.265-279.
1998 The Postmodern Marx, Manchester: Manchester U.P.
Castree, Noel
1996“Birds, Mice and Geography: marxisms and dialectics”,
Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers 21(2),
pp.342-362.
Colletti, Lucio
1973 Marxism and Hegel, trans. by L. Garner, London: NLB.
Davis, John B. et al. eds.,
1998 The Handbook of Economic Methodology, Cheltenham:
Edward Elgar.
Dickey, Laurence
1990“Review of William Maker ed., Hegel on Economics and
Freedom”, Economics and Philosophy 6(1), pp.169-176.
Dupré, Louis
1966 The Philosophical Foundations of Marxism, N.Y.: Harcourt,
Brace & World.
1972“Hegel''s Concept of Alienation and Marx''s Reinterpretation
of It”, Hegel-Studien Bd.7, pp.217-236.
Duquette, David Albert
1985 Idealism and Materialism: Hegel and Marx on history,
society and the state, Ph.D. Thesis of University of Kansas.
1988“Methodology and Development in Marx and Hegel”, The
Owl of Minerva 19(2), pp.131-148.
1993“C.J. Arthur on Marx and Hegel on Alienation”,
Auslegung 19(1), pp.75-85.
Fine, Ben
1982 Theories of the Capitalist Economy, London: Edward Arnold.
1985-6“Banking Capital and the Theory of Interest”, Science
and Society 49(4), pp.387-413.
1986“On Marx’s Theory of Agricultural Rent(& a rejoinder to
M. Ball )”, in Fine ed., The Value Dimension, London:
RKP, pp.114-151, 175-179; reprinted from Economy and
Society 1979 & 1980.
1989 Marx’s Capital, 3rd edition, London: Macmillan.
Forster, John
1993“Hegel''s Dialectical Method”, in F.C. Beiser ed., The
Cambridge Companion to Hegel, N.Y.: Cambridge U.P.,
pp.130-170.
Frank, Manfred
1989“Schelling’s Critique of Hegel and the Beginning of
Marxian Dialectics”, Idealistic Studies 19(3), pp.251-268。
Freeman, Alan
1998“A General Refutation of Okishio’s Theorem and a Proof
of the Falling Rate of Profit”, in R. Bellofiore ed., 1998b,
pp.139-162。
Freeman, A. & G. Carchedi eds.
1996 Marx and Non-Equilibrium Economics, Cheltenham:
Edward Elgar。
Groenewegen, Peter
1987“Marx’s Conception of Classical Political Economy”,
Political Economy: Studies in the Surplus Approach 3(1),
pp.19-35.
Hardimon, Michael O.
1994 Hegel''s Social Philosophy: the Project of Reconciliation,
N.Y.: Cambridge U.P.
Harris, Errol E.
1982“Marxist Interpretations of Hegel''s Phenomenology of
Spirit”, in M.Westphal ed., Method and Speculation in
Hegel''s Phenomenology, N.J.: Humanities Press,
pp.117-137.
Harris, Henry Silton
1976“The Use and Abuse of Hegel”, in G. Ryle ed.,
Contemporary Aspects of Philosophy, London: Oriel Press,
pp.223-238.
1987a“Hegel''s Science of Experience”, Bulletin of the Hegel
Society of Great Britain, no.15, pp.13-37.
1987b“Hegel''s Jena Logic and Metaphysics”, The Owl of
Minerva, 18(2), pp.209-221.
1993“The Social Ideal of Hegel''s Economic Theory”, in
L.S. Stepelevich ed., Selected Essays on G.W.F. Hegel,
N.J.: Humanities Press, pp.187-212.
1994“Hegel''s Correspondence Theory of Truth”, Bulletin of the
Hegel Society of Great Britain, no.29, pp.1-13.
1995 Hegel: Phenomenology and System, Indiana: Hackett Pub.
Hartmann, Klaus
1972“Hegel: a Non-Metaphysical view”, in A. MacIntyre ed.,
Hegel: a Collection of Critical Essays, Notre Dame:
University of Notre Dame Press, pp.101-124.
1984“Toward a New Systematic Reading of Hegel''s Philosophy of
Right”, in Z.A. Pelczynski ed., State and Civil Society:
Studies in Hegel''s Political Philosophy, N.Y.: Cambridge U.P.,
pp.114-136.
Harvey, David
1989“Land Rent under Capitalism”, chap.3 of his The Urban
Exerience, Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University Press。
Hegel, G.W.F.
1969 Hegel''s Science of Logic, trans. by A.V. Miller, London:
George Allen & Unwin.
1970 Hegel''s Philosophy of Nautre, being part 2 of The
Encyclopedia of Philosophical Sciences(1830), trans. by
A.V. Miller, Oxford: Clarendon Press.
