管理才能發展訓練方案成效評估：以公部門教育訓練機構為例_

:::

詳目顯示

第 1 筆 / 總合 1 筆

/1頁

來源文獻資料
摘要
外文摘要
引文資料

題名：	管理才能發展訓練方案成效評估：以公部門教育訓練機構為例
書刊名：	人力資源管理學報
作者：	黃佳純／謝慧賢
作者(外文)：	Huang, Jie-tsuen／Hsieh, Hui-hsien
出版日期：	2011
卷期：	11:3
頁次：	頁1-26
主題關鍵詞：	訓練評估；Kirkpatrick四階層評估模式；效用分析；公部門教育訓練；管理發展；Training evaluation；Kirkpatrick's four-level evaluation model；Utility analysis；Public sector training；Management development
原始連結：	連回原系統網址
相關次數：	被引用次數:期刊(4) 博士論文(1) 專書(0) 專書論文(0) 排除自我引用:4 共同引用:48 點閱:694

隨著強調實際貢獻的課責要求及結果導向績效管理制度之興起，人力資源發展乃由過去的活動導向轉為成果導向，而訓練評估的焦點也應延伸至更高層次的評估，如訓練效用與投資報酬率。因此，本研究乃以一結合Kirkpatrick四階層評估模式與效用分析的訓練評估架構，透過個案研究方式針對公部門訓練專責機構所舉辦之管理才能發展訓練方案進行系統化的訓練成效衡量與評估。結果顯示，受訓者在反應、學習、行為、成果等四個評估層級中皆有良好的訓練成效，且經由效用分析得知此管理才能發展訓練方案能夠產生3,233,385（元）的淨經濟效益，整體訓練方案的投資報酬率為718%。最後，結論乃針對人力資源發展人員、組織管理者、公部門訓練機構等三方面與未來研究方向提出相關建議。

以文找文

Accompanying the rise of accountability demands and outcome-based performance management, Human Resource Development will move from activity-based in the past toward more results-based. In addition, the focus of training evaluation should extend to higher levels such as the utility and return on investment of training program. Therefore, for building a both activity-based and result-based model, this study proposes a training evaluation framework combining Kirkpatrick's four-level evaluation model and utility analysis and conducts a case study on a management development training program implemented by a public sector training institution. The results indicate that the trainees have satisfactory outcomes in the four evaluation levels of reaction, learning, behavior, and results. Meanwhile, through utility analysis, the net benefits of the management development training program is NT$ 3,233,385, and the program's return on investment is 718%. In conclusion, suggestions towards human resource development professionals, organization managers, public sector training institutions, and future research are provided.

