:::

詳目顯示

回上一頁
題名:湘學與晚清學術思潮之轉變
作者:黃聖旻
作者(外文):Sheng-min Huang
校院名稱:國立成功大學
系所名稱:中國文學系碩博士班
指導教授:宋鼎宗
學位類別:博士
出版日期:2006
主題關鍵詞:淩廷堪湘學清學學術史文本義理以禮調和漢宋曾國藩魏源以禮代理MancHunan of academicthe academic custom of
原始連結:連回原系統網址new window
相關次數:
  • 被引用次數被引用次數:期刊(1) 博士論文(1) 專書(0) 專書論文(0)
  • 排除自我引用排除自我引用:1
  • 共同引用共同引用:0
  • 點閱點閱:30
《湘學與晚清學術思潮的轉變》
論文摘要
本論文的理論建構基礎,是在深信學術有一內在理路的發展下,檢驗晚清學術的變化所得致的結論,並蒐羅學術資料,以證明湘學與晚清學術內在理路脫軌之間的關聯。
然而湘學一個地方學派何以對清代學術觀念的轉變,竟有舉足輕重的影響呢?為分析此一現象,本文的進行方式如下:
第一章是前言,其中首要說明的是文章的題旨及動機,其次則是路徑,以便解釋所採行的研究方法以及章節的概要。
第二章主旨在析論清代學術的內涵。欲剝析此一命題,必須自兩方面入手,一是清代學術的定位,一是清代學術特質。
在定位方面,筆者的著眼點,首在於釐清成見。我們知道,當前的學術界,是由自戊戌、五四以降的學運份子的支裔形成中堅,因此,在熟讀梁氏《清代學術概論》的學者眼中,往往只知有公羊、西潮,而不知有國粹、復古,只知有康梁譚夏,而不知有清一代,學界實是人材備出,甚者並目為陳腐守舊,無足觀也;以至迄今所有的清代學術思想史中,自戴震以後竟無一翻脫梁啟超的品題,彷彿除了今文家所激動的清初幾位先生及公羊家本身外,清代的知識份子便全無足觀了。今日欲深入研究清學,此一膜翳是務必先行翦除的障礙。在特質方面,前節已述,筆者堅信學術實是一有機體,有其內在需求所衍生的理路必須遵循,既是由內在理路逼衍而出,其特質的呈現自必與此需求的滿足是息息相關的,因而本章第一節的處理,旨在呈現此一成果。第二節筆者選擇自中國學術流變的三大動因,追索湘學何在此學術氛圍中發揮影響,實應與清代學術本身的脈絡有關。中國學術迄清,已有繁瑣的變因存在其中,當中的變因除了與內在理路的需求相關外,清代學術呈現各省各域的在地化特色,也是影響清代學術由魯、吳、皖、浙、揚、湘、粵各地學術輪番繼起掄元的主因,而學術中以禮改革的傳統,更是何以清學終世都不曾跳脫治禮需求的因素。故而敘述此三大動因,將有助於釐清湘學躋身影響清代學術的現象。
第三章是敘述湘學的在地化特質。
根據筆者追索的結果,發現湘學的前身受南學與理學的影響,因而第一節中,筆者先敘述南學的形成及其學術特質。第二節則追索南學特質在落實於湘地學術中時,是透過什麼方式深化的,被強固的特質又為何。第三節,筆者將根據前二節的探索,抽繹出湘學的三大在地化特質:一是偏重形下的義理學風、二是堂廡特大的學術形態,三則是禮學的時務傳統。此三大特質與清學形成激盪之後,將對清代學術形成深遠的影響。
第四章將討論清代湘學的轉變。
在地化的學術在面臨時空轉捩的情形下,本就有偏移的可能。因而本章第一節談及清乾嘉年間盛行的樸學,雖不同於湘學本身特重義理的學風,但是處在此氛圍之下,善於兼賅的湘學仍然選擇融會並蓄。也開啟了湘學對考據學的認識。第二節則是論述清中葉所興起的經世之學,因湘學本身便有特重時務傳統的情形下,很快地甚至崛起為經世學風風雲會聚之處。第三節論及清中葉的崇禮思想是如何挑起漢宋爭隙,因而本有禮學特質又擅長兼容並蓄的湘學選擇「以禮調和漢宋」的主張,也自此阻滯了清學的發展。
第五章則反向探索清代湘學對晚清學術思潮轉變的影響,重點在呈現兩方面:一是在經世學風的影響下,湘地學者如何接軌此一學風,而湘學學者又如何因自身的雜揉特質以致在變古與復古思潮間矛盾地擺蕩,於是形成第一節「在復古與變古的取捨」的內容;其次又注到注意湘學的兼容並蓄畢竟仍是受限於自身特質形成的好尚,以致在西學的引進上也出現擁抱技藝科學,但卻排斥以中學揉雜西學的現象,因而論述第二節「對西教的引進與排斥」。
第六章則是結論。總結上述章節,並論證整個晚清歷史上風起雲湧的變革,實與湘學有著至深至切的關係。
《Hunan of academic and the change of the academic custom of Manchu Dynasty later period》
Thesis summary
The theories of this thesis constructs foundation, is believing deeply academic have the development of own internality reason road under, examination Manchu Dynasty later period of academic variety income with the result that of conclusion, and Sou Luo's academic data, with certificate Hunan of academic with night pure and academic of inside reason the road jump the track, two relevant is existence.
