This paper, by examining a child accident, is focused on the diverse religious interpretations, controversies and understandings among the Bunun people in their contemporary daily lives. It is suggested that these different religious interpretations and proposals seem to reveal people’s diverse religious affiliations, including Bunun traditional religion, Christianity, the Han Chinese folk religion and Yikuandao. However, by analysing closely the data through field study, I argue that there is no outstanding difference among these religious beliefs although each of them holds distinct viewpoint and idea on the surface. Their various discourses are in fact based on some communal Bunun cultural concepts, such as the idea of hanitu (spirit) and the relation between individual and group. In other words, it is the Bunun idea of personhood that they all concern. This paper illustrates how these diverse ideas and concepts struggle, negotiate, compromise and conciliate in the contemporary Bunun social lives.