1977 Phenomenology of Spirit, trans. by A.V. Miller, Oxford:
Oxford U.P..
1988 Lectures on The Philosophy of World History, Introduction:
Reason in History, trans. by H.B. Nisbet, N.Y.: Cambridge
U.P.
1991a The Encyclopaedia Logic, part 1 of The Encyclopaedia of
Philosophical Sciences(1830) with the Zusätze, trans. by
T.F. Geraets, W.A. Suchting & H.S. Harris, Indiana:
Hackett Pub..
1991b Elements of Philosophy of Right, trans. by H.B. Nisbet,
ed. by A. Wood, N.Y.: Cambridge U.P.
Himka, John-Paul
1984“Comments on Manfred Turban[''s]‘Roman Rosdolsky''s
Reconsideration of the Traditional Marxist Debate on the
Schemes of Reproduction on New Methodological
Grounds’”, in I.S. Koropeckyj ed., Selected Contributions
Of Ukrainian Scholars to Economics, Cambridge: Harvard
U.P., pp.135-147.
Horstmann, Rolf-Peter
1998“Hegel”, entry in E. Craig ed., Routledge Encyclopedia
of Philosophy, vol.4, pp.259-280。
Houlgate, Stephen
1991 Freedom, Truth and History: An Introduction to Hegel''s
Philosophy, London: Routledge.
1993“A Reply to Joseph Flay''s‘Hegel''s Metaphysics’”,
The Owl of Minerva 24(2), pp.153-161.
1995“The Unity of Theoretical and Practical Spirit in Hegel''s
Concept of Freedom”, Review of Metaphysics 48(4),
pp.859-881.
1997“Hegel''s Critique of the Triumph of Verstand in
Modernity”, Bulletin of The Hegel Society of Great Britain,
no.35, pp.54-70.
1999“Schelling’s Critique of Hegel''s Science of Logic”, The
Review of Metaphysics 53(1), pp.99-128.
Inwood, Michael
1992 A Hegel Dictionary, Oxford: Blackwell.
Kliman, Andrew J.
1996“A Value-Theoretic Critique of the Okishio Theorem”, in
Freeman & Carchedi eds., pp.206-224.
1997“The Okishio Theorem: An Obituary”, Review of Radical
Political Economics 29(3), pp.42-50.
Kliman, A.J. & Ted McGlone
1999“A Temporal Single-System Interpretation of Marx’s Value
Theory”, Review of Political Economy 11(1), pp.33-59.
Lobkowicz, Nicolas
1978“Materialism and Matter in Marxism-Leninism”, in
E. McMullin ed., The Concept of Matter in Modern Philosophy,
Notre Dame: University of Notre Dame Press, pp.154-188.
Maker, William A.
1981“Understanding Hegel Today”, Journal of the History of
Philosophy 19(3), p.343-375.
1994 Philosophy without Foundations: Rethinking Hegel, N.Y.:
SUNY Press.
1998“The Very Idea of the Idea of Nature, or Why Hegel Is Not
an Idealist”, in S. Houlgate ed. Hegel and the Philosophy of
Nature, N.Y.: SUNY Press, pp.1-27.
Marx, Karl
1973 Grundrisse; Foundations of the Critique of Political
Economy(Rough Draft), trans. by M. Nicolaus, London:
Penguin Books.
1975 Early Writings, trans. by R. Livingstone et als., N.Y.:
Vintage Books.
1976 The Poverty of Philosophy, in Marx & Engels, Collected
Works, vol.6, London: Lawrence & Wishart.
1977 Capital: a Critique of Political Economy, vol.1, trans. by
B. Fowkes, London: Pelican Books.
1978 Capital, vol.2, trans. by D. Fernbach, Harmondsworth:
Penguin Books.
1981 Capital, vol.3, trans. by D. Fernbach, Harmondsworth:
Penguin Books.
1989“Marginal Notes on Adolph Wagner’s Lehrbuch der
Politischen Oekonomie”, in Marx & Engels, Collected Works,
vol.19, London: Lawrence & Wishart.
1994 Early Political Writings, ed. & trans. by J. O''Malley, N.Y.:
Cambridge U.P.
1996 Later Political Writings, ed. & trans. by T. Carver, N.Y.:
Cambridge U.P.
Marx & F. Engels
1975a The Holy Family, or a Critique of Critical Critique, in
Marx & Engels, Collected Works, vol.4, London: Lawrence
& Wishart.
1975b Selected Correspondence 1846-1895, Westport:
Greenwood Press.
1998 The German Ideology, N.Y.: Prometheus Books.
Meaney, Mark E.
1995“Money, Monetary Crisis, and the Doctrine of Being”,
The Owl of Minerva 26(2), pp.149-169.