以文找文

期刊論文
1.	Anderson, Paul. A.(1983)。Decision Making by Objection and the Cuban Missile Crisis。Administrative Science Quarterly，28(2)，201-222。
2.	Pinfield, Lawrence T.(1986)。A Field Evaluation of Perspectives on Organizational Decision Making。Administrative Science Quarterly，31(3)，365-388。
3.	Holton, Elwood F.(1996)。The flawed four-level evaluation model。Human Resource Development Quarterly，7(1)，5-21。
4.	Alvarez, Kaye、Salas, Eduardo、Garofano, C. M.(2004)。An Integrated Model of Training Evaluation and Effectiveness。Human Resource Development Review，3(4)，385-416。
5.	Morrow, C. C.、Jarrett, M. Q.、Rupinski, M. T.(1997)。An Investigation of the Effect and Economic Utility of Corporate-Wide Training。Personnel Psychology，50(1)，91-119。
6.	Mulgan, R.(2000)。Comparing Accountability in the Public and Private Sectors。Australian Journal of Public Administration，59(1)，87-97。
7.	Schmidt, F. L.、Hunter, J. E.、McKenzie, R. C.、Muldrow, T. W.(1979)。Impact of Valid Selection Procedures on Work-Force Productivity。Journal of Applied Psychology，64(6)，609-626。
8.	Kraiger, Kurt、Ford, J. Kevin、Salas, Eduardo(1993)。Application of Cognitive, Skill-Based, and Affective Theories of Learning Output to New Methods of Training Evaluation。Journal of Applied Psychology，78(2)，311-328。
9.	蔡錫濤(2000)。訓練評鑑的焦點與模式。人力資源發展月刊，156，1-12。延伸查詢
10.	Boudreau, J. W.、Berger, C. J.(1985)。Decision-theoretic utility analysis applied to employee separations and acquisition。Journal of Applied Psychology，70，581-612。
11.	Kaufman, R.、Keller, J. M.(1994)。Levels of Evaluation: Beyond Kirkpatrick。Human Resource Development Quarterly，5(4)，371-380。
12.	Heinrich, C.(2002)。Outcomes-Based Performance Management in the Public Sector: Implications for Government Accountability and Effectiveness。Public Administration Review，62(6)，712-725。
13.	蘇偉業(20090300)。公共部門事前定向績效管理：反思與回應。公共行政學報，30，105-130。延伸查詢
14.	Tsui, A. S.、Pearce, J. L.、Porter, L. W.、Tripoli, A. M.(1997)。Alternative Approaches to the Employee-organization Relationship: Does Investment in Employees Pay off?。Academy of Management Journal，40(5)，1089-1121。
15.	Salas, E.、Cannon-Bowers, J. A.(2001)。The science of training: A decade of progress。Annual Review of Psychology，52(1)，471-499。
16.	Arthur, Winfred Jr.、Edens, Pamela S.、Bell, Suzanne T.、Bennett, Winston Jr.(2003)。Effectiveness of training in organizations: A meta-analysis of design and evaluation features。Journal of Applied Psychology，88(2)，234-245。
17.	Gersick, C. J. G.(1988)。Time and Transition in Work Teams: Toward a New Model of Group Development。Academy of Management Journal，31(1)，9-41。
18.	Eisenhardt, Kathleen M.(1989)。Building Theories from Case Study Research。Academy of Management Review，14(4)，532-550。
19.	Boudreau, J. W.(1983)。Effects of employee flows on utility analysis of human resource productivity improvement programs。Journal of Applied Psychology，68，396-406。
20.	Boudreau, J. W.、Rynes, S. L.(1985)。Role of recruitment in staffing utility analysis。Journal of Applied Psyschology，70，354-366。
21.	Brogden, H. E.(1946)。On the interpretation of the correlation coefficienct as a measure of predictive efficiency。Journal of Educational Psychology，37，65-76。
22.	Highhouse, S.(1996)。The utility estimate as a communication device: Practical questions and research directions。Journal of Business and Psychology，11，85-100。
23.	Honeycutt, E. D. Jr.、Karande, K.、Attia, A.、Maurer, S. D.(2001)。An utility based framework for evaluating the financial impact of sales force training programs。The Journal of Personal Selling & Sales Management，21，229-238。
24.	Judiesch, M. K.、Schmidt, F. L.、Hunter, J. E.(1993)。Has the problem of judgment in utility analysis been solved。Journal of Applied Psychology，78，903-911。
25.	Brogden, H. E.(1949)。When testing pays off。Personal Psychology，2，171-183。
26.	Cascio, W. F.、Ramos, R. A.(1986)。Development and application of a new method for assessing job performance in behavior/economic terms。Journal Applied Psychology，71，20-28。
27.	Kim, H.、Cervero, R. M.(2007)。How power relations structure the evaluation process for HRD programmes。Human Resource Development International，10，5-20。
28.	Kearns, P.(2005)。Form return on investment to added value evaluation: The Foundation for organizational learning。Advances in Developing Human Resources，7，135-145。
29.	Alliger, G. M.、Janak, E. A.(1989)。Kirkpatrick's levels of training criteria: Thirty years leater。Personnel Psychology，42，331-342。
30.	Kirkpatrick, D. L.(1959)。Techniques for evaluating traning programs。Journal of the American Society of Training Directors，13，3-9。