However Hunan of academic just a school of thought of local area, why to Manchu dynasty of academic idea of change, but have count for much influence?For analyzing this phenomenon, so the way of the treatise of the thesis is like a following article:
Chapter 1 is a foreword, wanting what to explain first among them is an aim and motive of the article, is a path secondly, for explaining the research method and the essentials of the chapter adopted.
The subject of chapter 2 the academic content in analytical Manchu dynasty.Want analytical this problem, have to study from two aspects, an is the academic fixed position of the Manchu dynasty, an is the academic characteristic of the Manchu dynasty.
In the aspects of positioning, my target, want clearance prejudice first.Everyone knows the academic circles of now, by from E Xu coup, 54 exercises of learning and carrying the member paid a descendant to constitute key personnel, therefore, perusal Leung Qi super Sir of 《the academic general outline of the Manchu dynasty 》of scholar, usually only know having ram learns, west of academic, and don't know to have the heritage cultural parties with revive old customs of thought, only knows the Kang has for, Leung Qi is super, the Tan Si don't know the whole Manchu dynasty together, the academic circles has a lot of talented persons in fact, someone even thinks the scholars of the Manchu dynasty are all conservative and unworthy a lift;So in now manily jot down Manchu dynasty of academically and the thought of the historical recordses, no one can be opposed to a super opinion of Leung Qi, seeming to in addition to what he like a few Sirs and ram learned in the early Ching dynasty of scholar, the educated person of the Manchu dynasty is then whole unworthy a lift.Want academic scholar of thorough research Manchu dynasty today, this idea must be got rid of at the earliest stage.At the characteristic aspect, the ex- section has already said, I believe firmly academic is an organism, have own the inside need develops of the reason road have to be followed, since was evolved by the inside reason road of, this characteristic of present nature to have to is demanding and contented and this is vitally related, so this section 1, the subject is presenting this result. Section 2 my choice uses the three greatest factors that China flows to change academically, analytical Hunan of academic why can exertive influence in the academic environment of the Manchu dynasty, should have something to do with academic own grain of the Manchu dynasty in fact.China of academic develop to settle generation, have already had tedious fluctuation factor to save therein, in the middle of fluctuation factor in addition to with inside of the need of the reason road is related, Manchu dynasty of academic present everyplace square of localization of special features, also is influence Manchu dynasty of academic by Shandong, Jiangsu, Anhui, Zhejiang, Yang state, Hunan, Guangdong everyplace academic by turn become center of main cause, and wants to use the tradition that the gift reforms in academically, is also why whole of Manchu dynasty of academic didn't jump to take off research gift to learn of the factor of[with] target.So describe these three greatest factors, will will influence the academic phenomenon of the Manchu dynasty for finding Hunan of academically why, is helpful.
Chapter 3 is to describe Hunan of academic, and Hunan of academic present of the characteristic of the localization.