Mirowski, Philip J.
1988“Morishima on Marx”, chap.10 of his Against Mechanism:
Protecting Economics from Science, Totawa.: Rowman &
Littlefield, pp.171-190.
1988“What were von Neumann and Morgenstern trying to
Accomplish?”, in E.R. Weintraub ed., Toward a History of
Game Theory(HOPE, supplement), Durham: Duke U.P.,
pp.113-147.
Moseley, Fred
1998 “Marx’s Reproduction Schemes and [Adam] Smith’s
Dogma”, in Arthur & Reuten eds., pp.159-185.
Moseley, Fred ed.,
1993 Marx''s Method in Capital: a Reexamination, N.J.:
Humanities Press.
Moseley, F. & Martha Campbell eds.,
1997 New Investigations of Marx''s Method, N.J.: Humanities
Press.
Murray, Patrick
1993“The Necessity of Money: how Hegel helped Marx surpass
Ricardo’s theory of value”, in F. Moseley ed., pp.37-61.
Negishi, Takashi
1998“General Equilibrium Theory and beyond: Yasuma Takata
and Kei Shibata”, in S. Sugihara et als. eds., Economic
Thought and Modernization in Japan, Cheltenham: Edward
Elgar, pp.97-116.
Oakley, Allen
1976“Two Notes on Marx and the Transformation Problem”,
Economica v.43(no.172), pp.411-417.
1983 The Making of Marx''s Critical Theory: a Bibliographical
Analysis, London: Routledge & Kegan Paul.
Okishio, Nobuo
1987“Choice of Technique and the Rate of Profit”, in J. Eatwell
et als. eds., The New Palgarve: A Dictionary of Economics,.
vol.1, London: Macmillan, pp.418-421.
Peach, Terry
1999“Surplus to Requirements: Kurz and Salvadori’s The Elgar
Companion to Classical Economics”, Journal of the History
of Economic Thought 21(4), pp.449-462.
Pinkard, Terry
1985“Logic of Hegel''s Logic”, in M. Inwood ed., Hegel, Oxford:
Oxford U.P., pp.85-109; reprinted from Journal of The
History of Philosophy 1979.
1990“How Kantian was Hegel?”, Review of Metaphysics 43(4),
pp.831-838.
Postone, Moishe
1993 Time, Labor and Social Domination: a Reinterpretation of
Marx’s Critical Theory, N.Y.: Cambridge U.P..
Postone, Moishe & Helmut Reinicke
1974-5“On Nicolaus‘Introduction’to the Grundrisse”, Telos
no.22, p.130-1148.
Rees, John
1998 The Algebra of Revolution: the Dialectic and the Classical
Marxist Tradition, London: Routledge.
Rehmann, Jan
1999“‘Abolition’of Civil Socity?: remarks on a widespread
misunderstanding in the interpretation of‘Civil Society’”, Socialism and Democracy, 13(2), pp.1-18.
Reuten, Geert
1991“Accumulation of Capital and the Foundation of the
Tendency of the Rate of Profit to Fall”, Cambridge Journal of
Economics 15(1), pp.79-93.
1993“The Difficult Labor of a Theory of Social Value:
metaphors and systematic dialectics at the beginning of
Marx’s Capital”in F. Moseley ed., pp.89-113.
1998“The Status of Marx’s Reproduction Schemes:
conventional or dialectical logic”, in Arthur & Reuten eds.,
pp.187-229.
1999“Knife-edge Caricature Modelling: the case of Marx’s
reproduction schema”, in M. Morgan & M. Morrison eds.,
Models as Mediators, N.Y.: Cambridge U.P., pp.197-240
Reuten, Geert & Michael Williams
1989 Value-Form and the State: the Tendencies of Accumulation
and the Determination of Economic Policy in Capitalist Society, London: Routledge.
Rockmore, Tom.
1980 Fichte, Marx, and the German Philosophical Tradition,
Edwardsville: Southern Illinois U.P.
1993 Before and After Hegel, Berkeley: University of California
Press.
1997 Cognition: an Introduction to Hegel''s Phenomenology of
Spirit, Berkeley: University of California Press.
Rosdolsky, Roman
1974“Comments on the Method of Marx''s Capital and its
importance for Contemporary Marxist Scholarship”, trans.
by D. Bathrick & A. Rabinbach, New German Critique no.3,
pp.62-72.
1977 The Making of Marx''s Capital, trans. by P. Burgess, London:
Pluto Press.
Rosenthal, John
1998 The Myth of Dialectics: Reinterpretating the Marx-Hegel
Relation, London: Macmillan.
