:::

詳目顯示

回上一頁
題名:平等或適足?兩種教育正義觀的比較
書刊名:人文及社會科學集刊
作者:陳俊宏 引用關係
作者(外文):Chen, Chun-hung
出版日期:2016
卷期:28:3
頁次:頁377-412
主題關鍵詞:教育機會均等教育平等教育適足民主適足論Equality of educational opportunityEducation equalityEducational adequacyDemocratic adequacy
原始連結:連回原系統網址new window
相關次數:
  • 被引用次數被引用次數:期刊(2) 博士論文(0) 專書(0) 專書論文(0)
  • 排除自我引用排除自我引用:2
  • 共同引用共同引用:57
  • 點閱點閱:64
近年來,平等論與適足論對於教育資源分配的論辯,是教育哲學討論的重要議題。平等論主張,資源必須平等分配,教育機會不應受到個人無法控制的外在因素所影響,教育的不平等若起因於這些元素,就是不正義。適足論則主張,資源的分配應以適足性為原則,只要每個人獲得最低門檻的資源,則在門檻之上的不平等,不能稱為不正義。本文試圖從兩派對於教育目的以及教育資源分配的論辯,比較兩種理論觀點的差異,以及各自遭遇的難題。本文認為,一個完整的教育正義觀,必須有效處理兩派所遭遇的難題,本文將提出一個得以解決兩派主張的規範性觀點。
Over the past decades, there has been ongoing philosophical debate between luck egalitarians and relational egalitarians. Recently, an equivalent debate has been taking place in the sphere of education. According to the educational equality approach, justice requires prospects for educational achievement to be dependent upon a child's ability and willingness to learn, and not on factors outside of her control. Nevertheless, proponents of what can be called adequacy approach have instead argued that the state is required to ensure all children have adequate education. Once this threshold is obtained, there is no injustice in the fact that some children have better education than others. This paper tries to address this debate. It will not only lay out at conceptual level the difference between equality and adequacy but also to show what these conceptual differences mean for educational policies.
期刊論文
1.Dworkin, Ronald(2003)。Equality, Luck, and Hierarchy。Philosophy and Public Affairs,31(2),190-198。  new window
2.Scheffler, Samuel(2003)。What is Egalitarianism?。Philosophy and Public Affairs,31(1),5-39。  new window
3.Anderson, Elizabeth(2004)。Rethinking Equality Opportunity: Comment on Adam Swift's How Not to Be a Hypocrite。Theory and Research in Education,2(2),99-110。  new window
4.Anderson, Elizabeth(2007)。Fair Opportunity in Education: A Democratic Equality Perspective。Ethics,117(4),595-622。  new window
5.Brighouse, Harry、Swift, Adam(2006)。Equality, Priority, and Positional Goods。Ethics,116(3),471-497。  new window
6.Brighouse, Harry、Swift, Adam(2006)。Parents' Rights and the Value of the Family。Ethics,117(1),80-108。  new window
7.Brighouse, Harry、Swift, Adam(2008)。Putting Educational Equality in Its Place。Education Finance and Policy,3(4),444-466。  new window
8.Brighouse, Harry、Swift, Adam(2009)。Educational Equality versus Educational Adequacy: A Critique of Anderson and Satz。Journal of Applied Philosophy,26(2),117-128。  new window
9.Brighouse, Harry、Swift, Adam(2009)。Legitimate Parental Partiality。Philosophy & Public Affairs,37(1),43-80。  new window
10.Casal, Paula(2007)。Why Sufficiency Is Not Enough。Ethics,117(2),296-327。  new window
11.Darby, Derrick、Levy, Richard E.(2011)。Slaying the Inequality Villain in School Finance: Is the Right to Education the Silver Bullet?。Kansas Journal of Law & Public Policy,20(3),351-387。  new window
12.Giesinger, Johannes(2011)。Education, Fair Competition, and Concern for the Worst Off。Educational Theory,61(1),41-54。  new window
13.Koski, William S.、Reich, Rob(2007)。When "Adequate" Isn't: The Retreat from Equity in Educational Law and Policy and Why It Matters。Emory Law Journal,56(3),545-617。  new window
14.Scheffler, Samuel(2005)。Choice, Circumstance, and the Value of Equality。Politics, Philosophy & Economics,4(1),5-28。  new window
15.Schemmel, Christian(2012)。Luck Egalitarianism as Democratic Reciprocity? A Response to Tan。The Journal of Philosophy,109(7),435-448。  new window
16.Schemmel, Christian(2012)。Distributive and Relational Equality。Politics, Philosophy & Economics,11(2),123-148。  new window