31.	Kirkpatrick, D. L.(1959)。Techniques for evaluating programs. Part 2: Learning。Journal of the American Society of Training Directors，13，21-26。
32.	Kirkpatrick, D. L.(1960)。Techniques for evaluating programs. Part 3: Behavior。Journal of the American Society of Training Directors，14，13-18。
33.	Kirkpatrick, D. L.(1960)。Techniques for evaluating programs. Part 4: Resuls。Journal of the American Society of Training Directors，14，28-32。
34.	Cronshaw, S. F.(1986)。The utility of employment testing for clerical/administrative trades in the Canadian military。Canadian Journal of Administrative Sciences，3，376-385。
35.	Cronshaw, S. F.、Alexander, R. A.(1985)。One answer to the demand for accountability: Selection utility as an investmen decision。Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes，35，102-118。
36.	Fandt, P. M.(1991)。The relationship of accountabililty and interdependent behavior to enhancing team consequences。Group & Organization Management，16，300-312。
37.	Florin-Thuma, B. C.、Boudreau, J. W.(1987)。Performance feedback utility in a small organization: Effects on organizational outcomes and managerial decision processes。Personnel Psychology，40，693-713。
38.	Hazer, J. T.、Highhouse, S.(1997)。Factors influencing managers' reactions to utility analysis: Effects of SDy method。Journal of Applied Psychology，82，104-112。
39.	Landy, F. J.、Farr, J. L.、Jacobs, R. R.(1982)。Utility concepts in performance measurement。Organizational Behavior and Human Performance，30，15-40。
40.	Raju, N. S.、Burke, M. J.、Normand, J.、Lezotte, D. V.(1993)。What would be if what is wasn't? A rejoinder to Judiesch, Schmidt and Hunter (1993)。Journal of Applied Psychology，78，912-916。
41.	Rauschenberger, J. M.、Schmidt, F. L.(1987)。Measuring the economic impact of human resource programs。Journal of Business and Psychology，2，50-59。
42.	Russ-Eft, D.、Preskill, H.(2005)。In search of the holy grail: Return on investment evaluation in human resource development。Advances in Developing Human Resources，7，71-85。
43.	Macan, T. H.、Foster, J.(2004)。Managers' reactions to utility analysis and perceptions of what influences their decisions。Journal of Business and Psychology，19，241-253。
44.	Mathieu, J. E.、Leonard, R. L. Jr.(1987)。Applying utility concepts to a training program in supervisory skills: A time-based approach。Academy of Management Journal，30，316-335。
45.	Morgan, R. B.、Casper, W. J.(2000)。Examining the factor structure of participant reactions to training: A multidimensional approach。Human Resource Development Quarterly，11，301-317。
46.	Moynihan, D. P.、Ingraham, P. W.(2003)。Look for the silver lining: When performance-based accountability systems work。Journal of Pulbic Administration Research and Theory，13，469-490。
47.	Nickols, F. W.(2005)。Why a stakeholder approach to evaluating training。Advances in Developing Human Resources，7，121-134。
48.	Niiranen, V.(2008)。The manay purposes of performance evaluation。International Journal of Public Administration，31，1208-1222。
49.	Pineda, P.(2010)。Evaluation of training in organizations: a proposal for an integrated model。Journal of European Industrial Training，34(7)，673-693。
50.	Yang, K.、Hsieh, J. Y.(2007)。Managerial effectiveness of government performance measurement: Testing a middle-range model。Public Adminsistration Review，67，861-879。
51.	Raju, N. S.、Burke, M. J.、Normand, J.(1990)。A new approach for utility anlaysis。Journal of Applied Psychology，75，3-12。
52.	Schmidt, F. L.、Hunter, J. E.、Pearlman, K.(1982)。Assessing the economic impact of personnel programs on workforce productivity。Personnel Psychology，35，333-347。
53.	Praslova, L.(2010)。Adaptation of Kirkpatrick's four level model of training criteria to assessment of learning outcomes and program evluation in higher education。Educational Assessment, Evaluation, and Accountability，22，215-225。
54.	Sturman, M. C.(2003)。Utility analysis: A tool for quantifying the value of hospitality human resource interventions。Cornell Hotel and Restaurant Administration Quarterly，44(2)，106-116。
55.	Swanson, R. A.(1998)。Demonstrating the financial benefit of human resource development: Status and update on the theory and practice。Human Resource Development Quarterly，9，285-295。
56.	Ulrich, D.、Smallwood, N.(2005)。HR's new ROI: Return on intangibles。Human Resource Management，44，137-142。
57.	Wang, G. G.、Wang, J.(2005)。Human resource development evaluation: Emerging market, barriers, and theory building。Advances in Developing Human Resources，7，22-36。