Saad-Filho, Alfredo
1993“A Note on Marx’s Analysis of the Composition of Capital”
, Capital and Class no.50, pp.127-146
1997a“Re-reading both Hegel and Marx: the New Dialectics and
the Method of Capital”, Revista de Economia Politica 17(1),
pp.107-120.
1997b“Concrete and Abstract Labour in Marx’s Theory of
Value”, Review of Political Economy 9(4), pp.457-477.
Sayers, Sean
1990“Marxism and the Dialectical Method: a Critique of
G.A.Cohen”, in P. Osborne & S. Sayers eds., Socialism,
Feminism and Philoosphy, London: Roueledge, pp.140-168;
reprinted from Radical Philosophy 1984.
Schmidt, James
1980-81“Recent Hegel Literature [I]: general surveys and the
young Hegel”, Telos no.46, pp.113-147.
1981“A Paideia for the‘Bürger als Bourgeois’: the concept
of‘Civil Society’in Hegel''s political thought”, History
of Political Thought 2(3), pp.469-493.
Shaikh, Anwar M.
1978“An Introduction to the History of Crisis Theories”, in
URPE ed., US Capitalism in Crisis, N.Y.: URPE, pp.219-241.
1984“The Transformation form Marx to Sraffa: Prelude to a
Critique of the Neo-Ricardians”, in E. Mandel &
A. Freeman eds., Marx, Richard, Sraffa, London: Verso,
pp.43-84.
1990“Organic Composition of Capital”, entry in J. Eatwell
et als. eds., The New Palgrave: Marxian Economics, London:
MacMillan, pp.304-309; originally published in The New
Palgrave: A Dictionary of Economics, 1987.
Skinner, Andrew
1996 A System of Social Science: Papers Relating to Adam Smith,
2rd edition, Oxford: Clarendon Press.
Smith, Tony
1990 The Logic of Marx''s Capital: Reply to Hegelian Criticisms,
N.Y.: SUNY Press.
1991 The Role of Ethics in Social Theory: Essays form a
Habermasian Perspective, N.Y.: SUNY Press.
1993a Dialectical Social Theory and its Critics, N.Y.: SUNY Press.
1993b“Marx''s Capital and Hegelian Dialectical Logic”. in
F. Moseley ed., pp.15-36.
1999“The Relevance of Systematic Dialectics to Marxian
Thought”, working paper available from Prof. Smith(
aasmith@fee.uva.nl; tonys@iastate.edu).
2000“The Systematic Place of Technological Rents in Capital
III”, in A.Light & M. Nagel eds., Race, Class and Community
Identity, N.Y.: Humanity Books, pp.117-132.
Stewart, Jon
1998“The Architectonic of Hegel''s Phenomenology of Spirit”, in
Stewart ed., The Phenomenology of Spirit Reader: Critical and
Interpretive Essays, N.Y.: SUNY Press, pp.444-477.
Stillman, Peter G.
1980“Property, Freedom and Individuality in Hegel’s and
Marx’s Political Thought”, in J.R. Pennock et als. eds.,
Property(NOMOS 22), N.Y.: New York U.P., pp.130-167.
Tran, Van-Doan(陳文團)
1994“The Dialectic of Tradition and Modernity”, 臺大哲學評
論, 十七期, 頁129-163。
1996“Difference, De-Difference, Identity: reflection on
ideological dialogue”, 臺大哲學評論, 十九期, 頁1-48。
1998“Asian Marxism or the Dialectic of Violence”, 臺大哲學
評論, 二十一期, 頁125-165。
Uchida, Hiroshi
1988 Marx’s Grundrisse and Hegel’s Logic, London: Routledge。
Warminski, Andrzej
1998“Hegel/Marx: Consciousness and Life”, in S. Barnett ed.,
Hegel after Derrida, London: Routledge, pp.171-193;
reprinted from Yale French Studies 1995.
Weeks, John
1981 Capital and Exploitation, N.J.: Princeton U.P.
1982“Equilibrium, Uneven Development and the Tendency of
the Rate of Profit to Fall”, Capital and Class no.16,
pp.62-77.
Williams, Robert R.
1997 Hegel’s Ethics of Recognition, Berkeley: University of
California Press.
Wood, Allen W.
1998“Kant''s Historical Materialism”, in J. Kneller & S. Axinn
eds., Autonomy and Community: Readings in Contemporary
Kantian Social Philosophy, N.Y.: SUNY Press, pp.16-37.
Wood, Ellen Meiksins.
1995 Democracy Against Capitalism: Renewing Historical
Materialism, N.Y.: Cambridge U.P.
Zarembka, Paul ed.
1999 Economic Theory of Capitalism and its Crises, (Research
in Political Economy, v.17), N.Y.: JAI Press.
 
 
 
 
第一頁 上一頁 下一頁 最後一頁 top
:::
無相關著作
 
QR Code
QRCODE