17.Tan, Kok-Chor(2008)。A Defense of Luck Egalitarianism。The Journal of Philosophy,105(11),665-690。  new window
18.Wolff, Jonathan(1998)。Fairness, Respect, and the Egalitarian Ethos。Philosophy & Public Affairs,27(2),97-122。  new window
19.陳麗珠(20061100)。從公平性邁向適足性:我國國民教育資源分配政策的現況與展望。教育政策論壇,9(4),101-117。new window  延伸查詢new window
20.Arneson, Richard J.(1989)。Equality and equal opportunity for welfare。Philosophical Studies,56(1),77-93。  new window
21.Arneson, Richard J.(2000)。Luck Egalitarianism and Prioritarianism。Ethics,110(2),339-349。  new window
22.Frankfurt, Harry G.(1987)。Equality as a Moral Ideal。Ethics,98(1),21-43。  new window
23.Anderson, Elizabeth S.(1999)。What is the Point of Equality?。Ethics,109(2),287-337。  new window
24.詹盛如(20081200)。臺灣教育經費的現況分析。教育資料集刊,40,1-25。new window  延伸查詢new window
圖書
1.Sen, Amartya K.(1992)。Inequality reexamined。Clarendon Press。  new window
2.Walzer, Michael(1983)。Spheres of justice: a defense of pluralism and equality。New York:Basic Books。  new window
3.Young, Michael(1958)。The Rise of the Meritocracy, 1870-2033: An Essay on Education and Equality。London:Thames and Hudson。  new window
4.Cohen, Gerald A.(2000)。If You're an Egalitarian, How Come You're So Rich?。Cambridge, MA:Harvard University Press。  new window
5.Knight, Carl(2009)。Luck Egalitarianism: Equality, Responsibility, and Justice。Edinburgh:Edinburgh University Press。  new window
6.Moss, Jeremy(2014)。Reassessing Egalitarianism。Houndmills:Palgrave Macmillan。  new window
7.Peters, Richard S.(1966)。Ethics and Education。Scott, Foresman and Company。  new window
8.Roemer, John(1994)。Egalitarian Perspectives: Essays in Philosophical Economics。New York:Cambridge University Press。  new window
9.Swift, Adam(2003)。How Not to Be a Hypocrite: School Choice for the Morally Perplexed Parent。London:Routledge。  new window
10.Tooley, James(1996)。Education without the State。London:IEA。  new window
11.Bowles, Samuel、Gintis, Herbert、Groves, Melissa Osborne(2005)。Unequal Chances: Family Background and Economic Success。Princeton, NJ:Princeton University Press。  new window
12.Brighouse, Harry(2000)。School Choice and Social Justice。Oxford University Press。  new window
13.Hirsch, Fred(1976)。Social Limits to Growth。Cambridge, MA:Harvard University Press。  new window
14.United Nations(1948)。Universal declaration of human rights。N.Y.:United Nations。  new window
15.Rawls, John、Kelly, Erin(2001)。Justice as Fairness: A Restatement。Cambridge, MA:Harvard University Press。  new window
16.Gutmann, Amy(1987)。Democratic Education。Princeton University Press。  new window
17.Dworkin, Ronald M.(2000)。Sovereign Virtue: The Theory and Practice of Equality。Harvard University Press。  new window
18.Young, Iris Marion(1990)。Justice and the Politics of Difference。Princeton University Press。  new window
19.Sen, Amartya Kumar(1999)。Development as Freedom。Alfred A. Knopf。  new window
圖書論文
1.Anderson, Elizabeth(2012)。Equality。The Oxford Handbook of Political Philosophy。Oxford:Oxford University Press。  new window
2.Arneson, Richard(2010)。Luck Egalitarianism: A Primer。Responsibility and Distributive Justice。Oxford University Press。  new window
3.Brighouse, Harry(2010)。Educational Equality and School Reform。Educational Equality。New York:Continuum。  new window
4.Brighouse, Harry、Swift, Adam(2014)。The Place of Educational Equality in Educational Justice。Education, Justice and the Human Good: Fairness and Equality in the Education System。Routledge。  new window
5.Reich, Rob(2013)。Equality, Adequacy, and K-12 Education。Education, Justice and Democracy。Chicago:University of Chicago Press。  new window
 
 
 
 
第一頁 上一頁 下一頁 最後一頁 top
:::
無相關著作
 
QR Code
QRCODE