研究報告
1.	American Society for Training and Development.(2003)。2003 ASTD state of the industry report。Alexandria, VA。

學位論文
1.	吳秉恩(1984)。管理才能發展方案實施與成效關係之研究(博士論文)。國立政治大學。延伸查詢

圖書
1.	Phillips, J. J.(1997)。Handbook of training evaluation and measurement methods。Houston, TX：Gulf Publishing。
2.	Phillips, J. J.、Phillips, P. P.(2005)。ROI at work: best-practice case studies from the real world。Alexandria, VA：ASTD Press。
3.	Van Buren, M. E.、Erskine, W.(2002)。The 2002 ASTD State of the Industry Report。Alexandria, VA：American Society of Training and Development。
4.	Ulrich, David(2001)。人力資源最佳實務。臺北：商周。延伸查詢
5.	Becker, Brain E.、Huselid, Mark A.、Ulrich, Dave(2001)。The HR Scorecard: Linking People, Strategy, and Performance。Harvard Business School Press。
6.	Swanson, R. A.、Holton III, E. F.(2001)。Foundations of Human Resource Development。San Francisco：Berrett-Koehler Publishers, Inc.。
7.	Brinkerhoff, Robert O.(1987)。Achieving results from training: How to evaluate human resource development to strengthen programs and increase impact。Jossey-Bass Publishers。
8.	Kirkpatrick, D. L.、Kirkpatrick, J. D.(1994)。Evaluating training programs: The four levels。San Francisco, CA：Berrett-Koehler。
9.	Hamblin, A. C.(1974)。Evaluation and control of training。McGraw-Hill。
10.	Yin, Robert K.(1994)。Case study research: Design and methods。Sage Publications。
11.	Cascio, W. F.(2000)。Costing human resources: The financial impact of behavior in organizations。Boston。
12.	Cronbach, L. J.、Gleser, G. C.(1965)。Psychological tests and personnel decision (2nd ed。Urbana, IL。
13.	Noe, R. A.(2005)。Employee training & development。New York。
14.	Phillips, J. J.(2003)。Return on investment in training and performance improvement programes。Boston。
15.	Phillips, J. J.、Phillips, P. P.、Hodges, T. K.(2004)。Make training evaluation work。Alexandria, VA。
16.	Swanson, R. A.、Holton, E. F. III.(1999)。Results: How to assess performance, learning and perceptions in organizations。San Francisco。
17.	Werner, J. M.、DeSimone, R. L.(2009)。Human resource development。Mason, OH：Thomson South-Western。
18.	Kearns, P.(2005)。Evaluating the ROI from learning: How to develop value-based training。London。
19.	Kidder, T.(1981)。The soul of a new machine。New York：Avon。
20.	Rivera, R. J.、Paradise, A.(2006)。2006 state of the industry in leading enterprises: ASTD's annual review of trends in workplace learning and performance。Alexandria, VA。
21.	Boudreau, J. W.(1991)。Utility analysis for decsions in human resource management。Handbook of industrial and organizational psychology。Palo Alto, CA。
22.	Garnettl, T.(2005)。Leadership development training。ROI at work。Alexandria, VA。