Find Hunan according to my the result for analyzing of academic have ever been subjected to south to learn the influence that learned with reason, so in section 1, I described first south of academic formation, and its cademic characteristic.Section 2 then the academic characteristic of the analytical south be carrying out in the academic China Times of Hunan, is through what way turn deeply, is enhanced of characteristic again is what.Section 3, I will is two quest of the sections according to the front, analyzing Hunan of academic have three characteristics that localize:While ising the thought that inclines toward the research material, two is a tolerant academic appearance, three tradition of the use that study a gift at that times.After the academic formation of these three greatest characteristics and Manchu dynasty surge, will to Manchu dynasty of academic become profound influence.
Chapter 4 will discuss in the Manchu dynasty period, Hunan of academic is how change.
Regional academic all change in time and the spaces under, certainly there is the possibility for deflecting.So this section 1 analysis the Manchu dynasty test according to of academic, although differ from Hunan of academic, thought because of the academic value research of Hunan.But under the fad of the Manchu dynasty, the academic choice of Hunan tolerates, also therefore understanding to test according to of academic.Section 2 explains then the middle of Manchu Dynasty appears through a life time atmosphere of a school, Hunan of academic always is value material, so became very soon through the center of gravity of a life time atmosphere of a school.Section 3 explains the middle of Manchu Dynasty values the thought that the gift learns, why will cause the Sinology and Song learn of quarrel, Hunan of academic also value a gift to learn, and then is tolerant academic custom, so the academic attempt of Hunan is learned with the gift in harmony with Sinology and Song learn, also therefore hinder an academic development of settling the generation.
Chapter 5 then is anti- toward Hunan of Manchu dynasty of quest of academic have to the later period of Manchu dynasties what influence, the point is presenting both side:One is at through under the influence of a life time atmosphere of a school, how the scholar of Hunan is with is in line with through a life time atmosphere of a school, but own tolerant characteristic, so in become the ancient time with revive old customs captivation, hence formation section 1"Be reviving old customs and becoming ancient time of taking or rejecting" of content;Afterwards again the Zhu go to attention Hunan of academic although tolerate, is thoughted by value of the characteristic limit, with the result that learned in the west of introduce up also appear embrace the technical skill science, but reject with west academic add academic phenomenon in China, as a result discuss section 2"introduce and reject academically to the west".
Chapter 6 is a conclusion.Tally up a previous chapter, and argument the whole thought of later period of Manchu Dynasty, solid and Hunan of academic have a close relation.
主要參考書目:(依書刊名筆劃數、作者名筆劃數依序排列)
一、古籍文獻資料
二十二史
二十二史剳記上下趙 翼臺北:世界書局1988.4十版
今世說.新世說周駿富臺北:明文書局1985
戊戌人物變法傳稿周駿富臺北:明文書局1985
天岳山館文鈔李元度臺北:文海出版社1969
中國學術流變上下馮天瑜上海:華東師範大學出版社2003.2
世說新語劉義慶臺北:華正出版社1989
五禮通考秦蕙田桃園:聖環圖書公司1994
朱子語類黎靖德臺北:正中書局1962
全上古三代秦漢三國六朝文嚴可均臺北:世界書局1961
存學編顏 元臺北:臺灣商務印書館1966
宋元學案黃宗羲北京:中國書店1990.12
孟子字義疏證戴 震臺北:臺灣中華書局1998
近世人物志.同光風雲錄周駿富臺北:明文書局1985
東塾讀書記陳 澧臺北:臺灣商務印書館1997.6臺二版
明儒學案黃宗羲北京:中國書店1990.12
南雷文定黃宗羲臺北:臺灣商務印書館1965
思辨錄輯要陸世儀臺北:臺灣商務印書館1973
校禮堂文集淩廷堪北京:中華書局1998.2
船山全書王夫之長沙:嶽麓書社1996
清文彙祝秀俠等編臺北:臺灣中華書局1960
陶文毅公集陶 澍臺北:文海出版社1968
清史列傳臺北:臺灣中華書局1962
清史稿趙爾巽北京:中華書局1998
清代樸學大師列傳支偉成臺北:明文書局1985
晚清文選鄭振鐸北京:中國社會科學出版社2002.9
清學案小識唐 鑒臺北:臺灣商務印書館1975.8臺二版
章學誠遺書章學誠北京:文物出版社1985.8
清儒學案徐世昌北京:新華書店1990.9
清儒學案小傳周駿富輯臺北:明文書局1985
清儒學案新編楊向奎濟南:齊魯書社1985-1994
黃氏日抄黃 震京都:中文出版社1979.5
曾文正公全集曾國藩臺北:臺灣東方書店1963.12
虛受堂文集王先謙臺北:文海出版社1971
湖南通志曾國荃臺北:京華書局1967.12
湘綺樓文集王闓運臺北:文海出版社1970
新譯顧亭林文集顧炎武臺北:三民書局2000.5
嘉定錢大昕全集錢大昕南京:江蘇古籍出版社1997.12
揅經室集阮 元臺北:臺灣商務印書館1967.3
雕菰集焦 循臺北:鼎文書局1977
養晦齋文集.詩集
上、下劉 蓉臺北:文海出版社1969
漢學商兌方東樹臺北:臺灣商務印書館1978.6
漢學師承記江 藩臺北:臺灣商務印書館1977.11臺二版
魏源集魏 源臺北:鼎文書局1978.11
戴震全書戴 震合肥:黃山書社1994.9
顏習齋先生言行錄顏 元臺北:臺灣商務印書館1966
譚瀏陽全集譚嗣同臺北:文海出版社1962.11
覺迷要錄葉德輝臺北:文海出版社1987
龔自珍全集龔自珍臺北:河洛圖書出版社1975.9
二、相關研究著作
十八世紀禮學考證的思想活力張壽安臺北:中央研究院近代史研究所專刊(86)2001.12
古史辨運動的興起王汎森臺北:允晨文化公司1993.8初版二刷
王先謙《荀子集解》研究究黃聖旻臺南:成功大學碩士論文1997.1
千年講壇──岳麓書院歷代大師講學錄朱漢民長沙:湖南大學出版社2003.4
中國古代哲學問題發展史方立天臺北:洪業文化事業有限公司1995
中國古代哲學發展史方立天臺北:臺灣中華書局1990