推文
推薦
引用網址
引用嵌入語法
轉寄

top

:::

相關期刊
相關論文
相關專書
相關著作
熱門點閱

1.	航空工業公司員工之人格特質及人員教育訓練對工作滿意度之研究
2.	是的，問題就在「不夠協力」--回應蘇偉業教授之評論
3.	「績效弔詭」是否為不夠「協力」之反映？對〈協力決策後的績效弔詭：以性別影響評估和生態度檢核表為例〉之回應與反思
4.	教育訓練成效、個人環境適配與工作績效關係之研究--以通過人才發展品質管理系統(TTQS)之企業為例
5.	國際金融機構間環境社會標準之浮現與影響--從世界銀行保障政策到赤道原則
6.	三等警察特考錄取人員陞職訓練評估之研究
7.	臺灣地方文化活動契約委外的績效觀感：客家節慶利害關係人的角度
8.	設計系學生之人格特質與團體績效之關係研究
9.	協力決策後的績效弔詭：以性別影響評估和生態檢核表為例
10.	員工參與企業志工後的職能轉變與影響因素之研究
11.	訓練成效評估模式之發展--以個案B公司為例
12.	績效悖理之潛因探析：制度邏輯與心理帳戶觀點
13.	新公共管理改革的弔詭與非意圖結果
14.	公部門績效管理之法制變革與實踐策略
15.	從行政院研究發展考核委員會檢視我國績效體系的形成與發展

1.	非營利老人福利機構績效管理之研究：責信的觀點
2.	公立醫院醫療獎勵金制度及策略性待遇：臺大醫院及臺北市立聯合醫院之比較分析
3.	員工旅遊式教育訓練與工作投入、組織認同、員工自我提升關係之研究
4.	國貿人員屬性與職能訓練成效之關係
5.	地方教育領導、組織學習與組織績效關係之探究
6.	政府捐助財團法人財務課責之研究
7.	成人學習動機、學習行為、創新能力與訓練成效關係之研究-以T公司主管人才培訓班為例
8.	國民小學校長儲訓成效評鑑指標之建構及實證研究
9.	國營事業民營化策略－以台塩為例
10.	影響台灣與中國大陸企業遴選主管之決定因素研究
11.	中小型製造業的訓練投入產出關聯性之研究
12.	職業訓練機構辦理中高齡失業者再就業訓練方案規劃與成效之研究
13.	私立技術學院高階主管才能與組織績效之研究

1.	民營化策略
2.	從複雜理論審視公部門組織績效之管理

無相關著作

1.	產婦特性與採用剖腹產:以臺大醫院為例
2.	人力派遣採購最有利標評選項目與權重之研究
3.	社會工作專業人力繼續教育的訓練成效評鑑：訓練成效與經濟效用之評鑑建構
4.	合作學習與閱讀理解應用於國小二年級國語文領域閱讀教學之行動研究
5.	運用同儕師徒制促進國中學生國文學習成就與學習適應之行動研究
6.	探討國家公園志工訓練、地方依附感與組織承諾之關係
7.	教師成長社群實施「問題導向學習」課程之行動研究--以中部某科技大學為例
8.	我國大學教師人力資源管理實施現況、問題與解決策略
9.	應用案例教學於師資培育課程之行動研究--以教育人員專業倫理為例
10.	以社會網絡方法分析工作世界：科系就業樣態與職能潛在通性的探索
11.	從微觀至鉅觀--運用現象學探討人力資源發展
12.	國民小學教師實施同儕教練之協同行動研究
13.	警察面對記者採訪的回應能力教育訓練芻議
14.	人力資本或是信心資產？自我效能對大學畢業生的學習經驗與就業力間之中介效果

QR Code

臺灣人文及社會科學引文索引資料庫系統

詳目顯示

臺灣人文及社會科學引文索引資料庫