中國古代思想史論李澤厚臺北:風雲時代出版公司1990
中國近三百年學術史梁啟超臺北:里仁書局1995.2
中國近三百年學術史錢 穆臺北:臺灣商務印書館1990.10
中國近代思想史論王爾敏臺北:臺灣商務印書館1996
中國近代思想史論李澤厚臺北:風雲時代出版公司1990
中國近代思想與學術的系譜王汎森臺北市:聯經出版公司2003.6
中國近代啟蒙思潮丁守和北京:社會科學文獻出版社1999.11
中國近代新學的展開張立文臺北:東大圖書公司1991.12
中國思想通史侯外廬北京:人民出版社1957
中國思想傳統的現代詮釋余英時臺北:聯經出版公司1990.4初版四刷
中國哲學十九講牟宗三臺北:臺灣學生書局1991.12初版四刷
中國哲學史馮友蘭臺北:藍燈出版公司1989
中國哲學原論─原性篇唐君毅臺北:臺灣學生書局1989
中國哲學原論─原道篇唐君毅臺北:臺灣學生書局1986
中國哲學原論─導論篇唐君毅臺北:臺灣學生書局1980.5
中國學術思想變遷之大勢梁啟超臺北:華正書局1981
中國書院史樊克政臺北:文津出版社1995.9
中國儒學謝祥皓
劉宗賢臺北:水牛出版社1995.10
心體與性體 牟宗三臺北:正中書局1968
先秦兩漢經史稿李劍農臺北:華世出版社1981
以禮代理
─凌廷堪與清中葉儒學思想之轉變張壽安臺北:中央研究院近代史研究所專刊(72)1994.5
宋明以來儒家經世思想試釋張 灝臺北:中央研究院近代史研究所編《近世中國經世思想研討會論文集》1984
明末清初學術思想研究何冠彪臺北:臺灣學生書局1991.2
明末清初儒學之發展李紀祥臺北:文津出版社1992.12
近百年湖南學風錢基博北京:中國人民大學出版社2004
近代新學──中國傳統學術文化的嬗變與重構王先明北京:商務印書館2000.3
迎來近代劇變的經世學人──魏源與馮桂芬李少軍武漢:湖北教育出版社1999
明清之際儒家思想的變遷與發展林聰舜臺北:臺灣學生書局1990.10
明清史陳捷先臺北:三民書局1990
訄書章太炎臺北:世界書局1963
要籍解題及其讀法梁啟超臺北:華正書局1974
康章合論汪榮祖臺北:聯經出版事業公司1988
章太炎的思想王汎森臺北:時報文化出版公司1985
清代考據學研究郭康松武漢:崇文書局2001.8
清末的公羊思想孫春在臺北:臺灣商務印書館1985初版二刷
清代思想史陸寶千臺北:廣文書局1983.9
清代新義理學張麗珠臺北:里仁書局2003.1.15
清代學術概論梁啟超臺北:水牛出版社1981.6
清代義理學新貌張麗珠臺北:里仁書局2002.3.15初版二刷
現代儒學的回顧與展望余英時北京:生活.讀書.新知三聯書店2004.12
清代《儀禮》文獻研究鄧聲國上海:上海古籍出版社2006.4
清初學術思辨錄陳祖武北京:中國社會科學出版社1992
清季的洋務新政樊百川上海:上海書店2003.4
晚明清初思想十論王汎森上海:復旦大學出版社2004.12
國故論衡章太炎臺北:廣文書局1977
晚清四大幕府李志茗上海:上海人民出版社2002
晚清的經世史學彭明輝臺北:麥田出版公司2002.7
晚清民國的國學研究桑 兵上海:上海古籍出版社2001.10
晚清湖南史王繼平長沙:湖南人民出版社2004.5
晚清湖南學術思想史稿王繼平長沙:湖南人民出版社2004.12
晚清新學史論陳國慶西安:三秦出版社2003.11
晚清傳統與西化的論爭孫廣德臺北:臺灣商務印書館1994
國學與漢學桑 兵杭州:浙江人民出版社1999.11
清儒學記張舜徽濟南:齊魯書社1991.11
乾嘉學者的義理學林慶彰
張壽安臺北:中央研究中國文哲研究所經學研究叢刊(6)2003
乾嘉學派研究陳祖武
朱彤窗石家莊:河北人民出版社2005.10
乾嘉學術編年陳祖武
朱彤窗石家莊:河北人民出版社2005.1
飲冰室文集類編梁啟超臺北:華正書局1974
湖南紳士與晚清政治變遷許順富長沙:湖南人民出版社2004.5
飲冰室專集梁啟超臺北:臺灣中華書局1987.12臺三版
湘軍集團與晚清湖南王繼平北京:中國社會科學出版社2002.3
湖湘學派史論朱漢民長沙:湖南大學出版社2004.2
湘學原道錄朱漢民北京:中國社會科學出版社2002.10
開創時期的湖湘學派王立新長沙:岳麓書社2003.4
經學源流考甘鵬雲臺北:廣文書局1977.1
經學歷史皮錫瑞北京:漢京文化事業有限公司1983
劍橋中國晚清史費正清北京:中國社會科學出版社1993.9
維新運動與兩湖教育曹運耕武漢:湖北教育出版社2001
劉申叔遺書劉師培南京:江蘇古籍出版社1997
歷史與思想余英時臺北:聯經出版公司1992.4初版十七刷
儒家哲學梁啟超臺北:臺灣中華書局1980
儒家倫理與秩序情結張德勝臺北:巨流出版公司1989
儒家傳統與現代轉化杜維明北京:北京廣播學院1992
魏源研究陳耀南香港:乾惕書屋1982.11再版
魏源評傳陳其泰
劉蘭肖南京:南京大學出版社2004.9
魏源與西學東漸彭大成
韓秀珍長沙:湖南師範大學出版社2005.10
儒學地域化的近代形態──三大知識群體動的比較研究楊念群北京:生活、讀書、新知三聯書店1997.6
樸學與清代社會黃愛平石家莊:河北人民出版社2003.1
論戴震與章學誠余英時臺北:華世出版社1977.9
 
 
 
 
第一頁 上一頁 下一頁 最後一頁 top
:::
無相關著作
 
無相關點閱
 
QR Code
QRCODE